Comparative
research
on
language,
music,
and
action
in
cognitive
neuroscience
keeps
finding
evidence
for
both
shared
non-shared
components
of
systems.
The
discussions,
then,
tend
to
quickly
fall
into
the
sterile
dichotomy
between
domain-specific
vs.
domain-general
options.
In
this
position
paper,
we
take
issue
with
argue
an
alternative
account
based
neural
reuse
theories
understand
findings
relationship
action.
We
that
differences
those
systems
can
be
explained
terms
specialization
same
brain
mechanism(s)
each
domain,
which
emerges
course
development
and/or
evolution.
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Sept. 3, 2023
Abstract
Models
of
the
neurobiology
language
suggest
that
a
small
number
anatomically
fixed
brain
regions
are
responsible
for
functioning.
This
observation
derives
from
centuries
examining
injury
causing
aphasia
and
is
supported
by
decades
neuroimaging
studies.
The
latter
rely
on
thresholded
measures
central
tendency
applied
to
activity
patterns
resulting
heterogeneous
stimuli.
We
hypothesised
these
methods
obscure
whole
distribution
supporting
language.
Specifically,
cortical
‘language
regions’
corresponding
network’
consist
input
connectivity
hubs.
primarily
coordinate
peripheral
whose
variable,
making
them
likely
be
averaged
out
following
thresholding.
tested
hypotheses
in
two
studies
using
meta-analyses
functional
magnetic
resonance
imaging
during
film
watching.
Both
converged
averaging
over
words
localised
historically
associated
with
but
distributed
throughout
most
when
not
sensorimotor
properties
those
words.
word
composed
highly
data
shows
hubs
fixed.
Rather,
they
spatiotemporally
dynamic,
connections
44%
at
any
moment,
only
appear
aggregate
time.
Results
an
artefact
indiscriminately
across
representations
linguistic
processes.
mostly
dynamic
coordinating
whole-brain
distributions
networks
processing
complexities
real-world
use,
explaining
why
damage
results
aphasia.
Frontiers in Language Sciences,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
2
Published: Sept. 15, 2023
The
language
production
deficit
in
post-stroke
agrammatic
aphasia
(PSA-G)
tends
to
result
from
lesions
the
left
inferior
frontal
gyrus
(LIFG)
and
is
characterized
by
a
triad
of
symptoms:
fragmented
sentences,
errors
functional
morphology,
dearth
verbs.
Despite
decades
research,
mechanisms
underlying
patterns
PSA-G
have
been
difficult
characterize.
Two
major
impediments
progress
may
view
that
it
purely
morphosyntactic
disorder
(sometimes
overzealous)
application
linguistic
theory
without
interceding
psycholinguistic
evidence.
In
this
paper,
empirical
evidence
examined
present
an
integrated
portrait
evaluate
assumption
syntax-specific
syndrome.
light
extant
evidence,
proposed
results
combination
morphosyntactic,
phonomotor,
processing
capacity
limitations
cause
cumulative
bottleneck
at
point
articulatory
planning.
This
Synergistic
Processing
Bottleneck
model
presents
testable
framework
for
future
research.
paper
ends
with
recommendations
research
on
PSA-G.
Imaging Neuroscience,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
2, P. 1 - 21
Published: Jan. 25, 2024
Abstract
Control
processes
are
critical
for
the
context-appropriate
use
of
meaningful
stimuli.
Similar
definitions
have
been
adopted
in
two
distinct
literatures
focusing
on
identifying
neural
correlates
“semantic
control”
and
executive
control
across
domains
(the
“multiple
demand
network”).
Surprisingly,
despite
their
proposed
functions
varying
only
relation
to
domain-specificity,
these
networks
appear
differ
anatomically.
However,
prior
comparisons
confounded
by
variations
task
design.
To
what
extent
might
requirements
drive
differences
activation
patterns
that
typically
attributed
stimulus
domain?
Here,
first
time,
we
functional
MRI
disentangle
effects
process
domain
during
cognitively
demanding
tasks.
Participants
performed
an
odd-one-out
requiring
rule-switching,
inhibition
selection
processes,
n-back
working
memory
task,
each
with
semantic
non-semantic
stimuli,
a
factorial
Both
affected
regions
activated,
indicating
is
indeed
key
factor
confounding
studies.
core
(left
inferior
frontal
gyrus,
left
posterior
temporal
cortex)
also
showed
preference
stimuli
even
matched
while
more
peripheral
regions,
overlapping
multiple
network
(dorsomedial
prefrontal
cortex,
right
gyrus),
little
or
stimulus.
Conversely,
most
were
preferentially
engaged
These
results
highlight
mutual
importance
driving
variation
region
engagement,
both
between
networks.
Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
16
Published: Sept. 23, 2022
Among
the
many
lines
of
research
that
have
been
exploring
how
embodiment
contributes
to
cognition,
one
focuses
on
neural
substrates
language
may
be
shared,
or
at
least
closely
coupled,
with
those
action.
This
paper
revisits
a
particular
proposal
has
received
considerable
attention—namely,
forms
hierarchical
sequencing
characterize
both
linguistic
syntax
and
goal-directed
action
are
underpinned
partly
by
common
mechanisms
in
left
Brodmann
area
(BA)
44,
cortical
region
is
not
only
classically
regarded
as
part
Broca’s
area,
but
also
core
component
human
Mirror
Neuron
System.
First,
recent
multi-participant,
multi-round
debate
about
this
summarized
together
some
other
relevant
findings.
review
reveals
while
supported
variety
theoretical
arguments
empirical
results,
it
still
faces
several
challenges.
Next,
narrower
application
discussed,
specifically
involving
basic
word
order
subject
(S),
object
(O),
verb
(V)
simple
transitive
clauses.
Most
languages
either
SOV
SVO,
and,
building
prior
work,
argued
these
strong
syntactic
tendencies
derive
from
BA44
represents
sequential-hierarchical
structure
actions.
Finally,
aim
clarifying
what
might
mean
for
“common”
BA44,
two
different
versions
main
distinguished.
Hypothesis
1
states
very
same
subserve
aspects
action,
whereas
2
anatomically
distinct
functionally
parallel
Although
hypotheses
make
predictions,
point
neither
significantly
more
explanatory
power
than
other,
further
needed
elaborate
test
them.
Music & Science,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
5
Published: Jan. 1, 2022
Music
is
used
as
an
important
medium
for
communication
in
human
societies,
often
times
to
enhance
the
emotional
meaning
of
narrative
scenarios
and
ritual
events.
has
a
number
domain-specific
tonal
devices
doing
this,
spanning
from
scale
structure
harmonic
progressions
beyond.
In
order
explore
neural
basis
processing
music,
we
carried
out
activation
likelihood
estimation
(ALE)
meta-analysis
20
published
functional
magnetic
resonance
imaging
studies
cognition,
with
emphasis
on
harmony
processing.
The
most
concordant
areas
across
these
occurred
at
junction
inferior
frontal
gyrus,
anterior
insula,
orbitofrontal
cortex
Brodmann
47
13
right
hemisphere.
This
region
associated
not
only
emotion
general,
but
conveyance
affective
meanings
during
processes,
including
speech
prosody
music.
Musicae Scientiae,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: June 18, 2024
The
evolution
of
human
musicality
has
often
been
linked
to
the
faculty
language
since
development
musical
and
linguistic
abilities
seems
share
a
common
phase
in
their
ontogenesis.
Apart
from
that,
both
singing
speaking
are,
on
one
hand,
universal
forms
vocal
expression
and,
other
consist
culturally
specific
elements.
Such
probable
co-occurrence
predisposition
speak
sing,
with
cultural
variability
these
communication,
prompted
researchers
indicate
gene–culture
co-evolution
as
mechanism
responsible
for
emergence
language.
However,
most
evolutionary
scenarios
proposed
so
far,
paths
music
followed
independently
after
divergence
precursor.
This
article,
based
observations
contemporary
interactions
between
music,
presents
different
view
which
language-like
proto-communication
interacted
leading
repurposing
some
neural
mechanisms.
In
this
process,
Baldwinian
interplay
plasticity
canalization
that
shaped
our
musicality.
premises
support
presence
cross-domain
co-evolutionary
communicative
niche
Homo
sapiens
are
indicated.
Nature Human Behaviour,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Nov. 21, 2024
Abstract
This
study
aimed
to
test
theoretical
predictions
over
biological
underpinnings
of
previously
documented
phenotypic
correlations
between
human
language-related
and
musical
rhythm
traits.
Here,
after
identifying
significant
genetic
rhythm,
dyslexia
various
traits,
we
adapted
multivariate
methods
capture
signals
common
genome-wide
association
studies
(
N
=
606,825)
1,138,870).
The
results
revealed
16
pleiotropic
loci
P
<
5
×
10
−8
)
jointly
associated
with
impairment
dyslexia,
intricate
shared
neurobiological
architectures.
joint
signal
was
enriched
for
foetal
adult
brain
cell-specific
regulatory
regions,
highlighting
complex
cellular
composition
in
their
underpinnings.
Local
correlation
a
key
white
matter
tract
(the
left
superior
longitudinal
fasciculus-I)
substantiated
hypotheses
about
auditory–motor
connectivity
as
genetically
influenced,
evolutionarily
relevant
neural
endophenotype
language
processing.
Overall,
provide
empirical
evidence
multiple
aspects
biology
linking
contributing
novel
insight
into
the
evolutionary
relationships
musicality
linguistic
communication
Frontiers in Neuroscience,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
18
Published: June 17, 2024
Timbre
is
a
central
aspect
of
music
that
allows
listeners
to
identify
musical
sounds
and
conveys
emotion,
but
also
for
the
recognition
actions
an
important
structuring
property
music.
The
former
functions
are
known
be
implemented
in
ventral
auditory
stream
processing
timbre.
While
latter
commonly
attributed
areas
dorsal
other
domains,
its
involvement
timbre
so
far
unknown.
To
investigate
if
involves
both
pathways,
we
carried
out
activation
likelihood
estimation
(ALE)
meta-analysis
18
experiments
from
17
published
neuroimaging
studies
on
perception.
We
identified
consistent
activations
Brodmann
(BA)
41,
42,
22
bilateral
transverse
temporal
gyri,
posterior
superior
gyri
planum
temporale,
BA
40
inferior
parietal
lobe,
13
Insula,
right
anterior
insula
gyrus.
vast
majority
regions
associated
with
streams.
therefore
propose
frame
dual-stream
model.
Moreover,
activated
show
similarities
brain
involved
several
fundamental
aspects
music,
indicating
possible
shared
neural
bases
domains.