The
links
between
β-amyloid
(Aβ)
and
tau
in
Alzheimer's
disease
are
unclear.
Cognitively
unimpaired
persons
with
signs
of
Aβ
pathology
had
increased
cerebrospinal
fluid
(CSF)
phosphorylated
(P-tau181
P-tau217)
total-tau
(T-tau),
which
over
time,
despite
no
detection
insoluble
aggregates
[normal
Tau
positron
emission
tomography
(PET)].
CSF
P-tau
T-tau
started
to
increase
before
the
threshold
for
Amyloid
PET
positivity,
while
after
positivity.
Effects
on
were
mediated
by
P-tau,
high
predicted
rates.
Individuals
Acta Neuropathologica,
Год журнала:
2020,
Номер
140(3), С. 267 - 278
Опубликована: Июль 27, 2020
The
neuropathological
confirmation
of
amyloid-β
(Aβ)
plaques
and
tau
neurofibrillary
tangles
(NFT)
remains
the
gold
standard
for
a
definitive
diagnosis
Alzheimer's
disease
(AD).
Nowadays,
in
vivo
AD
is
greatly
aided
by
both
cerebrospinal
fluid
(CSF)
positron
emission
tomography
(PET)
biomarkers.
Although
highly
accurate,
their
broad
implementation
restricted
high
cost,
limited
accessibility
invasiveness.
We
recently
developed
high-performance,
ultrasensitive
immunoassay
quantification
phosphorylated
at
threonine-181
(p-tau181)
plasma,
which
identifies
pathophysiology
with
accuracy.
However,
it
unclear
whether
plasma
p-tau181,
measured
years
before
death,
can
predict
eventual
AD,
successfully
discriminates
from
non-AD
dementia
pathologies.
studied
unique
cohort
115
individuals
longitudinal
blood
collections
clinical
evaluation
8,
4
2
prior
to
assessment
death.
results
demonstrate
that
p-tau181
associates
better
neuropathology
Braak
staging
than
8
post-mortem.
Moreover,
while
all
patients
had
during
life,
proved
discriminate
pathologies
accuracy
(AUC
=
97.4%,
95%
CI
94.1-100%)
even
Additionally,
trajectory
was
assessed
patients.
found
main
increases
occurred
between
death
later
plateauing.
In
contrast,
controls
exhibited
minor,
albeit
significant,
up
until
Overall,
our
study
demonstrates
predictive
specific
post-mortem
examination.
These
data
add
further
support
use
aid
management
primary
care
recruitment
trials.
EMBO Molecular Medicine,
Год журнала:
2019,
Номер
11(12)
Опубликована: Ноя. 11, 2019
Article11
November
2019Open
Access
Transparent
process
Cerebrospinal
fluid
and
plasma
biomarker
trajectories
with
increasing
amyloid
deposition
in
Alzheimer's
disease
Sebastian
Palmqvist
Corresponding
Author
[email
protected]
orcid.org/0000-0002-9267-1930
Clinical
Memory
Research
Unit,
Department
of
Sciences,
Lund
University,
Lund,
Sweden
Neurology,
Skåne
University
Hospital,
Search
for
more
papers
by
this
author
Philip
S
Insel
Psychiatry,
California,
San
Francisco,
CA,
USA
Erik
Stomrud
Clinic,
Malmö,
Shorena
Janelidze
Henrik
Zetterberg
Psychiatry
Neurochemistry,
The
Sahlgrenska
Academy
at
the
Gothenburg,
Mölndal,
Neurochemistry
Laboratory,
Neurodegenerative
Disease,
UCL
Institute
Queen
Square,
London,
UK
Dementia
UCL,
Britta
Brix
Euroimmun
AG,
Lübeck,
Germany
Udo
Eichenlaub
Roche
Diagnostics
GmbH,
Penzberg,
Jeffrey
L
Dage
Eli
Lilly
Company,
Indianapolis,
IN,
Xiyun
Chai
Kaj
Blennow
Niklas
Mattsson
orcid.org/0000-0002-8885-7724
Wallenberg
Center
Molecular
Medicine,
Oskar
Hansson
orcid.org/0000-0001-8467-7286
Information
*,1,2,
Insel1,3,
Stomrud1,4,
Janelidze1,
Zetterberg5,6,7,8,
Brix9,
Eichenlaub10,
Dage11,
Chai11,
Blennow5,6,
Mattsson1,2,12
*,1,4
1Clinical
2Department
3Department
4Memory
5Department
6Clinical
7Department
8UK
9Euroimmun
10Roche
11Eli
12Wallenberg
*Corresponding
author.
Tel:
+46
46
177808;
E-mail:
40-335036;
Fax:
40-335657;
EMBO
Mol
Med
(2019)11:e11170https://doi.org/10.15252/emmm.201911170
ELECSYS,
COBAS,
COBAS
E
are
registered
trademarks
Roche.
All
mentioned
enjoy
legal
protection
PDFDownload
PDF
article
text
main
figures.
Peer
ReviewDownload
a
summary
editorial
decision
including
letters,
reviewer
comments
responses
to
feedback.
ToolsAdd
favoritesDownload
CitationsTrack
CitationsPermissions
ShareFacebookTwitterLinked
InMendeleyWechatReddit
Figures
&
Info
Abstract
Failures
(AD)
drug
trials
highlight
need
further
explore
mechanisms
alterations
biomarkers
during
development
AD.
Using
cross-sectional
data
from
377
participants
BioFINDER
study,
we
examined
seven
cerebrospinal
(CSF)
six
relation
β-amyloid
(Aβ)
PET
uptake
understand
their
evolution
In
CSF,
Aβ42
changed
first,
closely
followed
Aβ42/Aβ40,
phosphorylated-tau
(P-tau),
total-tau
(T-tau).
CSF
neurogranin,
YKL-40,
neurofilament
light
increased
after
point
Aβ
positivity.
findings
were
replicated
using
Aβ42,
Aβ40,
P-tau,
T-tau
assays
five
different
manufacturers.
Changes
seen
approximately
simultaneously
biomarkers.
Overall,
had
smaller
dynamic
ranges,
except
P-tau
which
similar.
conclusion,
state-of-the-art
biomarkers,
identified
first
changes
Aβ,
soluble
tau.
Only
became
abnormal,
neuroinflammation,
synaptic
dysfunction,
neurodegeneration
altered.
These
lend
vivo
support
cascade
hypotheses
humans.
Synopsis
Analysis
13
key
accumulation
confirms
hypothesis,
presence
other
already
prior
threshold
study
examines
tau,
then
markers
dysfunction
neurodegeneration.
results
T-tau.
Introduction
Continued
failures
clinical
against
presumably
correct
targets
research
all
important
what
stage
they
occur
become
measurable
(Honig
et
al,
2018;
Jack
Egan
2019;
Knopman,
Selkoe,
2019).
pathogenesis
AD
is
complex
involves
many
mechanisms.
According
hallmark
pathology
abnormal
that
can
start
decades
before
dementia
continues
throughout
course
(Villemagne
2013).
thought
trigger
or
drive
tau
pathology,
which,
possibly
together
inflammatory
mechanisms,
may
cause
result
cognitive
impairment
(Jack
2013;
Sperling
2014).
There
now
several
that,
extent,
measure
these
pathogenic
Examining
these,
especially
earlier
stages
AD,
would
allow
us
better
disease,
essential
identifying
potential
targets,
designing
trials,
improving
diagnostics
work-up
(Blennow
2010).
By
comparing
also
identify
measuring
blood
instead
samples.
elderly,
non-demented
(Aβ42
Aβ40),
(neurogranin),
[total-tau
(T-tau)
chain
(NfL)],
glial
activation
neuroinflammation
(YKL-40,
measured
only
CSF).
modeled
as
functions
positron
emission
tomography
(PET)
signal
measures
amount
accumulated
fibrillar
neocortex
(used
proxy
time
disease).
We
load
significant
occurred
(change
trajectory).
Differences
between
change
points
map
temporal
Finally,
T-tau,
manufacturers
compared
assess
generalizability
results.
Results
Demographic
shown
Table
1.
Of
included
participants,
242
cognitively
unimpaired
(CU)
135
mild
(MCI).
mixture
modeling-derived
cutoff
<
0.736
SUVR,
151
(40%)
Aβ-positive
(Aβ+)
226
(60%)
Aβ-negative
(Aβ−).
significantly
Aβ+
Aβ−
neurogranin.
stratified
positivity
Variable
Total
population
P-value
N
Age
(years)
72.1
(5.4)
72.6
(5.0)
71.8
(5.6)
0.10
Sex
(female)
50%
44%
54%
0.042
MMSE
(0–30
points)
28.3
(1.6)
27.8
28.5
(1.5)
<0.001
APOE
ε4-positive
38%
66%
22%
(SUVR)a
0.782
(0.23)
1.023
(0.18)
0.622
(0.05)
Hippocampus
volume/ICV
0.0045
(0.00069)
0.00425
(0.00062)
0.00468
(0.00068)
(pg/ml)
1,321
(650)
818
(319)
1,657
(596)
Aβ40
22,811
(82,293)
29,261
(129,856)
18,501
(5,362)
0.57
Aβ42/Aβ40
0.0717
(0.028)
0.0448
(0.0164)
0.0898
(0.0187)
256
(116)
319
(139)
215
(73.0)
22.8
(12.4)
30.0
(15.1)
17.9
(6.7)
NfL
1,192
(948)
1,399
(1,133)
1,053
(847)
Neurogranin
405
(213)
480
(253)
356
(164)
YKL-40
194,090
(63,108)
205,273
(64,958)
186,618
(60,847)
0.003
Plasma
31.6
(4.9)
29.9
(4.7)
32.7
484
(72)
483
(73)
485
(71)
0.66
0.0657
(0.0082)
0.0622
(0.0078)
0.0680
(0.0077)
17.8
(5.3)
18.2
17.6
(5.5)
0.12
2.7
(4.6)
3.4
(3.2)
2.1
22.9
(17.0)
23.9
(11.2)
22.2
(19.9)
20,205
(10,655)
19,414
(10,961)
20,735
(10,437)
0.17
Values
mean
(SD)
if
not
otherwise
stated.
Mann–Whitney
was
used
compare
groups.
Bold
P-values
indicate
statistical
significance
P
0.05.
CU,
unimpaired;
ICV,
intra
cranial
volume;
MCI,
impairment;
MMSE,
Mini-Mental
State
Examination;
N,
number
participants;
NfL,
chain;
phosphorylated-tau;
SD,
standard
deviation,
T-tau;
total-tau.
Early
accumulating
ROI
composite
reference
region
(see
Materials
Methods).
function
monotone
spline
models
Fig
1A.
Separate
points,
level,
r2
value
Appendix
S1.
Note
fitted
plasma,
data.
Initial
declines
both
flat
curve
(i.e.,
no
association
increases
SUVR)
while
continued
decrease
level
when
reached.
concordance
this,
ratio
started
plateau,
later
drop
(note
increase
be
estimated
given
priori
assumption
monotonicity
respect
SUVR).
Around
1.0
SUVR
(after
reached),
Aβ42/40
flattened
out
did
continue
decline
further.
very
similar
greatest
neurogranin
showed
modest
range
span,
even
(<
0.5
z-score).
exhibited
sigmoid
trajectory
subtle
initial
around
same
most
marked
span
SUVRs
(Fig
1A).
Based
on
appearance,
two
established
below
As
expected
dependent
variable,
best
model
fits
(r2
=
0.42)
0.55),
poorer
0.30),
0.25),
0.11),
0.02),
0.02).
Figure
A,
B.
where
acted
(A)
(B)
separately,
but
selected
direct
comparisons
3.
Individual
actual
Figs
S1
S2.
modeling
statistics.
Point
(also
referred
change)
vertical
dashed
lines.
They
defined
2
SE
(derived
500
bootstrap
samples)
starting
trajectory.
missing
34
cases.
To
facilitate
levels
have
been
transformed
z-scores
based
distribution
present
z-score
0
corresponds
cohort).
Download
figure
PowerPoint
A
(or
"change
point")
error
(SE)
lines
1
95%
CIs
Aβ42/Aβ40.
Later,
seen,
differences
them
overlapping
CIs).
latter
just
Slightly
later,
hippocampal
volume
seen.
second
last
than
changes.
2.
CIsChange
divided
total
intracranial
added
reference.
splines
1B.
models,
(Appendix
S2).
Similar
an
initial,
parallel
line
resulting
3A).
contrast
over
entire
(about
vs.
about
CSF;
3A)
overall
lesser
agreement
(plasma
r2:
0.07–0.12;
0.42–0.55;
This
true
corresponding
S2),
3B).
Comparison
A.
Same
1A
B
Aβ42/40,
panel
easier
comparison.
Spline
dataset
there
(n
343);
i.e.,
1B,
slightly
Data
information:
2,
S1),
non-significant
models.
Compared
wider
CIs,
indicating
greater
variability
early
phase
and/or
less
rapid
Comparisons
comparative
analysis
performed
subset
complete
available
352
n
population).
(Elecsys®,
EUROIMMUN,
INNOTEST,
MSD),
P-tau181,
P-tau217),
MSD)
4A–D.
assays.
No
obtained
any
5).
4.
vendors
A–D.
(A),
(B),
(C),
(D)
assays,
Significant
some
almost
identical
therefore
partially
hidden
5
overview
points).
sample
whole
5.
assaysSignificant
377)
gave
Elecsys®
assay
full
dataset.
Discussion
individuals
who
242)
MCI
135),
7
6
(measured
PET)
onset
dementia.
found
(which
concurrently
ratio).
Overt
(as
hippocampus
second,
pronounced
increase)
neither
nor
2).
When
3).
could
confirm
(Figs
4
conduct
comparison
accumulation,
include
(except
plasma).
Two
recent
studies
rare
autosomal
dominant
variant
symptoms
variable
Dominantly
Inherited
Network
(DIAN)
(McDade
Schindler
Despite
samples
sequence
changing
shortly
(neurogranin
one
diverge
healthy
controls).
has
recently
demonstrated
Disease
Neuroimaging
Initiative
(ADNI)
longitudinal
estimate
(Insel
under
review).
agree
current
postulating
initiating
factor
hitherto
do
2)
previous
showing
becomes
(Palmqvist
2016,
2017;
Vlassenko
2016).
Further,
might
explanations
higher
(dichotomous)
2),
reported
previously
(Janelidze
Lewczuk
Doecke
2018).
Although
difference
stable
3A),
supported
(Schindler
finding
should
interpreted
cautiously
since
driven
few
barely
(P
0.02;
S1)
0.37;
Even
though
supporting
use
isolation
detect
(Mattsson
2015,
2019b;
2017),
probably
provides
reliable
fibrils
its
specificity
acts
peptide
can,
example,
account
inter-individual
concentrations
pre-analytical
handling
lead
false-positive
false-negative
2016;
2017).
phosphorylation
state
inflammation
(YKL-40),
(NfL
T-tau)
still
stage,
known
pathological
develop
fairly
long-lasting
manifest
("Aβ
positivity")
required
occur.
well
accordance
work,
brain
hypometabolism
accelerate
reached
However,
complicate
matters,
must
consider
examining
validity
does
it
supposed
measure)
thus
clearly
affect
It
is,
possible
reflects
neuronal
reaction
amyloidosis,
rather
neurofibrillary
2017b;
Sato
2018),
activity
secretion
variety
intra-neuronal
proteins
event
(Cirrito
2008;
Li
case
peptides
extracellular
space
without
new
taking
place
(other
secretion).
for,
too
clinically
relevant
(early
point;
overt
(late
hypothesis
contradictory
detected
16
years
(Preische
2019),
noticeable
2019a,b).
addition
validity,
sensitivity
(for
detecting
underlying
pathology)
For
much
sensitive
find
mechanism
brain.
want
note
order
refers
translate
appears
overlapped
2;
S1).
Nonetheless,
considerable
trajectories.
considerably
lower
values
ranges
S2,
B,
JAMA Neurology,
Год журнала:
2020,
Номер
78(2), С. 149 - 149
Опубликована: Ноя. 9, 2020
There
is
an
urgent
need
for
inexpensive
and
minimally
invasive
blood
biomarkers
Alzheimer
disease
(AD)
that
could
be
used
to
detect
early
changes.To
assess
how
in
the
course
of
AD
plasma
levels
tau
phosphorylated
at
threonine
217
(P-tau217)
start
change
compared
with
established
cerebrospinal
fluid
(CSF)
positron
emission
tomography
(PET)
pathology.This
cohort
study
included
cognitively
healthy
control
individuals
(n
=
225)
participants
subjective
cognitive
decline
89)
or
mild
impairment
176)
from
BioFINDER-2
study.
Participants
were
enrolled
2
different
hospitals
Sweden
January
2017
October
2019.
All
underwent
P-tau217
assessments
tau-
amyloid-β
(Aβ)-PET
imaging.
A
subcohort
111
had
3
tau-PET
scans.Changes
preclinical
prodromal
changes
CSF
PET
measures.Of
490
participants,
251
women
(51.2%)
mean
(SD)
age
was
65.9
(13.1)
years.
Plasma
increased
unimpaired
abnormal
Aβ-PET
but
normal
entorhinal
cortex
(Aβ-PET+/
tau-PET-
group
vs
Aβ-PET-/
group:
median,
2.2
pg/mL
[interquartile
range
(IQR),
1.5-2.9
pg/mL]
0.7
[IQR,
0.3-1.4
pg/mL]).
Most
who
discordant
positive
negative
(P-tau217+/tau-PET-:
36
[94.7%];
P-tau217-/tau-PET+:
[5.3%]).
Event-based
modeling
cross-sectional
data
predicted
those
impairment,
both
would
before
signal
cortex,
followed
by
more
widespread
cortical
changes.
When
testing
association
global
Aβ
load
nonlinear
spline
models,
lower
values
measures.
Among
baseline
tau-PET,
rates
longitudinal
increase
higher
(median
standardized
uptake
value
ratio,
0.029
-0.006
0.041]
-0.001
-0.021
0.020];
Mann-Whitney
U,
P
.02).In
this
study,
during
stages
when
insoluble
aggregates
not
yet
detectable
tau-PET.
may
hold
promise
as
a
biomarker
brain
pathology.
The
links
between
β-amyloid
(Aβ)
and
tau
in
Alzheimer's
disease
are
unclear.
Cognitively
unimpaired
persons
with
signs
of
Aβ
pathology
had
increased
cerebrospinal
fluid
(CSF)
phosphorylated
(P-tau181
P-tau217)
total-tau
(T-tau),
which
over
time,
despite
no
detection
insoluble
aggregates
[normal
Tau
positron
emission
tomography
(PET)].
CSF
P-tau
T-tau
started
to
increase
before
the
threshold
for
Amyloid
PET
positivity,
while
after
positivity.
Effects
on
were
mediated
by
P-tau,
high
predicted
rates.
Individuals