Click
to
increase
image
sizeClick
decrease
sizeThis
article
refers
to:Consciousness
in
a
Rotor?
Science
and
Ethics
of
Potentially
Conscious
Human
Cerebral
OrganoidsHuman
Organoids:
Implications
Ontological
considerationsMacro-bio-ethical
Versus
Micro-bio-ethical
Issues
Concerning
Brain
OrganoidsLikely
Looming?
The
Labyrinthine
ELSI
Landscape
Copying
ConsciousnessWho
Owns
the
Brains
behind
Machine?
Will
Hot
Debate
on
AI's
Inventorship
Authorship
Rights
Force
Premature
Determination
Machine
Consciousness?Searching
for
Consciousness
Unfamiliar
Entities:
Need
Both
Systematic
Investigation
ImaginationRebutting
Ethical
Considerations
regarding
Challenging
AssumptionsA
Teleological
Approach
Status
OrganoidsSymbolic
Value
Shifting
Focus
from
Sociocultural
Perspectives
ResemblanceRegulating
Possibly
Sentient
Organoids
DISCLOSURE
STATEMENTNo
potential
conflict
interest
was
reported
by
author(s).Additional
informationFundingThe
author(s)
there
is
no
funding
associated
with
work
featured
this
article.
Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
6
Опубликована: Янв. 5, 2024
Human
brain
organoids,
aka
cerebral
organoids
or
earlier
"mini-brains",
are
3D
cellular
models
that
recapitulate
aspects
of
the
developing
human
brain.
They
show
tremendous
promise
for
advancing
our
understanding
neurodevelopment
and
neurological
disorders.
However,
unprecedented
ability
to
model
development
function
Biotechnology Advances,
Год журнала:
2023,
Номер
68, С. 108233 - 108233
Опубликована: Авг. 7, 2023
Integrating
neural
cultures
developed
through
synthetic
biology
methods
with
digital
computing
has
enabled
the
early
development
of
Synthetic
Biological
Intelligence
(SBI).
Recently,
key
studies
have
emphasized
advantages
biological
systems
in
some
information
processing
tasks.
However,
neither
technology
behind
this
development,
nor
potential
ethical
opportunities
or
challenges,
been
explored
detail
yet.
Here,
we
review
aspects
that
facilitate
SBI
and
explore
applications.
Considering
these
foreseeable
use
cases,
various
implications
are
proposed.
Ultimately,
work
aims
to
provide
a
robust
framework
structure
considerations
ensure
can
be
both
researched
applied
responsibly.
Advanced Healthcare Materials,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
13(21)
Опубликована: Янв. 13, 2024
Brain
organoids
are
three-dimensional
aggregates
of
self-organized
differentiated
stem
cells
that
mimic
the
structure
and
function
human
brain
regions.
Organoids
bridge
gaps
between
conventional
drug
screening
models
such
as
planar
mammalian
cell
culture,
animal
studies,
clinical
trials.
They
can
revolutionize
fields
developmental
biology,
neuroscience,
toxicology,
computer
engineering.
Conventional
microinstrumentation
for
cellular
engineering,
microfluidic
chips;
microelectrode
arrays
(MEAs);
optical,
magnetic,
acoustic
techniques,
has
limitations
when
applied
to
(3D)
organoids,
primarily
due
their
limits
with
inherently
two-dimensional
geometry
interfacing.
Hence,
there
is
an
urgent
need
develop
new
instrumentation
compatible
live
culture
techniques
scalable
3D
formats
relevant
organoids.
This
review
discusses
approaches
emerging
necessary
advanced
organoid-machine
interfaces.
Specifically,
this
article
surveys
recently
developed
microinstrumentation,
including
printed
curved
microfluidics,
fast-scan
optical
buckling
self-folding
MEAs,
interfaces
electrochemical
measurements,
spatially
controllable
magnetic
technologies
two-way
information
transfer
highlights
key
challenges
must
be
addressed
robust
organoid
reliable
spatiotemporal
transfer.
The Neuroscientist,
Год журнала:
2025,
Номер
unknown
Опубликована: Март 13, 2025
Harnessing
intelligence
from
brain
cells
in
vitro
requires
a
multidisciplinary
approach
integrating
wetware,
hardware,
and
software.
Wetware
comprises
the
themselves,
where
differentiation
induced
pluripotent
stem
offers
ethical
scalability;
hardware
typically
involves
life
support
system
setup
to
record
activity
deliver
stimulation
cells;
software
is
required
control
process
signals
coming
going
cells.
This
review
provides
broad
summary
of
foundational
technologies
underpinning
these
components,
along
with
outlining
importance
technology
integration.
Of
particular
that
this
new
ability
extend
beyond
traditional
methods
assess
primarily
survival
spontaneous
neural
cultures.
Instead,
focus
returns
core
function
tissue:
neurocomputational
information
respond
accordingly.
Therefore,
also
covers
work
that,
despite
relatively
early
state
current
technology,
has
provided
novel
meaningful
understandings
field
neuroscience
opening
exciting
avenues
for
future
research.
Abstract
Alongside
in
vitro
studies,
researchers
are
increasingly
exploring
the
transplantation
of
human
brain
organoids
(HBOs)
into
non-human
animals
to
study
development,
disease,
and
repair.
This
paper
focuses
on
ethical
issues
raised
by
such
studies.
In
particular,
it
investigates
possibility
that
they
might
yield
enhanced
function
recipient
(especially
primates),
thereby
fundamentally
altering
their
moral
status.
I
assess
critique,
major
voices
bioethics
science
communities,
according
which
concerns
premature
misleading.
identify
assumptions
underlying
this
skeptical
mention
some
objections
against
them,
followed
possible
replies.
proceed
argue
position
is
ultimately
implausible,
because
presupposes
an
unreasonably
high
standard
full
My
argument
appeals
David
DeGrazia’s
idea
a
“borderline
person”,
need
for
consistency
with
existing
animal
research
regulations.
outline
practical
implications
my
view
conduct
studies
result
development
status
transplanted
animal.
also
discuss
enhancement
(particularly
rodents)
below
threshold
associated
conclude
far
from
being
premature,
further
debate
these
urgently
needed
help
clarify
prospects
neural
chimera
attain
foreseeable
future,
level
quality
life
required
make
acceptable
knowingly
create
via
HBO
transplantation.
Acta Neuropathologica Communications,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
12(1)
Опубликована: Авг. 30, 2024
Research
in
the
field
of
traumatic
brain
injury
has
until
now
heavily
relied
on
use
animal
models
to
identify
potential
therapeutic
approaches.
However,
a
long
series
failed
clinical
trials
brought
many
scientists
question
translational
reliability
pre-clinical
results
obtained
animals.
The
search
for
an
alternative
conventional
that
better
replicate
human
pathology
is
thus
utmost
importance
field.
Recently,
orthotopic
xenotransplantation
organoids
into
living
been
achieved.
This
review
summarizes
existing
literature
this
new
method,
focusing
its
applications
preclinical
research,
both
context
cell
replacement
therapy
and
disease
modelling.
Given
obvious
advantages
approach
study
pathologies
vivo
context,
we
here
critically
current
limitations
while
considering
possible
research.
Oxford Open Neuroscience,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
3
Опубликована: Янв. 1, 2024
Abstract
Human
brain
organoids
equipped
with
complex
cytoarchitecture
and
closed-loop
feedback
from
virtual
environments
could
provide
insights
into
neural
mechanisms
underlying
cognition.
Yet
certain
cognitive
capacities
might
also
merit
moral
consideration.
A
precautionary
approach
has
been
proposed
to
address
these
ethical
concerns
by
focusing
on
the
epistemological
question
of
whether
possess
structures
for
morally-relevant
that
bear
resemblance
those
found
in
human
brains.
Critics
challenge
this
similarity
philosophical,
scientific,
practical
grounds
but
do
so
without
a
suitable
alternative.
Here,
I
introduce
an
architectural
infers
potential
cognitive-like
processing
based
pattern
information
flow
through
system.
The
kind
computational
architecture
acquired
organoid
then
informs
could,
theoretically,
be
supported
empirically
investigated.
implications
considerability
are
discussed.
Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics,
Год журнала:
2023,
Номер
unknown, С. 1 - 21
Опубликована: Окт. 18, 2023
Abstract
Organoids
and
specifically
human
cerebral
organoids
(HCOs)
are
one
of
the
most
relevant
novelties
in
field
biomedical
research.
Grown
either
from
embryonic
or
induced
pluripotent
stem
cells,
HCOs
can
be
used
as
vitro
three-dimensional
models,
mimicking
developmental
process
organization
developing
brain.
Based
on
that,
despite
their
current
limitations,
it
cannot
assumed
that
they
will
never
at
any
stage
development
manifest
some
rudimentary
form
consciousness.
In
absence
behavioral
indicators
consciousness,
theoretical
neurobiology
consciousness
being
applied
to
unresponsive
brain-injured
patients
considered
with
respect
HCOs.
clinical
neurology,
is
difficult
discern
a
capacity
for
who
provide
no
such
scenarios,
validated
neurobiological
theory
which
tells
us
what
neural
mechanisms
are,
could
identify
Like
diagnostic
difficulty
neurologists,
Therefore,
this
article
discusses
how
three
prominent
theories
apply
organoids.
From
perspective
Temporal
Circuit
Hypothesis,
Global
Neuronal
Workspace
Theory,
Integrated
Information
we
discuss
neuronal
structures
functions
might
indicate
have
conscious.
Organoids,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
3(2), С. 83 - 112
Опубликована: Май 13, 2024
Organoids
present
immense
promise
for
studying
organ
systems
and
their
functionality.
Recently,
they
have
become
the
subject
of
exploration
outside
purely
biomedical
uses
in
multiple
directions.
We
will
explore
rapidly
evolving
landscape
organoid
research
over
21st
century,
discussing
significant
advancements
highlighting
breakthroughs,
methodologies,
transformative
impact
on
our
understanding
physiology
modeling.
In
addition,
we
potential
use
biocomputing
harnessing
intelligence,
investigate
how
these
miniaturized
organ-like
structures
to
create
novel
computational
models
processing
platforms
allowing
innovative
approaches
drug
discovery,
personalized
medicine,
disease
prediction.
Lastly,
address
ethical
dilemmas
surrounding
by
dissecting
intricate
considerations
related
creation,
use,
implications
vitro
models.
Through
this
work,
goal
paper
is
provide
introductory
perspectives
bridges
that
connect
organoids
cybersecurity
applications
imperative
discourse
accompanying
its
with
commentary
future
uses.