Genome Research,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
34(10), С. 1595 - 1609
Опубликована: Окт. 1, 2024
Asgard
archaea
are
of
great
interest
as
the
progenitors
Eukaryotes,
but
little
is
known
about
mobile
genetic
elements
(MGEs)
that
may
shape
their
ongoing
evolution.
Here,
we
describe
MGEs
replicate
in
Atabeyarchaeia,
a
wetland
lineage
represented
by
two
complete
genomes.
We
used
soil
depth-resolved
population
metagenomic
data
sets
to
track
18
for
which
genome
structures
were
defined
and
precise
chromosome
integration
sites
could
be
identified
confident
host
linkage.
Additionally,
20.67
kbp
circular
plasmid
family-level
groups
viruses
linked
via
CRISPR
spacer
targeting.
Closely
related
40
possess
hypervariable
genomic
region
encoding
combinations
specific
genes
small
cysteine-rich
proteins
structurally
similar
restriction-homing
endonucleases.
One
10.9
integrative
conjugative
element
(ICE)
integrates
genomically
into
mLife,
Год журнала:
2022,
Номер
1(4), С. 359 - 367
Опубликована: Дек. 1, 2022
The
work
of
Carl
Woese
and
his
colleagues
the
Urbana
University
has
been
one
most
important
breakthroughs
in
biology
last
century
(for
historical
sketches,
see
Refs.1,
2).
pioneered
use
macromolecule
sequences
to
decipher
relationships
between
all
organisms,
fulfilling
Darwin's
dream
get
a
"fairly
true
genealogical
trees
each
great
kingdom
nature"3.
He
went
even
beyond
this
objective
since
he
was
finally
able
identify
connect
nature
(which
called
domains)
into
single
tree.
apex
discovery
1977
an
entire
new
domain
life,
hidden
before
our
eyes,
Archaea4.
16S
ribosomal
RNA
(rRNA)
as
molecular
chronometer
later
probe
for
PCR
not
only
revealed
third
life
but
also
paved
way
detection
identification
microorganisms
that
were
yet
amenable
cultivation5.
I
deeply
affected
when
passed
away
10
years
ago
because
my
three
scientific
heroes:
together
with
James
Watson,
DNA
double-helix,
Wang,
topoisomerases
(the
Ws).
surprised
still
shocked
despite
monumental
achievements,
death
completely
ignored
French
media,
suspect
it
same
countries
worldwide.
Notably,
died
day
famous
horse,
Ourasi,
had
won
several
competitions
such
"le
grand
prix
de
l'arc
Triumphe."
horse
made
headlines
media
day,
including
prime-time
TV
news.
could
resist
sending
short
piece
entitled
"the
scientist
horse"
Journal
Liberation
which
emphasize
difference
treatment
(and
like
horses)
greatest
scientists
century.
It
published
online
version
journal
link
now
removed,
you
can
read
at
end
fourth
chapter
book,
Microbes
from
Hell1.
ardent
activist
promoting
vision
living
world
by
discoveries.
criticized
misleading
prokaryotic/eukaryotic
paradigm,
classification
organisms
is
based
on
phenotypic
features,
sequel
anthropic
lower
higher
ones,
humans
top
classifications6.
paradigm
establish
15
Archaea7.
Therefore,
George
Fox
their
seminar
paper
Proc
Natl
Acad
Sci
USA
1977,
already
firmly
established.
prokaryote/eukaryote
easy
explain
(with
or
without
nucleus)
quickly
became
pillar
cellular
organisms8.
dichotomy
welcomed
cytologists
biologists
alike
modern
classification,
be
opposed
five-kingdom
favored
zoologists
botanists9.
This
probably
explains
why
so
many
biologists,
strongly
time
Woese's
proposal
though
data2,
10,
11
(see
Ref.12
answer
Ernst
Mayer).
Why
should
we
change
winning
team?
Here,
will
briefly
describe
various
encounters
Woese,
focusing
agreements
disagreements
concerning
universal
tree
Last
Universal
Common
Ancestor
(LUCA),
which,
according
definitely
less
recognized
major
question
today"13.
discuss
how
legacy
challenged
occasions
reactions.
Unfortunately,
no
longer
among
us
defend
legacy.
All
aware
existence
Archaea
recognize
merit
revealing
deep
divide
"prokaryotic
world,"
too
(in
opinion)
believe
view
fundamentally
wrong
favor
pre-Woesian
evolutionary
model.
dominant
one,
paralleled
virus/phage
virosphere,
layman
politicians
journalists
ignore
(still
confused
Bacteria).
More
troublesome
fact
(except
those
working
Archaea)
are
unaware
vastly
underestimate
importance.
seems
remind
generations
importance
history
science
fight
ideas
think
they
forefront
science.
discovered
reading
1981
review
Scientific
American
described
"Archaebacteria"
possibility
studying
"primary
kingdom"
determine
common
ancestor
domains,
progenote14.
turning
point
career
immediately
stop
replication
Bacteria
(Escherichia
coli)
started
Archaea,
polymerases.
Thanks
inspiration
help
few
pioneers
field,
especially
Wolfram
Zillig15,
rapidly
accumulate
significant
results
study
Halobacterium
halobium
Sulfolobus
acidocaldarius16,
17.
first
publications
topic,
invited
Zillig
participate
second
meeting
organized
Martinsried
Institute,
near
Munich
1985.
gave
me
opportunity
time.
vividly
remember
memorable
sparring
Lake
took
place
meeting.
Based
electron
microscopic
pictures
ribosomes,
just
two
papers
Science18,
19
proposed
replacing
"urkingdoms"
(Figure
1A)
four
1B).
In
unrooted
tree,
ribosome
structure,
Archaebacteria
split
"Archaebacteria
proper,"
limited
halophiles
methanogens,
urkingdom,
Eocytes,
grouping
other
thermophilic
archaea,
Thermococcus
Thermoplasma18.
Lake,
who
spoke
first,
violently
attacked
explained
him
different
values
versus
genotypic
data.
came
back
shivering
much
argument
opinion
people
present
explanation.
structural
signatures
Jim
used
define
Eocyte
indeed
observed
mesophilic
methanogen,
Methanococcus
vanielli29.
paper,
although
Science,
cited
today,
whereas
Lake's
1984
proponents
two-domains
(2D)
hypothesis
below)
supporting
favorite
hypothesis30,
31.
discouraged
failure
held
Victoria
Canadian
east
coast
fresh
arguments.
meantime,
learned
phylogenetic
techniques
designed
method
own,
parsimony32,
produced
rRNA
Thermoplasma
removed
Eocytes33.
If
root
localized
bacteria
obtains
2D
trees,
1988
(Ref.33)
clearly
(instead
1984)
description
1D).
After
talk
meeting,
stage
conclude
speaker
brought
arguments
theory.
striking
contrast
mute
Canada,
leaving
coworker
Gary
Olsen
against
Lake34.
seemed
bit
ongoing
debate.
How
realize
scenario
good
one?
wondering
mathematician
here
settle
dispute.
realized
myself
problem
primarily
mathematical
(today,
speaking
about
choose
best
model)
more
data
sets22.
fed
up
meetings
eager
person
opponents.
Besides
conflict
rejection
theory
evolutionists,
Mayer
Lynn
Margulis,
continue
support
paradigm2.
My
encounter
thus
delayed
until
1994,
very
beginning
genomic
era.
Despite
reluctance
attend
meetings,
joined
friendship
Zillig,
influential
bringing
gospel
Europe15.
We
waiting
genome
sequenced
(most
likely
bacterial
one),
Roger
Garret
Aarhus
Denmark35
small
roundtable
five
colleagues,
one)
archaeal
selected
mammoth
task.
Each
participant
name
archaeon
floor
expected
(hoping
would
one).
"We
sequence
least
five,"
declared
stupefaction
incredulity.
fact,
right
genomes
available
century,
Craig
Venter's
team
done
collaboration
1996
(Methanocaldococcus
vannielii)36.
example
lifetime.
being
heroes,
did
hesitate
disagree
him.
strong
proponent
rooting
groups
1980s37,
38.
obtained
combining
analysis
paralogous
proteins
originated
gene
duplication
LUCA.
For
time,
Hervé
Philippe,
these
reliable
attraction
long
branch
separated
corresponding
respective
outgroup39,
40.
suspected
preferred
Bacteria.
Indeed,
rooted
justify
changing
Archaea20
hoped
topology
simply
extreme
environments
1C).
while,
disagreed
Eukaryotes
domains.
liked
idea
some
eukaryotic
spliceosome,
possibly
Of
course,
rejected
have
old
division.
When
Philippe
defended
reporting
presence
bacterial-like
genes
than
eukaryotic-like
genomes39,
ridiculed
quantitative
qualitative,
quality
hallmark
translation
apparatus
studies41.
soon
right,
allowing
parsimonious
distribution
domains
life27
1E).
However,
cannot
solved
analyses
reasonable
guess
comparative
(Box
1).
LUCA
smaller
33–34
ribosomes
contain
around
60–80
proteins27.
mechanism
biosynthesis
simpler,
protein
involved
process42.
initiation
transcription
specific,
factor
set
elongation
Finn
Werner)43.
RNA,
explaining
replication,
replicase,
primase,
helicase,
homologous
Arkarya
Bacteria44
(Arkarya
clade
Eukarya)27.
(processivity
factor)
might
introduced
independently
lineages
viruses.
ATPase
synthase
ATP
fermentation
subunit
essential
synthesis
Arkarya45.
These
reasoning
sophistication
fundamental
mechanisms
takes
lineages.
Alternative
hypotheses
(complex
LUCA)
involve
replacement
Arkaryal
features
ones
vice
versa
ones.
There
obvious
selection
pressure
suggested
replacement,
except
simplification
branch40.
Although
simpler
progenote,
sensu
Fox21,
46,
sophisticated
membrane
pumps
capable
faithful
synthesis27.
seminal
"The
concept
evolution"46,
unfaithful
apparatus.
Again,
gap
exists
hand
Eukarya
evolution
always
parsimonious,
remain
open
possible
alternatives47.
partly
agree
LUCA,
do
stricto
sensu,
translate
mRNA
message
rather
faithfully.
conclusion
contained
transfer
(tRNA)
modifications
crucial
translation.
A
provided
Kae1
Sua5
t6A
biosynthesis,
tRNA
modification
ANN
codons.
need
additional
factors
perform
task
sufficient
synthesize
mitochondria,
suggesting
mitochondria
recapitulates
LUCA27.
adopted
promoted
so-called
"bacterial
branch,"
never
considered
finding
Eukarya.
departure
cladistic
rules
due
fear
weakening
three-domain
promoted.
if
follows
rules,
usually
assumed,
two-domain
Bacteria,
naming
Arkarya27.
Probably
bypassing
case
2002,
Darwinian
threshold
transition
period
ancestors
Archaeal
Ancestor,
LACA;
Bacterial
LBCA;
Eukaryotic
LECA),
hereafter
referred
ancestors21.
moment
transmission
genetic
information
moves
predominantly
horizontal
mode
lateral
(LGT)
vertical
mode.
assumed
LGTs
allow
organisms.
Accordingly,
argue
applicable
threshold,
separation
leading
Killing
birds
once,
tempo
dramatically
decreased
emergence
ancestors.
dramatic
reduction
observations
early
looking
shape
tree13.
rate
within
extrapolated
ancestors,
born
formation
Earth!
LGT
prevalence
correct
rarely
LGT48,
49.
2006,
replicated
repaired
faithfully
RNA50.
viruses
triggers
independent
RNA-to-DNA
transitions,
domain.
To
delight,
reject
agreed
refer
USA.
respond
critics
challenge
life.
prevalent
once
thought,
sometimes
far
apart
led
buzz
forgetting
trumpeting
"Darwin
wrong"
discussion
Ref.51).
profoundly
views,
authors
jokingly
percent"52
networks53.
save
upper
part
(those
context.
chance
meet
another
2003
personal
discussions
evolution.
little
afraid
knowledge
previous
disagreement
negative
impact
encounter.
case;
friendly,
real
lover
something
give
happy
figure
1982,
someone
remembered
review14.
Lund
Sweden
honor
awarded
Crafoord
prize
Royal
Swedish
Academy
Sciences.
received
King
Sweden,
Gustav
XVI,
descendant
Marshal
Napoleon
Bernadotte,
unexpected
turn
history.
occasion
humor
mimicked
official
dinner
ritual
master
ceremony
Chap.
4
Ref.1).
prize,
3
Nobel
(both
terms
money
ceremony!),
exception
complete
absence
press
coverage.
pity
Prize.
speak
archaea.
deserved
medicine,
considering
markers
microorganism
medicine.
recent
Svante
Pääbo
sequencing
Neanderthal
confirms
advances
fields
prize.
wonder
opposition
adversaries
evolutionists
played
role
final
distinction.
met
2007
Illinois
Urbana-Champaign
celebrate
30th
anniversary
Archaea.
"hidden
your
eyes"
resembling
visible,
decades
cousins
under
microscope.
visit
laboratory
opening
box
containing
film
two-dimensional
gel
chromatography
collection
oligonucleotides
after
digestion
Methanobacterium
thermoautotrophicum
RNase
T1
1
Ref.15).
honored
own
university
surrounded
friends
introduce
countries,
Karl
Stetter
Germany,
Yoshizumi
Ishino
Japan,
David
Prangishvili
former
USSR.
2012,
reawakening
Asgard
archaea24,
25.
am
really
reacted
twist
biology.
imagine
disturbed,
view.
decade,
paraphyletic,
considers
belong
1F).
make
things
worse,
often
depicted
fusions
(one
mitochondria)
archaeon,
Margulis
highly
despised
(figure
Ref14).
Archaebacteria,
hence
illustrated
contrasting
eukaryotes
emerged
fusion
prokaryotes
(only
time)14.
much.
going
past
becoming
one.
classical
during
decade
fast-evolving
species
sets,
combined
difficulty
recovering
testifying
monophyly
reviews
results,
Ref.54).
does
mean
archaea
breakthrough
provide
exciting
understand
Phylogenetic
odd
Signature
Proteins
(ESPs)
extensive
proto-eukaryotes54.
Studying
reconstruct
proto-eukaryotic
lineage.
proto-eukaryotes
suggests
thriving
LECA
environments,
indicating
shed
light
type
environment
inhabited
cultivated
Candidatus
Prometheoarchaem
synthrophicum,
turned
out
dependent
growth
its
physical
association
methanogenic
archaeon55.
tour
force
concluded
publication
genomics
"most
them,
all,
symbiotic
interactions."
tempting
suggest
facilitated
interactions
Asgard54.
One
live
ectosymbionts
today.
search
associations
biotopes
adventure
young
(or
young)
microbial
ecologists54.
assault
three-domains
concept,
deny
prokaryotic
At
2020,
heralded
putting
nail
coffin.
From
10,575
genomes,
381
markers,
"1.16
trillions
non
amino-acids,"
separates
shorter
previously
thought56.
branches
separating
altogether.
correct,
there
reason
separate
reunified
domain,
pre-Woese
area.
Looking
cursorily
claim,
flaws
conclusion.
included
6
34
shared
proteins.
They
is,
instance,
gyrase,
recruited
(Ref.
50
references
therein).
subsequently
refuted
Moody
identified
both
paralogy
Zhu
colleagues49.
noticed
14
include
priori
unbelievable
aim
measure
distance
68
others
25%
sampled
Strikingly,
(a
prerequisite
kind
analysis)
recovered
22
trees49.
indicated
that,
transferred
other.
review,
Refs.23,
57)
confirmed
recently
using
data,
non-ribosomal
proteins22,
48,
Long
lengths
criterion
determining
besides
widespread
domains48,
58.
Failure
consider
Weiss
colleagues59.
reported
355
supposed
starting
"6.1
million
protein-coding
genes"
"286,514
clusters."
showed
metabolism
similar
Clostridia
genome,
"prokaryote"
progenote.
thrived
high
temperatures
reverse
enzymes
found
mesophiles
hyperthermophiles,
gyrases
formed
monophyletic
analysis,
them
short,
gyrase
intermixed,
domains58.
reanalysis
colleagues'
Berkemer
McGlynn
82%
all),
LUCA48.
again
underrepresented
low
diversity.
looked
arrived
Using
criteria
represented
distantly
related
phylums,
15–20
"LUCA"
(unpublished
observations).
proteome
table.
scenarios
origin
mLife,
Год журнала:
2022,
Номер
1(4), С. 374 - 381
Опубликована: Дек. 1, 2022
Abstract
The
division
of
organisms
on
the
Tree
Life
into
either
a
three‐domain
(3D)
tree
or
two‐domain
(2D)
has
been
disputed
for
long
time.
Ever
since
discovery
Archaea
by
Carl
Woese
in
1977
using
16S
ribosomal
RNA
sequence
as
evolutionary
marker,
there
great
advance
our
knowledge
not
only
growing
diversity
but
also
relationships
between
different
lineages
living
organisms.
Here,
we
present
this
perspective
to
summarize
progress
archaeal
and
changing
notion
Life.
Meanwhile,
provide
latest
genomics/physiology‐based
Asgard
closest
relative
Eukaryotes.
Furthermore,
propose
three
major
directions
future
research
exploring
“next
one”
Eukaryote
relative,
deciphering
function
eukaryotic
signature
proteins
eukaryogenesis
from
both
genomic
physiological
aspects,
understanding
roles
horizontal
gene
transfer,
viruses,
mobile
elements
eukaryogenesis.
Genome Research,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
34(10), С. 1595 - 1609
Опубликована: Окт. 1, 2024
Asgard
archaea
are
of
great
interest
as
the
progenitors
Eukaryotes,
but
little
is
known
about
mobile
genetic
elements
(MGEs)
that
may
shape
their
ongoing
evolution.
Here,
we
describe
MGEs
replicate
in
Atabeyarchaeia,
a
wetland
lineage
represented
by
two
complete
genomes.
We
used
soil
depth-resolved
population
metagenomic
data
sets
to
track
18
for
which
genome
structures
were
defined
and
precise
chromosome
integration
sites
could
be
identified
confident
host
linkage.
Additionally,
20.67
kbp
circular
plasmid
family-level
groups
viruses
linked
via
CRISPR
spacer
targeting.
Closely
related
40
possess
hypervariable
genomic
region
encoding
combinations
specific
genes
small
cysteine-rich
proteins
structurally
similar
restriction-homing
endonucleases.
One
10.9
integrative
conjugative
element
(ICE)
integrates
genomically
into