British Journal of Sports Medicine,
Год журнала:
2021,
Номер
55(21), С. 1224 - 1232
Опубликована: Июнь 29, 2021
Objective
To
determine
the
effects
of
interventions
aimed
at
optimising
quantity
and
quality
physical
education
(PE)
on
cognition
academic
performance
in
children
adolescents.
Design
A
systematic
review
meta-analysis.
Data
sources
Studies
from
electronic
databases
inception
to
3
January
2021
were
identified.
Eligibility
criteria
for
selecting
studies
Experimental
that
assessed
effect
quantity-based
(ie,
increasing
amount
curriculum
time
allocated
PE)
or
quality-based
students’
participation
activity
during
PE
interventions,
both,
changes
and/or
youth
(aged
5–18
years)
included.
Results
19
trials
comprising
8676
(46.5%
girls)
Individual
increased
(Hedges’
g=0.38,
95%
CI
0.15
0.60;
I
2
=83.70%),
mainly
primary
settings
(g=0.48,
0.07
0.89;
=90.43%).
Academic
performance,
principally
mathematics-related
skills,
was
also
by
(g=0.15,
0.06
0.24;
=41.75%).
Among
these
teaching
strategies
favoured
similar
results,
but
without
heterogeneity
results
(g=0.12,
0.05
0.18;
=0%).
In
contrast,
had
a
very
small
non-significant
(g=0.09,
−0.05
Q=11.65;
=48.48%).
Finally,
there
no
differences
between
three
quantity,
quality,
combined
interventions)
regard
performance.
Conclusion
Improving
classes
may
improve
Importantly,
allocating
more
does
not
seem
compromise
this
Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise,
Год журнала:
2016,
Номер
48(6), С. 1197 - 1222
Опубликована: Май 17, 2016
Background
The
relationship
among
physical
activity
(PA),
fitness,
cognitive
function,
and
academic
achievement
in
children
is
receiving
considerable
attention.
utility
of
PA
to
improve
cognition
promising
but
uncertain;
thus,
this
position
stand
will
provide
clarity
from
the
available
science.
Objective
purpose
study
was
answer
following
questions:
1)
age
5–13
yr,
do
fitness
influence
cognition,
learning,
brain
structure,
function?
2)
Among
PA,
education
(PE),
sports
programs
standardized
test
performance
concentration/attention?
Study
Eligibility
Criteria
This
used
primary
source
articles
published
English
peer-reviewed
journals.
Articles
that
presented
data
on,
or
PE/sport
participation
function/structure,
achievement,
concentration/attention
were
included.
Data
Sources
Two
separate
searches
performed
identify
studies
focused
on
function
concentration/attention.
PubMed,
ERIC,
PsychInfo,
SportDiscus,
Scopus,
Web
Science,
Academic
Search
Premier,
Embase
searched
(January
1990–September
2014)
for
met
inclusion
criteria.
Sixty-four
criteria
first
search
(cognition/learning/brain),
73
second
(academic
achievement/concentration).
Appraisal
Synthesis
Methods
grouped
by
design
as
cross-sectional,
longitudinal,
acute,
intervention
trials.
Considerable
heterogeneity
existed
several
important
parameters;
therefore,
results
synthesized
design.
Results
A
majority
research
supports
view
single
bouts
interventions
benefit
children's
functioning.
Limited
evidence
concerning
effects
with
only
one
cross-sectional
meeting
Evidence
indicates
has
a
areas
support
complex
processes
during
laboratory
tasks.
Although
favorable
have
been
obtained
longitudinal
related
controlled
experiments
evaluating
benefits
are
mixed,
additional,
well-designed
needed.
Limitations
review
include
lack
randomized
trials,
limited
adequately
powered,
information
participant
characteristics,
failure
blind
outcome
measures,
proximity
measurement
outcomes,
accountability
known
confounders.
Therefore,
many
ranked
high
risk
bias
because
multiple
limitations.
Conclusions
present
systematic
found
suggest
there
positive
associations
achievement.
However,
findings
inconsistent,
numerous
elements
remain
be
explored,
such
type,
amount,
frequency,
timing.
Many
questions
regarding
how
best
incorporate
within
schools,
breaks
versus
active
lessons
relation
improved
Regardless,
literature
suggests
no
indication
increases
negatively
affect
growth
development
general
health.
On
basis
available,
authors
concluded
well
structure
function;
however,
more
necessary
determine
mechanisms
long-term
effect
strategies
translate
school
environment.
category
rating
B.
PE
neutral
Thus,
limitations
current
C.
British Journal of Sports Medicine,
Год журнала:
2018,
Номер
53(10), С. 640 - 647
Опубликована: Июль 30, 2018
Objective
To
summarise
the
current
evidence
on
effects
of
physical
activity
(PA)
interventions
cognitive
and
academic
performance
in
children,
formulate
research
priorities
recommendations.
Design
Systematic
review
(following
PRISMA
guidelines)
with
a
methodological
quality
assessment
an
international
expert
panel.
We
based
evaluation
consistency
scientific
findings
reported
studies
rated
as
high
quality.
Data
sources
PubMed,
PsycINFO,
Cochrane
Central,
Web
Science,
ERIC,
SPORTDiscus.
Eligibility
criteria
for
selecting
PA-intervention
children
at
least
one
or
assessment.
Results
Eleven
(19%)
58
included
intervention
received
high-quality
rating
quality:
four
assessed
PA
performance,
six
both.
All
contrasted
additional/adapted
activities
regular
curriculum
activities.
For
10
21
(48%)
constructs
analysed
showed
statistically
significant
beneficial
PA,
while
15
25
(60%)
analyses
found
effect
PA.
Across
all
five
assessing
mathematics,
were
out
seven
(86%)
outcomes.
Experts
put
forward
46
questions.
The
most
pressing
priority
cluster
concerned
causality
relationship
between
cognitive/academic
performance.
remaining
clusters
pertained
to
characteristics,
moderators
mechanisms
governing
‘PA–performance’
miscellaneous
topics.
Conclusion
There
is
currently
inconclusive
overall
children.
conclude
that
there
strong
maths
panel
confirmed
more
‘high-quality’
warranted.
By
prioritising
important
questions
formulating
recommendations
we
aim
guide
researchers
generating
evidence.
Our
focus
adequate
control
groups
sample
size,
use
valid
reliable
measurement
instruments
compliance
data
analysis.
PROSPERO
registration
number
CRD42017082505.
The
effect
of
physical
activity
(PA)
on
different
areas
academic
achievement
and
classroom
behaviors
how
characteristics
PA
interventions
could
modify
the
remain
unclear.The
objective
was
twofold:
(1)
to
assess
in
childhood
(2)
determine
individuals
programs
that
enhance
performance.We
identified
studies
from
database
inception
October
16,
2016.We
selected
intervention
aimed
at
examining
exercise
developmental
age.Random-effects
models
were
used
calculate
pooled
size
for
all
primary
outcomes
(language-
mathematics-related
skills,
reading,
composite
score,
time
on-task
behavior).
Positive
values
represent
a
direct
relationship
between
scores
or
behaviors.A
total
26
(10
205
children,
aged
4
13)
included.
Pooled
(95%
confidence
interval)
estimates
as
follows:
0.16
(-0.06
0.37)
language-related
skills;
0.21
(0.09
0.33)
(3)
0.13
(0.02
0.24)
reading;
(4)
0.26
(0.07
0.45)
scores;
(5)
0.77
(0.22
1.32)
behaviors.Limitations
included
variety
tools
measure
limited
number
reported
after-school
interventions.PA,
especially
education,
improves
benefits
several
aspects
achievement,
youth.
Journal of sport and health science/Journal of Sport and Health Science,
Год журнала:
2014,
Номер
4(1), С. 47 - 55
Опубликована: Дек. 24, 2014
Definitive
conclusions
concerning
the
impact
of
exercise
interventions
on
children's
mental
functioning
are
difficult
to
ascertain
because
procedural
differences
among
studies.
A
narrative
review
studies
was
conducted
evaluate
role
two
types
cognition.
Acute
and
chronic
were
classified
as
quantitative
or
qualitative
basis
manipulations
task
complexity
and,
by
inference,
engagement.
Both
enhance
aspects
cognition;
however,
their
effects
metacognitive
processes
unknown.
The
regulation
behavior
academic
performance
highlighted.
Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology,
Год журнала:
2015,
Номер
37(6), С. 575 - 591
Опубликована: Дек. 1, 2015
Although
the
positive
effects
of
different
kinds
physical
activity
(PA)
on
cognitive
functioning
have
already
been
demonstrated
in
a
variety
studies,
role
engagement
promoting
children’s
executive
functions
is
still
unclear.
The
aim
current
study
was
therefore
to
investigate
two
qualitatively
chronic
PA
interventions
primary
school
children.
Children
(
N
=
181)
aged
between
10
and
12
years
were
assigned
either
6-week
education
program
with
high
level
exertion
team
games
),
but
low
aerobic
exercise
or
both
control
condition
).
Executive
(updating,
inhibition,
shifting)
fitness
(multistage
20-m
shuttle
run
test)
measured
before
after
respective
condition.
Results
revealed
that
(team
exercise)
impact
(4–5%
increase
estimated
VO
2
max).
Importantly,
an
improvement
shifting
performance
found
only
not
Thus,
inclusion
seems
be
most
promising
type
intervention
enhance
children,
providing
further
evidence
for
importance
qualitative
aspects
PA.
Psychological Bulletin,
Год журнала:
2019,
Номер
145(7), С. 653 - 697
Опубликована: Апрель 29, 2019
In
the
present
meta-analysis
all
available
evidence
regarding
efficacy
of
different
behavioral
interventions
for
children's
executive
function
skills
were
synthesized.
After
a
systematic
search
we
included
experimental
studies
aiming
to
enhance
(up
12
years
age)
functioning
with
neurodevelopmental
tests
as
outcome
measures.
The
results
100
independent
effect
sizes
in
90
including
data
8,925
children
confirmed
that
it
is
possible
foster
these
childhood
(Diamond
&
Lee,
2011).
We
did
not
find
convincing
evidence,
however,
benefits
remain
on
follow-up
assessment.
Different
approaches
effective
typically
and
nontypically
developing
samples.
For
(including
disorders
or
behavior
problems)
acquiring
new
strategies
self-regulation
biofeedback-enhanced
relaxation
strategy
teaching
programs
most
effective.
found
moderate
beneficial
effects
mindfulness
practices.
Although
small
explicit
training
tasks
loading
form
computerized
noncomputer
found,
consistently
weaker
who
might
actually
be
more
need
such
training.
Thus,
atypically
seem
profit
from
compared
practice
tasks.
propose
does
meaningful
implicitly
functions
are
similarly
effective,
activities
enjoyable
can
easily
embedded
everyday
activities.
(PsycINFO
Database
Record
(c)
2019
APA,
rights
reserved).
British Journal of Sports Medicine,
Год журнала:
2019,
Номер
53(22), С. 1397 - 1404
Опубликована: Фев. 8, 2019
To
synthesise
randomised
controlled
trials
(RCTs)
regarding
the
effects
of
chronic
exercise
interventions
on
different
domain-specific
executive
functions
(EFs)
among
children
and
adolescents.Systematic
review
with
meta-analysis.PsycINFO,
PubMed,
SPORTDiscus,
Academic
Search
Premier,
Embase
Web
Science
were
searched.RCTs
or
cluster
RCT
design,
which
employ
target
healthy
(age
6-12
years)
adolescents
13-17
years).
We
defined
as
physical
activity
(PA)
consists
multiple
sessions
per
week
lasts
for
an
extended
period
time
(typically
over
6
weeks).We
included
19
studies,
a
total
5038
participants.
The
results
showed
that
improved
overall
EFs
(standardised
mean
difference
(SMD)=0.20,
95%
CI
0.09
to
0.30,
p<0.05)
inhibitory
control
(SMD=0.26,
0.08
0.45,
P<0.05).
In
meta
regression,
higher
body
mass
index
was
associated
greater
improvements
in
performance
(β=0.03,
0.0002
0.06,
p<0.05),
whereas
age
duration
not.
subgroup
analysis
by
intervention
modality,
sports
PA
programme
(SMD=0.21,
0.12
0.31,
curricular
(SMD=0.39,
0.69,
performance,
but
integrated
did
not
(SMD=0.02,
-0.05
0.09,
p>0.05).
Interventions
session
length
<
90
minutes
(SMD=0.24,
95%CI
0.10
0.39,
p=0.02),
≥
(SMD=0.05,
-0.03
0.14).
No
other
moderator
found
have
effect.Despite
small
effect
sizes,
interventions,
implemented
settings,
might
be
promising
way
promote
aspects
functions,
especially
control.