Comparative effectiveness of electroencephalogram-neurofeedback training of 3–45 frequency band on memory in healthy population: a network meta-analysis with systematic literature search
Journal of NeuroEngineering and Rehabilitation,
Год журнала:
2025,
Номер
22(1)
Опубликована: Апрель 24, 2025
Abstract
Objective
To
investigate
which
brain
activity
frequency
of
electroencephalogram
(EEG)-neurofeedback
training
(NFT)
was
the
most
effective
for
enhancing
working
memory
(WM)
and
episodic
(EM)
in
healthy
participants
through
network
meta-analysis
(NMA).
Methods
Searched
PubMed,
Embase,
Cochrane
Library
studies
published
from
January
1990
to
2025.
We
performed
Bayesian
NMA,
pooling
continuous
outcome
data
using
standardized
mean
difference
effect
size
(ES).
Global
local
evaluations
inconsistency
were
conducted
chi-square
test,
side-splitting,
loop-specific
approaches.
A
consistency
model
applied
global
approach
showed
no
significance.
Efficacy
ranks
determined
surface
under
cumulative
ranking
curve
(SUCRA)
each
intervention.
Publication
bias
assessed
comparison-adjusted
funnel
plot
Egger’s
test.
Finally,
sensitivity
analysis
confirmed
our
findings’
robustness.
Results
Sixty
included,
comprising
50
trials
on
WM
24
EM.
While
significant
(χ
2
(22)
=
30.89,
p
0.10)
EM
(10)
13.48,
0.19),
exhibited
between
active
control
(AC)
alpha
combined
with
(WMT)
(ES
6.64,
<
0.001)
WM,
AC
0.84,
0.01)
Alpha
WMT
(100%)
NFT
(87.0%)
also
highest
efficacy
according
SUCRA.
No
publication
found
either
type
memory.
The
aligns
original
results.
Conclusion
Through
(7–13
Hz)
may
be
a
crucial
impacting
Brain
other
methods
requires
more
robust
future
investigation.
This
study
registered
www.crd.york.ac.uk/prospero/
(CRD42024539656).
Язык: Английский
Exploring neurofeedback as a therapeutic intervention for subjective cognitive decline
European Journal of Neuroscience,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
60(12), С. 7164 - 7182
Опубликована: Ноя. 26, 2024
Abstract
Impact
statement
This
study
addresses
the
pressing
issue
of
subjective
cognitive
decline
in
aging
populations
by
investigating
neurofeedback
(NFB)
as
a
potential
early
therapeutic
intervention.
By
evaluating
efficacy
individualised
NFB
training
compared
to
standard
protocols,
tailored
each
participant's
EEG
profile,
it
provides
novel
insights
into
personalised
treatment
approaches.
The
incorporation
innovative
elements
and
rigorous
analytical
techniques
contributes
advancing
our
understanding
NFB's
modulatory
effects
on
frequencies
function
individuals.
In
context
an
population,
concerns
surrounding
memory
become
increasingly
prevalent,
particularly
individuals
transition
middle
age
beyond.
investigated
intervention
address
(SCD)
populations.
NFB,
biofeedback
technique
utilising
brain‐computer
interface,
has
demonstrated
promise
various
neurological
psychological
conditions.
Here,
we
evaluated
training,
protocol
aimed
at
increasing
peak
alpha
frequency
power,
enhancing
among
experiencing
SCD.
Our
incorporated
elements,
including
implementation
criterion
for
learning
success
ensure
consistent
achievement
levels
conclusion
sessions.
Additionally,
introduced
non‐learner
group
account
who
do
not
demonstrate
expected
proficiency
regulation.
Analysis
electroencephalographic
(EEG)
signals
during
sessions,
well
before
after
frequencies.
Contrary
expectations,
analysis
revealed
that
ability
with
SCD
modulate
signal
power
duration
specific
was
exclusive
intended
target.
Furthermore,
examination
recorded
using
high‐density
showed
no
discernible
alteration
between
pre‐
post‐NFB
Similarly,
significant
were
observed
questionnaire
scores
when
comparing
assessments.
Язык: Английский