SSRN Electronic Journal,
Год журнала:
2022,
Номер
unknown
Опубликована: Янв. 1, 2022
Background:
Seizure
risk
forecasting
could
reduce
injuries
and
even
deaths
in
people
with
epilepsy.
There
is
great
interest
using
non-invasive
wearable
devices
to
generate
forecasts
of
seizure
risk.
Forecasts
based
on
cycles
epileptic
activity,
times
or
heart
rate
have
provided
promising
results.
This
study
validates
a
method
multimodal
recorded
from
devices.
Methods:
were
extracted
13
participants.
The
mean
period
data
smartwatch
was
562
days,
125
self-reported
seizures
smartphone
app.
relationship
between
onset
time
phases
investigated.
An
additive
regression
model
used
project
cycles.
results
cycles,
combination
both
compared.
Forecasting
performance
evaluated
6/13
participants
prospective
setting,
long-term
collected
after
algorithms
developed.Findings:
showed
that
the
best
achieved
area
under
receiver-operating
characteristic
curve
(AUC)
0.71
9/13
showing
above
chance.
Subject-specific
AUC
0.77
4/6
chance.Interpretation:
this
demonstrate
detected
can
be
combined
within
single,
scalable
algorithm
provide
accurate
robust
performance.
presented
enabled
estimated
for
an
arbitrary
future
generalized
across
range
types.
In
contrast
earlier
work,
current
prospectively,
subjects
blinded
their
outputs,
representing
critical
step
towards
clinical
applications.Funding
Information:
funded
by
Australian
Government
National
Health
Medical
Research
Council
BioMedTech
Horizons
grant.
also
received
support
Epilepsy
Foundation
America's
'My
Gauge'
grant.Declaration
Interests:
Dr.
Brinkmann
reports
grants
America,
My
Gauge,
during
conduct
study;
other
Cadence
Neurosciences,
outside
submitted
work
15
Stirling
Training
Program
Scholarship,
Karoly
(NHMRC),
personal
fees
Seer
Medical,
work;
addition,
has
patent
Methods
Systems
issued.
Cook
Australia,
Epi
Minder,
Nurse
MTPConnect,
Freestone
USA,
Richardson
All
authors
no
interests
disclose.Ethics
Approval
Statement:
approved
St
Vincent's
Hospital
Human
Ethics
Committee
(HREC
009.19)
all
written
informed
consent.
Nature Communications,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
15(1)
Опубликована: Авг. 13, 2024
Abstract
Epilepsy
is
defined
by
the
abrupt
emergence
of
harmful
seizures,
but
nature
these
regime
shifts
remains
enigmatic.
From
perspective
dynamical
systems
theory,
such
critical
transitions
occur
upon
inconspicuous
perturbations
in
highly
interconnected
and
can
be
modeled
as
mathematical
bifurcations
between
alternative
regimes.
The
predictability
represents
a
major
challenge,
theory
predicts
appearance
subtle
signatures
on
verge
instability.
Whether
measured
before
impending
seizures
uncertain.
Here,
we
verified
that
predictions
applied
to
onset
hippocampal
providing
concordant
results
from
silico
modeling,
optogenetics
experiments
male
mice
intracranial
EEG
recordings
human
patients
with
epilepsy.
Leveraging
pharmacological
control
over
neural
excitability,
showed
boundary
physiological
excitability
inferred
passively
recorded
or
actively
probed
circuits.
Of
importance
for
design
future
neurotechnologies,
active
probing
surpassed
passive
recording
decode
underlying
levels
notably
when
assessed
network
propagating
responses.
Our
findings
provide
promising
approach
predicting
preventing
based
sound
understanding
their
dynamics.
Scientific Reports,
Год журнала:
2023,
Номер
13(1)
Опубликована: Апрель 11, 2023
Abstract
The
development
of
seizure
prediction
models
is
often
based
on
long-term
scalp
electroencephalograms
(EEGs)
since
they
capture
brain
electrical
activity,
are
non-invasive,
and
come
at
a
relatively
low-cost.
However,
suffer
from
major
shortcomings.
First,
EEG
usually
highly
contaminated
with
artefacts.
Second,
changes
in
the
signal
over
long
intervals,
known
as
concept
drift,
neglected.
We
evaluate
influence
these
problems
deep
neural
networks
using
time
series
shallow
widely-used
features.
Our
patient-specific
were
tested
1577
hours
continuous
EEG,
containing
91
seizures
41
patients
temporal
lobe
epilepsy
who
undergoing
pre-surgical
monitoring.
results
showed
that
cleaning
data,
previously
developed
artefact
removal
method
convolutional
networks,
improved
performance.
also
found
retraining
reduced
false
predictions.
Furthermore,
show
although
processing
less
susceptible
to
alarms,
may
need
more
data
surpass
feature-based
methods.
These
findings
highlight
importance
robust
denoising
periodic
adaptation
models.
Abstract
Objective
Seizure
unpredictability
can
be
debilitating
and
dangerous
for
people
with
epilepsy.
Accurate
seizure
forecasters
could
improve
quality
of
life
those
epilepsy
but
must
practical
long‐term
use.
This
study
presents
the
first
validation
a
seizure‐forecasting
system
using
ultra‐long‐term,
non‐invasive
wearable
data.
Methods
Eleven
participants
were
recruited
continuous
monitoring,
capturing
heart
rate
step
count
via
wrist‐worn
devices
seizures
electroencephalography
(average
recording
duration
337
days).
Two
hybrid
models—combining
machine
learning
cycle‐based
methods—were
proposed
to
forecast
at
both
short
(minutes)
long
(up
44
days)
horizons.
Results
The
Warning
System
(SWS),
designed
forecasting
near‐term
seizures,
Risk
(SRS),
risk,
outperformed
traditional
models.
In
addition,
SRS
reduced
high‐risk
time
by
29%
while
increasing
sensitivity
11%.
Significance
These
improvements
mark
significant
advancement
in
making
more
effective.
EBioMedicine,
Год журнала:
2023,
Номер
93, С. 104656 - 104656
Опубликована: Июнь 16, 2023
BackgroundSeizure
risk
forecasting
could
reduce
injuries
and
even
deaths
in
people
with
epilepsy.
There
is
great
interest
using
non-invasive
wearable
devices
to
generate
forecasts
of
seizure
risk.
Forecasts
based
on
cycles
epileptic
activity,
times
or
heart
rate
have
provided
promising
results.
This
study
validates
a
method
multimodal
recorded
from
devices.MethodSeizure
were
extracted
13
participants.
The
mean
period
data
smartwatch
was
562
days,
125
self-reported
seizures
smartphone
app.
relationship
between
onset
time
phases
investigated.
An
additive
regression
model
used
project
cycles.
results
cycles,
combination
both
compared.
Forecasting
performance
evaluated
6
participants
prospective
setting,
long-term
collected
after
algorithms
developed.FindingsThe
showed
that
the
best
achieved
area
under
receiver-operating
characteristic
curve
(AUC)
0.73
for
9/13
showing
above
chance
during
retrospective
validation.
Subject-specific
AUC
0.77
4/6
chance.InterpretationThe
this
demonstrate
detected
can
be
combined
within
single,
scalable
algorithm
provide
robust
performance.
presented
enabled
estimated
an
arbitrary
future
generalised
across
range
types.
In
contrast
earlier
work,
current
prospectively,
subjects
blinded
their
outputs,
representing
critical
step
towards
clinical
applications.FundingThis
funded
by
Australian
Government
National
Health
&
Medical
Research
Council
BioMedTech
Horizons
grant.
also
received
support
Epilepsy
Foundation
America's
'My
Seizure
Gauge'
Epilepsy & Behavior,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
157, С. 109876 - 109876
Опубликована: Июнь 7, 2024
Over
recent
years,
there
has
been
a
growing
interest
in
exploring
the
utility
of
seizure
risk
forecasting,
particularly
how
it
could
improve
quality
life
for
people
living
with
epilepsy.
This
study
reports
on
user
experiences
and
perspectives
forecaster
app,
as
well
potential
impact
mood
adjustment
to
A
lot
of
mileage
has
been
made
recently
on
the
long
and
winding
road
toward
seizure
forecasting.
Here
we
briefly
review
some
selected
milestones
passed
along
way,
which
were
discussed
at
International
Conference
for
Technology
Analysis
Seizures-ICTALS
2022-convened
University
Bern,
Switzerland.
Major
impetus
was
gained
from
wearable
implantable
devices
that
record
not
only
electroencephalography,
but
also
data
motor
behavior,
acoustic
signals,
various
signals
autonomic
nervous
system.
This
multimodal
monitoring
can
be
performed
ultralong
timescales
covering
months
or
years.
Accordingly,
features
metrics
extracted
these
now
assess
dynamics
with
a
greater
degree
completeness.
Most
prominently,
this
allowed
confirmation
long-suspected
cyclical
nature
interictal
epileptiform
activity,
risk,
seizures.
The
cover
daily,
multi-day,
yearly
cycles.
Progress
fueled
by
approaches
originating
interdisciplinary
field
network
science.
Considering
epilepsy
as
large-scale
disorder
yielded
novel
perspectives
pre-ictal
evolving
epileptic
brain.
In
addition
to
discrete
predictions
will
take
place
in
specified
prediction
horizon,
community
broadened
scope
probabilistic
forecasts
risk
continuously
time.
shift
gears
triggered
incorporation
additional
quantify
performance
forecasting
algorithms,
should
compared
chance
constrained
stochastic
null
models.
An
imminent
task
utmost
importance
is
find
optimal
ways
communicate
output
seizure-forecasting
algorithms
patients,
caretakers,
clinicians,
so
they
have
socioeconomic
impact
improve
patients'
well-being.
Epilepsia Open,
Год журнала:
2023,
Номер
8(2), С. 285 - 297
Опубликована: Апрель 19, 2023
Many
state-of-the-art
methods
for
seizure
prediction,
using
the
electroencephalogram,
are
based
on
machine
learning
models
that
black
boxes,
weakening
trust
of
clinicians
in
them
high-risk
decisions.
Seizure
prediction
concerns
a
multidimensional
time-series
problem
performs
continuous
sliding
window
analysis
and
classification.
In
this
work,
we
make
critical
review
which
explanations
increase
models'
decisions
predicting
seizures.
We
developed
three
methodologies
to
explore
their
explainability
potential.
These
contain
different
levels
model
transparency:
logistic
regression,
an
ensemble
15
support
vector
machines,
convolutional
neural
networks.
For
each
methodology,
evaluated
quasi-prospectively
performance
40
patients
(testing
data
comprised
2055
hours
104
seizures).
selected
with
good
poor
explain
Then,
grounded
theory,
how
these
helped
specialists
(data
scientists
working
epilepsy)
understand
obtained
dynamics.
four
lessons
better
communication
between
clinicians.
found
goal
is
not
system's
but
improve
system
itself.
Model
transparency
most
significant
factor
explaining
decision
prediction.
Even
when
intuitive
features,
it
hard
brain
dynamics
relationship
models.
achieve
understanding
by
developing,
parallel,
several
systems
explicitly
deal
signal
changes
help
develop
complete
formulation.
Scientific Reports,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
14(1)
Опубликована: Март 7, 2024
Epilepsy
affects
around
1%
of
the
population
worldwide.
Anti-epileptic
drugs
are
an
excellent
option
for
controlling
seizure
occurrence
but
do
not
work
one-third
patients.
Warning
devices
employing
prediction
or
forecasting
algorithms
could
bring
patients
new-found
comfort
and
quality
life.
These
would
attempt
to
detect
a
seizure's
preictal
period,
transitional
moment
between
regular
brain
activity
seizure,
relay
this
information
user.
Over
years,
many
studies
using
Electroencephalogram-based
methodologies
have
been
developed,
triggering
alarm
when
detecting
period.
Recent
suggested
shift
in
view
from
forecasting.
Seizure
takes
probabilistic
approach
problem
question
instead
crisp
prediction.
In
field
study,
triggered
symbolize
detection
period
is
substituted
by
constant
risk
assessment
analysis.
The
present
aims
explore
capable
establish
comparison
with
results.
Using
40
EPILEPSIAE
database,
we
developed
several
patient-specific
different
classifiers
(a
Logistic
Regression,
15
Support
Vector
Machines
ensemble,
Shallow
Neural
Networks
ensemble).
Results
show
increase
sensitivity
relative
up
146%
number
that
displayed
improvement
over
chance
300%.
results
suggest
methodology
may
be
more
suitable
warning
than
one.
Epilepsy
is
characterized
by
spontaneous
seizures
that
recur
at
unexpected
times.
Nonetheless,
using
years-long
electroencephalographic
(EEG)
recordings,
we
previously
found
patient-reported
consistently
occur
when
interictal
epileptiform
activity
(IEA)
cyclically
builds
up
over
days.
This
multidien
(multiday)
interictal-ictal
relationship,
which
shared
across
patients,
may
bear
phasic
information
for
forecasting
seizures,
even
if
individual
patterns
of
seizure
timing
are
unknown.
To
test
this
rigorously
in
a
large
retrospective
dataset,
pretrained
algorithms
on
data
recorded
from
group
and
forecasted
other,
unseen
patients.We
used
long-term
participants
(N
=
159)
the
RNS
System
clinical
trials,
including
intracranial
EEG
recordings
(icEEG),
two
UNEEG
Medical
trial
subscalp
system
(sqEEG).
Based
IEA
detections,
extracted
instantaneous
phases
trained
generalized
linear
models
(GLMs)
recurrent
neural
networks
(RNNs)
to
forecast
probability
occurrence
24-h
horizon.With
GLMs
RNNs,
could
be
above
chance
79%
81%
subjects
with
median
discrimination
area
under
curve
(AUC)
.70
.69
Brier
skill
score
(BSS)
.07
.08.
In
direct
comparison,
individualized
had
similar
performance
(AUC
.67,
BSS
.08),
but
fewer
(60%).
Moreover,
calibration
maintained
accommodate
different
rates
subjects.Our
findings
suggest
based
cycles
can
generalize
drastically
reduce
amount
needed
issue
forecasts
individuals
who
recently
started
collecting
chronic
data.
addition,
show
generalization
independent
method
record
(patient-reported
vs.
electrographic)
or
(icEEG
sqEEG).