Assessing the Utility of Organoid Intelligence: Scientific and Ethical Perspectives DOI Creative Commons
Michael W. Nestor, Richard L. Wilson

Organoids, Год журнала: 2025, Номер 4(2), С. 9 - 9

Опубликована: Май 1, 2025

The development of brain organoids from human-induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) has expanded research into neurodevelopment, disease modeling, and drug testing. More recently, the concept organoid intelligence (OI) emerged, proposing that these constructs could evolve to support learning, memory, or even sentience. While this perspective driven enthusiasm in field suggested new applications fields such as neuromorphic computing, it also introduces significant scientific conceptual concerns. Current lack anatomical complexity, network organization, sensorimotor integration necessary for Despite this, claims surrounding OI often rely on oversimplified interpretations neural activity, fueled by neurorealist reification biases misattribute neurophysiological properties biologically limited systems. Beyond limitations, framing risks imposing ethical regulatory challenges based speculative concerns rather than empirical evidence. assumption might possess sentience, develop over time, lead unnecessary restrictions legitimate while misrepresenting their actual capabilities. Additionally, comparing biological systems silicon-based computing overlooks fundamental differences scalability, efficiency, predictability, raising questions about whether can meaningfully contribute computational advancements. must recognize limitations models prematurely defining a distinct domain. A more cautious, evidence-driven approach is ensure remain valuable tools neuroscience without overstating potential. To maintain credibility public trust, essential separate narratives grounded research, thus allowing continued progress studies reinforcing misconceptions

Язык: Английский

Engineering organoids as cerebral disease models DOI Creative Commons
Alexander Geidies,

Marija Lj Medar,

Hannes M. Beyer

и другие.

Current Opinion in Biotechnology, Год журнала: 2025, Номер 92, С. 103253 - 103253

Опубликована: Янв. 14, 2025

Cerebral organoids pioneered in replicating complex brain tissue architectures vitro, offering a vast potential for human disease modeling. They enable the vitro study of physiological and pathophysiological mechanisms various neurological diseases disorders. The trajectory technological advancements organoid generation engineering over past decade indicates that technology might, future, mature into indispensable solutions at horizon personalized regenerative medicine. In this review, we highlight recent advances as models discuss some challenges opportunities future research rapidly evolving field.

Язык: Английский

Процитировано

1

Brain organoids: A new tool for modelling of neurodevelopmental disorders DOI Creative Commons
Yirizhati Aili, Nuersimanguli Maimaitiming, Zengliang Wang

и другие.

Journal of Cellular and Molecular Medicine, Год журнала: 2024, Номер 28(17)

Опубликована: Сен. 1, 2024

Abstract Neurodevelopmental disorders are mostly studied using mice as models. However, the mouse brain lacks similar cell types and structures those of human brain. In recent years, emergence three‐dimensional organoids derived from embryonic stem cells or induced pluripotent allows for controlled monitoring evaluation early neurodevelopmental processes has opened a window studying various aspects development. such lack original anatomical structure during maturation, maturation that rely on unique cellular interactions neural network connections limited. Consequently, difficult to be used extensively effectively while modelling later stages development disease progression. To address this problem, several methods technologies have emerged aim enhance sophisticated regulation developmental through bioengineering approaches, which may alleviate some current limitations. This review discusses advances application areas organoid culture methods, aiming generalize optimization strategies systems, improve ability mimic development, value organoids.

Язык: Английский

Процитировано

3

Assessing the Utility of Organoid Intelligence: Scientific and Ethical Perspectives DOI Creative Commons
Michael W. Nestor, Richard L. Wilson

Organoids, Год журнала: 2025, Номер 4(2), С. 9 - 9

Опубликована: Май 1, 2025

The development of brain organoids from human-induced pluripotent stem cells (iPSCs) has expanded research into neurodevelopment, disease modeling, and drug testing. More recently, the concept organoid intelligence (OI) emerged, proposing that these constructs could evolve to support learning, memory, or even sentience. While this perspective driven enthusiasm in field suggested new applications fields such as neuromorphic computing, it also introduces significant scientific conceptual concerns. Current lack anatomical complexity, network organization, sensorimotor integration necessary for Despite this, claims surrounding OI often rely on oversimplified interpretations neural activity, fueled by neurorealist reification biases misattribute neurophysiological properties biologically limited systems. Beyond limitations, framing risks imposing ethical regulatory challenges based speculative concerns rather than empirical evidence. assumption might possess sentience, develop over time, lead unnecessary restrictions legitimate while misrepresenting their actual capabilities. Additionally, comparing biological systems silicon-based computing overlooks fundamental differences scalability, efficiency, predictability, raising questions about whether can meaningfully contribute computational advancements. must recognize limitations models prematurely defining a distinct domain. A more cautious, evidence-driven approach is ensure remain valuable tools neuroscience without overstating potential. To maintain credibility public trust, essential separate narratives grounded research, thus allowing continued progress studies reinforcing misconceptions

Язык: Английский

Процитировано

0