This article suggests that there is a mobility bias in migration research: by focusing on the “drivers” of migration — the forces that lead to the initiation and perpetuation of migration flows — migration theories neglect the countervailing structural and personal forces that restrict or resist these drivers and lead to different immobility outcomes. To advance a research agenda on immobility, it offers a definition of immobility, further develops the aspiration-capability framework as an analytical tool for exploring the determinants of different forms of (im)mobility, synthesizes decades of interdisciplinary research to help explain why people do not migrate or desire …
Climate and Development,
Год журнала:
2020,
Номер
13(4), С. 348 - 359
Опубликована: Июль 17, 2020
This
article
uses
storytelling
methodology
to
investigate
the
connections
between
urban
climate-induced
loss
of
wellbeing
and
(im)mobility
in
Bhola
Slum,
an
informal
settlement
Dhaka,
Bangladesh.
The
houses
Internally
Displaced
People
from
southern
coast
who
built
named
slum
after
their
home
-
Island.
sessions
revealed
that
belonging,
identity,
quality
life
social
value
produced
people
a
desire
return.
Nostalgic
storylines
also
shaped
narratives
children
born
often
referred
island
as
home.
Some
women
felt
move
had
resulted
more
liberty,
but
claimed
it
increased
risk
punishment
stigmatisation.
Social
stigma
extended
parents
children.
More
than
men
reported
feeling
unsafe,
depressed
anxious.
Mental
physical
ill
health
were
both
common
consequences
compromised
living
working
conditions
slum.
Loss
(due
injuries
or
disease)
damaged
people's
pushed
already
fragile
families
into
downward
spiral
with
no
escape.
Few
empirical
studies
'trapped'
populations
non-economic
losses
damages
environments.
insights
gained
this
work
can
therefore
help
safeguard
vulnerable
worldwide
build
robust
climate
policy
frameworks.
Mobilities,
Год журнала:
2019,
Номер
14(4), С. 484 - 499
Опубликована: Июнь 2, 2019
There
is
now
a
large
literature
discussing
how
mobilities
are
part
of
contemporary
everyday
power
geometries
and
resource
to
which
people
have
unequal
access.
This
body
work
has,
thus,
valorised
mobility
as
desirable
good.
Why
some
choose
immobility
what
has
be
mobilised
enable
this
received
much
less
attention.
paper
draws
on
interviews
with
international
distance
education
students
in
Namibia
Zimbabwe
studying
at
the
University
South
Africa
(UNISA)
explore
spatio-temporal
underpinnings
why
remain
home
while
abroad
arranged.
It
outlines
infrastructures
reach
that
student
their
incomplete
nature
means
rely
extensive
systems
other
objects
ensure
study
progresses
without
own
educational
mobility.
In
doing
so
we
move
away
from
considering
result
limited
access
Instead,
set
out
new
research
agenda
immobilities
important
research.
Regional Environmental Change,
Год журнала:
2021,
Номер
21(2)
Опубликована: Апрель 29, 2021
Abstract
Why
do
communities
prefer
to
stay
in
place
despite
potentially
dangerous
changes
their
environment,
even
when
governmental
support
for
outmigration
or
resettlement
is
provided?
That
the
key
question
this
paper
seeks
answer.
Voluntary
immobility
a
burgeoning
research
topic
environmental
change-related
migration
studies,
although
role
of
local
sense-making
perceived
risks
and
pressures
has
received
only
little
attention.
In
order
examine
decisions
non-migration,
we
argue
that
need
consider
people’s
ontological
security,
subjective
sense
existential
safety,
which
shapes
risk
perceptions.
We
apply
case
Villa
Santa
Lucía
Chilean
Patagonia,
where
population
rejected
relocation
policies
after
village
was
severely
damaged
by
mudslide
December
2017.
show
how
rejection
not
based
on
lack
abilities
move,
but
fundamentally
different
assessment
grounded
locally
specific
social
representations
nature
human-nature
relations.
This
alternative
understanding
allows
uphold
security
while
remaining
Lucía,
renders
avoid
exposure
natural
hazards
futile
inconsistent
with
identities.
conclude
an
important
component
more
fine-grained
non-migration
decisions.
Planned
Relocation
is
a
form
of
mobility
in
response
to
climate-related
shocks
and
slow
onset
change.
While
the
primary
focus
seminal
Foresight
report
on
Migration
Environmental
Change
dealt
with
processes
migration
displacement,
planned
relocation
was
discussed
as
viable,
yet
fraught
adaptation
strategy.
Since
publication
2011,
considerable
research
into
has
progressed
understanding,
part
due
emerging
case
study
examples
globally
over
last
10
years.
The
authors
this
article
have
undertaken
communities
across
Australia
Fiji
who
initiated
processes,
varying
degrees
completion
success.
As
Research
Topic—Climate
Policy
Connections:
Progress
Report—in
we
look
back
at
lessons
that
emerged
from
report,
provide
key
insights
our
experiences,
well
through
drawing
broader
literature,
doing
so
offer
learned,
policy
for
these
regions,
beyond.
This
especially
relevant
given
context
two
nations:
Australia,
country
experienced
severe
fires
flooding
events
few
years,
which
raised
important
questions
around
role
may
play
future
national
discussions
planning,
buy-back
schemes
occurring
country;
Fiji,
forefront
globally,
800
listed
need
by
Government
numerous
cases
completed,
emerging.
Primary
findings
indicate:
there
are
people
choosing
remain
sites
exposure
despite
plans,
making
notion
“voluntariness”
essential;
potential
be
successful
option
if
strong
participatory
governance;
think
broadly
holistically
needs
livelihoods
effected
planning;
longitudinal
studies
track
implications
impacts
(both
positive
negative)
long
term.
Abstract
Non-technical
summary
We
identify
a
set
of
essential
recent
advances
in
climate
change
research
with
high
policy
relevance,
across
natural
and
social
sciences:
(1)
looming
inevitability
implications
overshooting
the
1.5°C
warming
limit,
(2)
urgent
need
for
rapid
managed
fossil
fuel
phase-out,
(3)
challenges
scaling
carbon
dioxide
removal,
(4)
uncertainties
regarding
future
contribution
sinks,
(5)
intertwinedness
crises
biodiversity
loss
change,
(6)
compound
events,
(7)
mountain
glacier
loss,
(8)
human
immobility
face
risks,
(9)
adaptation
justice,
(10)
just
transitions
food
systems.
Technical
The
Intergovernmental
Panel
on
Climate
Change
Assessment
Reports
provides
scientific
foundation
international
negotiations
constitutes
an
unmatched
resource
researchers.
However,
assessment
cycles
take
multiple
years.
As
to
cross-
interdisciplinary
understanding
diverse
communities,
we
have
streamlined
annual
process
synthesize
significant
advances.
collected
input
from
experts
various
fields
using
online
questionnaire
prioritized
10
key
insights
relevance.
This
year,
focus
on:
overshoot
urgency
scale-up
joint
governance
accelerated
amidst
present
succinct
account
these
insights,
reflect
their
implications,
offer
integrated
policy-relevant
messages.
science
synthesis
communication
effort
is
also
basis
report
contributing
elevate
every
year
time
United
Nations
Conference.
Social
media
highlight
–
more
than
200
experts.