Ecological Insights From Camera Trapping Span Biological Taxa, and the Globe
Ecology and Evolution,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
15(2)
Published: Feb. 1, 2025
Camera
trap
research
has
grown
to
encompass
the
globe,
with
applications
in
terrestrial,
marine,
and
aquatic
environments.
Insights
on
plant,
invertebrate,
vertebrate
communities
are
rapidly
expanding
our
knowledge
of
ecological
systems.
A
technological
revolution
was
launched
by
advancements
camera
trapping
(Kucera
Barrett
2011;
O'Connell,
Nichols,
Karanth
2011).
"Trapping"
an
observation
a
species
its
environment
at
fixed
place
time
allowed
scientists
sample
widening
range
taxa
ecosystems.
With
application
appropriate
sampling
designs
statistical
models
(Burton
et
al.
2015),
have
been
able
answer
questions
never
before
possible.
Mammal
ecologists
were
early
adopters,
taking
advantage
passive
heat-in-motion
detectors
developed
2000s
homeotherms
(Finn
2005;
Vercauteren,
Smith,
Stevenson
2005).
The
development
larger
memory
cards
long-lasting
power
enabled
use
repeated
time-lapse
photography
for
ectotherms
vegetation,
now
insights
derived
from
traps
span
biological
hierarchies.
In
this
special
issue
Ecology
Evolution,
we
invited
camera-trap
papers
around
globe
showcase
depth
breadth
applications.
We
particularly
aimed
representation
global
south,
which
rich
heretofore
relatively
untapped
potential
compared
north
(Steenweg
2017;
Agha
2018;
Fisher
2023;
Mugerwa
2024).
some
great
versatility
scientific
they
offer
(Figure
1).
provide
unique
into
species'
behaviour,
as
allow
observations
without
intrusive
effects
in-person
observer
(Caravaggi
2017,
2020).
Research
aspects
such
parental
investment
offspring
care,
can
shed
new
light.
Antarctic,
Adélie
penguins
(Pygoscelis
adeliae)
reproduction
varies
environmental
factors,
but
also
degree
maternal
building
nests,
limited
resources
(stones)
(McLatchie
revealed
that
occupying
nests
earlier,
resulting
earlier
clutch
initiation,
associated
high-quality
increased
reproductive
success.
Larger
advantageous
successful
breeding,
these
more
likely
be
created
built
Environmental
factors
mediated
relationship,
innovative
study
illustrates
what
emerge
future
combines
behaviour
heterogeneity.
Behaviour
is
important
part
risk
avoidance,
many
studies
showing
humans
impose
perceived
mammals,
even
via
non-consumptive
activities
recreation
(Taylor
Knight
2003;
Larson
2016).
British
Columbia,
Canada,
Fennell
(2023)
examined
spatiotemporal
avoidance
eight
large
mammals
alpine
protected
area.
They
observed
spatial
co-occurrence
between
ungulates
consistent
human
shield
hypothesis
(Berger
2007),
not
expected
consequent
segregation
carnivores
humans;
instead,
(and
herbivores)
temporally
displaced
recreationists
(Fennell
2023).
Scaling
up
(sensu
Steenweg
(2017))
landscape
10
landscapes
across
Canadian
west,
Granados
conducted
similar
analysis.
used
hierarchical
quantify
influence
(roads
logging)
ungulate
carnivore
site
use.
Across
vast
heterogeneous
space,
found
support
hypothesis,
positive
negative
responses
disturbance
(Granados
signal
temporal
ran
contrary
predictions,
overlap
people
deer
road
density.
Such
macroecological
studies—made
possible
networking
arrays
(Gallo
2019;
Fidino
2021;
Barnas
2024)–are
revealing
much
about
large-scale
departures
phenomena
smaller
scales.
Territorial
defence
another
behavioural
mechanism
minimised,
sometimes
means
scent-marking.
Previously,
most
scent-marking
focused
transmitting
individual,
receivers
harder
observe;
filled
gap.
northern
Botswana,
latrines
scent-marked
African
wild
dogs
(Lycaon
pictus)
classify
behaviours
sniffing
(less
aggressive
response)
or
overmarking
(aggressive
(Claase
Wild
exhibited
"dear
enemy"
response
competitors,
less
neighbours
than
strangers.
This
changed
increasing
size
responding
pack,
switching
strongly
neighbour
scent
marks
("nasty
hypothesis")
Animals'
activity
pattern
component
illuminated
traps,
continuously
through
diel
cycle
(Frey
2017).
Rhode
Island,
USA,
Mayer
multi-state
occupancy-modelling
framework
informed
data
investigate
how
14
mammal
responded
anthropogenic
development.
All
respect
magnitude
season,
illustrating
plasticity
trait,
adaptation
(Mayer
body
complexity
species-human
interactions
their
changing
contexts,
marked
challenge
coming
century.
One
greatest
strengths
ability
observe
multiple
syntopic
simultaneously
(Rovero
Zimmermann
2016)–as
opposed
GPS
collars,
typically
restricted
one
two
species.
Thus,
community
composition
like
before;
being
done
regions
previously
rarely
researched.
Nepal,
Regmi
native
occurrence
forest
cover
livestock
detections
while
declining
proximity
settlements.
provided
15
studied
species,
including
blue
sheep
(Pseudois
nayaur)
giant
flying
squirrels
(Petaurista
magnificus)
relationships
diverse
understudied
region
(Regmi
South
Africa,
live
uneasy
coexistence,
competing
subject
intraguild
mortality.
placed
elephant
(Loxodonta
Africana)
carcasses
association
shared
peak
periods
black-backed
jackals
(Lupulella
mesomelas)
spotted
hyaenas
(Crocuta
crocuta),
indicating
resource
sharing
(Honiball
Conversely,
analysis
showed
lions
(Panthera
leo),
suggesting
latter
dominates
scavenging
opportunities.
Parsing
apart
dominance
dynamics
key
area
investigation
facilitated
Serengeti
National
Park,
Tanzania,
van
den
Bosch
aardwolves
(Proteles
cristata)
aardvarks
(Orycteropus
afer)—both
nocturnal
insectivores—to
examine
competitors.
fact,
multispecies
occupancy
modelling
high
evidence
commensals:
increase
food
accessibility
(van
Mozambique's
Gorongosa
Grabowski,
Phillips,
Gaynor
(2024)
explore
patterns
niche
partitioning
among
mesocarnivores:
large-spotted
genet
(Genetta
maculata),
civet
(Civettictis
civetta),
honey
badger
(Mellivora
capensis),
marsh
mongoose
(Atilax
paludinosus).
Statistical
analyses
no
and,
indicated
civets
mongooses,
competition
syntopy
different
diets
(Grabowski,
Differing
outcomes
ecosystems
reveal
ways
strategies
affect
coexistence.
Many
modern
contain
invasive
major
threat
biodiversity
(Rosenzweig
2001).
Tianjin,
China,
Li
generalised
additive
mixed
see
(Canis
lupus
familiaris
Felis
silvestris)
three
indigenous
(Siberian
weasels,
Mustela
sibirica;
Amur
hedgehogs
Erinaceus
amurensis,
Tolai
hares,
Lepus
tolai)
densities
along
gradient
urbanisation.
Densities
cats,
urbanisation,
green
spaces
urban
areas
predictors
density
(Li
2023)–a
critical
finding
when
growing
(Seto
Simkin
2022).
urbanisation
effect
Australia
Alting
dingoes
dingo).
sought
dispersion
suggests
concentrated
should
shrink
home-range
sizes.
Both
corroborated
dingoes,
subsidies
(Alting
2024),
repercussions
Australian
non-native
diversity
(Johnson,
Isaac,
2007).
Prior
predator–prey
ecology
largely
radiocollar
predation
rates
predator
prey
(or
both)
observed.
discern
until
capability
bridged
design
how–for
example–anthropogenic
extraction
affects
predators
space
time.
Boczulak
deployed
western
Alberta,
Canada
wolves
lupus)
avoid
features
extraction,
presumably
due
risk—unless
occur
those
patches,
point
switch
strong
selection
features.
interaction
novel
availability
understanding
respond
change
(Boczulak
cougars
(Puma
concolor)
eastern
Cougars
positively
only
prey—particularly
snowshoe
hares
(Lepus
americanus)
(Gaston
Invasive
white-tailed
(Odocoileus
virginianus)
played
discernible
role,
defying
predictions
difficult
it
extrapolate
conclusions
within
same
guild.
Scavenging,
case
interactions,
prime
research,
yield
competition.
northeastern
Norway,
Lacombe
asymmetric
Arctic
fox
(Vulpes
lagopus)
red
vulpes)
sites
supplied
carrion.
tended
occupied
heterospecific,
either
clearly
benefitting.
Geographic
variation
rodent
(prey)
abundance
affected
dynamics,
yielding
delicate
interplay
potentially
cold
systems
(Lacombe
There
inherent
trapping,
so
threatened
endangered
Mortality
always
concern,
moreover,
catchability
often
declines
rarity.
non-invasive
sampler
rare
United
Kingdom
(UK),
Shannon,
Valle,
Shuttleworth
monitor
squirrel
(Sciurus
vulgaris)
populations,
image-capture
rate
correlated
well
live-capture
rate.
identify
characteristics
greater
inform
conservation
planning,
crucial
UK's
deforested
(Shannon,
Climate
generate
wholesale
changes
distributions
(Pereira,
Navarro,
Martins
2012),
devoted
adapt
(Boutin
Lane
2014).
Among
pelage
primary
variably
snowy
environments,
arise
whether
phenological
mismatches
snow
may
occur.
Stokes
network
mountain
hare
timidus)
coat
colour
climatic
gradients.
Mountain
higher
latitudes
altitudes
retained
winter
white
coats
longer
did
lower
altitudes.
Moreover,
coastal
climates
inland
variable
conditions
(Stokes
spans
marine
well,
continuous
video
feed
commonly
"trap"
(Willis,
Millar,
Babcock
2000;
Whitmarsh,
Fairweather,
Huveneers
Bulger,
Volpe,
2019).
Red
Sea
coral
reef,
Lilkendey
feeding
mechanics
foraging
energy
expenditure
herbivorous
brown
surgeonfish
(Acanthurus
nigrofuscus)
yellowtail
tang
(Zebrasoma
xanthurum).
Here,
"camera
trapping"
included
remote
underwater
stereo
processed
AI-driven
recognition,
classification,
3D
tracking.
exerted
grazing
pressure
reef
spite
low
biomass.
Brown
specialist
strategy,
tangs
generalist
differentiation
maintaining
efficiency.
combination
assisting
technologies
showcases
revolutionary
biotic
sensing
environments
(Lilkendey
Exciting
opportunities
lay
land-water
interface.
Sullivan,
Rittenhouse,
Vokoun
cold-water
patches
riverine
These
refuges
aggregators
fish
seeking
thermal
refuges,
there
become
susceptible
Avian
mammalian
pervasive
concentrate
(Sullivan,
southern
Mexico,
Delgado-Martínez
ephemeral
water
bodies
birds
seasonally
dry
tropical
forests.
surface
pools
tree
holes
recorded
behaviour.
Terrestrial
preferentially
bodies,
whereas
arboreal
scansorial
small
medium
common
bodies;
complementary
sources
thus
facilitate
gamma
(Delgado-Martínez
Finland,
Holopainen
artificial
(with
eggs)
wetlands
ground-nesting
boreal
ducks.
Predation
surrounded
agricultural
land
forested
land.
Shoreline
had
further
away
contribute
duck
population
Finland
(Holopainen
summary,
work
illuminates
importance
spanning
interface,
ripe
discoveries.
Homeothermic
focus
taxonomic
camera-based
inquiry
expanded
greatly
frequent
timelapse
photos.
plant
phenology
(Hofmeester
2020;
Sun
2021)
plant-insect
(Naqvi
2022)
very
holds
exciting
potential.
California,
Simokat
pollinator
endemic
Encinitas
baccharis
(Baccharis
vanessae).
focal
compare
efficacy
methods.
discovered
attended
insect
groups.
Focal
underreported
approximately
half
images
too
low-resolution
visually
Cameras
benefit
recording
activity;
however,
dominated
Lepidopterans
(Simokat
study,
Gao
ground-facing
imagery
soil-dwelling
invertebrate
China.
quantifying
Formicidae,
Diplopoda,
Gastropoda,
Araneae,
Coleoptera,
Orthoptera,
Chilopoda,
Oligochaeta.
Like
scale
problems
(Levin
1992),
abundance,
richness,
all
quite
sensitive
frame
(shooting
area),
authors
effective
protocol
(Gao
As
image
resolution
increases
gets
cheaper,
sure
accelerate
near
future.
field
nascent
endeavour,
having
newly
evolved
natural
philosophy
biogeography
parentage
past
It
still
developing
coherent
theoretical
framework,
suffers
scale,
middle-number
problems,
lack
unified
theories,
general
laws
(Peters
1991;
Levin
1992;
Lawton
1999;
Allen
Starr
Nonetheless,
march
on,
daily
inexorably
accumulate.
plays
role
discoveries
fast
world.
networks
researchers
citizen
pooling
data,
scaling
local
continental
scope
2017)
efforts
Snapshot
USA
(Kays
2022),
Canada's
WildCAM
2023),
Safari
(Pardo
2021).
will
scales
help
us
concepts
system
function.
Evolution
promote
endeavours
continuing
publish
highlight
camera-trapping
papers,
adding
virtual
online.
Jason
T.
Fisher:
conceptualization
(lead),
project
administration
software
visualization
(supporting),
writing
–
original
draft
review
editing
(lead).
Thanks
&
editors-in-chief,
Drs.
Moore,
Andrew
Beckerman,
Gareth
Jenkins,
especially
Marcus
Lashley
Arley
Muth,
contributions
revisions.
thanks,
associate
editors
reviewers
who
gave
generously
make
peer-review
process
successful.
Jeff
Dixon
illustrated
Figure
1
under
direction
licence
JTF.
funded
JTF
work.
author
declares
conflicts
interest.
nothing
report.
Language: Английский
A global assessment of large terrestrial carnivore kill rates
Biological reviews/Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Sept. 11, 2024
ABSTRACT
Through
killing
and
instilling
fear
in
their
prey,
large
terrestrial
carnivores
shape
the
structure
function
of
ecosystems
globally.
Most
carnivore
species
have
experienced
severe
range
population
declines
due
to
human
activities,
many
are
now
threatened
with
extinction.
Consequently,
impacts
these
predators
on
food
webs
been
diminished
or
lost
completely
from
ecosystems.
Kill
rates
provide
a
fundamental
metric
for
understanding
ecology
assessing
comparing
predation
within
across
ecological
communities.
Our
systematic
review
mammalian
kill
reveals
significant
positive
geographic
(North
America,
Europe,
Africa)
taxonomic
(grey
wolf
Canis
lupus
,
puma
Puma
concolor
lion
Panthera
leo
Eurasian
lynx
Lynx
)
bias,
most
studies
apparently
motivated
by
human–carnivore
conflict
over
access
ungulate
prey
wildlife
management
objectives.
current
behaviour
functional
roles
populations
thus
remains
limited.
By
synthesising
rates,
we
show
that
solitary
(e.g.
brown
bears
Ursus
arctos
felids)
exhibit
higher
per
capita
than
social
carnivores.
However,
is
typically
limited
neonates
during
short
period.
Lower
suggests
group
living
significantly
reduces
energetic
demands,
or,
alternatively,
group‐living
defend
consume
greater
proportion
carcasses,
may
acquire
more
through
other
means
scavenging,
kleptoparasitism)
hunters.
consumption
Canidae
–
measured
as
kilograms
kilogram
day
positively
correlated
body
mass,
consistent
increasing
energy
costs
associated
cursorial
hunting
strategy.
contrast,
ambush
such
felids
an
opposite
trend,
potential
advantage
strategy
mass
increases.
Additionally,
remain
relatively
constant
felid
sizes,
indicative
constraints
optimal
foraging.
rate
estimates
also
reveal
insights
into
trophic
structuring
guilds,
subordinate
often
larger
counterparts,
which
be
having
cope
losses
scavengers
dominant
competitors.
Subordinate
serve
important
role
provisioning
levels
respective
Importantly,
clarify
misconceptions
around
predatory
spotted
hyaenas
Crocuta
crocuta
wolverines
Gulo
gulo
considered
rather
capable
hunters
they
are)
various
Despite
importance
predator–prey
interactions,
utility
not
widely
recognised,
insufficient
research
limits
our
ability
fully
appreciate
predict
consequences
modified
regimes,
justify
actions
affecting
carnivores,
inform
effective
conservation
measures.
Together
robust
address
deficiencies
highlight
will
deeper
foraging
behaviours
ecosystem
world's
aiding
actions.
Language: Английский