Comparative Effectiveness of mRNA-1273 and BNT162b2 COVID-19 Vaccines Among Adults with Underlying Medical Conditions: Systematic Literature Review and Pairwise Meta-Analysis Using GRADE
Advances in Therapy,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: March 10, 2025
This
systematic
literature
review
and
pairwise
meta-analysis
evaluated
the
comparative
effectiveness
of
mRNA-1273
versus
BNT162b2
in
patients
with
at
least
one
underlying
medical
condition
high
risk
for
severe
COVID-19.
MEDLINE,
Embase,
Cochrane
databases
were
searched
relevant
articles
from
January
1,
2019
to
February
9,
2024.
Studies
reporting
data
two
doses
vaccination
adults
conditions
developing
COVID-19
according
US
Centers
Disease
Control
Prevention
included.
Outcomes
interest
SARS-CoV-2
infection
(overall,
symptomatic,
severe),
hospitalization
due
COVID-19,
death
Risk
ratios
(RRs)
calculated
random
effects
models.
Subgroup
analyses
by
specific
conditions,
number
vaccinations,
age,
variant
conducted.
Heterogeneity
between
studies
was
estimated
chi-square
testing.
The
certainty
evidence
assessed
using
Grading
Recommendations,
Assessments,
Development,
Evaluations
framework.
Sixty-five
observational
capturing
original/ancestral-containing
primary
series
Omicron-containing
bivalent
original-BA4-5
vaccinations
included
meta-analysis.
associated
significantly
lower
(RR,
0.85
[95%
CI,
0.79–0.92];
I2
=
92.5%),
symptomatic
0.75
0.65–0.86];
62.3%),
0.83
0.78–0.89];
38.0%),
0.88
0.82–0.94];
38.7%),
0.84
0.76–0.93];
1.3%)
than
BNT162b2.
Findings
generally
consistent
across
subgroups.
Evidence
low
or
very
because
sufficiently
powered
randomized
controlled
trials
are
impractical
this
heterogeneous
population.
Meta-analysis
65
showed
that
a
COVID-19-related
Language: Английский
Systemic lupus erythematosus following COVID-19 vaccination. A systematic review of case reports and case series
Lupus,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
33(4), P. 375 - 386
Published: Feb. 5, 2024
Objective
Vaccination
against
SARS-CoV-2
reduced
morbidity
and
mortality
rates
due
to
COVID-19
worldwide.
However,
several
adverse
effects
have
been
documented
of
great
interest
such
as
Systemic
Lupus
Erythematosus
(SLE).
The
aim
the
present
study
was
perform
a
systematic
review
case
reports
series
describing
development
SLE
following
vaccination.
Methods
Case
report
studies
were
included.
Systematic
reviews,
narratives,
letters
editor,
correspondence,
etc.
excluded.
A
selective
bibliographic
search
performed
in
PubMed,
Scopus,
EMBASE
databases.
In
addition,
Web
Science
platform
consulted.
Joanna
Brigs
Institute
(JBI)
tool
used
assess
risk
bias
quality
studies.
Statistical
Package
for
Social
Sciences
(SPSS)
23.0
formal
analysis
descriptive
data.
Results
12
met
eligibility
criteria
reported
total
16
patients.
mean
age
42.4
±
18.69
years.
slight
predominance
post-vaccination
observed
females
(females
(
n
=
9)
males
7).
higher
association
found
with
Pfizer-BioNTech-162b2
vaccine
(75%),
followed
by
Sinopharm
(12.5%),
Moderna
(6.25%).
AstraZeneca
(6.25%)
vaccines.
Most
cases
associated
first
dose
(56.25%),
second
(37.5%)
only
one
third
dose.
number
days
elapsed
from
administration
appearance
clinical
manifestations
between
1
30
days.
Mainly
there
involvement
musculoskeletal
cutaneous
system.
All
patients
responded
well
treatment
good
evolution
no
death.
Conclusion
Cases
vaccination
are
infrequent.
monitoring
is
recommended
persons
receiving
vaccine,
mainly
those
vaccine.
Language: Английский
Comparative Effectiveness of the mRNA-1273 and BNT162b2 COVID-19 Vaccines Among Adults With Underlying Medical Conditions: A Systematic Literature Review and Pairwise Meta-Analysis Using GRADE
medRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Sept. 14, 2024
ABSTRACT
Introduction
This
systematic
literature
review
and
pairwise
meta-analysis
evaluated
the
comparative
effectiveness
of
mRNA-1273
versus
BNT162b
in
patients
with
at
least
one
underlying
medical
condition
high
risk
for
severe
COVID-19.
Methods
MEDLINE,
Embase,
Cochrane
databases
were
searched
relevant
articles
from
January
1,
2019
to
February
9,
2024.
Studies
reporting
data
two
doses
BNT162b2
vaccination
adults
conditions
developing
COVID-19
according
US
Centers
Disease
Control
Prevention
included.
Outcomes
interest
SARS-CoV-2
infection
(overall,
symptomatic,
severe),
hospitalization
due
COVID-19,
death
Risk
ratios
(RRs)
calculated
random
effects
models.
Subgroup
analyses
by
specific
conditions,
number
vaccinations,
age,
variant
conducted.
Heterogeneity
between
studies
was
estimated
chi-square
testing.
The
certainty
evidence
assessed
using
Grading
Recommendations,
Assessments,
Development,
Evaluations
framework.
Results
Sixty-five
observational
capturing
original/ancestral-containing
primary
series
Omicron-containing
bivalent
original-BA4-5
vaccinations
included
meta-analysis.
associated
significantly
lower
(RR,
0.85
[95%
CI,
0.79–0.92];
I
2
=92.5%),
symptomatic
0.75
0.65–0.86];
=62.3%),
0.83
0.78–0.89];
=38.0%),
0.88
0.82–0.94];
=38.7%),
0.84
0.76–0.93];
=1.3%)
than
BNT162b2.
Findings
generally
consistent
across
subgroups.
Evidence
low
or
very
because
sufficiently
powered
randomized
controlled
trials
are
impractical
this
heterogeneous
population.
Conclusion
Meta-analysis
65
showed
that
a
COVID-19-related
Language: Английский
Vaccination updates and special considerations for systemic lupus erythematosus patients
Jammie Law,
No information about this author
Cristina Sorrento,
No information about this author
Amit Saxena
No information about this author
et al.
Current Opinion in Rheumatology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
36(2), P. 148 - 153
Published: Nov. 16, 2023
Purpose
of
review
We
the
latest
guidelines
and
note
special
considerations
for
systemic
lupus
erythematosus
(SLE)
patients
when
approaching
vaccination
against
SARS-CoV-2,
influenza,
pneumococcus,
herpes
zoster,
potentially
respiratory
syncytial
virus
(RSV)
vaccine
in
future.
Recent
findings
SLE
have
unique
infectious
risks
due
to
newer
treatments
nature
disease
itself.
It
is
important
balance
benefit
additional
protective
immunity
from
updated
vaccines
possible
risk
activity
exacerbations.
Summary
continuously
evaluate
safety
immunogenicity
specifically
patients.
Additionally,
newly
approved
RSV
should
be
considered
this
population
reduce
severe
illness.
Language: Английский
Breakthrough SARS-CoV-2 infection in fully vaccinated patients with systemic lupus erythematosus: results from the COVID-19 Vaccination in Autoimmune Disease (COVAD) study
Rheumatology International,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
44(10), P. 1923 - 1933
Published: Aug. 13, 2024
Abstract
Objective
To
determine
the
occurrence
of
breakthrough
COVID-19
infections
(BIs)
in
patients
with
systemic
lupus
erythematosus
(SLE)
compared
other
rheumatic
autoimmune
diseases
(rAIDs),
non-rheumatic
(nrAIDs),
and
healthy
controls
(HCs).
Methods
The
study
was
based
on
data
from
7035
fully
vaccinated
respondents
to
online
COVAD
questionnaire
SLE
(N
=
852),
rAIDs
3098),
or
nrAIDs
414),
HCs
2671).
BI
defined
as
infection
occurring
individuals
≥
2
doses
(or
1
dose
J&J)
14
days
after
vaccination
not
6
months
since
last
vaccine
dose.
Data
were
analysed
using
linear
logistic
regression
models.
Results
A
total
91/852
(10.7%)
reported
at
least
one
BI.
frequency
BIs
comparable
that
among
(277/2671;
p
0.847)
nrAID
(39/414;
0.552)
but
higher
than
(235/3098;
0.005).
No
demographic
factors
treatments
associated
(
0.05
for
all).
Joint
pain
more
frequent
(odds
ratio
[OR]:
3.38;
95%
confidence
interval
[CI]:
1.89–6.04;
<
0.001)
(OR:
2.44;
CI:
1.04–5.75;
0.041).
Patient
did
report
a
hospitalisation
need
advanced
treatment
disease
HCs,
respectively.
Conclusion
conferred
similar
protection
against
terms
severity
by
individuals.
Language: Английский
Lupus and SARS-CoV-2: What have we learned after the pandemic?
Lupus,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Dec. 17, 2024
After
the
end
of
COVID-19
public
health
emergency,
we
analysed
relationship
between
Systemic
Lupus
Erythematosous
(SLE)
and
from
virologist's
perspective
based
on
recent
findings.
SLE
co-morbidity
present
unique
challenges,
as
individuals
with
may
be
at
increased
risk
for
severe
illness
due
to
immune
system
abnormalities
ongoing
therapies.
Effective
management
both
diseases
requires
careful
monitoring,
adherence
vaccination
programs,
preventive
measures
approved
patient-tailored
This
review
covers
various
aspects,
including
clinical
outcome
patients
infected
by
SARS-CoV-2,
impact
this
infection
onset
or
flare-ups
benefits
population.
Furthermore,
presents
most
recommendations
in
rheumatic
patients,
those
SLE,
discussing
currently
available
therapeutic
options.
Finally,
explore
effective
tools
SARS-CoV-2
diagnosis
autoimmune
conditions
examine
prognostic
biomarkers
potential
implications
their
oversight.
By
adopting
a
comprehensive
approach,
address
these
complexities
perspective,
aiming
improve
care
vulnerable
Language: Английский