Public Policy and Administration,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
39(3), P. 475 - 496
Published: June 3, 2023
Analyses
of
‘wicked
problems’
often
lead
to
recommendations
for
collaborative
governance
as
a
metagovernance
solution.
The
case
deadlocked
European
Union
genetically
modified
crop
authorization
processes
offers
good
example.
However,
the
stalemate
is
not
result
inherent
‘wickedness’
problem
posed
by
risk
genetic
modification
technology
applied
agricultural
production
food
and
feed.
Rather,
policy
lock-in
results
from
structure
dynamics
network.
Rigid
interactions
between
same
institutionalized
actors
sustain
instigation
power
games
interlaced
with
question–answer
or
probing
that
jointly
reproduce
clash
differently
structured
problems
over
again.
This
has
created
typical
wrong-problem
situation:
EC
imposing
‘safety’
‘consumer
choice’
GM
crops
on
member
states,
business
interests
anti-GM
NGOs
that,
different
reasons,
saw
cultivation
an
uncertain
normatively
conflicted
activity.
Neither
issue
network’s
opposing
discourses
advocacy
coalitions
gained
sufficient
political
bring
their
preferred
structuring
journeys
closure.
Critical
reflection
practices
suggest
scepticism
about
meta-governance
stakeholder
dialogues
solutions
deal
wickedness.
Instead,
we
argue
Commission’s
recent
coping
strategy
constitutes
incomplete
but
intelligent
management
relational
distances
in
regard
complex
problem.
Annual Review of Resource Economics,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
15(1), P. 351 - 381
Published: July 12, 2023
Agroecology
is
often
considered
as
the
ultimate
and
most
comprehensive
solution
to
many
challenges
of
agricultural
food
system,
also
referred
agri-food
system.
This
review
investigates
what
extent
agroecology
can
become
mainstream
model
for
transforming
agriculture
toward
more
sustainable
resilient
systems
within
given
economic
political
context.
We
find
that
enhancing
will
require
a
fully
integrated
multiscale
approach
from
farm
region
globe.
The
must
consider
relevant
processes
relationships,
actors
stakeholders
well
drivers,
sustainability
indicators,
respective
assessment
methods
across
all
scales.
Giving
specific
attention
drivers
related
economy,
technology,
policy
we
point
out
needs
be
economically
viable
farmers
other
system
actors.
In
particular,
new
emerging
technologies
digitalization
breeding
should
consideration
in
agroecological
transformation.
stress
need
an
analytical
operational
framework
adequate
design
suggest
six
areas
needed
support
large-scale
adoption
agroecology.
Elementa Science of the Anthropocene,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
12(1)
Published: Jan. 1, 2024
Farmer-managed
seed
systems
and
the
conservation
of
agrobiodiversity
are
increasingly
recognized
as
important
components
food
sovereignty.
In
contrast,
hybrid,
genetically
modified
(GM),
and,
increasingly,
gene-edited
crops
continue
to
be
promoted
by
Green
Revolution
proponents
a
“climate
smart”
package
that
includes
fertilizers,
pesticides,
purchased
seeds,
links
global
markets.
Influencing
laws
policies
support
uptake
modern
crop
varieties
has
been
key
entry
point
in
many
countries,
facilitated
networks
foreign
donors,
philanthropists,
governments,
multinational
companies.
Using
case
South
Africa,
where
GM
have
grown
for
several
decades,
we
provide
insights
on
implications
Malawi,
which
passed
Seed
Act
2022,
implicitly
supporting
crops.
Both
countries
histories
colonial
agriculture
with
strong
policy
modern,
hybrid
maize,
replacement
(and
displacement)
local,
open-pollinated
maize
varieties.
studies
revealed
contamination
smallholder
fields
systems.
Through
political
ecology
lens,
explore
how
its
cotechnologies
were
commodified
Africa
what
African
experiences
adoption
farming
can
tell
us
about
challenges
faced
Malawian
farmers.
We
reveal
ongoing
colonialities
power,
knowledge,
being,
nature
shape
character
form
both
running
counter
needs
agroecological
farmers
their
ways
knowing
being.
conclude
envisioning
reimagined,
transformed
decolonial
approaches
might
look
like
continent,
they
contribute
toward
attainment
sovereignty
an
future.
Sustainability Science Practice and Policy,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
20(1)
Published: July 22, 2024
The
bioeconomy
is
touted
as
an
innovative
economic
approach
to
make
economies
more
sustainable
through
the
use
of
biological
resources
and
processes.
In
many
policies,
expansion
biomass
key
enabled
by
new
biotechnologies
precision
agriculture
(PA).
We
respond
demand
for
critical
approaches
sustainability
ask:
How
can
feminist
(sustainability)
research
–
specifically
ecological
economics
science
technology
studies
help
assess
shortcomings
socio-technical
innovations
in
bioeconomy?
have
drawn
from
these
two
fields
construct
a
framework
analysis
illustrate
its
application
looking
at
field
PA,
which
has
emblematic
production
agricultural
bioeconomy.
how
this
analytical
reveal
manifold
linked
innovations,
such
reinforcement
power
relations;
promotion
productivism;
undermining
precaution,
sufficiency,
cooperation
development;
fetishization
data;
delegitimization
local
knowledge.
While
only
exemplary,
it
shows
allows
fine-grained
multifaceted
assessment
specific
draw
attention
structural
systemic
are
often
overlooked.
Agriculture and Human Values,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
40(3), P. 913 - 928
Published: April 21, 2023
Abstract
Agricultural-technology
(ag-tech)
and
agroecology
both
promise
a
better
farming
future.
Ag-tech
seeks
to
improve
the
food
system
through
development
of
high-tech
tools
such
as
sensors,
digital
platforms,
robotic
harvesters,
with
many
ag-tech
start-ups
promising
deliver
increased
agricultural
productivity
while
also
enhancing
sustainability.
Agroecology
incorporates
diverse
cropping
systems,
low
external
resource
inputs,
indigenous
farmer
knowledge,
is
increasingly
associated
political
calls
for
more
just
system.
Recently,
demand
has
grown
potentially
groundbreaking
benefits
their
convergence,
University
California,
Santa
Cruz
(UCSC)
attempting
union.
Building
on
its
combined
expertise
in
engineering
agroecology,
well
longstanding
reputation
socially
progressive
institution,
university
administrators
believe
that
UCSC
could
produce
unique,
form
designed
small,
low-resource
farmers—a
rare
contribution
given
ag-tech’s
tendency
cater
primarily
large-scale
agribusiness.
This
paper
examines
complexities
uniting
interviews
agroecologists,
engineers,
social
scientists
involved
UCSC’s
initiative.
Within
setting
historically
radical
yet
neoliberalizing
university,
I
find
significant
epistemic
structural
barriers
exist
come
together
an
even
playing
field.
case
study
contributes
broader
discussions
future
by
focusing
contours
challenges
widely
called-for
collaboration,
highlighting
difficulty
but
areas
possibility
particularly
rich,
contested
context.
PLoS Biology,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
20(7), P. e3001716 - e3001716
Published: July 26, 2022
As
climate
change
increasingly
threatens
agricultural
production,
expanding
genetic
diversity
in
crops
is
an
important
strategy
for
resilience
many
contexts.
In
this
Essay,
we
explore
the
potential
of
crop
biotechnology
to
contribute
diversification,
especially
industrialized
systems,
by
using
historical
perspectives
frame
current
dialogue
surrounding
recent
innovations
gene
editing.
We
unearth
comments
about
possibility
enhancing
made
ambitious
scientists
early
days
recombinant
DNA
and
follow
implementation
technology,
which
has
not
generated
diversification
some
anticipated.
then
turn
claims
promise
editing
tools
with
respect
same
goal.
encourage
researchers
other
stakeholders
engage
activities
beyond
laboratory
if
they
hope
see
what
technologically
possible
translated
into
practice
at
critical
point
transformation.
Sociologia Ruralis,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
63(2), P. 348 - 369
Published: Feb. 26, 2023
Abstract
This
study
investigates
how
proponents
and
critics
of
gene
editing
in
agriculture
food
(GEAF)
employ
expectations—discourses
with
future‐oriented
impacts—as
they
compete
to
secure
desired
futures
mobilise
social
processes
resources
towards
their
goal
influencing
GEAF
(re)regulation
agro‐food
systems
within
the
EU.
We
draw
on
27
semi‐structured
interviews
53
Euractiv
media
articles
identify
analyse
proponents’
critics’
responses
2018
European
Court
Justice
regulatory
decision
that
will
be
regulated
as
genetically
modified
organisms.
Despite
similar
themes
environmental
sustainability,
security
winners
losers
agricultural
innovation
systems,
discourses
reflect
divergent
expectations
GEAF.
argue
both
groups
link
concerns
about
path
dependencies
technological
innovations
which
serve
influence
emerging
political,
public
elite
perspectives
Although
some
extent
performative,
these
offer
important
insights
should
problematised
engaged
governance
spaces.
is
conceptually
framed
by
socio‐technical
futures,
dependency
political
economy
literature.
Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
351, P. 108472 - 108472
Published: March 23, 2023
Finding
a
balance
between
the
agroecological
benefits
of
in-field
crop
diversification
and
associated
management
demands,
while
maintaining
expected
production
levels,
is
essential
for
making
diversity
work
farmers.
The
aim
this
study
was
to
find
workable
resolution
within
context
an
on-station
organic
arable
cropping
systems
experiment
in
Netherlands.
tested
gradient
treatments
from
sole-crop
references
strip
(3
m
x
54
strips
sown
adjacent
pairs
varying
complexity)
pixel
(0.25
m2
plots
each
with
one
out
six
total
crops
arranged
7.5
12
grids).
In
these
we
assessed
performance
multiple
agroecosystem
service
(AES)
indicators
(soil
fertility,
yield
quality,
weed
cover
diversity,
natural
enemy
activity
density)
three
focal
(cabbage,
wheat,
potato)
using
years
field
data
three-part
analysis.
First,
used
linear
mixed
models
assess
effects
treatment
on
AES
indicators.
We
found
no
clear
indication
that
performed
better
than
rest
across
Second,
developed
novel
method
quantifying
temporal,
spatial,
genetic
structural
into
compound
scores,
scores
analyze
response
relationships
increasing
delivery.
Here
had
positive
effect
species
density.
For
indicators,
observed
inflection
point
most
diverse
treatment,
performing
notably
poorly.
Third,
multivariate
analysis
approach
contribution
delivery,
but
individual
dimensions
These
findings
suggest
prospects
are
when
it
comes
balancing
aims
increases
other
also
feasibility.
Reconciling
shortcomings
highly
(e.g.
through
development
appropriate
technologies)
may
be
way
mitigate
trade-offs
ecological
at
resolutions
higher
cropping.