bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Aug. 15, 2022
Abstract
The
human
brain
tracks
the
temporal
envelope
of
speech,
which
contains
essential
cues
for
speech
understanding.
Linear
models
are
most
common
tool
to
study
neural
tracking.
However,
information
on
how
is
processed
can
be
lost
since
nonlinear
relations
precluded.
As
an
alternative,
mutual
(MI)
analysis
detect
both
linear
and
relations.
Yet,
several
different
approaches
calculating
MI
applied
without
consensus
approach
use.
Furthermore,
added
value
techniques
remains
a
subject
debate
in
field.
To
resolve
this,
we
analyses
electroencephalography
(EEG)
data
participants
listening
continuous
speech.
Comparing
approaches,
conclude
that
results
reliable
robust
using
Gaussian
copula
approach,
first
transforms
standard
Gaussians.
With
this
valid
technique
studying
Like
models,
it
allows
spatial
interpretations
processing,
peak
latency
analyses,
applications
multiple
EEG
channels
combined.
Finally,
demonstrate
components
single-subject
level,
beyond
limits
models.
We
more
informative
Significance
statement
In
present
study,
addressed
key
methodological
considerations
applications.
Traditional
methodologies
require
estimation
probability
distribution
at
first.
show
step
introduce
bias
and,
consequently,
severely
impact
interpretations.
propose
parametric
method,
demonstrated
against
biases.
Second,
analysis,
there
variance
explain
proving
its
statistically
powerful
tracking
than
addition,
retains
characteristics
processing
when
complex
deep
networks.
To
what
extent
does
speech
and
music
processing
rely
on
domain-specific
domain-general
neural
networks?
Using
whole-brain
intracranial
EEG
recordings
in
18
epilepsy
patients
listening
to
natural,
continuous
or
music,
we
investigated
the
presence
of
frequency-specific
network-level
brain
activity.
We
combined
it
with
a
statistical
approach
which
clear
operational
distinction
is
made
between
shared
,
preferred,
domain-
selective
responses.
show
that
majority
focal
activity
processing.
Our
data
also
reveal
an
absence
anatomical
regional
selectivity.
Instead,
domain-selective
responses
are
restricted
distributed
coherent
oscillations,
typical
spectral
fingerprints.
work
highlights
importance
considering
natural
stimuli
dynamics
their
full
complexity
map
cognitive
functions.
Traditional
theoretical
models
conceive
the
neural
system
of
speech
and
language
as
a
set
hierarchical
modules
that
transform
continuous
acoustic
stream
into
discrete
concepts.
This
modular
view
arises
from
traditional
neuropsychology
has
largely
been
backed
up
by
statistical
allow
for
controlled
variation
few
experimental
factors
at
time,
thus
allowing
clear
interpretations
to
be
made.
Recently,
exploration
large
datasets
led
emergence
more
complex
can
capture
patterns
distributed
across
space
time.
However,
interpretation
these
is
challenging
due
increased
correlations
spatio-temporal
dependencies
between
variables,
which
obscure
links
activations
linguistic
functions.
To
guide
experimenter
data
analyst
through
complexity
approaches
in
neuroscience,
we
have
designed
taxonomy
delineates
trade-off
model
interpretability.
Research Square (Research Square),
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Oct. 11, 2022
Abstract
To
what
extent
do
speech
and
music
processing
rely
on
domain-specific
domain-general
neural
networks?
Adopting
a
dynamical
system
framework,
we
investigate
the
presence
of
frequency-specific
network-level
selectivity
combine
it
with
statistical
approach
in
which
clear
distinction
is
made
between
shared,
preferred,
category-selective
responses.
Using
intracranial
EEG
recordings
18
epilepsy
patients
listening
to
natural
continuous
music,
show
that
majority
focal
activity
shared
processing.
Our
data
also
reveal
an
absence
regional
selectivity.
Instead,
restricted
dis-
tributed
coherent
oscillations,
typical
spectral
fingerprints.
work
addresses
longstanding
debate
redefines
epistemological
posture
how
map
cognitive
brain
functions.
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Aug. 15, 2022
Abstract
The
human
brain
tracks
the
temporal
envelope
of
speech,
which
contains
essential
cues
for
speech
understanding.
Linear
models
are
most
common
tool
to
study
neural
tracking.
However,
information
on
how
is
processed
can
be
lost
since
nonlinear
relations
precluded.
As
an
alternative,
mutual
(MI)
analysis
detect
both
linear
and
relations.
Yet,
several
different
approaches
calculating
MI
applied
without
consensus
approach
use.
Furthermore,
added
value
techniques
remains
a
subject
debate
in
field.
To
resolve
this,
we
analyses
electroencephalography
(EEG)
data
participants
listening
continuous
speech.
Comparing
approaches,
conclude
that
results
reliable
robust
using
Gaussian
copula
approach,
first
transforms
standard
Gaussians.
With
this
valid
technique
studying
Like
models,
it
allows
spatial
interpretations
processing,
peak
latency
analyses,
applications
multiple
EEG
channels
combined.
Finally,
demonstrate
components
single-subject
level,
beyond
limits
models.
We
more
informative
Significance
statement
In
present
study,
addressed
key
methodological
considerations
applications.
Traditional
methodologies
require
estimation
probability
distribution
at
first.
show
step
introduce
bias
and,
consequently,
severely
impact
interpretations.
propose
parametric
method,
demonstrated
against
biases.
Second,
analysis,
there
variance
explain
proving
its
statistically
powerful
tracking
than
addition,
retains
characteristics
processing
when
complex
deep
networks.