Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
20(8), P. 3144 - 3153
Published: April 3, 2024
We
analyze
the
varying
susceptibilities
of
different
density
functional
approximations
(DFAs)
to
present
spurious
oscillations
on
profiles
several
vibrational
properties.
Among
other
problems,
these
cause
significant
errors
in
harmonic
and
anharmonic
IR
Raman
frequencies
intensities.
This
work
hinges
a
judicious
strategy
dissect
exchange
correlation
components
DFAs
pinpoint
origins
oscillations.
identify
derivatives
all
energy
with
respect
nuclear
displacements,
including
those
terms
that
do
not
involve
numerical
integrations.
These
Nanotechnology,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
35(19), P. 192001 - 192001
Published: Feb. 7, 2024
Abstract
Since
the
inception
of
density
functional
theory
(DFT)
by
Hohenberg
and
Kohn
in
1964,
it
rapidly
became
an
indispensable
theoretical
tool
across
various
disciplines,
such
as
chemistry,
biology,
materials
science,
among
others.
This
has
ushered
a
new
era
computational
research,
paving
way
for
substantial
advancements
fundamental
understanding.
Today,
DFT
is
routinely
employed
diverse
range
applications,
probing
material
properties
providing
profound
understanding
mechanisms
underlying
physical,
chemical,
biological
processes.
Even
after
decades
active
utilization,
improvement
principles
never
been
slowed
down,
meaning
that
more
accurate
results
are
continuously
generated
with
time.
work
highlights
latest
achievements
acquired
specific
research
field,
namely
investigations
doped
TiO
2
systems,
which
have
not
comprehensively
reviewed
summarized
yet.
Successful
progress
this
niche
currently
hard
to
imagine
without
support
DFT.
It
can
accurately
reveal
introducing
desired
dopant
help
find
optimal
system
design
application
prior
proceeding
time-consuming
expensive
experimental
research.
Hence,
evaluating
selection
most
recent
studies,
we
aim
highlight
pertinent
aspects
they
relate
study
systems.
We
also
shed
light
on
strengths
weaknesses
present
primary
strategies
thus
far
predict
systems
reliably.
ABSTRACT
The
hundreds
of
density
functional
theory
(DFT)
methods
developed
over
the
past
three
decades
are
often
referred
to
as
“zoo”
DFT
approximations.
In
line
with
this
terminology,
numerous
benchmark
studies
might
be
considered
“safari”
evaluation
efforts,
reflecting
their
abundance,
diversity,
and
wide
range
application
methodological
aspects.
These
benchmarks
have
played
a
critical
role
in
establishing
dominant
approach
quantum
chemical
applications
remain
essential
for
selecting
an
appropriate
method
specific
properties
(e.g.,
reaction
energy,
barrier
height,
or
noncovalent
interaction
energy)
systems
organic,
inorganic,
organometallic).
vital
tool
both
users
selection
developers
design
parameterization.
This
review
provides
best‐practice
guidance
on
key
aspects
benchmarking,
such
quality
reference
values,
dataset
size,
geometries,
basis
sets,
statistical
analysis,
electronic
availability
data.
Additionally,
we
present
flowchart
assist
systematically
choosing
these
aspects,
thereby
enhancing
reliability
reproducibility
benchmarking
studies.
The Journal of Chemical Physics,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
162(2)
Published: Jan. 8, 2025
In
this
paper,
we
demonstrate
the
performance
of
several
density-based
methods
in
predicting
inversion
S1
and
T1
states
a
few
N-heterocyclic
triangulene
based
fused
ring
molecules
(popularly
known
as
INVEST
molecules)
with
an
eye
to
identify
well
performing
but
cost-effective
preliminary
screening
method.
Both
conventional
linear-response
time-dependent
density
functional
theory
(LR-TDDFT)
ΔSCF
(namely
maximum
overlap
method,
square-gradient
minimization
restricted
open-shell
Kohn–Sham)
are
considered
for
excited
state
computations
using
exchange–correlation
(XC)
functionals
from
different
rungs
Jacob’s
ladder.
A
well-justified
systematism
is
observed
when
compared
against
fully
internally
contracted
multireference
configuration
interaction
singles
doubles
and/or
equation
motion
coupled-cluster
(EOM-CCSD),
most
important
feature
being
capture
spin-polarization
presence
correlation.
set
least
mean
absolute
error
proposed
both
approaches,
LR-TDDFT
ΔSCF,
which
can
be
more
alternatives
on
synthesizable
larger
derivatives
templates
studied
here.
We
have
our
findings
extensive
studies
three
cyclazine-based
molecular
templates,
additional
six
related
templates.
Previous
benchmark
subsets
were
conducted
domain-based
local
pair
natural
orbital-similarity
transformed
EOM-CCSD
(STEOM-CCSD),
resulted
inadequate
evaluation
due
deficiencies
theory.
The
role
exact-exchange,
spin-contamination,
context
DFT
comes
forefront
supports
numerical
XC
these
applications.
Suitable
connections
drawn
two
exciton
models,
minimal
physics
governing
interactions
molecules.
The Journal of Chemical Physics,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
157(20)
Published: Nov. 7, 2022
Relativistic
two-component
density
functional
calculations
are
carried
out
in
a
non-collinear
formalism
to
describe
spin-orbit
interactions,
where
the
exchange-correlation
is
constructed
as
generalization
of
non-relativistic
approximation.
Contrary
theory
(DFT),
coupling,
however,
leads
non-vanishing
paramagnetic
current
density.
Density
functionals
depending
on
kinetic
energy
density,
such
meta-generalized
gradient
approximations,
should
therefore
be
framework
DFT
(CDFT).
The
latter
has
previously
exclusively
been
used
regime
strong
magnetic
fields.
Herein,
we
present
consistent
CDFT
approach
for
relativistic
DFT,
including
coupling.
Furthermore,
assess
importance
terms
ground-state
energies,
excitation
nuclear
resonance
shielding,
and
spin-spin
coupling
constants,
well
hyperfine
Δg-shifts,
quadrupole
interaction
tensor
electron
(EPR)
spectroscopy.
most
notable
changes
found
EPR
properties.
impact
current-dependent
rises
with
number
unpaired
electrons,
consequently,
properties
more
sensitive
toward
CDFT.
Considerable
observed
strongly
constrained
appropriately
normed
functionals,
B97M
family
TASK.
less
important
when
exact
exchange
incorporated.
At
same
time,
kernel
ensures
stability
response
all
cases.
We,
therefore,
recommend
use
self-consistent
calculations.
Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
18(7), P. 4418 - 4427
Published: June 23, 2022
In
the
framework
of
computational
determination
highly
accurate
vertical
excitation
energies
in
small
organic
compounds,
we
explore
possibilities
offered
by
equation-of-motion
formalism
relying
on
approximate
fourth-order
coupled-cluster
(CC)
method,
CC4.
We
demonstrate,
using
an
extended
set
more
than
200
reference
values
based
CC
including
up
to
quadruples
excitations
(CCSDTQ),
that
CC4
is
excellent
approximation
CCSDTQ
for
excited
states
with
a
dominant
contribution
from
single
average
deviation
as
0.003
eV.
next
assess
accuracy
several
additive
basis
correction
schemes,
which
obtained
compact
and
high-order
method
are
corrected
lower-order
calculations
performed
larger
set.
Such
strategies
found
be
overall
very
beneficial,
though
their
depends
significantly
actual
scheme.
Finally,
employed
improve
theoretical
best
estimates
QUEST
database
molecules
containing
between
four
six
(nonhydrogen)
atoms,
previous
were
computed
at
CCSDT
level.
Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
26(5), P. 3755 - 3794
Published: Dec. 12, 2023
Time-dependent
density
functional
theory
(TD-DFT)
is
the
most
widely-used
electronic
structure
method
for
excited
states,
due
to
a
favorable
combination
of
low
cost
and
semi-quantitative
accuracy
in
many
contexts,
even
if
there
are
well
recognized
limitations.
This
Perspective
describes
various
ways
which
states
from
TD-DFT
calculations
can
be
visualized
analyzed,
both
qualitatively
quantitatively.
includes
not
just
orbitals
densities
but
also
well-defined
statistical
measures
electron-hole
separation
Frenkel-type
exciton
delocalization.
Emphasis
placed
on
mathematical
connections
between
methods
that
have
often
been
discussed
separately.
Particular
attention
paid
charge-transfer
diagnostics,
provide
indicators
when
may
trustworthy
its
categorical
failure
describe
long-range
electron
transfer.
Measures
size
charge
directly
connected
underlying
transition
recommended
over
more
Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
20(5), P. 2152 - 2166
Published: Feb. 8, 2024
Theoretical
predictions
of
NMR
chemical
shifts
from
first-principles
can
greatly
facilitate
experimental
interpretation
and
structure
identification
molecules
in
gas,
solution,
solid-state
phases.
However,
accurate
prediction
using
the
gold-standard
coupled
cluster
with
singles,
doubles,
perturbative
triple
excitations
[CCSD(T)]
method
a
complete
basis
set
(CBS)
be
prohibitively
expensive.
By
contrast,
machine
learning
(ML)
methods
offer
inexpensive
alternatives
for
shift
but
are
hampered
by
generalization
to
outside
original
training
set.
Here,
we
propose
several
new
ideas
ML
H,
C,
N,
O
that
first
introduce
novel
feature
representation,
based
on
atomic
shielding
tensors
within
molecular
environment
an
quantum
mechanics
(QM)
method,
train
it
predict
shieldings
high-level
composite
theory
approaches
accuracy
CCSD(T)/CBS.
In
addition,
model
through
progressive
active
workflow
reduces
total
number
expensive
calculations
required
while
allowing
continuously
improve
unseen
data.
Furthermore,
algorithm
provides
error
estimation,
signaling
potential
unreliability
if
is
large.
Finally,
approach
keep
rotational
invariance
features
tensor
vectors
(TEVs)
yields
highest
compared
similar
data
augmentation.
We
illustrate
predictive
capacity
resulting
(iShiftML)
models
across
benchmarks,
including
NS372
set,
gas-phase
small
organic
molecules,
much
larger
more
complex
natural
products
which
accurately
differentiate
between
subtle
diastereomers
assignments.
Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
20(9), P. 3809 - 3822
Published: May 2, 2024
The
performance
of
time-independent,
orbital-optimized
calculations
excited
states
is
assessed
with
respect
to
charge
transfer
excitations
in
organic
molecules
comparison
the
linear-response
time-dependent
density
functional
theory
(TD-DFT)
approach.
A
direct
optimization
method
converge
on
saddle
points
electronic
energy
surface
used
carry
out
local
approximation
(LDA)
and
generalized
gradient
(GGA)
functionals
PBE
BLYP
for
a
set
27
15
molecules.
time-independent
approach
fully
variational
provides
relaxed
state
electron
from
which
extent
quantified.
TD-DFT
are
generally
found
provide
larger
distances
compared
calculations,
even
when
including
orbital
relaxation
effects
Z-vector
method.
While
error
excitation
relative
theoretical
best
estimates
increase
up
ca.
−2
eV
TD-DFT,
no
correlation
observed
LDA
GGA
mean
absolute
∼0.7
eV,
outperforming
both
global
hybrid
long-range
character.
Orbital-optimized
B3LYP
range-separated
CAM-B3LYP
selection
short-
indicate
that
inclusion
exact
exchange
has
small
effect
distance,
while
it
significantly
improves
energy,
best-performing
providing
an
typically
around
0.15
eV.
The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
14(7), P. 1968 - 1976
Published: Feb. 14, 2023
We
report
a
minimal
auxiliary
basis
model
for
time-dependent
density
functional
theory
(TDDFT)
with
hybrid
functionals
that
can
accurately
reproduce
excitation
energies
and
absorption
spectra
from
TDDFT
while
reducing
cost
by
about
2
orders
of
magnitude.
Our
method,
dubbed
TDDFT-ris,
employs
the
resolution-of-the-identity
technique
just
one
s-type
function
per
atom
linear
response
operator,
where
Gaussian
exponents
are
parametrized
across
periodic
table
using
tabulated
atomic
radii
single
global
scaling
factor.
By
tuning
on
small
test
set,
we
determine
functional-independent
scale
factor
balances
errors
in
spectra.
Benchmarked
organic
molecules
compared
to
standard
TDDFT,
TDDFT-ris
has
an
average
energy
error
only
0.06
eV
yields
close
agreement
TDDFT.
Thus,
enables
simulation
realistic
large
would
be
inaccessible