The Anatomical Record,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
307(1), P. 5 - 48
Published: June 20, 2023
Abstract
To
date,
several
studies
describe
post‐hatching
ontogenetic
variation
in
birds;
however,
none
of
these
document
and
compare
the
entire
skull
multiple
avian
species.
Therefore,
we
studied
two
bird
species
with
very
different
ecologies,
Pica
pica
,
Struthio
camelus
using
μCT
based
3D
reconstructions.
For
each
specimen,
performed
bone‐by‐bone
segmentation
order
to
visualize
morphological
bone
during
ontogeny
estimated
average
sutural
closure
skulls
identify
stages.
Although
fusion
P
.
occurs
more
rapidly
than
that
S
general
sequence
follows
a
similar
trend
from
posterior
anterior,
but
detailed
analysis
reveals
some
interspecific
patterns.
growth
persists
over
longer
period
adults
former
are
significantly
larger,
most
mature
is
still
less
fused
Different
patterns
indicate
could
be
related
heterochronic
developments.
Nevertheless,
this
hypothesis
needs
tested
broader
phylogenetic
framework
detect
evolutionary
direction
potential
transformations.
Biology Letters,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
21(1)
Published: Jan. 1, 2025
Among
the
most
revolutionary
insights
emerging
from
200
years
of
research
on
dinosaurs
is
that
clade
Dinosauria
represented
by
approximately
11
000
living
species
birds.
Although
origin
birds
among
has
been
reviewed
extensively,
recent
have
witnessed
tremendous
progress
in
our
understanding
deep
evolutionary
origins
numerous
distinctive
avian
anatomical
systems.
These
advances
enabled
exciting
new
fossil
discoveries,
leading
to
an
ever-expanding
phylogenetic
framework
with
which
pinpoint
characteristic
features.
The
present
review
focuses
four
notable
systems
whose
Mesozoic
history
greatly
clarified
discoveries:
brain,
kinetic
palate,
pectoral
girdle
and
postcranial
skeletal
pneumaticity.
Communications Biology,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
3(1)
Published: April 24, 2020
Abstract
In
contrast
to
the
vast
majority
of
reptiles,
skulls
adult
crown
birds
are
characterized
by
a
high
degree
integration
due
bone
fusion,
e.g.,
an
ontogenetic
event
generating
net
reduction
in
number
bones.
To
understand
this
process
evolutionary
context,
we
investigate
postnatal
changes
bird
and
non-avian
theropods
using
anatomical
network
analysis
(
AnNA
).
Due
greater
bones
contacts,
early
juvenile
have
less
integrated
skulls,
resembling
their
theropod
ancestors,
including
Archaeopteryx
lithographica
Ichthyornis
dispars
.
Phylogenetic
comparisons
indicate
that
skull
fusion
resulting
modular
represent
peramorphosis
(developmental
exaggeration
ancestral
trait)
evolved
late
during
avialan
evolution,
at
origin
crown-birds.
Succeeding
general
paedomorphic
shape
trend,
occurrence
additional
reflects
mosaic
complexity
avian
evolution.
Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
289(1983)
Published: Sept. 28, 2022
Among
terrestrial
vertebrates,
only
crown
birds
(Neornithes)
rival
mammals
in
terms
of
relative
brain
size
and
behavioural
complexity.
Relatedly,
the
anatomy
avian
central
nervous
system
associated
sensory
structures,
such
as
vestibular
inner
ear,
are
highly
modified
with
respect
to
those
other
extant
reptile
lineages.
However,
a
dearth
three-dimensional
Mesozoic
fossils
has
limited
our
knowledge
origins
distinctive
endocranial
structures
birds.
Traits
an
expanded,
flexed
brain,
ventral
connection
between
spinal
column,
have
been
regarded
exclusive
Neornithes.
Here,
we
demonstrate
all
these
‘advanced’
traits
undistorted
braincase
from
Upper
Cretaceous
enantiornithine
bonebed
southeastern
Brazil.
Our
discovery
suggests
that
bird-like
may
originated
prior
split
Enantiornithes
more
crownward
portion
phylogeny
over
140
Ma,
while
coexisting
remarkably
plesiomorphic
cranial
base
posterior
palate
region.
Altogether,
results
support
interpretation
morphologies
their
relatives
affected
by
complex
trade-offs
spatial
constraints
during
development.
The
Early
Cretaceous
diversification
of
birds
was
a
major
event
in
the
history
terrestrial
ecosystems,
occurring
during
earliest
phase
Terrestrial
Revolution,
long
before
origin
bird
crown-group.
Frugivorous
play
an
important
role
seed
dispersal
today.
However,
evidence
fruit
consumption
early
from
outside
crown-group
has
been
lacking.
Jeholornis
is
one
earliest-diverging
birds,
only
slightly
more
crownward
than
Archaeopteryx,
but
its
cranial
anatomy
poorly
understood,
limiting
trophic
information
which
may
be
gleaned
skull.
Originally
hypothesised
to
granivorous
based
on
seeds
preserved
as
gut
contents,
this
interpretation
become
controversial.
We
conducted
high-resolution
synchrotron
tomography
exquisitely
new
skull
Jeholornis,
revealing
remarkable
plesiomorphies
combined
with
specialised
rostrum.
use
provide
near-complete
reconstruction
and
exclude
possibility
that
granivorous,
morphometric
analyses
mandible
(3D)
cranium
(2D),
comparisons
3D
alimentary
contents
extant
birds.
show
provides
for
indicates
have
recruited
stages
avian
radiation.
As
mobile
dispersers,
frugivorous
could
expanded
scope
biotic
plants,
might
therefore
explain,
at
least
part,
subsequent
evolutionary
expansion
fruits,
indicating
potential
bird-plant
interactions
Revolution.Birds
plants
close
relationship
developed
over
millions
years.
Birds
became
diverse
abundant
around
135
million
years
ago.
Shortly
after,
started
developing
different
kinds
fruits.
Today,
fruit-eating
help
reproduce
by
spreading
their
droppings.
This
suggests
coevolved,
changing
together
time.
But
it
not
clear
exactly
how
started.
One
species
hold
answers
known
Jeholornis.
It
lived
China
Cretaceous,
120
Palaeontologists
discovered
inside
fossilised
remains.
question
is,
did
they
get
there?
Some
eat
directly,
cracking
them
open
or
grinding
up
stomach
extract
nutrients
inside.
Other
swallow
when
are
eating
fruit.
If
belonged
second
group,
represent
steps
plant-bird
coevolution.
Hu
et
al.
scanned
reconstructed
compared
skulls,
especially
mandibles,
modern
including
grind
seeds,
crack
leaving
whole.
ruled
out
cracking.
distinguish
between
eating.
remains
found
fossils
eaten
were
intact
showed
no
grinding.
ate
whole
fruits
part
year.
At
time
alive,
world
entering
called
characterized
explosion
both
flowering
finding
opens
avenues
scientists
explore
plant
evolved
together.
Similar
unlock
about
other
interacted
environments.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
122(13)
Published: March 17, 2025
The
origin
of
birds
represents
a
pivotal
transition
in
vertebrate
evolution,
marked
by
significant
changes
both
brain
size
and
feeding
biomechanics.
evolution
the
avian
skull
involved
dramatic
modifications,
such
as
segmented
palate
development
powered
cranial
kinesis
neognath
birds.
Powered
kinesis,
ability
to
move
parts
independently,
is
considered
key
innovation
behind
dietary
diversity
evolutionary
success
However,
processes
driving
emergence
have
remained
unclear
until
recently.
By
analyzing
data
from
Mesozoic
birds,
including
reinterpretations
homology,
3D
jaw
muscle
biomechanics,
linkage
analysis,
researchers
quantified
forces
their
effects
on
mechanics
during
theropods
As
neurocranium
expanded
non-avian
theropods,
temporal
muscles
shifted
more
rostrocaudal
positions
aiding
segmentation
pterygoid.
This
musculoskeletal
transformation
increased
fore-aft
force
neognaths,
enabling
kinesis.
A
critical
change
was
separation
epipterygoid
ossification
braincase,
leading
breakdown
primitive
kinematic
linkages
new
basicranial
joint,
which
allowed
for
greater
flexibility.
These
findings
shed
light
how
neurosensory
systems
coevolved
bird
origins
offer
methods
identifying
extinct
vertebrates.