Unpacking the complexity of English language teacher-tutor identities in Kazakhstan: a qualitative inquiry
Innovation in Language Learning and Teaching,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
unknown, P. 1 - 16
Published: Jan. 23, 2025
Language: Английский
L2 motivation in shadow education: analysing students’ L2 learning experience in online English private tutoring
Kevin Wai Ho Yung,
No information about this author
Shu Fai Philip Wong
No information about this author
Language Learning Journal,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
52(5), P. 556 - 570
Published: Jan. 30, 2024
With
a
focus
on
the
neglected
'L2
learning
experience'
component
in
Dörnyei's
L2
Motivational
Self
System
(L2MSS),
this
study
investigated
secondary
students'
motivation
context
of
online
English
private
tutoring
(EPT).
Through
narrative
inquiry,
students
narrated
their
EPT
experience
and
reflected
it
comparison
with
that
face-to-face
environment.
an
initial
questionnaire,
in-depth
interviews
follow-up
conversations
12
senior
Hong
Kong,
revealed
participants'
generally
negative
EPT.
This
negativity
stemmed
from
constant
distractions
poor
concentration,
limited
interaction
tutor
peers
insufficient
support
These
experiences
disengaged
demotivated
language
process.
The
findings
contribute
to
our
understanding
L2MSS
impact
contexts
motivation.
indicates
that,
for
participants,
there
are
some
irreplaceable
elements
(e.g.
physical
proximity,
facial
expressions),
lack
which
affected
engagement
highlights
importance
researchers
practitioners
education
taking
into
account
learners'
situated
immediate
environment
when
conducting
relevant
studies
Language: Английский
Learning in the shadows: exploring primary school students and their parents’ perceptions of fee-charging private tutoring in Kazakhstan
Globalisation Societies and Education,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown, P. 1 - 15
Published: March 27, 2024
This
mixed-methods
study
explored
the
experiences
and
perceptions
of
primary
school
students
their
parents
towards
fee-charging
private
tutoring
(PT)
in
Astana,
Kazakhstan.
The
data
were
collected
from
503
Grade
6
(aged
11–12)
using
a
close-ended
questionnaire
followed
by
semi-structured
interviews
with
21
parents.
five
mainstream
schools
found
that
357
out
(71%)
received
PT,
highly
educated
invested
PT
more
than
other
A
total
29%
revealed
spent
31,000–40,000
tenge
(US$
67–87)
on
per
month,
9
acknowledged
was
financially
burdensome
for
them.
Both
affirmed
preparing
exams
securing
place
selective
represented
main
motives
having
PT.
Some
mentioned
soft,
intangible
gains
such
as
responding
appropriately
to
students'
social
emotional
needs.
Moreover,
48%
unaware
identity
tutors,
some
criticised
spread
less
qualified,
costly
tutors
due
unregulated
market
However,
none
supported
idea
banning
suggests
pedagogical
implications
areas
ongoing
research.
Language: Английский
Primary School Students’ Experiences of English Private Tutoring in Uzbekistan Using Participatory Methods
Anas Hajar,
No information about this author
Almira Tabaeva
No information about this author
The Asia-Pacific Education Researcher,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
33(6), P. 1501 - 1514
Published: Feb. 24, 2024
Language: Английский
Private supplementary tutoring and educational inequality in secondary education in Kazakhstan
Central Asian Survey,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
42(3), P. 617 - 636
Published: July 3, 2023
ABSTRACTThis
mixed-methods
study
is
the
first
to
explore
association
between
fee-charging
private
supplementary
tutoring
(PT)
participation
and
access
higher
education
in
Kazakhstan
from
perspectives
of
Grade
11
students
during
COVID-19
pandemic.
Guided
by
work
Entrich
2018,
a
four-dimensional
model
educational
inequality
PT,
this
found
that
scale
PT
had
expanded
pandemic,
with
75.06%
(623
out
830)
participants
engaged
mainly
excel
university
entrance
examinations
gain
state
grant
at
their
preferred
Kazakhstan.
Also,
73.8%
spent
40,000
tenge
(US$88)
or
less
on
per
month.
Although
participants'
families
prioritized
boys
for
providing
services,
most
neither
agreed
nor
disagreed
was
financial
pressure
families,
probably
because
majority
attended
group
delivered
tutorial
centres,
mode
reduced
unit
cost
gave
them
attention
they
needed
tutors.
The
30
interviewees
positive
attitudes
towards
but
some
mentioned
few
its
disadvantages,
including
spread
qualified,
costly
tutors
due
unregulated
market
This
suggests
pedagogical
implications
areas
ongoing
research.KEYWORDS:
tutoringaccess
educationeducational
inequalitysecondary
school
students'
perceptionsmixed-methods
AcknowledgementsThe
authors
thank
anonymous
reviewers
editors
insightful
comments
editorial
support.Disclosure
statementNo
potential
conflict
interest
reported
authors.Additional
informationFundingThis
supported
Nazarbayev
University
Graduate
School
Education
[grant
number
20122022FD4117].
Language: Английский
Being participatory: employing geographic lenses to understand young people’s experiences of private supplementary tutoring in Uzbekistan
Compare A Journal of Comparative and International Education,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown, P. 1 - 21
Published: March 22, 2024
This
mixed-methods
study
explores
the
experiences
and
perceptions
of
primary
school
students
fee-charging
private
supplementary
tutoring
(PST)
in
Uzbekistan.
The
data
were
collected
from
five
mainstream
schools,
using
a
close-ended
questionnaire
two
participatory
methods
–
group
interviews
drawings.
found
that
574
out
1024
(56%)
received
PST,
mainly
to
increase
their
knowledge
core
subjects,
boost
self-confidence,
accomplish
aspirations
studying/working
abroad.
Achieving
high
scores
examinations
was
secondary
goal
for
many
participants
because
they
did
not
have
high-stakes
examination
at
this
academic
level.
286
(50%)
reported
tutors
own
class
teachers,
which
raises
concerns
about
favouritism
coercion.
acted
agentively
by
highlighting
advantages
PST.
stresses
importance
adopting
effective
policies
regulate
PST
research
capture
children's
experiences.
Language: Английский
Internationalisation of Education: Focus on Central Asia and Eastern Neighbourhood
Huma Haider
No information about this author
Published: May 1, 2024
This
rapid
evidence
review
focuses
on
the
internationalization
of
education,
particularly
in
Central
Asia
and
Eastern
Neighbourhood.
It
examines
how
education
influences
development
outcomes,
emphasising
higher
education's
role
economic
growth
human
capital
enhancement.
The
highlights
challenges
accessing
quality
especially
addresses
issues
like
social
inequality
exclusion
children
with
disabilities.
Strategies
for
internationalization,
including
English
language
instruction,
are
explored,
alongside
efforts
to
counter
misinformation.
Despite
mobility
transnational
gaps
research
persist,
regarding
benefits
internationalisation
effectiveness
interventions
against
Language: Английский