The Cass Review: Cis-supremacy in the UK’s approach to healthcare for trans children
International Journal of Transgender Health,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown, P. 1 - 25
Published: March 14, 2024
Background
Since
2016
trans
people
in
the
UK,
and
particularly
children,
have
experienced
a
sustained
escalating
campaign
to
roll
back
freedoms,
rights
access
healthcare.
A
series
of
legislative,
politicized
media-driven
campaigns
resulted
year-by-year
worsening
affirmative
healthcare
for
children
UK.
Language: Английский
CRITICALLY APPRAISING THE CASS REPORT: METHODOLOGICAL FLAWS AND UNSUPPORTED CLAIMS
Chris Noone,
No information about this author
Alex Southgate,
No information about this author
Alex Ashman
No information about this author
et al.
Published: June 11, 2024
The
Cass
Report
aimed
to
provide
recommendations
for
how
services
gender
diverse
children
and
young
people
should
be
delivered
in
England.
Our
critical
appraisal
reveals
significant
methodological
conceptual
flaws
within
the
report
research
commissioned
inform
report,
which
included
seven
systematic
reviews
both
quantitative
qualitative
primary
research.
Using
ROBIS
tool,
we
identified
a
high
risk
of
bias
each
driven
by
unexplained
protocol
deviations,
ambiguous
eligibility
criteria,
inadequate
study
identification,
failure
integrate
consideration
these
limitations
into
conclusions
derived
from
evidence
syntheses.
We
also
potential
sources
unsubstantiated
claims
that
suggest
double
standard
quality
produced
compared
reviews.
discuss
issues
relation
regarding
affirming
care
is
framed,
wider
political
context,
future
care.
To
uphold
evidence-based
medicine,
gender-affirming
must
generate
robust
observational
data,
involve
transgender
communities,
prioritise
patient-centred
outcomes,
ensuring
validity,
generalisability,
cultural
relevance.
Report’s
recommendations,
given
its
misrepresentation
evidence,
warrant
scrutiny
ensure
ethical
effective
support
gender-diverse
youth.
Language: Английский
Acompañar la transexualidad desde la escuela: un estudio cualitativo con las familias
Revista de Psicodidáctica,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
29(1), P. 78 - 85
Published: Sept. 29, 2023
La
escuela
debe
ser
un
espacio
seguro
que
garantice
la
inclusión
de
diversidad
sexual.
El
profesorado,
así
como
otros
posibles
agentes
educativos,
tiene
papel
clave
en
esta
cuestión.
presente
estudio
por
objetivo
explorar
el
y
educativos
bienestar
del
alumnado
transexual.
A
tal
fin
se
han
recabado
22
relatos
vida
escritos
madres
padres
chicas
chicos
habían
realizado
tránsito
social,
los
ha
llevado
a
cabo
análisis
cualitativo
usando
herramienta
software
MAXQDA.
Para
ello,
considerado
tres
periodos
relatos:
antes,
durante
después
haber
tránsito.
Entre
aspectos,
recogen
valoran
acompañamiento
que,
desde
institución
escolar
da
menores,
destacando
las
familias
atribuyen
al
profesorado
garante
sus
hijas
e
hijos
agente
facilitador
desconocimiento
transexualidad
infantil
juvenil
falta
formación
respecto,
emergen
principales
dificultades
con
estas
encuentran
ámbito
escolar.
Se
destaca
también
grupo
iguales
contextos
no
formales
actividades
extraescolares
aportan,
mayoría
casos,
seguridad,
apoyo
aceptación,
forma
excepcional
rechazo
acoso.
Los
muestran
cuando
social
realiza
edades
tempranas,
sufrimiento
es
menor.
The
school
must
be
safe
space
that
guarantees
the
inclusion
of
sexual
diversity.
Teachers,
as
well
other
possible
educational
sources,
play
key
role
in
this
issue.
present
study
aims
to
explore
and
agents
well-being
trans
children
adolescents.
To
end,
life
stories
written
by
mothers
fathers
girls
boys
who
had
undergone
transition
have
been
collected
qualitative
analysis
has
carried
out
using
MAXQDA
tool.
For
purpose,
three
periods
considered
stories:
before,
during
after
having
made
transition.
Among
aspects,
include
value
support
is
given
school,
highlighting
families
attribute
teachers
guarantors
their
children's
wellbeing
at
facilitators
lack
knowledge
child
adolescent
transsexuality
teacher
training
regard,
emerge
main
difficulties
these
encounter
environment.
peer
group
non-formal
contexts
such
extracurricular
activities
are
also
highlighted
spaces
safety,
acceptance
being
cases
rejection
bullying,
an
exception.
show
when
takes
place
earlier
age,
distress
lower.
Accompaniment of transsexuality at school: A qualitative study with the families
Revista de Psicodidáctica (English ed ),
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
29(1), P. 78 - 85
Published: Sept. 22, 2023
The
school
must
be
a
safe
space
that
guarantees
the
inclusion
of
sexual
diversity.
Teachers,
as
well
other
possible
educational
sources,
play
key
role
in
this
issue.
present
study
aims
to
explore
and
agents
well-being
trans
children
adolescents.
To
end,
22
life
stories
written
by
mothers
fathers
girls
boys
who
had
undergone
social
transition
have
been
collected
qualitative
analysis
has
carried
out
using
MAXQDA
software
tool.
For
purpose,
three
periods
considered
stories:
before,
during
after
having
made
transition.
Among
aspects,
include
value
support
is
given
school,
highlighting
families
attribute
teachers
guarantors
their
children's
wellbeing
at
facilitators
lack
knowledge
child
adolescent
transsexuality
teacher
training
regard,
emerge
main
difficulties
these
encounter
environment.
peer
group
non-formal
contexts
such
extracurricular
activities
are
also
highlighted
spaces
safety,
acceptance
being
cases
rejection
bullying,
an
exception.
show
when
takes
place
earlier
age,
distress
lower.
La
escuela
debe
ser
un
espacio
seguro
que
garantice
la
inclusión
de
diversidad
sexual.
El
profesorado,
así
como
otros
posibles
agentes
educativos,
tiene
papel
clave
en
esta
cuestión.
presente
estudio
por
objetivo
explorar
el
y
educativos
bienestar
del
alumnado
transexual.
A
tal
fin
se
han
recabado
relatos
vida
escritos
madres
padres
chicas
chicos
habían
realizado
tránsito
social,
los
ha
llevado
cabo
análisis
cualitativo
usando
herramienta
MAXQDA.
Para
ello,
considerado
tres
periodos
relatos:
antes,
durante
después
haber
tránsito.
Entre
aspectos,
recogen
valoran
acompañamiento
que,
desde
institución
escolar
da
menores,
destacando
las
familias
atribuyen
al
profesorado
garante
sus
hijas
e
hijos
agente
facilitador
desconocimiento
transexualidad
infantil
juvenil
falta
formación
respecto,
emergen
principales
dificultades
con
estas
encuentran
ámbito
escolar.
Se
destaca
también
grupo
iguales
contextos
no
formales
actividades
extraescolares
aportan,
mayoría
casos,
seguridad,
apoyo
aceptación,
forma
excepcional
rechazo
acoso.
Los
muestran
cuando
realiza
edades
tempranas,
sufrimiento
es
menor.
Language: Английский