The meaning of mass extinctions and what the fossil record tells us about angiosperm survival at K-Pg: a reply to Hagen (2024)
Biology Letters,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
20(8)
Published: Aug. 1, 2024
Last
year,
we
published
research
using
phylogenetic
comparative
methods
(PCMs)
to
reveal
no
evidence
for
elevated
lineage-level
extinction
rates
in
angiosperms
across
K-Pg
(Thompson
JB,
Ramírez-Barahona
S.
2023
No
angiosperm
mass
at
the
Cretaceous–Palaeogene
(K-Pg)
boundary.
Biol.
Lett.
19
,
20230314.
(
https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2023.0314
)),
results
that
are
step
with
global
fossil
record.
In
a
critique
of
our
paper
(Hagen
ER.
2024
A
Thompson
and
(2023)
or:
how
I
learned
stop
worrying
love
20
2020240039
https://doi.org/10.1098/rsbl.2024.0039
simulation
work
is
presented
argue
erred
methodological
choices
interpretations,
should
have
deferred
evidence.
opinion,
underlying
this
poor
on
simulations
philosophical
problems
surrounding
definition
event,
which
leads
incorrect
interpretations
both
record
PCMs.
We
further
deferring
one
source
favour
other
shuts
door
important
evolutionary
questions.
Language: Английский
No phylogenetic evidence for angiosperm mass extinction at the Cretaceous–Palaeogene (K-Pg) boundary
Published: Sept. 16, 2024
The
Cretaceous–Palaeogene
mass
extinction
event
(K-Pg)
witnessed
upwards
of
75%
animal
species
going
extinct,
most
notably
among
these
are
the
non-avian
dinosaurs.
A
major
question
in
macroevolution
is
whether
this
influenced
rise
flowering
plants
(angiosperms).
fossil
record
suggests
that
K-Pg
had
a
strong
regional
impact
on
angiosperms
with
up
to
extinctions,
but
only
minor
rates
lineages
(families
and
orders).
Phylogenetic
evidence
for
angiosperm
dynamics
through
time
remains
unexplored.
By
analysing
two
mega-phylogenies
containing
approximately
32
000–73
000
extant
species,
here
we
show
relatively
constant
throughout
geological
no
at
boundary.
Despite
high
species-level
observed
record,
our
results
support
macroevolutionary
resilience
via
survival
higher
lineages.
Image
credit:
[Rhus
nigricans
(fossil
leaf)
(Green
River
Formation,
Eocene;
Utah,
USA).
James
St.
John,
Wikimedia
Commons.](https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Rhus_nigricans_(fossil_leaf)_(Green_River_Formation,_Eocene;_Utah,_USA)_2_(44366947535).jpg)
Language: Английский