Annual Review of Ecology Evolution and Systematics,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
54(1), P. 63 - 83
Published: Aug. 4, 2023
Many
natural
disturbances
have
a
strong
climate
forcing,
and
concern
is
rising
about
how
ecosystems
will
respond
to
disturbance
regimes
which
they
are
not
adapted.
Novelty
can
arise
either
as
attributes
of
the
regime
(e.g.,
frequency,
severity,
duration)
shift
beyond
their
historical
ranges
variation
or
new
agents
present
historically
emerge.
How
much
novelty
ecological
systems
absorb
whether
changing
lead
novel
outcomes
determined
by
responses
communities,
also
subject
change.
Powerful
conceptual
frameworks
exist
for
anticipating
consequences
regimes,
but
these
remain
challenging
apply
in
real-world
settings.
Nonlinear
relationships
tipping
points,
feedbacks)
particular
because
disproportionate
effects.
Future
research
should
quantify
rise
assess
capacity
changes.
Novel
be
potent
catalysts
Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment,
Journal Year:
2016,
Volume and Issue:
14(7), P. 369 - 378
Published: Sept. 1, 2016
Ecological
memory
is
central
to
how
ecosystems
respond
disturbance
and
maintained
by
two
types
of
legacies
–
information
material.
Species
life‐history
traits
represent
an
adaptive
response
are
legacy;
in
contrast,
the
abiotic
biotic
structures
(such
as
seeds
or
nutrients)
produced
single
events
material
legacies.
Disturbance
characteristics
that
support
maintain
these
enhance
ecological
resilience
a
“safe
operating
space”
for
ecosystem
recovery.
However,
can
be
lost
diminished
regimes
environmental
conditions
change,
generating
“resilience
debt”
manifests
only
after
system
disturbed.
Strong
effects
on
post‐disturbance
dynamics
imply
contingencies
(effects
cannot
predicted
with
certainty)
individual
disturbances,
interactions
among
climate
variability
combine
affect
resilience.
We
illustrate
concepts
introduce
novel
framework
examples
forest
primarily
from
North
America.
Identifying
particular
help
scientists
resource
managers
anticipate
when
disturbances
may
trigger
abrupt
shifts
ecosystems,
forests
likely
resilient.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,
Journal Year:
2017,
Volume and Issue:
114(18), P. 4582 - 4590
Published: April 17, 2017
Wildfires
across
western
North
America
have
increased
in
number
and
size
over
the
past
three
decades,
this
trend
will
continue
response
to
further
warming.
As
a
consequence,
wildland–urban
interface
is
projected
experience
substantially
higher
risk
of
climate-driven
fires
coming
decades.
Although
many
plants,
animals,
ecosystem
services
benefit
from
fire,
it
unknown
how
ecosystems
respond
burning
Policy
management
focused
primarily
on
specified
resilience
approaches
aimed
at
resistance
wildfire
restoration
areas
burned
by
through
fire
suppression
fuels
management.
These
strategies
are
inadequate
address
new
era
wildfires.
In
contrast,
policies
that
promote
adaptive
wildfire,
which
people
adjust
reorganize
changing
regimes
reduce
future
vulnerability,
needed.
Key
aspects
an
approach
(
i
)
recognizing
reduction
cannot
alter
regional
trends;
ii
targeting
increase
adaptation
some
residential
communities
more
frequent
fire;
iii
actively
managing
wild
prescribed
with
range
severities;
iv
incentivizing
planning
development
withstand
inevitable
wildfire.
represent
shift
policy
restoring
based
historical
baselines
adapting
unsustainable
defense
developing
fire-adapted
communities.
We
propose
accepts
as
catalyst
change
promotes
responses
warming
Journal of Applied Ecology,
Journal Year:
2016,
Volume and Issue:
54(1), P. 12 - 27
Published: May 9, 2016
Summary
Given
the
substantial
contributions
of
forest
biodiversity
and
ecosystem
services
to
society,
sciences
have
a
large
potential
contribute
integrity
sustainability
our
future.
This
is
especially
true
when
roles
for
sustaining
are
considered.
The
rapid
expansion
sustainable
management
(
SFM
)
has
resulted
in
adoption
various
frameworks
intended
safeguard
biodiversity.
Concurrently,
importance
been
increasingly
recognized.
Although
some
initiatives
aimed
at
conserving
both
emerging,
knowledge
gaps
still
exist
about
their
relationships
trade‐offs
forests.
recent
advancements,
increasing
opportunities
lags
ecology,
further
research
on
biodiversity,
functions
will
play
development
practices.
Here,
we
identified
key
issues
including
(i)
between
function
as
foundation
ecological
integrity,
(ii)
resilience
thinking
better
prepare
adapt
environmental
changes,
(iii)
social–ecological
perspectives
that
facilitate
real‐world
conservation
(iv)
theory‐driven
restoration
bridges
science
practice.
Thus,
illustrate
priorities
future
possibilities
applied
ecology
studies
forests,
which
help
society
ecosystems
build
capacity
face
uncertainty
changing
environment.
Synthesis
applications
.
Under
human
influences,
forests
highly
likely
be
largely
altered,
potentially
leading
emergence
novel
or
alternative
stable
states.
Management
thus
needs
more
flexible,
measures
address
significant
this
generates.
Resilience‐based
approaches
important
respond
adaptively
changes
cope
with
surprises,
providing
multiple
options.
challenges
exist,
theory
should
an
role
managing,
restoring
ecosystems.
discussed
here
receive
attention
context
goals
management.
Journal of Applied Ecology,
Journal Year:
2016,
Volume and Issue:
53(3), P. 617 - 624
Published: May 13, 2016
The
biosphere
is
under
unprecedented
pressure,
reflected
in
rapid
changes
our
global
ecological,
social,
technological
and
economic
systems.
In
many
cases,
ecological
social
systems
can
adapt
to
these
over
time,
but
when
a
critical
threshold
surpassed,
system
stress
undergo
catastrophic
change
reorganize
into
different
state.
concept
of
resilience,
introduced
more
than
40
years
ago
the
sciences,
captures
behaviour
that
occur
alternative
states.
original
definition
resilience
forwarded
by
Holling
(1973)
still
most
useful.
It
defines
as
amount
disturbance
withstand
before
it
shifts
an
stable
idea
states
has
clear
profound
implications
for
management.
Coral
reefs,
example,
are
high-diversity
provide
key
ecosystem
services
such
fisheries
coastal
protection.
Human
impacts
causing
significant,
ongoing
reef
degradation,
reefs
have
shifted
from
coral-
algal-dominated
response
anthropogenic
pressures
elevated
water
temperatures
overfishing.
Understanding
differentiating
between
factors
help
maintain
coral-dominated
vs.
those
facilitate
shift
undesired
state
step
towards
sound
management
conservation
these,
other,
important
social–ecological
Resilience
gained
popularity
among
both
academicians
laypeople,
term
meant
describe
systems'
ability
disturbance.
become
buzzword
last
decade,
shown
its
increasing
appearance
calls
research
proposals
scientific
citation
data
bases.
cases
lost
clarity
fact
frequently
used
manner
direct
opposition
definition.
Many
current
uses
loose
incorrect.
becoming
increasingly
normative
sense
(Brand
&
Jax
2007),
if
were
desirable
quality
However,
even
highly
undesirable
states,
macro-algae
dominated
or
city
cores
poverty
traps,
may
be
resilient,
which
say
they
attempts
transform
them
(desirable)
Operationalizing
application
been
difficult.
Misuse
significant
negative
impacts,
because
being
guide
responses
natural
disasters
assess
sustainability
ecosystems
urban
driving
international
priorities.
argued
basic
emergent
property
systems,
process
rate.
We
focus
on
described
Holling,
property;
managers
wish
enhance
erode
foster
transformation
Fostering
eroding
process.
When
perturbed
not
exceeded,
then
recovery
measured
Several
frameworks
operationalize
proposed.
A
decade
ago,
special
feature
focused
quantifying
was
published
journal
Ecosystems
(Carpenter,
Westley
Turner
2005).
approach
there
identifying
surrogates
few
papers
proposed
quantifiable
metrics.
Consequently,
remain
vague
difficult
quantify,
problem
this
aims
address.
considerable
progress
made
during
(e.g.
Pope,
Allen
Angeler
2014).
Although
some
argue
best
kept
unquantifiable,
(Quinlan
et
al.
2016),
useful
managers,
must
concrete
guidance
regarding
how
what
manage
measure
success
(Garmestani,
Benson
2013;
Spears
2015).
Ideas
'resilience
thinking'
utility
helping
stakeholders
conceptualize
their
little
make
management,
other
suggesting
ambiguous,
Goldilocks
just
right
diverse,
too
diverse;
connected,
connected).
Here,
we
clarify
prominent
terms
concepts,
introduce
synthesize
identify
core
unanswered
questions
related
resilience.
To
quantification
necessary
common
vocabulary.
Prior
introducing
broad
approaches
developed
quantify
discussing
contributions
feature,
definitions
commonly
science
theory.
Ecological
needed
one
set
processes
structures
(Holling
1973).
complex
recognizes
operate
multiple
basins
attraction.
From
human
perspective,
crucial
implies
predictable,
although
variable,
delivery
expected
services.
dynamics
achieving
sustainable
interactions
with
supporting
ecosystems.
An
high
requires
substantial
energy
transition
state,
whereas
low
would
relatively
small
energy.
systemic
phenomenon
through
assessment
mutually
non-exclusive
attributes,
including
scales,
feedbacks
thresholds.
Cross-scale
posits
enhanced
functional
diversity
traits
diverse
within
scales
reinforced
across
scales.
This
model
explicitly
considers
compartmentalization
patterns
spatial
temporal
cross-scale
established
operationalizing
(Peterson,
1998),
especially
understanding
relationship
biodiversity,
scale
assessed
evaluating
distribution
species
approaches,
discontinuity
analysis
time-series
modelling
tools,
available
assessing
(Angeler
Engineering
focuses
return
structural
attributes
predisturbance
conditions
following
Rapid
times
interpreted
reflecting
engineering
(Pimm
1991).
unit
measurement
time
recovery.
assumes
characterized
single
equilibrium
therefore
fails
account
potential
same
system.
context,
incorrectly
always
recovers
degraded
previous
therefore,
only
interest
time.
analogous
'bounce
back'
refers
capacity
initial
does
exclude
existence
thresholds
physical
material
shape
position
without
exceeding
elastic
limit),
equilibria
considered
More
include
Based
empirical
theoretical
knowledge
tractable
'shorthand'
is:
contribution
generate
vice
versa.
allows
operationalization
consistent
foundational
aspects
Nyström
Folke
(2001).
builds
upon
spatially
relevant
complexity,
asymmetries,
networks,
connectivity,
dispersal
information
processing
facets
general
generic
cope
disturbances
changing
define
part
might
cross
kinds
shocks
needs
deal
with,
copes
uncertainty
all
ways
(Folke
2010).
Managing
given
operating
at
distinct
spatiotemporal
need
accounted
for.
complexity
create
opportunities
re-evaluating
present
learning
past
situations,
boosting
novelty
innovation
triggering
policy
change.
That
is,
new
possibilities
adaptive
transformative
swiftly
baselines.
component
known,
anticipated
what,
(Carpenter
2001).
specified
problematic
particular
parts
specific
cause
lose
ways.
For
instance,
travel
Europe
became
developing
air
travel,
while
ground
transportation
deemphasized.
volcano
eruption
Iceland
2010
uncovered
extensive
cloud
ash
interfered
operation
aircrafts.
stability
characterize
communities
populations
unchanged
subject
inverse
resistance
sensitivity
(Grimm
Wissel
1997).
As
case
definitions,
point
view
do
Walker
(2004)
broadened
use
consider
Stability
multifaceted
concept,
components
variability,
resistance,
persistence
robustness
(Donohue
2013).
Despite
concepts
reductionist
less
integrative
dynamic
emanates.
Simply,
face
perturbation,
quickly
perturbation
alters
parameters.
generally
ignore
compartmentalized
attractor
domains.
often
hand,
variability
property,
adaption
evolution
infers
greater
Functional
redundancy
delivering
function,
trait.
studied
accounting
scaling
relationships
(Truchy
two
forms:
(i)
Redundancy
existing
scale,
whereby
identical
functions
redundant
strict
sense.
(ii)
occurs
functionally
similar
exploit
environment
case,
appropriate
reinforcement
accounts
function
impacted
scale.
Rather
focusing
trait
emphasizes
variation
environmental
group
(Elmqvist
2003).
Response
make-up
modulate
through,
colonization,
growth,
competition
abilities.
Variability
combinations
increases
respond
disturbances,
maintaining
behavioural
evolutionary
stress.
ecology,
adaptation
single-species
focus.
Adaptation
perhaps
understood
Darwinian
sense,
constantly
evolve
adjust
conditions,
confer
reproduce,
grow
survive
habitats.
With
warming,
mismatch
(e.g.,
thermal
tolerances
cold-stenothermic
species)
temperature
regimes,
leading
maladaptation
extinction.
capability
behaviourally
evolutionarily
unspecified
future
stresses.
extends
focus,
emphasizing
system-level
constant
adjustment
properties,
community
composition,
anticipate
regime.
confused
stresses,
example
climate
Adaptive
qualitatively
sciences
thus
varies
contexts
(Adger
2007).
Its
makes
either
indistinguishable
from,
subset
of,
highlighting
quantitative
approaches.
Thresholds
indicate
levels
surpassed
(Suding
Hobbs
2009).
equivalent
tipping
points
detected
discontinuities
bifurcation
emphasize
fundamental
reorganization
structure,
functions,
feedbacks,
distinguished
statistically
detectable
curvilinear
configuration
abundance
process,
Alternative
explicit
defined
structures,
separated
(Lewontin
1969).
Patterns,
differ
These
basin
regime
interchangeably.
specifically
structure
necessarily
results
arise
processes,
abiotic
species.
Feedbacks
control
effect
influencing
influenced
gave
rise
it.
positive
feedback
enhances
amplifies
opposite
effects.
Positive
imply
any
judgement
value
desirability
effects
outcomes.
theory;
regimes.
persistent
(Scheffer
shift,
usually
smooth
internal
(feedback)
(external
shocks)
triggers
completely
behaviour.
Shifts
abrupt
(years,
decades)
transitory
(centuries,
millennia),
depending
time-scale
observation
(Spanbauer
2014),
affect
locally,
regionally
globally
(Hughes
Regime
importance
ecology
substantially
flow
service
provisioning
societies.
Refers
situations
where
'the
path
out
in',
difficulty
reverse
Hysteresis
operates
observed
cannot
predicted
solely
based
variables,
also
system's
history.
undergone
change,
lake,
subjected
excessive
nutrient
loading,
will
unlikely
mitigation
nutrients
alone.
stabilizing
system,
break
hysteresis,
series
interventions
(nutrient
elimination,
food
web
manipulations)
required.
Discontinuity
theory
hierarchical
organization
ecosystems,
manifested
nonlinear
processes.
objectively
pioneered
using
body
size
animals
2016).
Animals
sizes
perceive
resources
similarly
presumably
Different
aggregations
species,
masses,
resulting
distributions
delineate
(Nash
applies
economies
(Sundstrom
Scaling
received
interpretations
extent
frequency,
structure.
commensurate
space
(i.e.
fast
slow
extents).
dual
nature,
meaning
encompasses
dimensions
(Angeler,
Göthe
Johnson
studies
carried
context
'scales'
matching
each
other.
circumstances,
scope
study,
whether
'temporal'
'spatial'
scaling,
explicit.
Process
conducting
experiments
designed
reduce
(Allen
2011).
misinterpreted
trial-error
approach,
tests
recalibrates
hypotheses
iteratively.
controllability
high,
interventions,
intervention
possible.
tandem
theory,
method
probe
inadvertently
governance
evolving
framework
analysing
institutional,
foundations
multilevel
modes
building
vast
challenges
posed
coupled
people
nature.
enables
incorporation
co-management,
various
forms
formal
informal
integrated
resource
offers
promising
(Green
Approaches
slowly
categorized
generally.
surveys
stakeholder
inhabit
(Nemec
type
qualitative
quantitative,
provides
metrics
uncertainty,
relative
quantitatively
trade-offs
Other
Alliance
Workbooks,
involve
intense,
brief,
intellectual
exploration
drivers
question.
certainly
awareness
drivers,
no
meaningful
metrics,
ignores
much
multiscale
Spatial
recently
(Cumming
2011)
geometric
Assessments
fruitful
led
recommendations
Finally,
combined
assessments,
scale-specific
methods
identification
(Standish
early
warning
indicators
aim
impending
(Burthe
complement
expand
research,
covering
mainly
arranged
cover
variety
includes
shifts,
linkages
conservation.
coverage
types
broad,
coral
streams,
lakes,
habitats,
forests,
dealing
ostrich
farming.
begins
broadens
there.
(2016)
discuss
providing
operational
overview
external
elements,
quantified.
take-home
message
paper
landscapes
appropriately
dimension
monitoring.
echoed
study
Moore,
Grewar
Cumming
(2016).
authors
network
movement
Western
Cape
Ostrich
industry
gradually
rebuilt
after
collapse
outbreak
avian
influenza.
lack
farming
sector
disease
fostered
vulnerable
diseases.
Nash
show
usefulness
address
challenges.
herbivorous
fish,
foraging
size,
support
temperature-induced
bleaching
event.
Their
proxy
fish
remove
algae
reefs.
On
herbivore
assemblages
prior
event
up
fishes
wider
range
operated
broader
likely
recover
shows
practical
indicator
found
organism
groups
discrete
mass
patterns,
limited
taxa
Seeking
fill
void,
Seidl
(2016),
Journal
Applied
Ecology
Issue
53:1,
evaluated
forest
They
suggest
bound
long-term
turn
locate
attraction
properties
build
describing
rate
trajectory
relation
serve
monitor
shifts.
(flickering,
slowing
down,
increased
autocorrelation,
variance;
Scheffer
2009)
major
efforts
(Lindegren
2012).
Eason
complemented
multivariate
metric
Fisher
Information
quantifies
order
detect
long
transitions
regimes
Burthe
evaluate
autocorrelation
variance
trophic
marine
freshwater
failed
predict
populations.
Also,
did
falsely
predicted.
advocated
incorporate
suite
candidate
non-abundance
increase
statistical
power,
together
improve
understanding.
Quinlan
strengths,
limitations,
involved
measuring
particularly
context.
highlight
property.
complimentary
integrate
principles
identified
enhancing
seen
recent
development
so
far
permeated
sciences.
paradigm
review
demonstrates
understand
areas
objective
indication
predicting
biological
invasions
extinctions,
guiding
monitoring
efforts.
rapidly
disciplines.
pace
exceeded
cross-pollinate
(including
legal
dimensions)
advance
Also
come
meanings
(bounce
back
versus
resilience),
poorly
differentiated,
implications.
distinction
tools
Significant
methodological
advances
analyses,
analyses
(time-series
analyses),
allowing
Much
remains
qualitative,
implementation
partly
scepticism
scholars
about
abilities
(but
see
Garmestani
2006).
Resolving
gaps
raison
d'être
endeavour,
could
open
research.
science,
several
remain.
Current
correlative
local
groups,
allow
representative
entire
large.
Using
result
Correlative
gain
better
insight
pattern–process
Recent
benefitted
data.
currently
availability
highlights
limited.
addition
issues,
limit
further
complementary
receiving
attention
means
ways,
applied
differently
unclear.
amenable
ecology.
Modelling
distinguish
role
regulated
deterministic
stochastic
(Baho
Further
warranted
collectively
Ultimately
fertile
additional
(Garmestani
law
rigid
hardly
dynamism
strong
inform
law,
adding
flexibility
realistic
There
advantages
limitations
transdisciplinary
combines
disciplines
(ecosystem
evolution,
surveillance,
citizen
communication),
arts.
Connection
translation
novel
schemes
needed.
Implementing
complements
enable
conservation,
decisions
reflect
inherent
supported
August
T.
Larsson
Foundation
Swedish
University
Agricultural
Sciences
(NJ
Faculty),
grants
Research
Councils
Formas
(2014-1193)
VR
(2014-5828),
United
States
Department
Defence.
Ahjond
provided
helpful
paper.
Nebraska
Cooperative
Fish
Wildlife
Unit
jointly
cooperative
agreement
U.S.
Geological
Survey,
Game
Parks
Commission,
Nebraska,
Service,
Management
Institute.
Any
trade,
firm,
product
names
descriptive
purposes
endorsement
Government.
Data
archived
article
contain
Nature Communications,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
12(1)
Published: Feb. 23, 2021
Abstract
Forest
disturbance
regimes
are
expected
to
intensify
as
Earth’s
climate
changes.
Quantifying
forest
vulnerability
disturbances
and
understanding
the
underlying
mechanisms
is
crucial
develop
mitigation
adaptation
strategies.
However,
observational
evidence
largely
missing
at
regional
continental
scales.
Here,
we
quantify
of
European
forests
fires,
windthrows
insect
outbreaks
during
period
1979–2018
by
integrating
machine
learning
with
data
satellite
products.
We
show
that
about
33.4
billion
tonnes
biomass
could
be
seriously
affected
these
disturbances,
higher
relative
losses
when
exposed
(40%)
fires
(34%)
compared
(26%).
The
spatial
pattern
in
strongly
controlled
interplay
between
characteristics
background
climate.
Hotspot
regions
for
located
borders
envelope,
both
southern
northern
Europe.
There
a
clear
trend
overall
driven
warming-induced
reduction
plant
defence
outbreaks,
especially
high
latitudes.
Forest Ecosystems,
Journal Year:
2019,
Volume and Issue:
6(1)
Published: April 9, 2019
Human
impacts
on
Earth's
ecosystems
have
greatly
intensified
in
the
last
decades.
This
is
reflected
unexpected
disturbance
events,
as
well
new
and
increasing
socio-economic
demands,
all
of
which
are
affecting
resilience
forest
worldwide
provision
important
ecosystem
services.
Anthropocene
era
forcing
us
to
reconsider
past
current
management
silvicultural
practices,
search
for
ones
that
more
flexible
better
at
dealing
with
uncertainty
brought
about
by
these
accelerating
cumulative
global
changes.
Here,
we
briefly
review
focus
limitations
practices
mainly
developed
Europe
North
America.
We
then
discuss
some
recent
promising
concepts,
such
managing
forests
complex
adaptive
systems,
approaches
based
resilience,
functional
diversity,
assisted
migration
multi-species
plantations,
propose
a
novel
approach
integrate
functionality
species-traits
into
network
multi-scale
way
manage
Anthropocene.
takes
consideration
high
level
associated
future
environmental
societal
It
relies
quantification
dynamic
monitoring
diversity
indices
network.
Using
this
approach,
most
efficient
can
be
determined,
where,
what
scale,
intensity
landscape-scale
resistance,
capacity
changes
improved.
Global Change Biology,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
26(7), P. 4013 - 4027
Published: April 17, 2020
Mountain
forests
are
at
particular
risk
of
climate
change
impacts
due
to
their
temperature
limitation
and
high
exposure
warming.
At
the
same
time,
complex
topography
may
help
buffer
effects
create
refugia.
Whether
can
lead
critical
transitions
mountain
forest
ecosystems
whether
such
reversible
remain
incompletely
understood.
We
investigated
resilience
composition
size
structure
change,
focusing
on
a
landscape
in
Eastern
Alps.
Using
individual-based
model
iLand,
we
simulated
ecosystem
responses
wide
range
climatic
changes
(up
6°C
increase
mean
annual
30%
reduction
precipitation),
testing
for
tipping
points
vegetation
under
different
scenarios.
found
that
warming
levels
above
+2°C
threshold
was
crossed,
with
system
into
an
alternative
state.
The
shifted
from
conifer-dominated
characterized
by
large
trees
dominated
smaller,
predominantly
broadleaved
trees.
Topographic
complexity
moderated
impacts,
smoothing
delaying
between
states.
subsequently
reversed
forcing
assess
ability
recover
impacts.
showed
hysteresis,
particularly
scenarios
lower
precipitation.
temperature,
equilibrium
species
differed
cooling
trajectories.
Here
show
even
moderate
corresponding
current
policy
targets
could
result
highlight
importance
topographic
as
buffering
agent.
Furthermore,
our
results
overshooting
ambitious
mitigation
be
dangerous,
ecological
irreversible
millennial
time
scales
once
point
has
been
crossed.