
The Journal of Physiology, Journal Year: 2024, Volume and Issue: 602(4), P. 537 - 538
Published: Feb. 1, 2024
Teleological justification – that is, assigning function to phenomena as opposed describing in purely mechanistic terms is inescapable Physiology, due the explanatory power it brings. Think: heart pumps blood order supply a situation-appropriate cardiac output and properly compensates when called upon. This teleological of serving relatively agreeable, vast body literature both supports takes tacit premise. Nevertheless, number physiologists have presented alternative non-cardiocentric conceptualizations (e.g. Furst & González-Alonso, 2023; Stöhr, 2022). Stöhr (2022) suggested perhaps serves different, yet unknown, purpose. posits: creation specific an example accidental utility rather than González-Alonso (2023) extended this: heart's purpose equilibrate arterial venous forces, but movement 'primed' by metabolic processes. Perhaps neither explanation perfectly correct answer lies dynamically somewhere amongst proposed theories. matter may be discussed heatedly rightly so; challenges convention require testing, can, if found case, generate new directions questions field. In similar vein, regarding cerebral vascular function, current issue The Journal Professor Buxton suggests extension understanding served sensitivity gases (Buxton, 2024). He responses flow (CBF) neural activation, hypoxia hypercapnia occur maintain ratio O2 CO2 brain tissue, which aids preserving appropriate phosphorylation potential, thus protects metabolism. Should tissue O2/CO2 fall below critical threshold, metabolism will also compromised. uses exceptionally comprehensive thermodynamic modelling convective diffusive transport estimate during different physiological states hypercapnia). Then, these estimates are compared calculated from published data CBF gases. Buxton's work provides perspective for how through upkeep (see Fig. 1). Further assessment use outcome measure exposure various environmental would aid deliberation this teleology's power. For instance, recent evidence CM R O 2 ${\mathrm{CM}}{{\mathrm{R}}_{{{\mathrm{O}}_{\mathrm{2}}}}}$ can become reduced iso-oxic (unpublished observations) could interpreted lens prioritization. During hypercapnia, elevated P C ${P_{{\mathrm{C}}{{\mathrm{O}}_{\mathrm{2}}}}}$ cannot 'fixed' increasing CBF; increases and, despite continued washout, continues greater (aside extreme exogenous hypercapnia) production. One interpret findings model indicate increase reduces degree compensated via changes, so oxidative reduction potential. Concerning contracting heart, argues principles mechanics such preload afterload, etc. been well characterized fact should considered modifying explanations illuminate beating '… because they modify contraction themselves do not explain it, since no clear biological has established relation principles…'. change akin Buxton's. They, essence, argue physiology concerning (1) reactivity ${P_{{{\mathrm{O}}_{\mathrm{2}}}}}$ (2) hypo- pH merely describe activity control, while 'clear purpose' lacking. I believe no-one disagrees metabolism, control delivery regulation/CO2 washout; however, expands suggest protection occurs maintenance ratio. Indeed, explaining sensitivity. Distinguishing authentic challenge embraced. Disputes functions often receive confused objection advocates order. Yet, charge our calling take subject them empirical examination shrewd study design careful measurement tease out truth, exists. consideration here thus: Does truly serve conceptual 'tissue ratio' accident? Or does ratio's direct ties conservation accidently. Disentangling somehow simultaneous (difficult) all factors isolated manipulations each (impossible?). Assuredly, noumenal reality likely combination options more, where combined 'pressures' measurable unmeasurable heat, pH, , perfusion pressure, relevant cations anions, endo-, para- autocrine signals, plus trans-cerebral gradients each), therefore best explained some unifying theory everything. But, explanation, among contemporary options, cuts closest truth greatest us physiologists? To echo Joyner's (2024) conclusion (2023), complex 'brain context proves hold true more situations arguably simpler alternatives, offers power, useful insights applications, then taken up. Either way, there done. Please note: publisher responsible content or functionality any supporting information supplied authors. Any queries (other missing content) directed corresponding author article. No competing interests declared. Sole author. funding was received work.
Language: Английский