Nature Communications,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
11(1)
Published: May 21, 2020
Facilitation
studies
typically
compare
plants
under
differential
stress
levels
with
and
without
neighbors,
while
the
density
of
neighbors
has
rarely
been
addressed.
However,
recent
empirical
indicate
that
facilitation
may
be
density-dependent
too
peak
at
intermediate
neighbor
densities.
Here,
we
propose
a
conceptual
model
to
incorporate
density-dependence
into
theory
about
changes
plant-plant
interactions
stress.
To
test
our
predictions,
combine
an
individual-based
incorporating
both
facilitative
response
effect,
experiment
using
salt
Arabidopsis
thaliana.
Theoretical
experimental
results
are
strikingly
consistent:
(1)
intensity
peaks
density,
this
shifts
higher
densities
increasing
stress;
(2)
shift
further
modifies
balance
between
competition
such
stress-gradient
hypothesis
applies
only
high
Our
suggests
must
considered
for
predicting
environmental
change.
Methods in Ecology and Evolution,
Journal Year:
2017,
Volume and Issue:
8(4), P. 443 - 452
Published: April 1, 2017
Summary
Joint
species
distribution
models
(
JSDM
)
are
increasingly
used
to
analyse
community
ecology
data.
Recent
progress
with
s
has
provided
ecologists
new
tools
for
estimating
associations
(residual
co‐occurrence
patterns
after
accounting
environmental
niches)
from
large
data
sets,
as
well
increasing
the
predictive
power
of
SDM
s)
by
such
associations.
Yet,
one
critical
limitation
developed
thus
far
is
that
they
assume
constant
However,
in
real
ecological
communities,
direction
and
strength
interspecific
interactions
likely
be
different
under
conditions.
In
this
paper,
we
overcome
shortcoming
present
allowing
covary
measured
covariates.
To
estimate
environmental‐dependent
associations,
utilize
a
latent
variable
structure,
where
factor
loadings
modelled
linear
regression
We
illustrate
performance
statistical
framework
both
simulated
Our
results
show
perform
substantially
better
inferring
than
single
s,
especially
sparse
Furthermore,
consistently
overperform
terms
generating
predictions
account
environment‐dependent
biotic
implemented
MATLAB
package,
which
includes
model
parameterization
post‐processing
results,
particularly
addressing
whether
how
depend
on
provides
tool
who
wish
investigate
non‐manipulative
observational
dependency
context.
method
can
applied
answer
fundamental
questions
about
species’
shift
changing
conditions,
predict
future
changes
response
global
change.
Biological reviews/Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
99(3), P. 753 - 777
Published: Jan. 4, 2024
ABSTRACT
Weed
communities
influence
the
dynamics
of
ecosystems,
particularly
in
disturbed
environments
where
anthropogenic
activities
often
result
higher
pollution.
Understanding
existing
between
native
weed
and
invasive
species
is
crucial
for
effective
management
normal
ecosystem
functioning.
Recognising
potential
resistance
to
invasion
can
help
identify
suitable
plants
restoration
operations.
This
review
aims
investigate
adaptations
exhibited
by
non‐native
weeds
that
may
affect
invasions
within
environments.
Factors
such
as
ecological
characteristics,
altered
soil
conditions,
potentially
confer
a
competitive
advantage
relative
or
are
analysed.
Moreover,
roles
biotic
interactions
competition,
mutualistic
relationships,
allelopathy
shaping
described.
Emphasis
given
consideration
key
factor
provides
insights
conservation
efforts
Additionally,
this
underscores
need
further
research
unravel
underlying
mechanisms
devise
targeted
strategies.
These
strategies
aim
promote
mitigate
negative
effects
By
delving
deeper
into
these
insights,
we
gain
an
understanding
ecosystems
develop
valuable
species,
restore
long‐term
sustainability.
Functional Ecology,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
30(1), P. 88 - 97
Published: Nov. 12, 2015
Summary
After
a
period
of
heavy
emphasis
on
negative
interactions,
such
as
predation
and
competition,
the
past
two
decades
have
seen
an
explosion
literature
role
positive
interactions
in
ecological
communities.
Such
can
take
many
forms.
One
possibility
is
that
amelioration
environmental
stress
by
plants
or
sessile
animals
enhances
growth,
reproduction
survival
others,
but
more
intricate
patterns
exist.
Importantly
may
contribute
to
creating
feedback.
For
instance,
biomass
lead
improved
conditions
causing
better
growth
therefore
leading
biomass.
A
feedback
necessary
(but
not
sufficient)
condition
for
emergence
alternative
stable
states
at
community
scale.
However,
plant
animal
communities
rarely
addresses
this
connection.
Here,
we
address
gap,
asking
question
when
states,
hence
set
stage
catastrophic
transitions
tipping
points
ecosystems.
We
argue
that,
although
there
are
number
now
classical
examples
which
clearly
main
actors
loops,
empirical
theoretical
research
scaling
up
from
individual‐level
ecosystem
scale
processes
needed
further
understand
under
trigger
thereby
states.
PLoS Biology,
Journal Year:
2018,
Volume and Issue:
16(9), P. e2006852 - e2006852
Published: Sept. 4, 2018
Habitat-forming
species
sustain
biodiversity
and
ecosystem
functioning
in
harsh
environments
through
the
amelioration
of
physical
stress.
Nonetheless,
their
role
shaping
patterns
distribution
under
future
climate
scenarios
is
generally
overlooked.
Focusing
on
coastal
systems,
we
assess
how
habitat-forming
can
influence
ability
stress-sensitive
to
exhibit
plastic
responses,
adapt
novel
environmental
conditions,
or
track
suitable
climates.
Here,
argue
that
habitat-former
populations
could
be
managed
as
a
nature-based
solution
against
climate-driven
loss
biodiversity.
Drawing
from
different
ecological
biological
disciplines,
identify
series
actions
resilience
marine
change,
well
effectiveness
reliability
rescuing
increasingly
adverse
conditions.
Journal of Ecology,
Journal Year:
2018,
Volume and Issue:
106(5), P. 1839 - 1852
Published: Aug. 13, 2018
Abstract
Coexistence
between
plant
species
is
well
known
to
depend
on
the
outcomes
of
interactions
within
an
environmental
context.
The
incorporation
variation
into
empirical
studies
coexistence
are
rare,
however,
due
complex
experiments
needed
do
so
and
lack
feasible
modelling
approaches
for
determining
how
factors
alter
specific
mechanisms.
In
this
article,
we
present
a
simple
framework
assessing
in
across
gradients
impact
niche
overlap
fitness
differences,
two
core
determinants
coexistence.
We
use
novel
formulation
annual
population
dynamics
model
that
allows
competitive
facilitative
strength
direction
these
gradients.
Using
framework,
examine
plant–plant
four
commonly
co‐occurring
from
Western
Australian
woodlands.
then
determine
differences
vary
three
previously
identified
as
important
structuring
diversity
patterns
system:
soil
phosphorus,
shade
water.
found
facilitation
be
widespread
phenomenon
most
pairs
shift
multiple
Environmental
conditions
also
altered
strength,
relative
both
nonlinear
unpredictable
ways.
Synthesis
.
provide
incorporating
heterogeneity
explorations
Our
findings
highlight
importance
environment
outcome
potential
pairwise
species.
prevalence
our
system
indicates
need
improve
current
theoretical
frameworks
include
noncompetitive
ways
translating
effects
explicit
predictions
study
suggests
further
research
which
result
consistent
responses
variation.
Such
information
will
ability
predict
coexistence,
invasion
events
whole
communities
future
change.
Frontiers in Microbiology,
Journal Year:
2016,
Volume and Issue:
7
Published: Dec. 16, 2016
Community
assembly
processes
generate
shifts
in
species
abundances
that
influence
ecosystem
cycling
of
carbon
and
nutrients,
yet
our
understanding
remains
largely
separate
from
ecosystem-level
functioning.
Here,
we
investigate
relationships
between
changes
microbial
metabolism
across
space
time
hyporheic
communities.
We
pair
sampling
two
habitat
types
(i.e.,
attached
planktonic)
through
seasonal
sub-hourly
hydrologic
fluctuation
with
null
modeling
temporally-explicit
multivariate
statistics.
demonstrate
multiple
selective
pressures—imposed
by
sediment
porewater
physicochemistry—integrate
to
community
composition
at
distinct
timescales
among
types.
These
are
reflective
contrasting
associations
Betaproteobacteria
Thaumarchaeota
ecological
selection
metabolism.
present
a
conceptual
model
based
on
results
which
increases
when
oscillating
pressures
oppose
temporally-stable
pressures.
Our
is
pertinent
both
macrobial
systems
experiencing
presents
an
avenue
for
assimilating
into
predictions
Functional Ecology,
Journal Year:
2016,
Volume and Issue:
30(1), P. 3 - 9
Published: Jan. 1, 2016
Facilitation
(positive
interactions
among
organisms)
in
communities
has
been
the
subject
of
increasing
interest
for
community
ecologists
since
mid-nineties
(Fig.
1),
although
this
is
a
pioneer
core
concept
theory,
proposed
100
years
before
issue
by
Clements
(1916),
as
main
driving
biotic
mechanism
plant
succession.
However,
it
was
neglected
most
decades
due
to
overwhelming
popularity
at
that
time
individualistic
(Gleason
1926;
Whittaker
1956)
and
competition
theories
(Grime
1974;
Tilman
1982).
Until
mid-nineties,
far
studied
interaction,
particular
(see
Fig.
1:
more
than
90%
studies
published
concerned
only
competition).
evidence
facilitation
experiments
conducted
severe
conditions
from
marine
intertidal
terrestrial
environments,
Bertness
&
Callaway
(1994)
conceptual
model
where
switches
with
environmental
severity.
Since
then,
during
following
two
decades,
never
ceased
increase
currently
76%
concerns
During
first
half
period
emergence
an
important
research
area,
number
evidenced
multiple
ecosystem
implications
(Callaway
1995,
1997,
1998;
Pugnaire,
Haase
Puigdefábregas
1996;
Walker
1997;
Hacker
Gaines
Holmgren,
Scheffer
Huston
Brooker
Callaghan
Stachowicz
2001;
Bruno,
2003;
Lortie
et
al.
2004;
Armas
Pugnaire
2005;
2006;
Padilla
2006),
many
empirical
focused
on
experimental
test
(e.g.
Luque
2002;
but
see
2007
2008
reviews).
became
well-established
phenomenon.
strong
controversy
questioned
2005
importance
dry
environments
and,
thus,
validity
Stress
Gradient
Hypothesis
(Maestre,
Valladares
Reynolds
Michalet
2006,
2007;
Maestre
2009;
Armas,
Rodríguez-Echeverría
2011).
This
followed
publication
other
alternative
models
SGH,
proposing
collapse
extremely
stressful
(Michalet
2014a;
Xiao
Holmgren
2010;
Verwijmeren
2013;
Le
Bagousse-Pinguet
2014a).
At
refinement,
European
Science
Foundation
meeting
held
Arcachon
(France)
conclusions
which
were
collected
highly
cited
(Brooker
2008;
1).
(2008)
also
highlighted
several
key
issues
developing
future
basis
BES
symposium
organized
2009
Aberdeen
subsequent
special
Journal
Ecology
The
goal
open
new
directions,
actively
develop
links
fields
would
profit,
such
evolutionary
ecology,
restoration
ecology
sciences.
field
moved
incredibly
fast
There
have
novel
recent
advances,
assessment
consequences
2011;
Thorpe
Butterfield
2013),
feedback
effects
between
facilitator
facilitated
species
Schöb
2014a,b,c),
functional
Schöb,
2012;
2013)
or
below-ground
organisms
Hortal
2013).
Several
meta-analyses
theoretical
further
analysed
relevance
SGH
contrasting
results
(He,
Altieri
He
2014;
2014a,b;
Soliveres
Soliveres,
Smit
2015;
2015).
Pakeman
(2009)
asked
after
symposium,
we
believe
will
soon
reach
kind
maturity,
beyond
confrontations
simple
picture
greater
(Semchenko
2016).
As
Grime-Tilman
debate
eighties
early
nineties,
are
now
aware
no
single
may
explain
occurrence
disappearance
along
gradients.
Nature
much
complex
our
models,
rather
keep
deepen
knowledge
mechanisms
their
implications.
Special
Feature
go
back
basics
facilitation,
trying
review
(papers
1–4),
structure
5–8)
functions
services
9
10).
complements
journal
2013
(Robinson,
Trinder
authors
represent
large
panel
specialists
positive
ecological
communities,
extend
group
researchers.
preparation
Issue
closely
aligned
Baeza
(Spain)
September
2014,
acknowledge
all
participants
helpful
comments
certainly
improved
quality
Feature.
(2016)
address
one
contentious
debates
surrounding
stress
gradient
hypothesis
(SGH),
relationship
water
limitation
facilitation.
mentioned
above,
topic
hotly
debated
2005.
take
here
close
look
role
soil
moisture
mediating
plant–plant
interactions.
By
assessing
climate
texture
process
using
empirically
parameterized
model,
simulated
dynamics
beneath
shrubs
gaps
data
1000
sites
Western
United
States.
They
found
difference
under
decreased
aridity
when
long-term
average
considered,
contrary
expectations
based
SGH.
extreme
shrub
greatest
intermediate
points
spatial
gradient,
consistent
hump-backed
2010).
These
suggest
predictable,
highlight
accounting
temporal
heterogeneity
determining
plant–soil
relationships.
Rather
focusing
predictions,
be
beneficial
explicitly
incorporate
into
predictive
interaction
outcome
drylands.
In
related
paper,
Metz
Tielbörger
modifying
impact
change
communities.
magnitude
even
direction
response
changes
–
gradients
remains
debated,
especially
limited
ecosystems.
Unfortunately,
mechanistic
manipulations
rare
compared
correlative
approaches
infer
patterns
observations
climatic
gradients,
predictions
these
range
aridification.
argue
methodology
used
greatly
affect
outcome.
use
unique
combined
large-scale,
whether
about
yield
similar
manipulations,
variation.
assessed
shrub–annual
three
different
27
natural
rainfall
(spatial)
varying
(temporal)
8
wet
ambient
(experimental)
mimicked
regional
scenarios.
differed
approaches.
Experimental
hardly
altered
annual
Along
shifted
clearly
negative
mildly
facilitative
towards
drier
sites,
whereas
variations
showed
opposite
trend:
years.
Based
approach,
conclude
shrub-annual
remain
unaltered
climates.
conclusion
contrasts
suggestion
made
space-for-time
should
change.
Long-term
appear
critical
evaluating
impacts.
misleading,
overestimating
Despite
growing
microbiota
fitness
dynamics,
little
explored
date.
Rodríguez-Echeverría,
Lozano
Bardgett
synthesize
scant
available
effect
nurse
plants
abundance,
composition
activity
microbial
addressing
nurses
beneficiary
species.
Evidence
suggests
promote
larger,
differentiated
high
activity,
dominance
competitive
bacteria
larger
mycorrhizal
networks,
adjacent
soils
without
nurses.
Such
establishment,
growth
through
variety
mechanisms,
including
increased
nutrient
availability,
stabilization
niche
complementarity,
direct
molecular
signalling
microbes
defence
Although
mounting,
there
still
few
draw
general
conclusions.
its
infancy,
needed
understand
precise
they
influence
plants.
date
primarily
plants,
often
neglecting
extended
cascade
networks.
Lortie,
Filazolla
Sotomayor
propose
framework
explores
roles
interacting
species,
quantitatively
summarize
current
state
examining
A
examined
animals
benefactor-subordinate
association.
Selecting
36
documented
interactions,
generated
total
53
independent
instances
either
shrub–plant–animal
shrub–animal–plant
split
indirect
animals.
Hypotheses
frequently
tested
included
seed
trapping,
herbivore
protection,
magnet
pollination
facilitation-mediated
secondary
dispersal.
common
protection
herbivory,
animal
associated
plant-facilitation
complexes
consumer.
multitrophic,
integrated
sets
incorporating
advancing
management
high-stress
ecosystems
wherein
commonly
reported.
set
papers
focuses
diversity
ranging
alpine
arctic
general.
best
known
(Hacker
Lázaro
2000;
Cavieres
Badano
2009).
patch
level,
comparing
within
patches
vs.
away
them
areas,
2014).
Issue,
literature
dominated
cushion
forms,
show
community-level
cases
some
systems
dominant
measured
level.
Indeed,
if
add
present
areas
high-stress-
disturbance-intolerance,
whole
(cushions
+
areas)
presence
Additionally,
stronger
impoverished
local
diversity,
suggesting
acts
insurance
policy
harsh
environments.
study
highlights
scale
studies,
patchy
ecosystems,
very
frequent
arid
Tewksbury
Lloyd
2001).
another
Bräthen
contribution
depending
height
tundra.
Across
wide
biomass
(11–800
g
m−2),
both
stressed
relatively
benign
conditions,
observed
Norway
humped-back
richness/biomass
theory
1973;
Fraser
Increasing
significantly
richness
showing
canopies
occurs
conditions.
result
because
contribute
shaping
curve
not
absent
weak
2006).
expected
mediated
changing
neighbour
gradient.
words,
tallest
neighbours
mid-sized
mid-position
Finally,
become
too
short
any
(Le
2014b).
comparisons
needed,
interesting
might
ubiquitous
originally
thought
argued
McIntire
Fajardo
(2014).
physical
induced
can
dependent
could
overwhelm
Levine
1999;
2015a,b).
Building
facilitation-expanded
(2003),
Bulleri
explore
particular,
broadening
niches
potential
overlap
competitors,
net
diversity.
realized
depend
trade-off
fundamental
expansion
competitors
predators
determine
intensity
assess
niche-broadening
responses
Facilitated
benefactors.
Feedback
poorly
addressed
(but
1996),
call
(Bronstein
2009),
2014a,b,c).
Most
effects.
Using
base
(2013),
(2014)
(2014a,b),
additional
survey
north-western
China,
grasses
higher
forbs
legumes.
strength
grass
mesic
sites.
ideas
(sensu
2016)
legumes
All
network
selective
pressures
ultimately
eco-evolutionary
stability
(Bascompte,
Jordano
Olesen
Whitham
Bronstein
Kéfi,
focus
stable
states
level
organisms,
connection
rarely
gap,
asking
lead
states,
hence
stage
catastrophic
transitions
tipping
getting
clearer
understanding
species-level
ecosystem-level
shifts
investigating
networks
abiotic
environment,
merging
Therefore,
need
integration
decade
(2003).
better
essential
smart
(and
prevention
shifts)
(the
trigger
loops).
Knowledge
final
paper
emerging
problem
derived
agricultural
intensification,
reductions
farmland
biodiversity.
Ecological
applied
agriculture
enable
biodiversity
conservation
farmlands
whilst
pressing
food
security.
Obvious
examples
intercropping
systems,
combinations
crop
circumstances
allow
reduced
inputs
agrochemicals
(fertilizers,
pesticides)
per
unit
yield,
knock-on
benefits
conservation.
Other
processes
play
Increased
genetic
help
protect
crops
pests
diseases.
overlooked
research,
involved
operate
analogous
manner
associational
against
herbivores,
well
recognized
literature.
intercropping,
nature
arise
pesticide
harvested
crop.
Our
arising
work
lessons
semi-natural
easy
identify
quantify
non-crop
deserve
consideration.
emphasize
deliver
sustainable
practices.
being
fully
comprehensive
overview
numerous
underlying
relevant
topics
are,
example,
phylogenetic
hot
Al
Hayek
provides
science.
sheds
light
variation
historically
dominated,
sometimes
excessively,
For
modelling
comparative
incredible
complexity
dependency
types
data.
section
revealed
aspects
relation
trophic
levels,
micro-organisms
two-first
second
(community
implications)
ubiquity
types.
contrast,
last
fitness,
how
crucial
improving
sustainability
efficiency
greener
world.
Twenty
modern
shows
vitality
potential.
We
amplify
likely
relationships
diversities
deserves
2015c).
New
efforts
invested
analyses.
improve
change,
infancy
Anthelme,
Dangles
thank
International
University
Andalucia
(UNIA)
hosting
partly
funding
2014
workshop
Baeza,
Spain,
discussed.
grateful
vivid
discussions,
helped
papers.
Ken
Thompson
David
Robinson
manuscript.