Ethology,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
129(1), P. 47 - 54
Published: Nov. 7, 2022
Abstract
Female
singing
and
coordinated
male–female
duetting
are
often
but
not
always
found
in
the
same
species.
Both
behaviors
more
common
tropical
than
temperate
songbirds,
few
studies
have
differentiated
between
factors
selecting
for
each.
Here
we
investigate
evolution
of
female
vocal
complexity
coordination
Carolina
wrens
(
Thryothorus
ludovicianus
),
one
non‐tropical
members
a
songbird
family
(Troglodytidae)
that
is
well
known
producing
duets.
to
sing;
rather,
they
produce
relatively
simple,
sex‐specific
chatters,
during
territorial
encounters.
We
analyzed
field
recordings
show
females
coordinate
these
chatters
with
male
songs
at
rates
similar
those
observed
some
wren
then
used
phylogenetic
comparative
methods
evolutionary
ancestors
had
were
acoustically
complex
vocalizations
current
females,
suggesting
past
selection
against
complexity.
Levels
males,
contrast,
changed
little
from
ancestors.
Our
results
suggest
two
aspects
behavior,
acoustic
evolved
independently
different
functions
communication.
Journal of Field Ornithology,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
95(3)
Published: Jan. 1, 2024
Female
song
has
been
significantly
understudied
compared
with
male
song,
and
our
understanding
of
how
this
elaborate
signal
trait
may
function
limited
as
a
result.
Reconstruction
ancestral
singing
behaviors
indicate
that
Orchard
Orioles
(Icterus
spurius)
have
reduced
female
tropical
ancestors.
In
study,
we
found
orioles
on
their
breeding
territories
responded
more
strongly
by
all
metrics
to
playback
than
playback.
Given
the
high
degree
qualitative
variation
in
response
playback,
results
suggest
be
under
relaxed
selection
pressure.
Sexual
dimorphism
complexity
frequency
songs
many
lineages
likely
evolved
result
reduction
or
loss
song.
However,
little
research
investigated
functional
significance
these
infrequent
songs.
More
is
required
investigate
specific
pressures
acting
behavior
songbirds.
Journal of Avian Biology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
2023(3-4)
Published: Jan. 24, 2023
Female
song
is
ancestral
to
songbirds
and
shows
considerable
phylogenetic
signal,
but
its
presence
also
appears
be
labile
correlated
with
life‐history
ecology.
While
previous
studies
have
examined
the
evolution
of
female
across
species‐rich
families,
here
we
studied
in
island
populations
a
recently
diverged
species‐complex,
chaffinches
(genus
Fringilla
).
We
show
this
behaviour
has
evolved
these
populations,
probably
on
two
independent
occasions.
In
F.
teydea
,
performed
loose
duets
males,
while
coelebs
produced
solo.
Populations
singing
females
showed
year‐round
territoriality
were
found
regions
low
seasonality
–
both
factors
previously
connected
high
rates
singing.
To
determine
relative
saliency
songs
conspecifics,
degree
which
they
instigate
territorial
defence
behaviours,
series
speaker
playback
experiments.
c.
canariensis
could
induce
comparable
responses
male
song,
whilst
duetting
similar
solo
songs,
therefore
may
relate
within‐pair
communication
instead.
Our
results
suggest
can
highly
trait
that
evolve
over
short
evolutionary
timescales.
Ethology,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
129(1), P. 47 - 54
Published: Nov. 7, 2022
Abstract
Female
singing
and
coordinated
male–female
duetting
are
often
but
not
always
found
in
the
same
species.
Both
behaviors
more
common
tropical
than
temperate
songbirds,
few
studies
have
differentiated
between
factors
selecting
for
each.
Here
we
investigate
evolution
of
female
vocal
complexity
coordination
Carolina
wrens
(
Thryothorus
ludovicianus
),
one
non‐tropical
members
a
songbird
family
(Troglodytidae)
that
is
well
known
producing
duets.
to
sing;
rather,
they
produce
relatively
simple,
sex‐specific
chatters,
during
territorial
encounters.
We
analyzed
field
recordings
show
females
coordinate
these
chatters
with
male
songs
at
rates
similar
those
observed
some
wren
then
used
phylogenetic
comparative
methods
evolutionary
ancestors
had
were
acoustically
complex
vocalizations
current
females,
suggesting
past
selection
against
complexity.
Levels
males,
contrast,
changed
little
from
ancestors.
Our
results
suggest
two
aspects
behavior,
acoustic
evolved
independently
different
functions
communication.