New Phytologist,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Dec. 25, 2024
The
effects
of
single
chromosome
number
change-dysploidy
-
mediating
diversification
remain
poorly
understood.
Dysploidy
modifies
recombination
rates,
linkage,
or
reproductive
isolation,
especially
for
one-fifth
all
eukaryote
lineages
with
holocentric
chromosomes.
on
have
not
been
estimated
because
modeling
numbers
linked
to
heterogeneity
along
phylogenies
is
quantitatively
challenging.
We
propose
a
new
state-dependent
model
evolution
that
links
rates
dysploidy
considering
and
differentiates
between
anagenetic
cladogenetic
changes.
apply
this
Carex
(Cyperaceae),
cosmopolitan
flowering
plant
clade
recover
two
distinct
modes
chromosomal
speciation
in
Carex.
In
one
mode,
occurs
frequently
drives
faster
rates.
the
other
rare,
driven
by
hidden,
unmeasured
factors.
When
we
use
excludes
hidden
states,
mistakenly
infer
strong,
uniformly
positive
effect
diversification,
showing
standard
models
may
lead
confident
but
incorrect
conclusions
about
diversification.
This
study
demonstrates
can
significant
role
large
despite
presence
factors
simultaneously
affect
Molecular Ecology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
33(24)
Published: Aug. 14, 2023
Repetitive
elements
can
cause
large-scale
chromosomal
rearrangements,
for
example
through
ectopic
recombination,
potentially
promoting
reproductive
isolation
and
speciation.
Species
with
holocentric
chromosomes,
that
lack
a
localized
centromere,
might
be
more
likely
to
retain
rearrangements
lead
karyotype
changes
such
as
fusions
fissions.
This
is
because
chromosome
segregation
during
cell
division
should
less
affected
than
in
organisms
centromere.
The
relationships
between
repetitive
how
they
may
translate
patterns
of
speciation
are
though
poorly
understood.
Here,
we
use
reference-free
approach
based
on
low-coverage
short-read
sequencing
data
characterize
the
repeat
landscape
two
independently
evolved
groups:
Erebia
butterflies
Carex
sedges.
We
consider
both
micro-
macro-evolutionary
scales
investigate
differentiation
populations
association
repeats
phylogenetic
framework
Carex.
At
micro-evolutionary
scale,
found
population
increases
overall
intraspecific
genetic
among
four
species.
indications
an
along
phylogenies.
Altogether,
our
results
suggest
associated
level
clades
therefore
play
role
adaptation
species
diversification.
Nature Plants,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
10(12), P. 1944 - 1954
Published: Nov. 25, 2024
Sex
chromosomes
have
evolved
hundreds
of
times
across
the
flowering
plant
tree
life;
their
recent
origins
in
some
members
this
clade
can
shed
light
on
early
consequences
suppressed
recombination,
a
crucial
step
sex
chromosome
evolution.
Amborella
trichopoda,
sole
species
lineage
that
is
sister
to
all
other
extant
plants,
dioecious
with
young
ZW
determination
system.
Here
we
present
haplotype-resolved
genome
assembly,
including
highly
contiguous
assemblies
Z
and
W
chromosomes.
We
identify
~3-megabase
sex-determination
region
(SDR)
captured
two
strata
includes
~300-kilobase
inversion
enriched
repetitive
sequences
contains
homologue
Arabidopsis
METHYLTHIOADENOSINE
NUCLEOSIDASE
(MTN1-2)
genes,
which
are
known
be
involved
fertility.
However,
remainder
SDR
does
not
show
patterns
typically
found
non-recombining
SDRs,
such
as
repeat
accumulation
gene
loss.
These
findings
consistent
hypothesis
dioecy
derived
pair
has
significantly
degenerated.
The
trichopoda
addresses
outstanding
questions
structure
content
recently
Communications Biology,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
8(1)
Published: March 13, 2025
Genomic
rearrangements
are
primary
drivers
of
evolution,
promoting
biodiversity.
Aphids,
an
agricultural
pest
with
high
species
diversity,
exhibit
rapid
chromosomal
evolution
and
diverse
karyotypes.
These
variations
have
been
attributed
to
their
unique
holocentric
chromosomes
parthenogenesis,
though
this
hypothesis
has
faced
scrutiny.
In
study,
we
generated
a
chromosomal-level
reference
genome
assembly
the
celery
aphid
(Semiaphis
heraclei)
conducted
comparative
genomic
analysis,
revealing
varying
rates
among
lineages,
positively
correlating
diversity.
Aphid
X
undergone
frequent
intra-chromosomal
recombination,
while
autosomes
show
accelerated
inter-chromosomal
recombination.
Moreover,
considering
both
inter-
rearrangements,
increased
autosomal
rearrangement
may
be
common
across
Aphidomorpha.
We
identified
that
expansion
DNA
transposable
elements
short
interspersed
nuclear
(SINEs),
coupled
gene
loss
duplication
associated
karyotypic
instability
(such
as
RIF1,
BRD8,
DMC1,
TERT),
play
crucial
roles
in
evolution.
Additionally,
our
analysis
revealed
mutation
detoxification
families
S.
heraclei
key
factor
adapting
host
plant
chemical
defenses.
Our
results
provide
new
insights
into
evolutionary
patterns
aphids,
aiding
understanding
diversity
adaptive
Chromosomal-level
comparisons
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: May 14, 2024
Sex
chromosomes
have
evolved
hundreds
of
times,
and
their
recent
origins
in
flowering
plants
can
shed
light
on
the
early
consequences
suppressed
recombination.
Amborella
trichopoda,
sole
species
a
lineage
that
is
sister
to
all
other
extant
plants,
dioecious
with
young
ZW
sex
determination
system.
Here
we
present
haplotype-resolved
genome
assembly,
including
highly-contiguous
assemblies
Z
W
chromosomes.
We
identify
~3-Megabase
sex-determination
region
(SDR)
captured
two
strata
includes
~300-Kilobase
inversion
enriched
repetitive
sequence
contains
homolog
Arabidopsis
METHYLTHIOADENOSINE
NUCLEOSIDASE
(MTN1-2)
genes,
which
are
known
be
involved
fertility.
However,
remainder
SDR
does
not
show
patterns
typically
found
non-recombining
SDRs,
like
repeat
accumulation
gene
loss.
These
findings
consistent
hypothesis
dioecy
recently
derived
chromosome
pair
has
significantly
degenerated.
Molecular Ecology,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
33(24)
Published: Nov. 25, 2024
The
field
of
evolutionary
and
speciation
genomics
has
been
revolutionised
by
the
ubiquity
availability
genomic
data
even
for
non-model
organisms.
capability
to
sequence
long-fragment
DNA
particularly
spurred
trans-national
initiatives
generate
publicly
available
chromosome-resolved
reference
genomes
across
Tree
Life.
Initiatives
such
as
Darwin
Life
(The
Project
Consortium
et
al.
2022)
or
European
Genome
Atlas
(ERGA;
Mazzoni,
Ciofi,
Waterhouse
2023)
enable
researchers
around
globe
address
unresolved
questions
pursue
novel
lines
research.
role
chromosomal
rearrangements
(CRs)
in
driving
evolution
a
long-standing
question
biology
(Berdan
2023;
Dobzhansky
Sturtevant
1938;
King
1995;
Robertson
1916;
Wellenreuther
Bernatchez
2018;
White
1978).
CRs
comprise
an
array
that
reorganise
linear
genome,
ranging
from
local
structural
variants
(SVs)
inversions
duplications,
large-scale
karyological
changes,
including
fusions
fissions
Lucek
2023).
Current
have
already
highlighted
are
much
more
common
diverse
taxa
than
previously
thought
(e.g.,
Damas
2022;
Weissensteiner
2020).
While
can
now
easily
be
mapped
within
taxa,
their
potential
species
diversification
often
remained
enigmatic,
theoretical
explorations
exist
only
few
types
CR
At
dawn
broad
genome
model
organisms
alike,
our
special
issue
aims
provide
update
on
impact
various
CRs.
Specifically,
asks
what
causes
establishment
whether
these
differ
among
taxa?
Are
randomly
distributed
do
they
cause
other
rearrangements?
How
promote
how
potentially
lead
speciation?
Is
same
different
CRs?
Finally,
depending
autosomes
sex
chromosomes
involved?
Whether
directly
indirectly
involved
adaptation
diversification,
detecting
them
understanding
factors
influencing
appearance
first
place
key
start
shedding
light
processes
linked
Traditionally,
were
detected
either
directly,
with
cytogenetic
screenings
(Krimbas
Powell
1992;
Stebbins
1971;
1973),
indirectly,
looking
at
consequences
1938).
However,
resolution
techniques
and/or
limitation
cross-species
comparisons
restricted
study
evolution.
In
this
issue,
several
contributions
successfully
used
chromosome-level
assemblies
long-read
sequencing
analyse
range
systems
scales.
Focusing
holocentric
sedges
genus
Carex,
Escudero
(2023)
estimated
overall
high
rate
genus.
Using
dual
approach,
authors
then
combined
linkage
maps
identify
between
species,
later
refine
using
Carex
outgroup
define
conserved
rearranged
regions.
Interestingly,
despite
rates
chromosome
fission
fusion,
longer
expected
syntenic
blocks
species.
Comparing
distribution
transposable
elements
(TEs)
genes
two
regions,
further
showed
regions
correlate
gene
dense
areas,
while
TEs,
pointing
hotspots
reshuffling.
Going
one
step
further,
Cornet
compared
repetitive
independently
evolved
clades
-
Erebia
butterflies
relation
result
karyotype
changes
clades.
First,
low-coverage
short-read
characterised
species-specific
repeat
landscape,
highlighting
classes
occur
four
collected
information
populations
landscapes
populations,
scale
degree
genetic
differentiation,
suggesting
similar
may
affect
rest
genome.
macroevolutionary
scale,
clustering
based
differences
landscape
general
concordance
gene-based
phylogeny,
although
was
stronger
Carex.
Moreover,
number
proxy
inter-chromosome
rearrangements,
found
certain
repeats
likely
associated
changes.
Overall,
results
fusion
events
but
relative
specific
karyotypic
differs
groups.
By
analysing
three
medaka
fishes
representing
major
karyotypes,
is,
metacentric
acrocentric
larger
smaller
arm
numbers,
respectively
well
large
chromosomes,
Ansai
tested
caused
centric
fissions,
pericentric
inversions,
centromere
repositioning,
tandem
fusions.
They
identified
putative
centromeric
continuous
long
reads
polished
short
reads,
assessed
unassembled
phylogenetic
analyses
compare
centromere-associated
study,
not
multiple
enriched
pericentromeric
also
some
sequences
all
centromeres
landscapes.
mechanism
played
fishes,
allowing
shape
without
altering
numbers.
Arias-Sardá,
Quigley,
Farré
aligned
26
ruminant
reconstructed
five
ancestral
ancestor
most
recent
bovids.
doing
so,
CRs,
breakpoint
(EBRs)
blocks.
maintaining
synteny
50
million
years,
others
rearrangement.
Similarly
(2023),
Arias-Sardá
colleagues
looked
into
TEs
showing
depleted
expression
least
nine
tissues
orthologous
housekeeping
genes.
breaks
genes,
tend
located
These
results,
previous
publications
carnivores
rodents
(Álvarez-González
Corbo
highlight
co-localise
boundaries
topologically
domains,
suggest
might
regulatory
disrupting
functional
essential
become
fixed
But
happens
when
occur?
Wang
hotspot
Neurospora
fungi
telomeres
where
duplication
relocation
led
lineage-specific
78%
telomeric
through
regional
rebirth.
To
investigate
functions
assembled
68
experiments
14
transcriptomic
studies,
covering
morphological
stages
distinct
culturing
conditions
N.
crassa.
Although
non-essential
partners
aspects
crassa
biology,
knocked
down
mas-1
increased
resistance
toxins,
contribute
new
phenotypes
under
conditions.
All
all,
highlights
source
novelty
speciation.
Chromosome
formation
structures,
neo-sex
autosome
chromosome.
tribe
Danaini,
Mora
(2024)
investigated
chromosomes.
stand
out
containing
prominent
examples
fused
chromosomes:
recently
neo-W
another
older
neo-Z
Oxford
Nanopore
Illumina
RNA-Seq
libraries
assemble
annotate
Danaini
levels
both
autosomes,
identifying
sex-biased
strong
association
presence
likelihood
turnover,
affecting
W
clusters
significantly
biased
towards
males
females,
roles
This
accumulation
influenced
mechanisms
sexual
antagonism,
emerges
critical
factor
contributing
observed
over
time
macro-evolutionary
perspective,
geographic
isolation
drivers
biodiversity.
Márquez-Corro
conducted
integrative
combining
phylogeography,
ecological
requirements
plant
complex,
Western
Euro-Mediterranean
region.
RADseq
152
samples,
constructed
phylogeny
studied
Combined
molecular
evidence
points
southern
Iberia–north
Africa
cradle
group.
addition,
74
loci
correlated
variables
related
adaptation,
temperature
precipitation.
climatic
variables.
Therefore,
supports
hypothesis
variation,
could
selected
optima
regimes.
Ranging
fungi,
mammals
monocentric
clear
picture
emerges,
genomes;
instead,
paired
elements.
moreover
traits.
If
selectively
advantageous
reproductive
isolation,
eventually
(Faria
Navarro
2010;
Kirkpatrick
Barton
2006).
empirical
observations
taxonomic
groups
2023),
fixation
is
easy
point
view:
meiotic
defects
heterozygotes,
would
hybrid
dysfunction
sterility
underdominant,
especially
low
frequency
(Navarro
2003).
Consequently,
strongly
underdominant
thus
unlikely
spread
fixation.
weak
underdominance
make
likely,
weaker
less
2019;
Faria
Rieseberg
2001).
ambiguous
consequently
referred
'underdominance
paradox'
(Spirito
1998).
Fixation
if
selective
advantage,
instance
overdominance,
via
inbreeding
drift,
which
counteract
negative
selection
facilitate
novel,
yet
(Guerrero
2014;
Hedrick
1981;
still
elusive
addressed
issue.
contribution
Jay,
Aubier,
Joron
implements
two-island
population
explore
flow
overdominant
act
supergenes.
Supergenes
represent
particular
type
polymorphism
group
elements,
segregate
single
Mendelian
locus
(Thompson
Jiggins
2014)
inversions.
Modelling
evolving
disruptive
resulted
poorly
adapted
immigrant
inversion
haplotypes.
model,
supergenes
evolve
maintained
balancing
because
maintenance
alternative
haplotypes
bear
unequal
benefits
adaptation.
case
recombination
load
balances
fitness
load,
loss
existing
locally
haplotype,
turn
differentially
non-recombining
extends
idea
environmental
(Schwander,
Libbrecht,
Keller
2014),
intrinsic
features
themselves.
forward-in-time
simulation
framework,
Banse
outcome
substitutions,
insertion-deletions
(InDels)
Their
models
duplications
reduce
epistasis,
together
support
long-term
Here,
higher
benefit
simulations
started
far
off
optimum,
adaptive
Within
simulated
small
InDels
size
differently.
allow
de
novo
instead
allowed
evolve,
introduce
random
material,
leading
fewer
Together,
evolution,
therefore
speciation,
conditions,
stress
need
develop
frameworks
go
beyond
widespread
Life,
it
remains
unclear
established
chance,
example,
drift
selection.
level
assemblies,
Mackintosh
Brenthis
butterflies.
Based
inferred
demographic
history
focal
show
neutral
very
weakly
system.
enough
fix
considerably
there
positive
natural
drive.
Indeed,
event
sweep,
though
distant
past
excluded.
framework
combines
whole-genome
scale.
Chromosomal
suppression
(Noor
2001;
2001)
inducing
heterozygote
disadvantage
(White
operate
Yoshida
Inversions
(Kirkpatrick
2006)
recombination,
thereby
capturing
linking
alleles,
divergence
face
flow.
comparatively
2018),
studies
focused
(but
see
Augustijnen
2024;
2024),
translocations
(see
Guerrero
(2014)),
Several
expand
polymorphisms.
For
instance,
Ravagni
characterise
absence
acts
supergene
quail
Coturnix
coturnix
Azores.
quails
Europe
Africa,
Macaronesian
archipelagos,
migratory
behaviour
(Sanchez-Donoso
2022).
Azores,
find
inverted
standard
configuration
minimal,
arrangements
coexisted
relatively
populations.
selection,
rather
divergent
maintains
frequencies
migration
absent
Azorean
present
not,
vary
geographical
those
underlying
repeated
ecotype
formation,
polymorphic
species'
explored
Reeve
(2023).
rough
periwinkle
Littorina
saxatilis,
closely
arcana,
polymorphisms
common,
tied
parallel
ecotypes
vast
nonetheless
location-dependent
patterns,
indicating
contain
sets
alleles
pressures.
Altogether,
suggests
complex
ecotypes,
given
basis
always
same.
complementary
approach
detect
spl
heterozygosity,
useful
cases
fully
resolved,
rare.
Mediterranean
long-snouted
seahorses
Hippocampus
guttulatus
Meyer
(2024),
similarly
large,
ancient
inversions:
alternatively
marine
lagoon
environments,
play
second
Sea
governed
combination
pseudo-overdominance
possible
breakdown
link
marine-lagoon
environment
polymorphic,
epistatic
interactions
bring
up
interesting
concerning
interplay
segregating
many
seem
involve
sections
(Meyer
Schaal,
Haller,
Lotterhos
does
case.
extensive,
sockeye
salmon
Oncorhynchus
nerka,
Euclide
islands
spawning
ground.
Most
consistently
everywhere.
Only
seems
hitchhiking.
radiation
multitude
mosaic
unique
allele
combinations
divergence.
require
importance.
architecture
strength
pressures
influence
Sex
disproportionately
(Payseur,
Presgraves,
Filatov
2018)
(Mora
Wright
2016).
Viitaniemi
effects
Z-chromosome
zebra
finch
Taeniopygia
guttata
sperm
morphology.
As
disrupt
regulation
tissue-specific
manner
Kraft
2019),
analysed
testes
liver
development.
impacts
liver,
heterokaryotypes
intermediate
resembling
homokaryotype
gene-specific
manner.
Taken
together,
pleiotropic
tissues.
Technical
limitations
CR.
Recent
developments,
overcome
obstacle
international
democratising
access
resources.
brings
diversity,
micro-
level,
explorations,
nature
classic
detection
methods
data,
use
current
state-of-the-art
comparative
approaches
Contrasting
predictions
homology
(Nadeau
Sankoff
1998),
as,
undergo
(Arias-Sardá,
(2023);
(2023)).
generality
investigation.
(Cornet
(Wang
diversity
genomes.
nevertheless
profound
structure,
repositioning
(Ansai
Despite
ease
genome-wide
quantified,
fixation,
enigmatic.
Overcoming
dominance
paradox,
context
dependent
(Ravagni
Sanchez-Donoso
Other
establish
adaptive,
promoting
Macroevolutionary
investigations
additional
extrinsic
agents
promoted
(Lucek
precipitation
(Potter
2017).
intraspecific
variation
(Euclide
2018).
Given
having
eukaryotic
becoming
reality
next
decade,
inferences
will
possible,
map
genera
families
test
Combining
intra-
interspecific
pan-genome
hold
bridge
Identifying
target
allows
experimental
CRISPR/CAS9
(Cheng
nanosurgery
(Blázquez-Castro,
Fernández-Piqueras,
Santos
2020)
correlational
associations.
Understanding
requires
so
2019)
numbers
InDels.
primarily
along
latter
folded
three-dimensional
structure
altered
technical
advances
organisms,
assess
(Mohan
2024).
contributed
writing
manuscript.
We
like
thank
who
articles
Special
Issue,
reviewers
evaluated
manuscripts.
executive
editor
Ben
Sibbett
his
help
throughout.
K.L.
supported
Swiss
National
Science
Foundation
(SNSF)
Eccellenza
'The
barriers
completion
speciation'
(Grant
ID
202869)
H.A.
SNSF
grant
184934
'Genomic
origin
awarded
Burckhardt-Bürgin
foundation
219283
Thomas
Flatt.
C.A.-S.
funded
GTA
fellowship
programme
University
Kent.
M.F.
Royal
Society
RGS/R1/211047.
declare
no
conflicts
interest.
editorial
any
data.
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: June 29, 2024
Abstract
Chromosomal
rearrangements
are
crucial
in
speciation,
acting
as
barriers
to
gene
flow.
Holocentric
chromosomes,
such
those
Lepidoptera,
can
facilitate
karyotype
changes.
Despite
chromosome
fusions
being
more
common,
speciation
events
mostly
linked
fissions.
Notable
karyotypic
variation
is
observed
three
clades
of
the
subfamily
Polyommatinae
(Lycaenidae),
with
numbers
ranging
from
n
=
10
225.
This
study
used
flow
cytometry
and
molecular
cytogenetic
analyses
investigate
genome
sizes
karyotypes
several
species
genera
Polyommatus
Lysandra
derived
modal
numbers.
The
findings
show
no
support
for
polyploidy,
supporting
diversification
via
fragmentation
chromosomes.
Species
high
have
larger
genomes,
which
indicates
a
potential
role
mobile
elements
but
contradicts
hypothesis
holocentric
drive.
Telomeric
signals
were
detected
at
ends
fragmented
No
interstitial
telomeric
sequences
on
autosomes.
Interstitial
sex
however,
revealed
multiple
systems
dorylas
icarus
,
two
races
differing
constitution
latter.
Pool-seq
coverage
indicated
shared
fusion
chromosomes
an
autosome
bearing
rDNA
locus,
followed
by
20
Czech
population.
Notably,
W
resists
fragmentation,
likely
due
epigenetic
silencing
protecting
it
activity
elements.
Research Square (Research Square),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Aug. 13, 2024
Abstract
Genomic
rearrangements
are
primary
drivers
of
evolution,
promoting
biodiversity
and
differentiation.
Aphids,
an
agricultural
pest
with
high
species
diversity,
exhibit
rapid
chromosomal
evolution
a
wide
range
nuclear
karyotype
variations.
These
variations
have
been
attributed
to
their
unique
holocentric
chromosomes
parthenogenetic
generations,
though
this
hypothesis
has
also
faced
scrutiny.
An
in-depth
comparative
genomics
analysis
aphid
genomic
will
enhance
our
understanding
diversity
evolution.
In
study,
by
generating
chromosomal-level
reference
genome
assembly
the
celery
(Semiaphis
heraclei)
conducting
analysis,
we
revealed
varying
rates
among
lineages,
positively
correlating
diversity.
Aphid
X
undergone
frequent
intra-chromosomal
recombination,
while
autosomes
show
accelerated
inter-chromosomal
recombination.
Moreover,
considering
both
inter-
rearrangements,
increased
autosomal
rearrangement
may
be
common
across
Aphidomorpha
lineage.
Additionally,
expansion
DNA
SINE-type
transposable
elements,
along
gene
loss
duplication
associated
karyotypic
instability
(such
as,
RIF1,
BRD8,
DMC1,
TERT),
play
crucial
roles
in
Our
results
provide
new
insights
into
evolutionary
patterns,
which
helpful
for
genetic
mechanisms
behind
adaptive
DNA Research,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
31(6)
Published: Oct. 24, 2024
Abstract
Satellite
DNAs
(satDNAs)
are
abundant
components
of
eukaryotic
genomes,
playing
pivotal
roles
in
chromosomal
organization,
genome
stability,
and
evolution.
Here,
we
combined
cytogenetic
genomic
methods
to
characterize
the
satDNAs
genomes
Leptidea
butterflies.
is
characterized
by
presence
a
high
heterochromatin
content,
large
extensive
reshuffling
as
well
occurrence
cryptic
species.
We
show
that,
contrast
other
Lepidoptera,
constitute
considerable
proportion
ranging
between
4.11%
11.05%.
This
amplification
satDNAs,
together
with
hyperactivity
transposable
elements,
contributes
substantial
expansion
Leptidea.
Using
mapping,
particularly
LepSat01-100
LepSat03-167
preferentially
localized
exhibiting
variable
distribution
that
may
have
contributed
highly
diverse
karyotypes
within
genus.
The
also
exhibit
W-chromosome
accumulation,
suggesting
their
involvement
sex
chromosome
Our
results
provide
insights
into
dynamics
Lepidoptera
highlight
role
which
could
influence
speciation
process.
repetitive
underscores
complex
evolutionary
revealing
interplay
architecture