Ornithischians
form
a
large
clade
of
globally
distributed
Mesozoic
dinosaurs,
and
one
their
three
major
radiations.Throughout
evolutionary
history,
exceeding
134
million
years,
ornithischians
evolved
considerable
morphological
disparity,
expressed
especially
through
the
cranial
osteodermal
features
most
distinguishable
representatives.The
nearly
two-century-long
research
history
on
has
resulted
in
recognition
numerous
diverse
lineages,
many
which
have
been
named.Following
formative
publications
establishing
theoretical
foundation
phylogenetic
nomenclature
throughout
1980s
1990s,
proposed
names
ornithischian
clades
were
provided
with
definitions.Some
these
definitions
proven
useful
not
changed,
beyond
way
they
formulated,
since
introduction.Some
names,
however,
multiple
definitions,
making
application
ambiguous.Recent
implementation
International
Code
Phylogenetic
Nomenclature
(ICPN,
or
PhyloCode)
offers
opportunity
to
explore
utility
previously
established
taxon
names.Since
Articles
ICPN
are
be
applied
retroactively,
all
published
prior
its
remain
informal
(and
ineffective)
light
Code.Here,
we
revise
dinosaur
clades;
revisit
76
preexisting
review
recent
historical
use,
formally
establish
definitions.Additionally,
introduce
five
new
names;
two
for
robustly
supported
later-diverging
hadrosaurids
ceratopsians,
uniting
Biological reviews/Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
96(2), P. 470 - 525
Published: Dec. 2, 2020
ABSTRACT
Morphology
forms
the
most
fundamental
level
of
data
in
vertebrate
palaeontology
because
it
is
through
interpretations
morphology
that
taxa
are
identified,
creating
basis
for
broad
evolutionary
and
palaeobiological
hypotheses.
Assessing
maturity
one
basic
aspects
morphological
interpretation
provides
means
to
study
evolution
ontogenetic
changes,
population
structure
palaeoecology,
life‐history
strategies,
heterochrony
along
lineages
would
otherwise
be
lost
time.
Saurian
reptiles
(the
least‐inclusive
clade
containing
Lepidosauria
Archosauria)
have
remained
an
incredibly
diverse,
numerous,
disparate
their
~260‐million‐year
history.
Because
great
disparity
this
group,
assessing
saurian
difficult,
fraught
with
methodological
terminological
ambiguity.
We
compiled
a
novel
database
literature,
assembling
>900
individual
instances
assessment,
examine
critically
how
has
been
diagnosed.
review
often
inexact
inconsistent
terminology
used
assessment
(e.g.
‘juvenile’,
‘mature’)
provide
routes
better
clarity
cross‐study
coherence.
describe
various
methods
assess
every
major
integrating
from
both
extant
extinct
give
full
account
current
state
field
providing
method‐specific
pitfalls,
best
practices,
fruitful
directions
future
research.
recommend
new
standard
subsection,
‘Ontogenetic
Assessment’,
added
Systematic
Palaeontology
portions
descriptive
studies
explicit
diagnoses
clear
criteria.
utility
different
criteria
highly
subclade
dependent
among
saurians,
even
widely
neurocentral
suture
fusion),
we
phylogenetic
context,
preferably
form
bracket,
justify
use
method.
Different
should
conjunction
as
independent
lines
evidence
when
maturity,
instead
diagnosis
resting
entirely
on
single
criterion,
which
common
literature.
Critically,
there
need
well‐represented
growth
series
integrated
fossil
record
ground
assessments
well‐constrained,
empirically
tested
methods.
PeerJ,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
9, P. e12362 - e12362
Published: Dec. 9, 2021
Ornithischians
form
a
large
clade
of
globally
distributed
Mesozoic
dinosaurs,
and
represent
one
their
three
major
radiations.
Throughout
evolutionary
history,
exceeding
134
million
years,
ornithischians
evolved
considerable
morphological
disparity,
expressed
especially
through
the
cranial
osteodermal
features
most
distinguishable
representatives.
The
nearly
two-century-long
research
history
on
has
resulted
in
recognition
numerous
diverse
lineages,
many
which
have
been
named.
Following
formative
publications
establishing
theoretical
foundation
phylogenetic
nomenclature
throughout
1980s
1990s,
proposed
names
ornithischian
clades
were
provided
with
definitions.
Some
these
definitions
proven
useful
not
changed,
beyond
way
they
formulated,
since
introduction.
names,
however,
multiple
definitions,
making
application
ambiguous.
Recent
implementation
International
Code
Phylogenetic
Nomenclature
(
ICPN
,
or
PhyloCode
)
offers
opportunity
to
explore
utility
previously
established
taxon
names.
Since
Articles
are
be
applied
retroactively,
all
published
prior
its
remain
informal
(and
ineffective)
light
Code.
Here,
we
revise
dinosaur
clades;
revisit
76
preexisting
review
recent
historical
use,
formally
establish
Additionally,
introduce
five
new
names:
two
for
robustly
supported
later-diverging
hadrosaurids
ceratopsians,
uniting
heterodontosaurids
genasaurs,
nodosaurids.
Our
study
marks
key
step
towards
formal
dinosaurs.
PLoS ONE,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
19(4), P. e0298242 - e0298242
Published: April 3, 2024
Dinosauria
debuted
on
Earth’s
stage
in
the
aftermath
of
Permo-Triassic
Mass
Extinction
Event,
and
survived
two
other
Triassic
extinction
intervals
to
eventually
dominate
terrestrial
ecosystems.
More
than
231
million
years
ago,
Upper
Ischigualasto
Formation
west-central
Argentina,
dinosaurs
were
just
getting
warmed
up.
At
this
time,
represented
a
minor
fraction
ecosystem
diversity.
Members
tetrapod
clades,
including
synapsids
pseudosuchians,
shared
convergently
evolved
features
related
locomotion,
feeding,
respiration,
metabolism
could
have
risen
later
dominance.
However,
it
was
that
radiated
Mesozoic
most
significantly
terms
body
size,
diversity,
global
distribution.
Elevated
growth
rates
are
one
adaptations
set
apart,
particularly
from
their
contemporary
crocodilian
mammalian
compatriots.
When
did
elevated
first
evolve?
How
strategies
earliest
known
compare
with
those
tetrapods
ecosystems?
We
studied
femoral
bone
histology
an
array
early
alongside
non-dinosaurian
contemporaries
order
test
whether
oldest
exhibited
novel
strategies.
Our
results
indicate
vertebrate
fauna
collectively
exhibits
relatively
high
rates.
Dinosaurs
among
fastest
growing
taxa
sample,
but
they
occupied
niche
crocodylomorphs,
archosauriformes,
large-bodied
pseudosuchians.
Interestingly,
these
grew
at
least
as
quickly,
more
continuously
sauropodomorph
theropod
Mesozoic.
These
data
suggest
that,
while
ancestral
for
likely
played
significant
role
dinosaurs’
ascent
within
ecosystems,
not
them
apart
contemporaries.
PLoS ONE,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
19(4), P. e0300289 - e0300289
Published: April 17, 2024
Giant
ichthyosaurs
with
body
length
estimates
exceeding
20
m
were
present
in
the
latest
Triassic
of
UK.
Here
we
report
on
discovery
a
second
surangular
from
lower
jaw
giant
ichthyosaur
Somerset,
The
new
find
is
comparable
size
and
morphology
to
specimen
Lilstock,
described
2018,
but
it
more
complete
better
preserved.
Both
finds
are
uppermost
Westbury
Mudstone
Formation
(Rhaetian),
comes
Blue
Anchor,
approximately
10
km
west
along
coast
Lilstock.
would
have
been
>2
long,
an
individual
estimated
at
~25
m.
identification
two
specimens
same
unique
geologic
age
geographic
location
warrants
erection
genus
species,
Ichthyotitan
severnensis
gen.
et
sp.
nov.
Thin
sections
revealed
histological
features
already
observed
similar
ichthyosaurian
specimens.
Our
data
also
supports
previous
suggestion
atypical
osteogenesis
jaws
ichthyosaurs.
geological
suggest
shastasaurid
affinities,
material
too
incomplete
for
definitive
referral.
nov.,
first-named
Rhaetian
probably
represents
largest
marine
reptile
formally
described.
Journal of Anatomy,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Jan. 28, 2025
Abstract
Ornithopods
are
an
extinct
group
of
dinosaurs
that
were
particularly
abundant
and
diverse
in
the
Cretaceous
Iberian
Peninsula,
whose
abundance
Maestrazgo
Basin
has
allowed
numerous
taxa
to
be
identified
over
last
decade.
Many
these
fossil
remains
still
taxonomically
indeterminate
require
a
more
detailed
study
on
both
macroscopic
microscopic
scale.
In
this
contribution,
osteohistological
analysis
is
carried
out
partial
skeleton—composed
five
incomplete
vertebrae,
two
dorsal
ribs,
ischium,
fibula,
tibia—found
province
Aliaga
(Teruel,
NE
Spain).
We
progressive
slowdown
tissue
apposition
variation
type
growth
marks
generated
every
bone,
allowing
precise
identification
ontogenetic
stage
specimen
as
subadult
individual.
The
skeletochronological
correlation
between
different
elements
also
suggests
reached
sexual
maturity
at
around
seven
years
age
died
nine
twelve
age.
Likewise,
usefulness
three‐front
model
proven
for
first
time
ornithopod
dinosaur,
tool
analysing
histology
expressed
by
bone
single
inferring
their
potential.
Comparison
with
other
reveals
great
variability
each
element
shows
depending
taxon
analysed,
which
prevents
us
from
determining
suitable
studying
skeletochronology
any
taxon.
Scientific Reports,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
11(1)
Published: June 11, 2021
Abstract
Senile
vertebrates
are
extremely
rare
in
the
fossil
record,
making
their
recognition
difficult.
Here
we
present
largest
known
representative
of
Late
Cretaceous
hadrosauriform
Gobihadros
mongoliensis
showing
features
cessation
growth
indicating
attainment
terminal
size.
Moreover,
this
is
first
non-avian
dinosaur
with
an
age-related
pathology
recognized
as
primary
calcium
pyrophosphate
deposition
disease
its
advanced
age.
Because
senile
dinosaurs
so
and
thus
“senescence”
unclear,
also
propose
a
new
unified
definition
dinosaur:
individual
which
achieved
size
revealed
by
presence
external
fundamental
system
closed
transcortical
channels,
has
completely
secondary
remodeled
weight-bearing
bones
possesses
non-traumatic,
non-contagious
bone
pathologies
correlated
Acta Palaeontologica Polonica,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
66
Published: Jan. 1, 2021
Five
new
partial
skulls
of
the
hadrosaurid
dinosaur
Maiasaura
peeblesorum
from
Linster
Quarry
bone
bed
(Two
Medicine
Formation,
Campanian)
in
Montana,
USA,
provide
basis
for
a
description
skull
roof
and
braincase
morphology
this
taxon.These
additionally
form
an
ontogenetic
series
consisting
one
subadult,
two
small
"intermediate
adults",
larger
"mature
adults".The
subadult
is
approximately
thirds
as
wide
largest
adult
lacks
nasofrontal
crest,
suggesting
that
crest
formed
relatively
late
ontogeny
compared
to
some
other
hadrosaurids.As
closely
related
taxa,
M.
have
proportionately
wider
larger,
more
rugosely
ridged
contact
supporting
crest.In
adults,
incipiently
overhangs
anterior
margin
dorsotemporal
fenestrae.In
examined,
semicircular
view
incorporates
flared,
anteriorly
concave
prefrontals
its
lateral
margins.Intraspecific
variation
observed
cranial
characters
previously
discussed
interspecific
including
prominence
dorsal
depressions
on
frontal,
position
foramen
facial
nerve
(CN
VII).Although
shares
trends
with
Brachylophosaurus
Probrachylophosaurus,
it
deviates
ways
previous
heterochronic
model
proposed
evolution
Maiasaurini.