Abstract.
Ocean
Alkalinity
Enhancement
(OAE)
is
a
Negative
Emissions
Technology
(NET)
that
shows
significant
potential
for
climate
change
mitigation.
By
increasing
the
bicarbonate
ion
concentration
in
ocean
water,
OAE
could
enhance
long-term
carbon
storage
and
mitigate
acidification.
However,
side
effects
and/or
co-benefits
of
on
natural
planktonic
communities
remain
poorly
understood.
To
address
this
knowledge
gap,
mesocosm
experiment
was
conducted
oligotrophic
waters
Gran
Canaria.
A
CO2-equilibrated
Total
(TA)
gradient
employed
increments
300
µmol·L-1,
ranging
from
~2400
to
~4800
µmol·L-1.
This
study
represents
first
attempt
evaluate
impacts
under
conditions.
The
results
show
Net
Community
Production
(NCP),
Gross
(GP),
Respiration
(CR)
rates,
as
well
metabolic
balance
(GP:CR),
did
not
exhibit
linear
response
whole
alkalinity
gradient.
Instead,
polynomial
regression
models
were
observed
all
rates
up
∆TA1800
relation
Dissolved
Inorganic
Carbon
(DIC)
concentrations.
Notably,
∆TA1500
1800
µmol·L-1
treatments
showed
peaks
NCP
shifting
heterotrophic
an
autotrophic
state,
with
values
4
8
µmol
O2
kg-1
d-1,
respectively.
These
optimum
curve
also
reflected
nanophytoplankton
abundance,
size-fractionated
chlorophyll
a14C
uptake
data.
Furthermore,
abiotic
precipitation
occurred
highest
treatment
after
day
21
but
no
impact
measured
parameters
detected.
Overall,
damaging
effect
range
applied
here,
phytoplankton
primary
production,
community
metabolism
composition
be
inferred.
In
fact,
co-benefit
form
positive
curvilinear
DIC
treatment.
Further
experimental
research
at
scale
key
gain
better
understanding
short
communities.
State of the Planet,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
unknown, P. 1 - 1
Published: Nov. 27, 2023
Abstract.
Monitoring,
reporting,
and
verification
(MRV)
refers
to
the
multistep
process
of
monitoring
amount
greenhouse
gas
removed
by
a
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
activity
reporting
results
third
party.
The
party
then
verifies
results.
While
MRV
is
usually
conducted
in
pursuit
certification
voluntary
or
regulated
CDR
market,
this
chapter
focuses
on
key
recommendations
for
relevant
ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
research.
Early
stage
OAE
research
may
become
foundation
which
markets
are
built.
Therefore,
such
carries
special
obligation
toward
comprehensiveness,
reproducibility,
transparency.
Observational
approaches
during
field
trials
should
aim
quantify
delivery
seawater
monitor
secondary
precipitation,
biotic
calcification,
other
ecosystem
changes
that
can
feed
back
sources
sinks
gases
where
measurably
elevated.
Observations
resultant
shifts
partial
pressure
CO2
(pCO2)
pH
help
determine
efficacy
amenable
autonomous
monitoring.
However,
because
turbulent
energetic
equilibration
between
atmosphere
take
several
months
longer,
added
will
be
diluted
perturbation
levels
undetectable
above
background
variability
timescales
MRV.
comprehensive
quantification
via
impossible
through
observational
methods
alone,
numerical
simulations
required.
development
fit-for-purpose
models,
carefully
validated
against
data,
critical
part
OAE.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
22(2), P. 405 - 415
Published: Jan. 22, 2025
Abstract.
The
urgent
necessity
of
reducing
greenhouse
gas
emissions
is
coupled
with
a
pressing
need
for
widespread
implementation
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
techniques
to
limit
the
increase
in
mean
global
temperature
levels
below
2
°C
compared
pre-industrial
times.
One
proposed
CDR
method,
ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE),
mimics
natural
rock
weathering
processes
by
introducing
suitable
minerals
into
ocean,
thereby
increasing
and
promoting
CO2
chemical
absorption.
While
theoretical
studies
hold
promise
OAE
as
climate
mitigation
strategy,
careful
consideration
its
ecological
implications
essential.
Indeed,
impact
enhanced
on
marine
organisms
remains
subject
investigation,
it
may
lead
changes
species
composition.
implicates
favorable
conditions
calcifying
enhancing
saturation
state
calcium
carbonate
decreasing
energetic
costs
calcification.
This
affect
primary
production
improving
phytoplankton,
among
which
coccolithophores
play
leading
role.
They
contribute
<
10
%
but
are
responsible
large
proportion
calcite
deposition.
previous
research
has
extensively
studied
effects
acidification
coccolithophores,
fewer
have
explored
impacts
elevated
pH
alkalinity.
In
this
context,
we
sensitivity
Emiliania
huxleyi,
most
coccolithophore
species,
culture
experiment.
We
monitored
species'
growth
calcification
response
progressively
total
(TA).
Above
change
(ΔTA)
∼
600
µmol
kg−1,
concentrations
decreased,
E.
huxleyi
rate
diminished,
suggesting
threshold
concentration
100
µatm
necessary
optimal
growth.
cellular
organic
ratio
(PIC
:
POC)
remained
stable
over
range.
Due
enhancement,
formation
was
lower.
rapidly
advancing
already
reached
field-testing
stage.
Hence,
our
study
contributes
critical
part
investigations
required
comprehend
potential
biological
before
large-scale
adopted.
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: April 9, 2023
Abstract
Anthropogenic
greenhouse
gas
emissions
are
leading
to
global
temperature
increases,
ocean
acidification,
and
significant
ecosystem
impacts.
Given
current
trajectories,
the
IPCC
reports
indicate
that
rapid
abatement
of
CO
2
development
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
strategies
needed
address
legacy
difficult
abate
sources.
These
CDR
methods
must
efficiently
safely
sequester
gigatons
atmospheric
.
Coastal
Enhanced
Weathering
(CEW)
via
addition
common
mineral
olivine
coastal
waters
is
one
promising
approach
enhance
alkalinity
for
large-scale
CDR.
As
weathers,
it
releases
several
biologically
active
dissolution
products,
including
alkalinity,
trace
metals,
nutrient
silicate.
Released
metals
can
serve
as
micronutrients
but
may
also
be
toxic
at
high
concentrations
marine
biota
phytoplankton
lie
base
food
webs.
We
grew
six
species
representing
globally
important
under
elevated
products
a
synthetic
leachate
(OL)
based
on
elemental
composition.
monitored
their
physiological
biogeochemical
responses,
which
allowed
us
determine
impacts
thresholds
concentrations,
in
individual
effects
specific
constituents.
found
both
positive
neutral
responses
no
evident
two
silicifying
diatoms,
calcifying
coccolithophore,
three
cyanobacteria.
In
single
competitive
co-cultures,
silicifiers
calcifiers
benefited
from
like
iron
silicate
or
enhanced
respectively.
The
non-N
-fixing
picocyanobacterium
could
use
olivine-derived
growth,
while
N
cyanobacteria
not.
However,
other
nickel
cobalt
supported
cyanobacterial
growth
across
groups.
Growth
benefits
groups
situ
will
depend
species-specific
ambient
required
nutrients.
Results
suggest
appear
unlikely
cause
negative
any
examined,
even
support
particular
taxa
some
conditions.
Future
studies
shed
light
long-term
eco-evolutionary
exposure
potential
microbes
turn
have
rates
regional
biogeochemistry.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
21(11), P. 2777 - 2794
Published: June 12, 2024
Abstract.
Gigatonne-scale
atmospheric
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
will
almost
certainly
be
needed
to
supplement
the
emission
reductions
required
keep
global
warming
between
1.5–2
°C.
Ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
is
an
emerging
marine
CDR
method
with
addition
of
pulverised
minerals
surface
ocean
being
one
widely
considered
approach.
A
concern
this
approach
potential
for
dissolution
products
released
from
impact
phytoplankton
communities.
We
conducted
experiment
10
pelagic
mesocosms
(M1–M10)
in
Raunefjorden,
Bergen,
Norway,
assess
implications
simulated
silicate-
and
calcium-based
mineral
OAE
on
a
coastal
plankton
community.
Five
(M1,
M3,
M5,
M7,
M9)
were
enriched
silicate
(∼
75
µmol
L−1
Na2SiO3),
along
gradient
0
∼
600
kg−1,
magnesium
proportion
additions.
The
other
five
(M2,
M4,
M6,
M8,
M10)
same
calcium
explored
many
components
community,
microbes
fish
larvae,
here
we
report
influence
based
diatom
silicification.
Macronutrients
(nitrate
phosphate)
limited
silicification
at
onset
until
nutrient
additions
day
26.
Silicification
was
significantly
greater
silicate-based
treatment,
all
genera
except
Cylindrotheca
displaying
increase
as
result
increased
concentration
dissolved
silicate.
In
contrast
effect
differences
concentrations
two
treatments,
increases
only
influenced
genera,
Pseudo-nitzschia
Nitzschia.
four
(Arcocellulus,
Cylindrotheca,
Skeletonema,
Thalassiosira)
investigated
displayed
no
significant
changes
kg−1
above
natural
levels.
summary,
our
findings
illustrate
that
via
methods
has
genus-specific
impacts
diatoms.
This
research
underscores
importance
understanding
full
breadth
different
approaches,
their
risks,
co-benefits,
interactive
effects.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
20(22), P. 4669 - 4682
Published: Nov. 27, 2023
Abstract.
Anthropogenic
greenhouse
gas
emissions
are
leading
to
global
temperature
increases,
ocean
acidification,
and
significant
ecosystem
impacts.
Given
current
trajectories,
the
IPCC's
reports
indicate
that
rapid
abatement
of
CO2
development
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
strategies
needed
address
legacy
difficult-to-abate
sources.
These
CDR
methods
must
efficiently
safely
sequester
gigatons
atmospheric
CO2.
Coastal
enhanced
weathering
(CEW)
via
addition
common
mineral
olivine
coastal
waters
is
one
promising
approach
enhance
alkalinity
for
large-scale
CDR.
As
weathers,
it
releases
several
biologically
active
dissolution
products,
including
alkalinity,
trace
metals,
nutrient
silicate.
Released
metals
can
serve
as
micronutrients
but
may
also
be
toxic
at
high
concentrations
marine
biota,
phytoplankton,
which
lie
base
food
webs.
We
grew
six
species
representing
globally
important
phytoplankton
under
elevated
products
a
synthetic
leachate
(OL)
based
on
olivine's
elemental
composition.
monitored
their
physiological
biogeochemical
responses,
allowed
us
determine
impacts
thresholds
concentrations,
in
individual
effects
specific
constituents.
found
both
positive
neutral
responses
no
evident
two
silicifying
diatoms,
calcifying
coccolithophore,
three
cyanobacteria.
In
single
competitive
co-cultures,
silicifiers
calcifiers
benefited
from
like
iron
silicate
or
respectively.
The
non-N2-fixing
picocyanobacterium
could
use
olivine-derived
growth,
while
N2-fixing
cyanobacteria
not.
However,
other
nickel
cobalt
supported
cyanobacterial
growth
across
groups.
Growth
benefits
groups
situ
will
depend
species-specific
ambient
required
nutrients.
Results
suggest
appear
unlikely
cause
negative
any
examined,
even
support
particular
taxa
some
conditions.
Future
studies
shed
light
long-term
eco-evolutionary
exposure
potential
microbes
turn
have
rates
regional
biogeochemistry.
Frontiers in Climate,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
6
Published: April 12, 2024
Research
over
the
past
decade
has
resulted
in
various
methods
for
removing
CO
2
from
atmosphere
using
seawater
and
electrochemically
generated
acids
bases.
This
Perspective
aims
to
present
a
unified
framework
comparing
these
approaches.
Specifically,
can
all
be
seen
as
falling
into
one
of
two
categories:
those
that
result
net
increase
ocean
alkalinity
use
“ocean
sponge”
atmospheric
(ocean
enhancement,
or
OAE)
cycle
pump”
cycling,
OAC).
In
this
Perspective,
approaches
marine
carbon
dioxide
removal
(mCDR)
electrochemistry
are
compared
framework,
similarities
differences
categories
explored.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
21(11), P. 2859 - 2876
Published: June 13, 2024
Abstract.
Ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
is
a
negative
emissions
technology
(NET)
that
shows
significant
potential
for
climate
change
mitigation.
By
increasing
the
bicarbonate
ion
concentration
in
ocean
water,
OAE
could
enhance
long-term
carbon
storage
and
mitigate
acidification.
However,
side
effects
and/or
co-benefits
of
on
natural
planktonic
communities
remain
poorly
understood.
To
address
this
knowledge
gap,
mesocosm
experiment
was
conducted
oligotrophic
waters
Gran
Canaria.
A
CO2-equilibrated
total
(TA)
gradient
employed
increments
300
µmol
L−1,
ranging
from
∼
2400
to
4800
L−1.
This
study
represents
first
attempt
evaluate
impacts
under
conditions.
The
results
show
net
community
production
(NCP),
gross
(GP),
respiration
(CR)
rates,
metabolic
balance
(GP:CR)
did
not
exhibit
linear
response
whole
gradient.
Instead,
polynomial
regression
models
were
observed
all
rates
up
ΔTA
1800
relation
dissolved
inorganic
(DIC)
concentrations.
Notably,
1500
L−1
treatments
showed
peaks
NCP
shifting
heterotrophic
an
autotrophic
state,
with
values
4
8
O2
kg−1
d−1,
respectively.
These
optimum
curve
also
reflected
nanoplankton
abundance,
size-fractionated
chlorophyll
a,
14C
uptake
data.
Furthermore,
abiotic
precipitation
occurred
highest
treatment
after
day
21,
but
no
impact
measured
parameters
detected.
Overall,
damaging
effect
range
applied
here
phytoplankton
primary
production,
metabolism,
composition
be
inferred.
In
fact,
co-benefit
form
positive
curvilinear
DIC
treatment.
Further
experimental
research
at
scale
key
gain
better
understanding
short-
communities.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
22(1), P. 71 - 86
Published: Jan. 8, 2025
Abstract.
Ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
has
been
proposed
as
a
carbon
dioxide
removal
technology
(CDR),
allowing
for
long-term
storage
of
in
the
ocean.
By
changing
carbonate
speciation
seawater,
OAE
may
potentially
alter
marine
ecosystems
with
implications
biological
pump.
Using
mesocosms
subtropical
North
Atlantic,
we
provide
first
empirical
insights
into
impacts
carbonate-based
on
vertical
flux
and
attenuation
sinking
particles
an
oligotrophic
plankton
community.
We
enhanced
total
(TA)
increments
300
µmol
kg−1,
reaching
up
to
ΔTA
=
2400
kg−1
compared
ambient
TA.
applied
pCO2-equilibrated
approach;
i.e.,
dissolved
inorganic
(DIC)
was
raised
simultaneously
TA
maintain
seawater
pCO2
equilibrium
atmosphere,
thereby
keeping
perturbations
chemistry
moderate.
The
major
elements,
including
carbon,
nitrogen,
phosphorus,
silicon,
well
their
stoichiometric
ratios
(e.g.,
carbon-to-nitrogen
ratios),
remained
unaffected
over
29
d
OAE.
particle
properties
controlling
attenuation,
velocities
remineralization
rates,
also
by
However,
observed
abiotic
mineral
precipitation
at
high
levels
(ΔTA
1800
higher)
that
resulted
substantial
increase
particulate
(PIC)
formation.
associated
consumption
reduces
efficiency
CO2
emphasizes
importance
maintaining
within
carefully
defined
operating
range.
Our
findings
suggest
export
communities
is
insensitive
using
pre-equilibrated
approach.
integrity
ecosystem
services
prerequisite
large-scale
application
should
be
further
tested
across
variety
nutrient
regimes
less
idealized
approaches.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
22(2), P. 499 - 512
Published: Jan. 28, 2025
Abstract.
Over
the
past
250
years,
atmospheric
CO2
concentrations
have
risen
steadily
from
277
to
405
ppm,
driving
global
climate
change.
In
response,
new
tools
are
being
developed
remove
carbon
atmosphere
using
negative
emission
technologies
(NETs),
in
addition
reducing
anthropogenic
emissions.
One
proposed
NET
is
ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE),
which
artificially
raising
favours
formation
of
bicarbonate
CO2,
leading
a
decrease
partial
pressure
water.
Subsequent
invasion
results
net
sequestration
carbon.
The
aim
this
study
was
investigate
impact
simulated
OAE,
through
alteration
pH,
on
phytoplankton
representative
spring
and
fall
blooms
nearshore,
temperate
waters.
potential
impacts
OAE
were
assessed
(1)
an
analysis
prior
studies
investigating
effects
elevated
pH
growth
rates
(2)
experimental
assessment
short-term
(10
min)
long-term
(8
d)
elevation
viability
subsequent
two
nearshore
species
phytoplankton.
Viability
with
modified
serial
dilution
culture–most
probable
number
assay.
Chlorophyll
fluorescence
used
test
for
changes
photosynthetic
competence
apparent
rates.
There
no
significant
or
diatom
Thalassiosira
pseudonana
prymnesiophyte
Diacronema
lutheri
(formerly
Pavlova
lutheri)
exposure
pH.
However,
there
Short-term
anticipated
more
closely
mirror
natural
systems
land-based
will
be
implemented
because
system
flushing
dilution.
indicates
wide
variability
response
within
between
taxonomic
groups,
about
50
%
expected
not
impacted
by
increase
unequilibrated
mineral-based
OAE.
To
extent
that
responses
reflect
(largely
unreported)
parallel
reductions
dissolved
inorganic
(DIC)
availability,
susceptibility
may
reduced
ingassing
prevented.