The Study of Consciousness Is Mired in Complexities and Difficulties: Can They Be Resolved? DOI Creative Commons
Jonathan Nash

Published: Aug. 29, 2024

This paper explores several etymological, semantic, sociolinguistic, and methodological issues that have, in my opinion, impeded the progress of consciousness research discourse; I offer some suggestions are hopefully worthy consideration. review historical extant conflation terms literature, a litany published definitions types consciousness, call for greater “semantic lucidity”. critique rationale underpinning search neural correlates advocate adherence to requirements an operational definition research, discuss paradigm as ‘process’ versus premise tangible ‘thing’ can somehow be found particular locus within material substrate nervous system.

Language: Английский

Growing Confidence and Remaining Uncertainty About Animal Consciousness DOI Open Access
Louis N. Irwin

Qeios, Journal Year: 2024, Volume and Issue: unknown

Published: July 3, 2024

While the study of consciousness has had a controversial history and, until recently, pessimistic prognosis, recent views within neuroscientific community suggest that maturing if incomplete scientific understanding is close at hand. The purpose this essay to specify major points on which in my opinion there widespread though not universal agreement, as proposed benchmarks for current state research across phylogenetic spectrum. Most published definitions boil down focus it process arising nervous system engaged with body and its environment, giving rise subjective (personal) experience. A broad consensus phenomenology sees consisting minimum (1) awareness_ _and focused attention, (2) unity perception, (3) qualitative variations content, (4) mental causation, (5) sense self. There also agreement substrate requires sizeable, complex systems organized into several hierarchical levels processing. Further insight gained by reconstructing evolution phenomenological experience ― most likely from multiple origins, hosted diversity brain architectures, diverging markedly different forms animal kingdom. However, three mysteries about remain unresolved are neurological correlates consciousness, apparent gap between mechanism, monitors activity admitted consciousness.

Language: Английский

Citations

3
The Study of Consciousness Is Mired in Complexities and Difficulties: Can They Be Resolved? DOI Creative Commons

Jonathan Nash

Published: Aug. 3, 2024

This paper explores several etymological, semantic, sociolinguistic, and methodological issues that have, in my opinion, impeded the progress of consciousness research discourse; I offer some suggestions are hopefully worthy consideration. review historical extant conflation terms literature, a litany published definitions types consciousness, call for greater “semantic lucidity”. critique rationale underpinning search neural correlates advocate adherence to requirements an operational definition research, discuss paradigm as ‘process’ versus premise tangible ‘thing’ can somehow be found particular locus within material substrate nervous system.

Language: Английский

Citations

0
The Study of Consciousness Is Mired in Complexities and Difficulties: Can They Be Resolved? DOI Creative Commons
Jonathan Nash

Published: Aug. 29, 2024

This paper explores several etymological, semantic, sociolinguistic, and methodological issues that have, in my opinion, impeded the progress of consciousness research discourse; I offer some suggestions are hopefully worthy consideration. review historical extant conflation terms literature, a litany published definitions types consciousness, call for greater “semantic lucidity”. critique rationale underpinning search neural correlates advocate adherence to requirements an operational definition research, discuss paradigm as ‘process’ versus premise tangible ‘thing’ can somehow be found particular locus within material substrate nervous system.

Language: Английский

Citations

0