Ecology,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
103(12)
Published: July 21, 2022
Abstract
The
outcomes
of
species
interactions
can
vary
greatly
in
time
and
space
with
the
some
determined
by
priority
effects.
On
coral
reefs,
benthic
algae
rapidly
colonize
disturbed
substrate.
In
absence
top‐down
control
from
herbivorous
fishes,
these
inhibit
recruitment
reef‐building
corals,
leading
to
a
persistent
phase
shift
macroalgae‐dominated
state.
Yet,
corals
may
also
colonization
macroalgae,
therefore
effects
herbivores
on
algal
communities
be
strongest
following
disturbances
that
reduce
cover.
Here,
we
report
results
experiments
conducted
fore
reef
Moorea,
French
Polynesia,
where
we:
(1)
tested
ability
macroalgae
invade
coral‐dominated
coral‐depauperate
under
different
levels
herbivory,
(2)
explored
juvenile
(
Pocillopora
spp.)
suppress
(3)
quantified
direct
indirect
fish
corallivores
corals.
We
found
proliferated
when
herbivory
was
low
but
only
recently
cover
low.
When
<10%,
increased
20‐fold
within
1
year
reduced
conditions
relative
high
controls.
(50%),
were
suppressed
irrespective
level
despite
ample
for
colonization.
Once
established
cover,
larvae,
reducing
capacity
replenishment.
However,
experimentally
small
(2
cm
diameter)
disturbance,
inhibited
invading
local
neighborhoods,
even
herbivores,
indicating
strong
effect
macroalgae–coral
interactions.
Surprisingly,
fishes
initially
facilitated
controlling
had
net
negative
via
predation.
Corallivores
growth
rates
exposed
~30%
exclosures,
competition
exclosures.
These
highlight
processes
are
important
structuring
ecosystems
at
successional
stages
underscore
need
consider
multiple
ecological
historical
contingencies
predict
community
dynamics.
PLoS ONE,
Journal Year:
2013,
Volume and Issue:
8(1), P. e54260 - e54260
Published: Jan. 24, 2013
The
Abrolhos
Bank
(eastern
Brazil)
encompasses
the
largest
and
richest
coral
reefs
of
South
Atlantic.
Coral
reef
benthic
assemblages
region
were
monitored
from
2003
to
2008.
Two
habitats
(pinnacles'
tops
walls)
sampled
per
site
with
3–10
sites
within
different
areas.
Different
methodologies
applied
in
two
distinct
sampling
periods:
2003–2005
2006–2008.
Spatial
coverage
taxonomic
resolution
lower
former
than
latter
period.
Benthic
differed
markedly
smallest
spatial
scale,
greater
differences
recorded
between
habitats.
Management
regimes
biomass
fish
functional
groups
(roving
territorial
herbivores)
had
minor
influences
on
assemblages.
These
results
suggest
that
local
environmental
factors
such
as
light,
depth
substrate
inclination
exert
a
stronger
influence
structure
protection
fishing.
Reef
walls
unprotected
coastal
showed
highest
cover
values,
major
contribution
Montastraea
cavernosa
(a
sediment
resistant
species
may
benefit
low
light
levels).
An
overall
negative
relationship
fleshy
macroalgae
slow-growing
reef-building
organisms
(i.e.
scleractinians
crustose
calcareous
algae)
was
recorded,
suggesting
competition
these
organisms.
opposite
trend
positive
relationships)
for
turf
algae
organisms,
beneficial
interactions
and/or
co-occurrence
mediated
by
unexplored
factors.
Turf
increased
across
2006
2008,
while
scleractinian
no
change.
need
continued
standardized
monitoring
program,
aimed
at
understanding
drivers
change
community
patterns,
well
subsidize
sound
adaptive
conservation
management
measures,
is
highlighted.
Annual Review of Marine Science,
Journal Year:
2016,
Volume and Issue:
9(1), P. 445 - 468
Published: Aug. 30, 2016
Coral
reefs
provide
critical
services
to
coastal
communities,
and
these
rely
on
ecosystem
functions
threatened
by
stressors.
By
summarizing
the
threats
functioning
of
from
fishing,
climate
change,
decreasing
water
quality,
we
highlight
that
stressors
have
multiple,
conflicting
effects
functionally
similar
groups
species
their
interactions,
overall
are
often
uncertain
because
a
lack
data
or
variability
among
taxa.
The
direct
links
functional
groups,
such
as
predator-prey
particularly
uncertain.
Using
qualitative
modeling,
demonstrate
this
uncertainty
stressor
impacts
(whether
they
positive,
negative,
neutral)
can
significant
models
stability,
reducing
is
vital
for
understanding
changes
reef
functioning.
This
review
also
provides
guidance
future
functioning,
which
should
include
interactions
cumulative
effect
Conservation Letters,
Journal Year:
2013,
Volume and Issue:
7(3), P. 176 - 187
Published: June 7, 2013
Abstract
Ecosystem
management
frequently
aims
to
manage
resilience
yet
measuring
has
proven
difficult.
Here,
we
quantify
the
ecological
of
largest
reef
in
Caribbean
and
map
potential
benefits
marine
reserves
under
two
scenarios
greenhouse
gas
emissions.
Resilience
is
calculated
using
spatial
models
defined
as
probability
a
remaining
its
coral‐dominated
basin
attraction
such
that
it
does
not
flip
into
an
alternate,
algal‐dominated
attractor.
In
practice,
coral
populations
will
maintain
ability
exhibit
recovery
trend
after
acute
disturbances
hurricanes.
The
inputs
required
estimate
are
reef's
initial
state,
physical
environment,
disturbance
regime.
One
major
driver
herbivory
by
parrotfish
recent
action
protect
Belize
was
found
have
increased
6‐fold.
However,
expected
protection
future
cover
were
relatively
modest
with
only
2‐
2.6‐fold
improvement
over
business‐as‐usual
scenario,
demonstrating
how
ecosystem
states
decoupled.
Global
reduce
emissions
had
little
impact
on
average
state
unless
accompanied
local
controls
fishing.
combined
global
reduced
rate
degradation
threefold.
Operationalizing
explicitly
integrates
available
biophysical
data
accommodates
complex
interactions
among
processes
multiple
types
disturbance.
Oikos,
Journal Year:
2012,
Volume and Issue:
122(4), P. 481 - 491
Published: Dec. 13, 2012
Synthesis
Coral
reefs
are
widely
thought
to
exhibit
multiple
attractors
which
have
profound
implications
for
people
that
depend
on
them.
If
become
‘stuck’
within
a
self‐reinforcing
state
dominated
by
seaweed,
it
becomes
disproportionately
difficult
and
expensive
managers
shift
the
system
back
towards
its
natural,
productive,
coral
state.
The
existence
of
is
controversial.
We
assess
various
forms
evidence
conclude
there
remains
no
incontrovertible
proof
reefs.
However,
most
compelling
evidence,
combines
ecological
models
field
data,
far
more
consistent
with
than
competing
hypothesis
only
single,
attractor.
Managers
should
exercise
caution
assume
degraded
can
stuck
there.
Testing
alternate
in
ecosystems
possess
slow
dynamics
frequent
pulse
perturbation
exceptionally
challenging.
typify
such
conditions
analyse
different
whether
they
support
or
challenge
Caribbean
reefs,
many
shown
phase
shifts
community
structure
from
algal
dominance.
Field
studies
alone
provide
insight
into
because
non‐equilibrial
nature
reef
prevents
equilibria
being
observed.
Statistical
risk
failing
sample
parameter
space
occur,
failed
account
confounding
effects
heterogeneous
environments,
anthropogenic
drivers
(e.g.
fishing),
major
disturbances
hurricanes).
Simple
complex
all
find
over
some
–
though
not
regions
driver
(fishing).
Tests
model
predictions
data
closely
match
theory
but
forward‐leaning
monotonic
curve
single
attractor
also
be
fitted
these
data.
Deeper
consideration
assumptions
this
relationship
reveal
significant
problems
disappear
under
attractors.
To
date,
against
while
definitive
proof,
balance
reasoning
favours
their
existence.
Theory
predicts
do
natural
disease‐induced
loss
two
key
functional
groups
has
generated
bistability.
Whether
persistent
element
brief
moment
geological
history
will
depend,
part,
ability
recover
impacts
climate
change
ocean
acidification
growth
mortality.
Global Change Biology,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
22(5), P. 1965 - 1975
Published: Dec. 18, 2015
Abstract
Habitat
structural
complexity
is
a
key
factor
shaping
marine
communities.
However,
accurate
methods
for
quantifying
underwater
are
currently
lacking.
Loss
of
linked
to
ecosystem
declines
in
biodiversity
and
resilience.
We
developed
new
using
stereo‐imagery
spanning
4
years
(2010–2013)
reconstruct
3D
models
coral
reef
areas
quantified
both
at
two
spatial
resolutions
(2.5
25
cm)
benthic
community
composition
characterize
changes
after
an
unprecedented
thermal
anomaly
on
the
west
coast
Australia
2011.
Structural
increased
quadrats
(4
m
2
)
that
bleached,
but
not
those
did
bleach.
Changes
were
driven
by
species‐specific
responses
warming,
highlighting
importance
identifying
small‐scale
dynamics
disentangle
ecological
disturbance.
demonstrate
effective,
repeatable
method
relationship
among
composition,
ocean
improving
predictions
response
ecosystems
environmental
change.
Restoration Ecology,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: April 2, 2025
In
response
to
declining
coral
populations
worldwide,
conservation
groups
are
increasingly
applying
restoration
strategies
bolster
abundance
and
diversity,
including
sexual
propagation
of
corals.
Collection
fertilization
gametes
as
well
larval
rearing
settlement
have
been
successful.
However,
post‐settlement
stages
remain
a
bottleneck
(80–100%
mortality),
which
makes
this
technique
costly
implement
at
scale.
To
address
challenge,
we
compared
the
survival
colony
size
three
sexually
propagated
Caribbean
species,
Diploria
labyrinthiformis
,
Pseudodiploria
strigosa
Orbicella
faveolata
reared
levels
investment:
direct
outplant
reef,
in
situ
field
nursery
rearing,
ex
aquaculture
facility
rearing.
As
part
work
St.
Croix,
United
States
Virgin
Islands,
recruits
were
for
1
year
before
being
outplanted
reef
plots
monitored
annually
subsequent
years.
The
cost‐effectiveness
each
strategy
was
calculated
monitoring
time
point
via
seeding
unit
yield
cost
per
unit.
Although
low
4
years
(0–1.8%),
corals
displayed
significantly
higher
therefore
lower
than
other
two
investment
strategies.
These
results
highlight
benefits
an
stage
increase
long‐term
juvenile
cost‐effectiveness.
return
on
suggests
that
outplanting
may
be
viable
strategy;
however,
proportion
surviving
highlights
current
limitations
when
degraded
reefs.
Global Change Biology,
Journal Year:
2013,
Volume and Issue:
19(10), P. 3011 - 3023
Published: June 6, 2013
This
study
reports
the
first
well-replicated
analysis
of
continuous
coral
growth
records
from
warmer
water
reefs
(mean
annual
sea
surface
temperatures
(SST)
>28.5
°C)
around
Thai-Malay
Peninsula
in
Southeast
Asia.
Based
on
analyses
70
colonies
sampled
15
within
six
locations,
region-wide
declines
calcification
rate
(ca.
18.6%),
linear
extension
15.4%)
and
skeletal
bulk
density
3.9%)
were
observed
over
a
31-year
period
1980
to
2010.
Decreases
rates
at
five
locations
ranged
ca.
17.2-21.6%
11.4-19.6%,
respectively,
whereas
decline
was
consequence
significant
reductions
only
two
6.9%
10.7%).
A
link
between
average
SST
found,
Porites
spp.
demonstrated
high
thermal
threshold
29.4
°C
before
declined.
Responses
individual
region
more
variable
with
links
being
four
locations.
Rates
temperature
warming
Andaman
Sea
(Indian
Ocean)
1.3
per
decade)
almost
twice
those
South
China
(Pacific
0.7
decade),
but
this
not
reflected
magnitude
corresponding
Considering
that
massive
are
major
reef
builders
Asia,
is
cause
for
concern
future
accretion
resilience.
However,
suggests
patterns
change
unlikely
be
uniform
or
dependent
solely
environment.
Oikos,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
125(5), P. 644 - 655
Published: July 30, 2015
A
single
ecosystem
can
exhibit
great
biogeographic
and
environmental
variability.
While
a
given
ecological
driver
might
have
strong
impact
in
one
region,
it
does
not
necessarily
hold
that
its
importance
will
extend
elsewhere.
Coral
reefs
provide
striking
example
coral
communities
low
resilience
the
Atlantic
remarkable
parts
of
species‐rich
Pacific.
Recent
experimental
evidence
from
finds
fishing
large
herbivorous
fish
be
resilience.
Here,
we
repeat
experiment
highly
resilient
forereef
Moorea
(French
Polynesia),
which
has
repeatedly
recovered
disturbances.
combination
cages,
deterrents
(FDs),
controls
allowed
us
to
simulate
consequences
herbivores
on
algal
assemblages,
recruitment,
demographic
rates
juveniles.
We
find
impacts
removing
reef
vary
with
early
ontogeny.
Reduced
herbivore
access
led
modest
macroalgal
bloom
reduction
recruitment.
However,
larger
juvenile
corals
(>
1
cm
diameter)
survived
better
grew
faster
under
these
conditions
because
corallivory.
To
determine
net
losing
fish,
combined
results
estimated
parameters
an
individual‐based
model.
Simulating
recovery
trajectories
for
five
years,
protecting
66–99%
simulations,
depending
underlying
assumptions
(with
more
credible
being
associated
greater
likelihood
positive
impacts).
effects
are
detrimental
both
Pacific
systems
studied,
nature
interactions
varied
markedly.
In
identical
previously‐published
study
Atlantic,
macroalgae
exhibited
rapid
caused
sufficiently
recruitment
force
predicted
shift
alternative
attractor.
The
commensurate
was
weak
yet
were
two
orders
magnitude
sensitive
presence.
do
suggest
lead
attractors
but
long‐term
risks
rate
cause
concern
as
mortality
projected
increase.
emerging
picture
is
less
likely
experience
blooms
surprisingly
such
if
they
occur.
Ecography,
Journal Year:
2017,
Volume and Issue:
41(7), P. 1077 - 1091
Published: Sept. 7, 2017
Habitat
structural
complexity
influences
biotic
diversity
and
abundance,
but
its
influence
on
marine
ecosystems
has
not
been
widely
addressed.
Recent
advances
in
computer
vision
robotics
allow
quantification
of
at
higher‐resolutions
than
previously
achieved.
This
provides
an
important
opportunity
to
determine
the
ecological
role
habitat
ecosystems.
We
used
high‐resolution
three‐dimensional
(3D)
maps
test
multiple
metrics,
depth
benthic
biota
as
surrogates
fish
assemblages
across
hundreds
meters
subtropical
reefs.
Non‐parametric
multivariate
statistics
were
relationship
between
these
entire
assemblage.
Fish
divided
into
functional
groups,
which
further
investigate
abundance
using
generalized
linear
models.
community
composition
strongly
related
depth.
Surface
rugosity
variance
had
a
significant
positive
piscivores
sediment
infauna
predators,
negative
effect
herbivores,
planktivores
cleaners.
Final
models
for
groups
explained
up
68%
variance.
The
best
metrics
explain
(25
±7.5%
explained,
mean
±
SE)
(16
±6.6%,
SE).
Our
results
show
that
3D
derived
can
predict
large
percentage
potentially
serve
useful
all
spatially
dynamic