Theoretical
and
methodological
research
on
threat
conditioning
provides
important
neuroscience-informed
approaches
to
studying
fear
anxiety.
The
framework
is
at
the
vanguard
of
physiological
neurobiological
into
core
mechanistic
symptoms
anxiety-related
psychopathology,
providing
detailed
models
neural
circuitry
underlying
variability
in
clinically-relevant
behaviors
(e.g.,
decreased
extinction,
heightened
generalization)
heterogeneity
clinical
anxiety
presentations.
Despite
strengths
approach
explaining
symptom-level
syndromal
heterogeneity,
vast
majority
psychopathology-oriented
work
has
been
conducted
using
Diagnostic
Statistical
Manual
(DSM)
paradigm.
Unfortunately,
DSM
categorizations
fail
capture
resolution
afforded
by
indices.
Further,
relations
between
fine-grained
neurobehavioral
measures
specific
are
substantially
attenuated
within-category
arbitrary
boundaries,
comorbidity,
limited
reliability
DSM.
Conversely,
Hierarchical
Taxonomy
Psychopathology
(HiTOP)
a
promising
for
modeling
studied
relating
broader
constructs.
To
date,
HiTOP
had
minimal
impact
field.
Here,
we
propose
that
combining
an
next
step
pathology.
We
provide
brief
review
prominent
critiques
how
they
affect
studies
suggest
solutions
recommendations
flow
from
perspective.
Our
hope
this
effort
serves
as
both
inflection
point
practical
primer
HiTOP-aligned
benefits
fields.
American Journal of Psychiatry,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
181(12), С. 1059 - 1075
Опубликована: Дек. 1, 2024
Anxiety
disorders
are
a
leading
source
of
human
misery,
morbidity,
and
premature
mortality.
Existing
treatments
far
from
curative
for
many,
underscoring
the
need
to
clarify
underlying
neural
mechanisms.
Although
many
brain
regions
contribute,
amygdala
has
received
most
intense
scientific
attention.
Over
past
several
decades,
this
scrutiny
yielded
detailed
understanding
function,
but
it
failed
produce
new
clinical
assays,
biomarkers,
or
cures.
Rising
urgent
public
health
challenge
demands
an
honest
reckoning
with
functional-neuroanatomical
complexity
shift
theories
anchored
on
"the
amygdala"
models
centered
specific
nuclei
cell
types.
This
review
begins
by
examining
evidence
studies
rodents,
monkeys,
humans
"canonical
model,"
idea
that
plays
central
role
in
fear-
anxiety-related
states,
traits,
disorders.
Next,
authors
selectively
highlight
work
indicating
canonical
model,
while
true,
is
overly
simplistic
fails
adequately
capture
actual
state
evidentiary
record,
breadth
amygdala-associated
functions
illnesses,
amygdala's
functional
architecture.
The
describe
implications
these
facts
basic
neuroimaging
research.
concludes
some
general
recommendations
grappling
accelerating
efforts
understand
more
effectively
treat
amygdala-related
psychopathology.
Emotional
experiences
can
profoundly
impact
our
conceptual
model
of
the
world,
modifying
how
we
represent
and
remember
a
host
information
even
indirectly
associated
with
that
experience
in
past.
Yet,
new
emotional
infiltrates
spreads
across
pre-existing
semantic
categories
is
unknown.
We
used
an
aversive
sensory
preconditioning
paradigm
fMRI
(N=35)
to
investigate
whether
threat
memories
integrate
pre-established
category
alter
representation
entire
category.
observed
selective
but
transient
changes
conceptually-related
items
amygdala,
medial
prefrontal
cortex,
occipitotemporal
cortex
following
conditioning
simple
cue
(geometric
shape)
pre-associated
different,
related,
set
exemplars.
These
representational
persisted
beyond
24-hours
hippocampus
perirhinal
cortex.
During
conditioning,
reactivation
interacted
hippocampal/medial
activity
predict
subsequent
amygdala
toward
novel
members
at
test,
providing
evidence
for
online
integration
promoting
generalization.
Behaviorally,
by
proxy
selectively
retroactively
enhanced
recognition
memory,
increased
perceived
typicality
threat.
findings
detail
complex
route
through
which
learning
generalizes
associative
networks
built
up
over
time
stored
memory
as
knowledge.
Behavior Research Methods,
Год журнала:
2024,
Номер
56(6), С. 6119 - 6129
Опубликована: Фев. 29, 2024
Abstract
Fear
conditioning,
also
termed
threat
is
a
commonly
used
learning
model
with
clinical
relevance.
Quantification
of
conditioning
in
humans
often
relies
on
conditioned
autonomic
responses
such
as
skin
conductance
(SCR),
pupil
size
(PSR),
heart
period
(HPR),
or
respiration
amplitude
(RAR),
which
are
usually
analyzed
separately.
Here,
we
investigate
whether
inter-individual
variability
differential
responses,
averaged
across
acquisition,
exhibits
multi-dimensional
structure,
and
the
extent
to
their
linear
combination
could
enhance
precision
inference
has
occurred.
In
mega-analytic
approach,
re-analyze
nine
data
sets
including
256
individuals,
acquired
by
group
last
author,
using
standard
routines
framework
psychophysiological
modeling
(PsPM).
Our
analysis
revealed
systematic
differences
effect
between
measures
datasets,
but
no
evidence
for
multidimensional
structure
various
combinations
measures.
We
derive
statistically
optimal
weights
combining
four
subsets
thereof,
provide
out-of-sample
performance
metrics
these
weights,
accompanied
bias-corrected
confidence
intervals.
show
that
achieve
same
statistical
power,
allows
relevant
reduction
sample
size,
common
scenario
amounts
roughly
24%.
To
summarize,
demonstrate
one-dimensional
measures,
terms
maximal
retrodictive
validity.
Fear
learning
processes
are
assumed
to
play
a
key
role
in
the
pathogenesis
of
anxiety
disorders,
heterogeneous
group
disorders
characterized
by
excessive
and
avoidance
behavior.
While
some
receive
more
attention
fear
safety
research,
others
remain
understudied.
Heterogeneity
concepts,
measures,
designs
within
field
further
contribute
inconsistent
study
outcomes.
Addressing
these
challenges,
we
conducted
systematic
meta-analysis,
adhering
PRISMA
guidelines,
examine
differences
conditioning
between
patients
healthy
participants,
updating
meta-analysis
Duits
et
al.
(2015).
We
extended
previous
analyses
conducting
subgroup
for
different
types
distinguished
physiological
behavioral
outcome
measurements.
This
includes
76
studies
published
1986
2022
with
data
from
1.974
3.154
participants.
The
results
support
acquisition
extinction
individuals
compared
More
specifically,
showed
heightened
responses
CS-
both
measures
during
acquisition,
increased
aversiveness
ratings
CS+.
Following
learning,
threat
expectancy
affect
CS+
CS-,
alongside
stronger
SCR
These
findings
suggest
that
may
exhibit
amplified
cues
along
delayed
learned
associations.
changes
lead
sensitivity
acquiring
detecting
slower
process,
resulting
enduring
responses.
characteristics
consistent
"better-safe-than-sorry"
information
processing
strategy
linked
susceptibility
anxiety.
integrate
our
into
current
literature
on
discuss
possible
underlying
mechanisms.
Furthermore,
explicitly
mention
give
recommendations
how
they
can
be
addressed.
Cerebral Cortex,
Год журнала:
2023,
Номер
33(15), С. 9325 - 9338
Опубликована: Июнь 8, 2023
Anxiety
disorders
are
effectively
treated
with
exposure
therapy
based
on
the
extinction
of
Pavlovian
fear
conditioning.
Animal
research
indicates
that
both
timing
and
test
important
factors
to
reduce
return
fear.
However,
empirical
evidence
in
humans
is
incomplete
inconsistent.
In
this
neuroimaging
study,
we,
therefore,
tested
103
young,
healthy
participants
a
2-factorial
between-subjects
design
group
(immediate,
delayed)
(+1
day
+7
days).
Immediate
led
greater
retention
memory
at
beginning
training
indicated
by
increased
skin
conductance
responses.
A
was
observed
groups,
trend
toward
immediate
extinction.
The
generally
higher
groups
an
early
test.
Neuroimaging
results
show
successful
cross-group
acquisition
retention,
as
well
activation
left
nucleus
accumbens
during
training.
Importantly,
delayed
showed
larger
bilateral
This
finding
discussed
terms
salience,
contingency,
relief,
prediction
error
processing.
It
may
imply
benefits
more
from
new
learning
opportunity.
Most
theories
in
psychological,
educational,
and
social
sciences
deal
with
latent,
not
directly
observable,
variables
such
as
memory,
cognitive
skills,
or
job
satisfaction.
Measurement
validation
ensures
that
the
actually
taken
measurements
relate
to
latent
variable
one
is
interested
in,
becoming
ever
more
pervasive
a
criterion
for
pre-registering
specific
sets
of
observables
data
processing
steps.
According
existing
research
canon,
quantitative
ideally
performed
within
context
multi-trait
multi-method
matrix
(MTMM).
While
statistically
fairly
well
developed,
this
approach
has
several
conceptual
practical
shortcomings
limit
its
domain
application:
(1)
requirement
discriminant
can
be
measured
same
methods,
(2)
conceptually
different
methods
disambiguate
trait
from
factors,
most
seriously
(3)
difficulty
identifying
valid
over
less
method.
Here,
we
compare
experiment-based
calibration,
complementary
externally
manipulated.
Inspired
by
practice
experimental
calibration
modern
metrology
(measurement
science),
relies
on
an
treatment
introduces
external
criterion,
which
procedurally
unrelated
measurement
methods.
We
show
how
even
closely
related
dispenses
need
variables,
allows
optimizing
psychometric
procedures
themselves.
Calibration
thus
complement
classical
psychometrics
are
amenable
manipulation,
could
become
part
integrative
validity
argument
sciences.
Journal of Mathematical Psychology,
Год журнала:
2023,
Номер
117, С. 102818 - 102818
Опубликована: Ноя. 8, 2023
Psychological
theories
are
often
formulated
at
the
level
of
latent,
not
directly
observable,
variables.
Empirical
measurement
latent
variables
ought
to
be
valid.
Classical
psychometric
validity
indices
can
difficult
apply
in
experimental
contexts.
A
complementary
index,
termed
retrodictive
validity,
is
correlation
theory-derived
predicted
scores
with
actually
measured
scores,
specifically
designed
calibration
experiments.
In
current
note,
I
analyse
how
experiments
maximise
information
garnered
and
specifically,
minimise
sample
variance
estimators.
First,
harness
asymptotic
limits
analytically
derive
different
distribution
features
that
impact
on
estimator
variance.
Then,
numerically
simulate
various
distributions
combinations
feature
values.
This
allows
deriving
recommendations
for
values,
resource
investment,
Finally,
highlight
cases
which
a
misspecified
theory
particularly
problematic.