Science Advances,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
7(15)
Published: April 7, 2021
Studies
have
documented
climate
change-induced
shifts
in
species
distributions
but
uncertainties
associated
with
data
and
methods
are
typically
unexplored.
We
reviewed
240
reports
of
climate-related
species-range
classified
them
based
on
three
criteria.
ask
whether
observed
distributional
compared
against
random
expectations,
multicausal
factors
examined
equal
footing,
studies
provide
sufficient
documentation
to
enable
replication.
found
that
only
~12.1%
compare
across
multiple
directions,
~1.6%
distinguish
patterns
from
~19.66%
examine
factors.
Last,
~75.5%
report
results
allow
show
despite
gradual
improvements
over
time,
there
is
scope
for
raising
standards
within
climate-change
induced
distribution.
Accurate
reporting
important
because
policy
responses
depend
them.
Flawed
assessments
can
fuel
criticism
divert
scarce
resources
biodiversity
competing
priorities.
The
Working
Group
II
contribution
to
the
Sixth
Assessment
Report
of
Intergovernmental
Panel
on
Climate
Change
(IPCC)
provides
a
comprehensive
assessment
scientific
literature
relevant
climate
change
impacts,
adaptation
and
vulnerability.
report
recognizes
interactions
climate,
ecosystems
biodiversity,
human
societies,
integrates
across
natural,
ecological,
social
economic
sciences.
It
emphasizes
how
efforts
in
reducing
greenhouse
gas
emissions
can
come
together
process
called
resilient
development,
which
enables
liveable
future
for
biodiversity
humankind.
IPCC
is
leading
body
assessing
science.
reports
are
produced
comprehensive,
objective
transparent
ways,
ensuring
they
reflect
full
range
views
literature.
Novel
elements
include
focused
topical
assessments,
an
atlas
presenting
observed
impacts
risks
from
global
regional
scales.
Available
as
Open
Access
Cambridge
Core.
Global Change Biology,
Journal Year:
2019,
Volume and Issue:
26(1), P. 119 - 188
Published: Dec. 31, 2019
Abstract
Plant
traits—the
morphological,
anatomical,
physiological,
biochemical
and
phenological
characteristics
of
plants—determine
how
plants
respond
to
environmental
factors,
affect
other
trophic
levels,
influence
ecosystem
properties
their
benefits
detriments
people.
trait
data
thus
represent
the
basis
for
a
vast
area
research
spanning
from
evolutionary
biology,
community
functional
ecology,
biodiversity
conservation,
landscape
management,
restoration,
biogeography
earth
system
modelling.
Since
its
foundation
in
2007,
TRY
database
plant
traits
has
grown
continuously.
It
now
provides
unprecedented
coverage
under
an
open
access
policy
is
main
used
by
worldwide.
Increasingly,
also
supports
new
frontiers
trait‐based
research,
including
identification
gaps
subsequent
mobilization
or
measurement
data.
To
support
this
development,
article
we
evaluate
extent
compiled
analyse
emerging
patterns
representativeness.
Best
species
achieved
categorical
traits—almost
complete
‘plant
growth
form’.
However,
most
relevant
ecology
vegetation
modelling
are
characterized
continuous
intraspecific
variation
trait–environmental
relationships.
These
have
be
measured
on
individual
respective
environment.
Despite
coverage,
observe
humbling
lack
completeness
representativeness
these
many
aspects.
We,
therefore,
conclude
that
reducing
biases
remains
key
challenge
requires
coordinated
approach
measurements.
This
can
only
collaboration
with
initiatives.
Global Ecology and Biogeography,
Journal Year:
2018,
Volume and Issue:
27(11), P. 1268 - 1276
Published: Sept. 6, 2018
Abstract
Aim
Species
are
responding
to
climate
warming
by
shifting
their
distributions
toward
historically
cooler
regions,
but
the
degree
which
expansions
at
cool
range
limits
balanced
contractions
warm
is
unknown.
We
synthesized
published
data
documenting
shifts
species’
versus
along
elevational
gradients
(a)
test
classic
ecological
theory
that
predicts
temperature
more
directly
influences
than
limits,
and
(b)
determine
how
warming‐associated
have
changed
extent
area
of
distributions.
Location
Global.
Time
period
1802–2012.
Major
taxa
studied
Vascular
plants,
endotherms,
ectotherms.
Methods
compiled
a
dataset
975
species
from
32
for
been
measured
both
limits.
compared
magnitude
variance
quantified
impacted
extents
areas.
Results
On
average
shifted
upslope
associated
with
increases
(warm
limit:
92
±
455
m/C;
131
465
overall
mean
SD
).
There
was
no
systematic
difference
in
or
thus
indication
controlled
temperature.
Species’
available
significantly
decreased
mountaintop
species.
Main
conclusions
Our
results
do
not
support
long‐standing
hypothesis
sensitive
responsive
find
that,
across
globe,
ranges
shrinking
as
they
shift
upslope,
supporting
predictions
high
elevation
especially
vulnerable
increases.
synthesis
highlights
extreme
variation
distributional
responses
warming,
may
indicate
biotic
interactions
play
prominent
role
setting
previously
thought.
Science,
Journal Year:
2019,
Volume and Issue:
365(6458), P. 1119 - 1123
Published: Sept. 12, 2019
Upward
shifts
of
mountain
vegetation
lag
behind
rates
climate
warming,
partly
related
to
interconnected
changes
belowground.
Here,
we
unravel
above-
and
belowground
linkages
by
drawing
insights
from
short-term
experimental
manipulations
elevation
gradient
studies.
Soils
will
likely
gain
carbon
in
early
successional
ecosystems,
while
losing
as
forest
expands
upward,
the
slow,
high-elevation
soil
development
constrain
warming-induced
shifts.
Current
approaches
fail
predict
pace
these
how
much
they
be
modified
interactions
among
plants
biota.
Integrating
soils
their
biota
into
monitoring
programs,
combined
with
innovative
comparative
approaches,
crucial
overcome
paucity
data
better
understand
ecosystem
dynamics
feedbacks
climate.
New Phytologist,
Journal Year:
2018,
Volume and Issue:
220(2), P. 447 - 459
Published: June 25, 2018
High
mountain
ecosystems
and
their
biota
are
governed
by
low-temperature
conditions
thus
can
be
used
as
indicators
for
climate
warming
impacts
on
natural
ecosystems,
provided
that
long-term
data
exist.
We
from
the
largest
alpine
to
nival
permanent
plot
site
in
Alps,
established
frame
of
Global
Observation
Research
Initiative
Alpine
Environments
(GLORIA)
Schrankogel
Tyrolean
Austria,
1994,
resurveyed
2004
2014.
Vascular
plant
species
richness
per
increased
over
entire
period,
albeit
a
lesser
extent
second
decade,
because
disappearance
events
markedly
latter
period.
Although
presence/absence
could
only
marginally
explain
range
shift
dynamics,
changes
cover
community
composition
indicate
an
accelerating
transformation
towards
more
warmth-demanding
drought-adapted
vegetation,
which
is
strongest
at
lowest,
least
rugged
subsite.
Divergent
responses
vertical
distribution
groups
suggest
direct
effects,
rather
than
competitive
displacement,
primary
causes
observed
patterns.
The
continued
decrease
cryophilic
imply
trailing
edge
dynamics
proceed
rapidly
successful
colonisation,
would
favour
period
accelerated
declines.
Biological reviews/Biological reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
96(5), P. 1816 - 1835
Published: April 27, 2021
Mountain
areas
are
biodiversity
hotspots
and
provide
a
multitude
of
ecosystem
services
irreplaceable
socio-economic
value.
In
the
European
Alps,
air
temperature
has
increased
at
rate
about
0.36°C
decade-1
since
1970,
leading
to
glacier
retreat
significant
snowpack
reduction.
Due
these
rapid
environmental
changes,
this
mountainous
region
is
undergoing
marked
changes
in
spring
phenology
elevational
distribution
animals,
plants
fungi.
Long-term
monitoring
Alps
offers
an
excellent
natural
laboratory
synthetize
climate-related
for
large
array
taxonomic
groups.
This
review
assesses
climatic
that
have
occurred
across
during
recent
decades,
phenological
upslope
shifts
plants,
animals
fungi
from
evidence
published
papers
previously
unpublished
data.
Our
provides
been
shifting
earlier
past
four
decades
ranges
show
upwards
trend
most
groups
which
there
sufficient
The
first
observed
activity
reptiles
terrestrial
insects
(e.g.
butterflies)
shifted
significantly
earlier,
average
-5.7
-6.0
days
,
respectively.
By
contrast,
semi-aquatic
dragonflies
damselflies)
amphibians,
as
well
singing
or
laying
dates
resident
birds,
smaller
non-significant
trends
ranging
-1.0
+1.3
.
Leaf-out
flowering
woody
herbaceous
showed
intermediate
with
mean
values
-2.4
-2.8
Regarding
species
distribution,
(N
=
2133
species)
elevation
maximum
abundance
(optimum
elevation)
similar
pace
(on
between
+18
+25
m
)
but
substantial
differences
among
taxa.
For
example,
optimum
upward
by
+36.2
+32.7
whereas
it
was
estimated
range
+11
insects,
ferns,
birds
wood-decaying
upper
limit
(leading
edge)
also
clearly
higher
(from
+47
+91
than
+17
+40
),
except
(-4.7
).
Although
regional
land-use
could
partly
explain
some
trends,
consistent
shift
found
almost
all
taxa
over
likely
reflecting
strong
warming
receding
snow
cover
taken
place
decades.
However,
possible
exception
organisms
seems
currently
too
slow
track
isotherm
induced
climate
warming,
+62
+71
1970.
light
results,
interactions
change
multiple
trophic
levels
through
spatial
mismatches.
nascent
research
field
deserves
greater
attention
allow
us
anticipate
structural
functional
better
level.
Global Change Biology,
Journal Year:
2019,
Volume and Issue:
25(7), P. 2485 - 2498
Published: May 6, 2019
Abstract
Elevational
gradients
are
often
used
to
quantify
how
traits
of
plant
species
respond
abiotic
and
biotic
environmental
variations.
Yet,
such
analyses
frequently
restricted
spatially
applied
along
single
slopes
or
mountain
ranges.
Since
we
know
little
on
the
response
intraspecific
leaf
elevation
across
globe,
here
perform
a
global
meta‐analysis
in
109
located
4
continents
reported
71
studies
published
between
1983
2018.
We
quantified
change
seven
morpho‐ecophysiological
elevational
gradients:
specific
area
(SLA),
mass
per
(LMA),
(LA),
nitrogen
concentration
unit
(N
),
phosphorous
(P
)
carbon
isotope
composition
(δ
13
C).
found
LMA,
N
,
δ
C
significantly
increase
SLA
decrease
with
increasing
elevation.
Conversely,
LA
P
showed
no
significant
pattern
worldwide.
larger
warmer
regions.
Larger
responses
were
apparent
for
herbaceous
compared
woody
species,
but
not
other
traits.
Finally,
also
detected
evidences
covariation
morphological
physiological
within
same
gradient.
In
sum,
demonstrate
that
there
common
cross‐species
patterns
trait
variation
Irrespective
whether
is
genetically
determined
via
local
adaptation
attributed
phenotypic
plasticity,
suggest
adapted
live
range
temperature
conditions.
distribution
biota
predominantly
shifting
upslope
changes
conditions,
our
results
important
further
understanding
plants
ecosystems
adapt
change.