Journal of Economic Entomology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
116(5), P. 1604 - 1612
Published: July 17, 2023
Pesticides
help
produce
food
for
humanity's
growing
population,
yet
they
have
negative
impacts
on
the
environment.
Limiting
these
impacts,
while
maintaining
supply,
is
a
crucial
challenge
modern
agriculture.
Mitigation
measures
are
actions
taken
by
pesticide
users,
which
modify
risk
of
application
to
nontarget
organisms,
such
as
bees.
Through
these,
pesticides
can
be
reduced,
with
minimal
efficacy
pesticide.
Here
we
collate
scientific
evidence
behind
mitigation
designed
reduce
bees
using
systematic
review
methodology.
We
included
all
publications
tested
effects
any
measure
(using
very
loose
definition)
bees,
at
scale
(from
individual
through
population
level),
so
long
presented
measure.
found
34
direct
topic,
covering
range
available
measures.
No
currently
used
were
thoroughly
tested,
and
some
entirely
lacked
empirical
support,
showing
weak
base
current
recommendations
policy.
research
predominantly
focuses
managed
potentially
failing
protect
wild
also
that
label-recommended
measures,
most
often
applied,
specifically
seldom
empirically.
Ultimately,
recommend
more,
stronger,
required
justify
existing
crop
protection.
EFSA Journal,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
21(5)
Published: May 1, 2023
The
European
Commission
asked
EFSA
to
revise
the
risk
assessment
for
honey
bees,
bumble
bees
and
solitary
bees.
This
guidance
document
describes
how
perform
from
plant
protection
products,
in
accordance
with
Regulation
(EU)
1107/2009.
It
is
a
review
of
EFSA's
existing
document,
which
was
published
2013.
outlines
tiered
approach
exposure
estimation
different
scenarios
tiers.
includes
hazard
characterisation
provides
methodology
covering
dietary
contact
exposure.
also
recommendations
higher
tier
studies,
metabolites
products
as
mixture.
Nature,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
628(8007), P. 355 - 358
Published: Nov. 29, 2023
Abstract
Sustainable
agriculture
requires
balancing
crop
yields
with
the
effects
of
pesticides
on
non-target
organisms,
such
as
bees
and
other
pollinators.
Field
studies
demonstrated
that
agricultural
use
neonicotinoid
insecticides
can
negatively
affect
wild
bee
species
1,2
,
leading
to
restrictions
these
compounds
3
.
However,
besides
neonicotinoids,
field-based
evidence
landscape
pesticide
exposure
is
lacking.
Bees
encounter
many
in
landscapes
4–9
this
colony
growth
development
any
remains
unknown.
Here
we
show
found
bumble
bee-collected
pollen
are
associated
reduced
performance
during
bloom,
especially
simplified
intensive
practices.
Our
results
from
316
Bombus
terrestris
colonies
at
106
sites
across
eight
European
countries
confirm
regulatory
system
fails
sufficiently
prevent
pesticide-related
impacts
even
for
a
eusocial
pollinator
which
size
may
buffer
against
10,11
These
findings
support
need
postapproval
monitoring
both
process
protective
limiting
collateral
environmental
damage
use.
Nature Ecology & Evolution,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
7(4), P. 547 - 556
Published: Feb. 27, 2023
Widespread
contamination
of
ecosystems
with
pesticides
threatens
non-target
organisms.
However,
the
extent
to
which
life-history
traits
affect
pesticide
exposure
and
resulting
risk
in
different
landscape
contexts
remains
poorly
understood.
We
address
this
for
bees
across
an
agricultural
land-use
gradient
based
on
assays
pollen
nectar
collected
by
Apis
mellifera,
Bombus
terrestris
Osmia
bicornis,
representing
extensive,
intermediate
limited
foraging
traits.
found
that
extensive
foragers
(A.
mellifera)
experienced
highest
risk-additive
toxicity-weighted
concentrations.
only
(B.
terrestris)
(O.
bicornis)
responded
context-experiencing
lower
less
land.
Pesticide
correlated
among
bee
species
between
food
sources
was
greatest
A.
mellifera-collected
pollen-useful
information
future
postapproval
monitoring.
provide
trait-
landscape-dependent
occurrence,
concentration
identity
encounter
estimate
risk,
is
necessary
more
realistic
assessment
essential
tracking
policy
goals
reduce
risk.
Annual Review of Entomology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
69(1), P. 551 - 576
Published: Oct. 12, 2023
Bees
are
essential
pollinators
of
many
crops
and
wild
plants,
pesticide
exposure
is
one
the
key
environmental
stressors
affecting
their
health
in
anthropogenically
modified
landscapes.
Until
recently,
almost
all
information
on
routes
impacts
came
from
honey
bees,
at
least
partially
because
they
were
only
model
species
required
for
risk
assessments
(ERAs)
insect
pollinators.
Recently,
there
has
been
a
surge
research
activity
focusing
effects
non-
Apis
including
other
social
bees
(bumble
stingless
bees)
solitary
bees.
These
taxa
vary
substantially
another
several
important
ecological
traits,
spatial
temporal
patterns,
foraging
nesting
requirements,
degree
sociality.
In
this
article,
we
review
current
evidence
base
about
pathways
consequences
We
find
that
insights
into
bee
resulting
across
biological
organizations,
landscapes,
mixtures,
multiple
still
infancy.
The
good
news
promising
approaches
could
be
used
to
advance
our
understanding,
with
priority
given
informing
pathways,
extrapolating
effects,
determining
how
well
(limited
very
few
mostly
neonicotinoid
insecticides
under
unrealistic
conditions)
can
generalized
diversity
lifestyles
global
community.
conclude
future
expand
knowledge
would
also
beneficial
ERAs
wider
policy
decisions
concerning
pollinator
conservation
regulation.
Journal of Applied Ecology,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
59(8), P. 2117 - 2127
Published: May 28, 2022
Abstract
Sustainable
agriculture
relies
on
pollinators,
and
wild
bees
benefit
yield
of
multiple
crops.
However,
the
combined
exposure
to
pesticides
loss
flower
resources,
driven
by
agricultural
intensification,
contribute
declining
diversity
abundance
many
bee
taxa.
Flower
plantings
along
margins
fields
offer
diverse
food
resources
not
directly
treated
with
pesticides.
To
investigate
potential
mitigate
pesticide
effects
support
reproduction,
we
selected
replicated
sites
in
intensively
farmed
landscapes
where
half
contained
plantings.
We
assessed
solitary
Osmia
lignaria
bumble
Bombus
vosnesenskii
nesting
reproduction
throughout
season
these
landscapes.
also
quantified
local
landscape
used
bee‐collected
pollen
determine
forage
resource
use
risk.
plantings,
their
increased
O.
probability.
was
more
strongly
related
than
resources.
Bees
at
without
experienced
similar
risk,
flowers,
alongside
flowers
landscape,
were
sources
particularly
for
.
mitigated
negative
B.
reproduction.
Synthesis
applications
are
threatened
through
intensification.
Therefore,
finding
solutions
deficiency
is
urgent.
Our
findings
point
towards
as
a
solution
populations
mitigating
providing
key
forage.
Further
investigation
balance
between
benefits
added
risk
needed
reveal
contexts
net
occur.
Journal of Animal Ecology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
92(9), P. 1802 - 1814
Published: June 29, 2023
Human-mediated
species
introductions
provide
real-time
experiments
in
how
communities
respond
to
interspecific
competition.
For
example,
managed
honey
bees
Apis
mellifera
(L.)
have
been
widely
introduced
outside
their
native
range
and
may
compete
with
for
pollen
nectar.
Indeed,
multiple
studies
suggest
that
overlap
use
of
floral
resources.
However,
resource
negatively
impact
collection
by
bees,
availability
must
also
decline,
few
investigate
impacts
bee
competition
on
visits
simultaneously.
In
this
study,
we
increasing
abundance
visitation
patterns,
diets,
nectar
two
Californian
landscapes:
wildflower
plantings
the
Central
Valley
montane
meadows
Sierra.
We
collected
data
flowers,
availability,
carried
bodies
across
sites
Sierra
Valley.
then
constructed
plant-pollinator
networks
assess
impacted
perceived
apparent
(PAC),
a
measure
niche
overlap,
pollinator
specialization
(d').
compared
PAC
values
against
null
expectations
address
whether
observed
changes
were
greater
or
less
than
what
would
expect
given
relative
abundances
interacting
partners.
find
clear
evidence
exploitative
both
ecosystems
based
following
results:
(1)
increased
between
(2)
led
decreased
(3)
responded
shifting
visits,
some
becoming
more
specialized
others
generalized
depending
ecosystem
taxon
considered.
Although
can
adapt
coexistence
is
tenuous
will
depend
availability.
Preserving
augmenting
resources
therefore
essential
mitigating
negative
California
ecosystems,
decreases
flowers
alters
diets
potential
implications
conservation
wildlands
management.
Environmental Research,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
235, P. 116612 - 116612
Published: July 14, 2023
Synthetic
pesticides
(e.g.
herbicides,
fungicides
and
insecticides)
are
used
widely
in
agriculture
to
protect
crops
from
pests,
weeds
disease.
However,
their
use
also
comes
with
a
range
of
environmental
concerns.
One
key
concern
is
the
effect
insecticides
on
non-target
organisms
such
as
bees,
who
provide
pollination
services
for
wild
plants.
This
systematic
literature
review
quantifies
existing
research
bees
broadly,
then
focuses
more
specifically
non-neonicotinoid
non-honeybees.
We
find
that
articles
honeybees
(Apis
sp.)
account
80%
all
research,
other
combined
making
up
20%.
Neonicotinoids
were
studied
34%
across
most
insecticide
class
non-honeybees
overall,
almost
three
times
many
studies
than
second
class.
Of
classes
non-honeybees,
pyrethroids
organophosphates
followed
by
carbamates,
represented
bee
taxa
bumblebees
(Bombus),
leaf-cutter
(Megachile)
mason
(Osmia).
Research
has
taken
place
several
countries,
highest
numbers
Brazil
US,
notable
gaps
countries
Asia,
Africa
Oceania.
Mortality
was
type,
while
sub-lethal
effects
behaviour
less
studied.
Few
tested
how
influenced
multiple
pressures,
climate
change
co-occurring
(cocktail
effects).
As
anthropogenic
pressures
do
not
occur
isolation,
we
suggest
future
addresses
these
knowledge
gaps.
Given
changing
global
patterns
use,
increasing
inclusion
both
pesticide
risk
assessment,
there
need
expanding
beyond
its
current
state
ensure
strong
scientific
evidence
base
development
assessment
associated
policy.
Ecological Processes,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
14(1)
Published: March 3, 2025
The
restoration
of
natural
landscape
elements
is
a
frequently
adopted
pathway
to
improve
wild
pollinator
abundance,
diversity,
and
their
pollination
services
in
intensively
used
agricultural
landscapes.
However,
pollinators
the
intended
refuges
can
become
exposed
agrochemicals
when
foraging
surrounding
fields.
In
order
effectively
design
conservation
measures
such
as
habitat
or
pesticide
reduction
schemes,
effect
land
use
configuration
on
exposure
service
requires
further
investigation.
We
developed
model
that
extends
existing
approaches
by
simulating
both
flights
concurrent
toxic
pesticides,
enabling
estimation
impacts
services.
calculated
health
for
set
artificial
landscapes,
which
varied
percentage
agriculture,
clustering
these
uses,
well
mortality
hazard
arising
from
pesticides
applied
agriculture.
Our
results
show
landscapes
with
less
than
10%
highly
are
mostly
safeguarded
compact
patches
habitat,
this
shelters
more
exposure.
With
increasing
amount
applications
causing
50%
pollinators,
dispersed
achieve
better
landscape.
tested
application
different
ranges
realistic
scenario.
For
shorter
ranges,
immediate
surroundings
determines
achieved
pollination.
species
longer
availability
resources
at
scale
controls
study
highlights
importance
assessing
spatial
effects
local
pollinators.
By
applying
insights,
managers
devise
arrangements
protect
habitats
establish
buffer
zones
support
activity
pesticide-intensive
As
current
guidelines
largely
lack
spatially-explicit
measures,
we
suggest
direct
future
research
policies
towards
underlying
processes
facilitation
parcel,
farm,
scale.
online
version
contains
supplementary
material
available
10.1186/s13717-025-00587-z.
Scientific Reports,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
15(1)
Published: March 28, 2025
Honey
bees
(Apis
mellifera)
often
encounter
a
variety
of
stressors
in
their
environment,
including
poor
nutrition
and
pesticides.
These
interact
can
be
exacerbated
large-scale
agroecosystems.
We
investigated
how
diets
varying
macronutrient
ratios
affect
nurse
bee
susceptibility
to
pesticide
stressors.
Nurse
were
fed
trace
concentrations
clothianidin
(CLO),
neonicotinoid
insecticide
known
have
sublethal
lethal
effects
on
honey
bees,
after
newly
emerged
given
proteins
lipids,
natural
pollen
diet,
or
sucrose
solution
diet.
Bees
had
improved
longevity,
physiology,
enzyme
activity,
gene
expression
related
detoxification.
The
artificial
helped
improve
health
physiology
but
did
little
promote
detoxification
enzymes
genes.
There
was
no
effect
the
CLO
treatments
its
own,
there
an
interactive
between
our
higher
treatment
longevity
vitellogenin
expression.
Our
results
suggest
that
(1)
exposure
even
with
undermine
adult
(2)
macronutrients
help
other
nutrients
pollen,
such
as
potentially
phytochemicals,
are
more
directly
linked
tolerance
stress.