Microbiology Spectrum,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Feb. 21, 2025
Antibiotic
resistance
is
emerging
as
a
significant
global
health
crisis,
necessitating
the
urgent
development
of
novel
antibiotics
or
alternative
therapies.
Although
it
recognized
that
bacteria
require
multiple
mutations
to
develop
levels
exceeding
mutant
prevention
concentration,
specific
mutation
combinations
conferring
high
have
been
largely
undefined.
Here,
we
investigated
multi-step
evolution
fluoroquinolone
in
Pseudomonas
aeruginosa
through
experimental
and
whole-genome
sequencing
coupled
with
proteomic
approaches.
We
discovered
low-dose
high-dose
scenarios,
negative
regulators
efflux
pumps
(nfxB/mexR)
DNA
gyrases
(gyrA/gyrB)
contributed
high-level
some
these
were
also
prevalent
clinical
isolates
P.
aeruginosa.
Notably,
selected
nfxB
mutation,
which
resulted
overexpression
MexCD-OprJ
pump,
exhibited
collateral
sensitivity
aminoglycosides
enhanced
antibiotic
tolerance.
It
was
further
revealed
pump
inhibitor
phenylalanine-arginine
β-naphthylamide
(PAβN)
could
effectively
prevent
for
both
laboratory
strains.
Our
work
highlights
critical
role
repressor-related
demonstrates
potential
targeting
impede
toward
resistance.IMPORTANCEIn
this
study,
examined
stepwise
using
evolution,
sequencing,
analyses.
findings
under
conditions,
gyrase
genes
synergistically
resistance.
These
not
only
observed
settings
but
detected
This
underscores
pivotal
progression
promise
strategy
Bacterial
populations
vary
in
their
stress
tolerance
and
population
structure
depending
upon
whether
growth
occurs
well-mixed
or
structured
environments.
We
hypothesized
that
evolution
biofilms
would
generate
greater
genetic
diversity
than
environments
lead
to
different
pathways
of
antibiotic
resistance.
used
experimental
whole
genome
sequencing
test
how
the
biofilm
lifestyle
influenced
rate,
mechanisms,
pleiotropic
effects
resistance
ciprofloxacin
Acinetobacter
baumannii
populations.
Both
evolutionary
dynamics
identities
mutations
differed
between
lifestyle.
Planktonic
experienced
selective
sweeps
including
primary
topoisomerase
drug
targets,
whereas
biofilm-adapted
acquired
regulators
efflux
pumps.
An
overall
trade-off
fitness
level
emerged,
wherein
clones
were
less
resistant
planktonic
but
more
fit
absence
drug.
However,
developed
collateral
sensitivity
cephalosporins,
demonstrating
clinical
relevance
on
EMBO Reports,
Journal Year:
2019,
Volume and Issue:
20(8)
Published: July 24, 2019
Review24
July
2019Open
Access
Microbial
Experimental
Evolution
–
a
proving
ground
for
evolutionary
theory
and
tool
discovery
Michael
J
McDonald
Corresponding
Author
[email
protected]
orcid.org/0000-0002-5735-960X
School
of
Biological
Sciences,
Monash
University,
Melbourne,
Vic.,
Australia
Search
more
papers
by
this
author
Information
*,1
1School
*Corresponding
author.
Tel:
+61
3
9905
1697;
E-mail:
EMBO
Reports
(2019)20:e46992https://doi.org/10.15252/embr.201846992
See
the
Glossary
abbreviations
used
in
article.
PDFDownload
PDF
article
text
main
figures.
ToolsAdd
to
favoritesDownload
CitationsTrack
CitationsPermissions
ShareFacebookTwitterLinked
InMendeleyWechatReddit
Figures
&
Info
Abstract
experimental
evolution
uses
controlled
laboratory
populations
study
mechanisms
evolution.
The
molecular
analysis
evolved
enables
empirical
tests
that
can
confirm
predictions
theory,
but
also
lead
surprising
discoveries.
As
with
other
fields
life
sciences,
microbial
has
become
tool,
deployed
as
part
suite
techniques
available
biologist.
Here,
I
provide
review
general
findings
evolution,
especially
those
relevant
microbiologists
are
new
field.
relate
these
results
design
considerations
an
experiment
suggest
future
directions
working
at
intersection
biology.
clonal
interference
slowed
rates
fixation
asexual
population
due
competition
between
lineages
each
carry
beneficial
mutation
coverage
length
concatenated
DNA-sequence
read
data
divided
genome
de
novo
occurs
spontaneously
during
period
fixed
state
which
allele
given
genetic
locus
is
frequency
1
barcode
short
DNA
sequence
identify
individual
or
lineage
haplotype
set
variants
physically
linked
on
single
chromosome
HGT
horizontal
gene
transfer
individuals
share
common
ancestor
within
time
LN
natural
log
LTEE
long-term
N
size
parallel
similar
phenotypes
genotypes
independently
evolving
selection
coefficient(s)
quantitative
representation
relative
fitness
reproductive
success
standing
variation
present
before
considered
observer
Introduction
studies
now
constitute
one
foundations
1.
In
particular,
bring
greater
power
precision
studies,
providing
means
out
elaborate
explore
ideas
biology
2.
A
typical
starts
culture,
just
like
any
microbiology
laboratory.
Cells
inoculated
into
media
left
grow
until
culture
reaches
high
density.
Instead
throwing
using
all
resultant
population,
evolutionist
transfers
dilutes
allow
continued
growth
division.
This
cycle
be
indefinitely,
generations
accumulate,
will
drive
adapt
environment.
simple
process
carried
range
systems,
summarised
Fig
Figure
Mechanisms
propagation
evolution(A)
Batch
requires
regular
dilution
fresh
media.
These
experiments
relatively
easy
establish,
since
vessels
commonly
batch
culture.
scaled
large
number
replicates,
example
when
96-well
plates.
(B)
Chemostat
systems
include
constant
supply
medium.
provides
continuous
cultures
without
fluctuations
phase.
(C)
Microfluidics
most
precise
control
over
supplements
cell
cultures.
may
need
custom
designed,
replicates
limited.
(D)
Emulsion
take
advantage
small
cell-containing
vesicles
form
mixing
oil,
surfactant
cells.
cells
vesicle
determined
ratio
cell,
oil.
mixed
back
vortexing
centrifuging
solution.
One
select
yield
per-vesicle
rather
than
rapid
144.
(E)
Mutation
accumulation
introduces
regular,
single-cell
bottleneck
replicate
population.
achieved
streaking
petri
dish
then
choosing
colony
(founded
cell)
streak
next
plate.
(F)
introduced
model
organism,
often
plant
mouse,
propagate
it
recovered
from
organism.
analysed
subjected
further
mode
allows
testing
unanticipated
organism-specific
features
environment
difficult
Download
figure
PowerPoint
Long-
short-term
approaches
Perhaps
striking
microbes
access
long
scales.
generation
times
up
tens
pass
every
day.
limited
only
how
experimentalist
maintain
transfers.
easily
stored
freezer,
indefinite
period,
so
saved
frozen
snapshot
restart
inevitable
accidents
happen.
longest
running,
probably
famous,
(LTEE).
comprised
12
E.
coli,
started
1987
still
passaged
daily
68,000
later
(see
here
recent
4).
What
learned
running
long?
Twenty
years
ago,
biologist
might
have
predicted
coli
would
reached
optimal
after
few
thousand
generations.
However,
we
know
continues
61,500
5,
6.
key
been
utilisation
citrate
(cit+
phenotype),
carbon
source
buffer
phenotype
significant
because
species-defining
characteristic
unable
utilised
under
oxidising
conditions
7.
effect
mutations
explicitly
cause
cit+
dependent
"potentiating"
do
not
seem
directly
influence
occurred
first
20,000
8.
words,
particular
trait
unlikely
experiment.
there
quicker
routes
many
An
alternative
propagating
term
evolve
shorter
time.
strong,
rapidly.
Adapting
temperatures,
Tenaillon
et
al
propagated
115
2,000
9.
Increasing
another
magnitude,
Lang
1,000
Saccharomyces
cerevisiae
10,
11.
massive
replication
confers
statistical
detect
change,
hundreds
shows
some
questions
highly
replicated
cannot
address;
however,
trends
emerging
consistent
across
both
long-
12,
13,
reviewed
below.
Repeatability,
diminishing
returns
diversification:
predictable
Parallel
same
phenotypes,
sometimes
mutations,
14.
Parallelism
driven
observed
short-
species
11,
15-19
(Fig
2A).
Repeatability
interesting
suggests
phenotypic
outcomes
could
predictable.
To
anticipate
response
environmental
changes
major
goal
20,
capacity
make
accurate
desirable.
unclear
whether
about
ever
enough
useful,
subject
ongoing
models
21,
22.
Three
experiments(A)
Genetic
parallelism.
signature
repeated
genes
independent
populations.
expected
multi-hit
mutated
six
hypothetical
1000-generation
(grey
shaded)
(orange
line)
Diminishing
epistasis.
negatively
correlated
background
(figure
adapted
25).
Stable
polymorphism
evolve,
whereby
multiple
ecotypes,
different
niche
microcosm,
coexist
27.
possible
outcome
successive
sweeps
mutation,
occasionally
hampered
(D).
At
onset
experiment,
adaptation
tends
slows
down
23.
LTEE,
rate
increase
follows
law,
no
attained
5.
explained
epistatic
interactions
effects
lower
better
24.
Experiments
show
engineered
low-fitness
larger
if
they
high-fitness
2B).
"diminishing
returns"
epistasis
M.
extorquens
S.
25,
well
26.
While
return
makes
specific
does
robust
made
although
true
experiencing
fluctuating
complex
environments.
Most
use
unicellular
organisms
adapting
defined-nutrient
diverse,
co-existing
subpopulations
niches,
evident
6,
27,
28
2C).
Diverse
heterogeneity
experimenter,
called
eco-evolutionary
feedback
29.
happens
populations,
altered
production
waste
products
consumption
modifications
change
ecology
alters
selective
pressures
experienced
30.
observation
emphasises
its
importance
real
communities
mechanism
experiments.
facilitate
fundamental
parameters
evolution:
environment,
Understanding,
manipulating,
factors
benefit
exerted
size,
founding
genotype
determines
therefore
drives
while
manipulating
variable
potentially
subtle
effects.
interpreting
setting
discussed
Population
(N)
strength
forces
minimum
detected
selection,
expressed
coefficient
(s),
1/N,
where
"N"
ineffective
Ns
<
31.
likely
experience
drift,
random
sampling
frequencies
chance
deleterious
loss
mutations.
consequence
expect
slower
and,
extreme
cases,
extinction
32.
Some
designed
consequences
33-36,
deliberately
1–10
1).
If
avoid
103–104
recommended.
Variation
experimenter
vary
much
variation,
"fuel"
supplied
37.
proportional
amount
38.
start
amounts
39-41,
founded
clone
3,
28,
42
adaptive
must
fuelled
43,
44,
elevated
artificially
induced
supplementing
mutagen
deleting
required
mismatch
repair.
antimicrobial
resistance
antibiotic
global
health
challenge
that,
sits
disciplines
biology,
microbiology,
genomics
20.
measure
costs
underlie
45-49,
probability
49.
Mutations
occur
important
biological
functions
reduction
viability
50.
Fitness
assays
Box
1:
How
fitness)
shown
confer
actually
47,
51-53,
always
come
cost.
When
costly,
resistant
microbe
secondary
compensate
primary
54.
Since
processes,
strategies
amelioration
resistance,
drugs,
should
account
55.
promising
line
research
characterise
susceptibilities
multidrug-resistant
strains.
order
attain
strains
several
compensatory
It
less
able
additional
Knowledge
multidrug
targeted
drug
combinations
based
clinical
pathogenic
organism
contribute
offspring
generation.
determine
degree
validate
experimentally
wide
assays.
Growth
145,
total
carrying
capacity,
biomass
105
speed
boundary
expansion
141
measures
gold
standard
measurement
competitive
starting
point
assay
obtain
construct
marked
reference
strain.
typically
modified
readily
distinguished
nature
marker
accuracy
For
instance,
fluorescent
differentiate
strain,
proportions
measured
flow
cytometry
10
10s
thousands
counted
ratios.
Alternatively,
mixture
spread
onto
agar
plates
containing
distinction
146,
counting
Initially,
strain
1:1
ratio.
Even
care
taken
mix
competitors
ratio,
very
initial
frequency,
difference
calculations
fitness.
Once
portion
aside
competing
diluted
incubated
time,
allowing
two
compete.
After
competition,
again.
calculated
measurements
dividing
individuals.
done
final
point.
(LN)
quotient
gives
performance
compared
value
passed
points,
yielding
per-generation
(s).
chosen
carefully.
too
long,
extinction,
thus
reducing
calculation
s.
short,
changed
detection
differences
genotypes.
bacteriophages
Bacteriophages
therapies
56,
bacteriophage
provided
insights
genetics
57.
Bacteriophage
genomes
small,
whole-genome
sequencing
phage
was
rise
next-generation
technologies
58.
head
exploited
19,
59,
60.
ease
bacteria
co-culture
led
co-evolutionary
dynamics.
infecting
isolation
61,
62.
diverse
bacteriophage,
increases
types
63.
bind
membrane
protein
gain
entry
cell.
facilitated
detailed
λ
site
64,
65.
Conversely,
bacterial
modifying
encodes
protein.
conferred
efflux
pumps,
hypothesised
targets
such
pump
tandem
comprise
"evolution
proof"
treatment
strategy
56.
principle
demonstrated
drove
MEX
pump,
thereby
restoring
sensitivity
P.
aeruginosa
66.
trait.
applications.
introduction
useful
properties
reductions
67.
yeast,
crossed
"wild-type"
promote
recombinants
possess
productivity
fast-growing
68.
Continuous
passaging
widely
restore
ethanol
xylose
69-71.
example,
C321
replace
UAG
codons
UAA.
ideal
biotechnological
applications,
incorporation
non-standard
amino
acids
code.
engineering
caused
slow
growth.
1,000-generation
resulted
restored
rates.
Moreover,
re-sequencing
revealed
mutational
causes
reduced
founder
72.
novel
hosts,
conditions.
Wolbachia
quickly
among
their
hosts
conferring
infected
females.
addition,
induce
insect
pathogens.
devised
Dengue
virus
amongst
mosquitos
originally
discovered
D.
melanogaster.
suited
dispersal
mosquito
A.
aegypti
mosquito's
intracellular
2
years.
newly
establish
stable
infection
73
thereafter
eventual
public
dengue
74.
Next,
introduce
describing
full
historical
recommend
books
1,
reviews
75-77
exhaustive
treatments
earlier
periods
non-microbial
78-81
aspects
You
get
what
you
for:
choices
Setting
beyond
normally
adaptation.
Adaptation
described,
including
temperatures
9,
82,
gradients
55
even
levels
ionising
radiation
83.
imagination.
parameter
pressure
differential
survival
relied
upon
regardless
pressure,
adaptations
predict.
Wildenberg
84
fluorescence-activated
sorter
brightest
24
h.
anticipated
expression
modulate
fluorescence.
Instead,
periodically
multicellular
clusters
increased
brightness
advantage.
unpredicted
did
diminish
elegance
serves
demonstrate
unpredictability
thwart
outcomes.
general,
complicated
regime,
unpredictable
noted
complicated,
well-designed,
elicit
selection.
sought
traits
selecting
against
germ
progenitor
cooperative
mats
fluorescens.
Although
were
unexpected,
successfully
applied
85.
Simple
environments
function
Natural
expose
microorganisms
nutrients
stresses
spatial
temporal
complexity
reflected
numbers
utilise
respond
stress.
Laboratory
86,
inactivate
superfluous
87.
Many
contain
source,
usually
glucose.
glucose
sole
concentration
limits
3.
h
"lag
time",
enter
via
pykF,
became
88.
specialisation
cost
sources.
Studies
showed
rbs
operon,
proteins
ribose
89,
disrupted
deleted
Measurements
~1%
90.
then,
disruption
genes,
sources,
maltose,
minimal
Other
yeast
concentrations
glucose,
Genes
91.
Whole-genome
half
disrupt
encode
negative
regulators
RAS/PKA
pathway
ac
Different
species
exposed
to
a
common
stress
may
adapt
by
mutations
in
shared
pathways
or
unique
systems,
depending
on
how
past
environments
have
molded
their
genomes.
Understanding
diverse
bacterial
pathogens
evolve
response
an
antimicrobial
treatment
is
pressing
example
of
this
problem,
where
discovery
molecular
parallelism
could
lead
clinically
useful
predictions.
Evolution
experiments
with
containing
antibiotics,
combined
periodic
whole-population
genome
sequencing,
can
be
used
identify
many
contending
routes
resistance.
We
separately
propagated
two
relevant
Gram-negative
pathogens,
Pseudomonas
aeruginosa
and
Acinetobacter
baumannii,
increasing
concentrations
tobramycin
different
each:
planktonic
biofilm.
Independently
the
pathogen,
populations
adapted
selection
parallel
evolution
fusA1,
encoding
elongation
factor
G,
ptsP,
phosphoenolpyruvate
phosphotransferase.
As
neither
gene
direct
target
aminoglycoside,
either
are
unexpected
underreported
causes
Additionally,
both
acquired
antibiotic
resistance-associated
that
were
more
prevalent
biofilm
lifestyle
than
lifestyle;
these
electron
transport
chain
components
A.
baumannii
lipopolysaccharide
biosynthesis
enzymes
P.
populations.
Using
existing
databases,
we
discovered
site-specific
fusA1
extends
across
phyla
clinical
isolates.
This
study
suggests
strong
selective
pressures,
such
as
treatment,
result
high
levels
predictability
targets
evolution,
despite
differences
between
organisms'
genetic
backgrounds
environments.IMPORTANCE
The
rise
resistance
leading
medical
threat,
motivating
efforts
forecast
its
evolutionary
dynamics
causes.
Aminoglycosides
major
class
antibiotics
disrupt
translation,
but
occur
number
mechanisms.
Here,
show
repeated
aminoglycoside
via
nitrogen-specific
phosphotransferase
system.
Laboratory
sequencing
targets,
at
identical
amino
acid
positions
also
found
published
genomes
identified
other
mechanisms
associated
growth
biofilms
likely
interfere
drug
binding
uptake.
Characterizing
multiple
presence
new,
repeatable
predicted
counteracted
alternative
treatment.
npj Biofilms and Microbiomes,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
7(1)
Published: Jan. 11, 2021
Abstract
Most
bacteria
in
nature
exist
biofilms,
which
are
inherently
tolerant
to
antibiotics.
There
is
currently
very
limited
understanding
of
how
biofilms
evolve
response
sub-lethal
concentrations
antimicrobials.
In
this
study,
we
use
a
biofilm
evolution
model
study
the
effects
sub-inhibitory
three
antibiotics
on
Salmonella
Typhimurium
biofilms.
We
show
that
rapidly
resistance
each
antibiotic
they
exposed
to,
demonstrating
strong
selective
pressure
from
low
concentrations.
While
all
tested
select
for
clinical
resistance,
there
no
common
mechanism.
Adaptation
antimicrobials,
however,
has
marked
cost
other
clinically
important
phenotypes,
including
formation
and
virulence.
Cefotaxime
selects
mutants
with
greatest
deficit
followed
by
azithromycin
then
ciprofloxacin.
Understanding
impacts
exposure
will
help
understand
evolutionary
trajectories
may
guide
best
context.
Experimental
combination
whole-genome
sequencing
powerful
tool
prediction
associated
PLoS Genetics,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
20(6), P. e1011154 - e1011154
Published: June 20, 2024
Lager
yeasts
are
limited
to
a
few
strains
worldwide,
imposing
restrictions
on
flavour
and
aroma
diversity
hindering
our
understanding
of
the
complex
evolutionary
mechanisms
during
yeast
domestication.
The
recent
finding
diverse
S
.
eubayanus
lineages
from
Patagonia
offers
potential
for
generating
new
lager
with
different
profiles.
Here,
we
leverage
natural
genetic
expand
repertoire
by
including
three
distinct
Patagonian
lineages.
We
used
experimental
evolution
selection
desirable
traits
enhance
fermentation
profiles
novel
cerevisiae
x
hybrids.
Our
analyses
reveal
an
intricate
interplay
pre-existing
diversity,
species-specific
mitochondria,
de-novo
mutations,
gene
copy
variations
in
sugar
metabolism
genes,
resulting
high
ethanol
production
unique
Hybrids
mitochondria
exhibited
greater
superior
fitness
post-evolution,
analogous
commercial
Using
genome-wide
screens
parental
subgenomes,
identified
changes
IRA2
,
IMA1
MALX
genes
that
influence
maltose
metabolism,
increase
glycolytic
flux
consumption
evolved
Functional
validation
transcriptome
confirmed
increased
maltose-related
expression,
influencing
maltotriose
This
study
demonstrates
industrially
viable
hybrids
wild
strains.
hybridization,
evolution,
mitochondrial
approach
produced
capacity
expands
beer
brewing
options.
mSystems,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
5(3)
Published: June 15, 2020
Our
work
demonstrated
that
the
specific
microbial
strains
used
to
construct
a
microbiome
could
impact
species
composition,
perturbation
responses,
and
functional
outputs
of
system.
These
findings
suggest
16S
rRNA
gene
taxonomic
profiles
alone
may
have
limited
potential
predict
dynamics
communities
because
they
usually
do
not
capture
strain-level
diversity.
Observations
from
our
synthetic
also
diversity
has
drive
variability
in
aesthetics
quality
surface-ripened
cheeses.