Psychotherapy and Psychosomatics,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
84(4), P. 193 - 207
Published: Jan. 1, 2015
Neurofeedback
draws
on
multiple
techniques
that
propel
both
healthy
and
patient
populations
to
self-regulate
neural
activity.
Since
the
1970s,
numerous
accounts
have
promoted
electroencephalography-neurofeedback
as
a
viable
treatment
for
host
of
mental
disorders.
Today,
while
number
health
care
providers
referring
patients
neurofeedback
practitioners
increases
steadily,
substantial
methodological
conceptual
caveats
continue
pervade
empirical
reports.
And
yet,
nascent
imaging
technologies
(e.g.,
real-time
functional
magnetic
resonance
imaging)
increasingly
rigorous
protocols
are
paving
road
towards
more
effective
applications
better
scientific
understanding
underlying
mechanisms.
Here,
we
outline
common
methods,
illuminate
tenuous
state
evidence,
sketch
out
future
directions
further
unravel
potential
merits
this
contentious
therapeutic
prospect.
Frontiers in Human Neuroscience,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
9
Published: Jan. 28, 2015
A
brain-computer
interface
(BCI)
is
a
communication
system
that
allows
the
use
of
brain
activity
to
control
computers
or
other
external
devices.
It
can,
by
bypassing
peripheral
nervous
system,
provide
means
for
people
suffering
from
severe
motor
disabilities
in
persistent
vegetative
state.
In
this
paper,
brain-signal
generation
tasks,
noise
removal
methods,
feature
extraction/selection
schemes,
and
classification
techniques
fNIRS-based
BCI
are
reviewed.
The
most
common
areas
fNIRS
primary
cortex
prefrontal
cortex.
relation
cortex,
imagery
tasks
were
preferred
execution
since
possible
proprioceptive
feedback
could
be
avoided.
showed
significant
advantage
due
no
hair
detecting
cognitive
like
mental
arithmetic,
music
imagery,
emotion
induction,
etc.
removing
physiological
data,
band-pass
filtering
was
mostly
used.
However,
more
advanced
adaptive
filtering,
independent
component
analysis,
multi
optodes
arrangement,
being
pursued
overcome
problem
filter
cannot
used
when
both
signals
occur
within
close
band.
extracting
features
related
desired
signal,
mean,
variance,
peak
value,
slope,
skewness,
kurtosis
noised-removed
hemodynamic
response
For
classification,
linear
discriminant
analysis
method
provided
simple
but
good
performance
among
others:
support
vector
machine,
hidden
Markov
model,
artificial
neural
network,
will
widely
monitor
occurrence
neuro-plasticity
after
neuro-rehabilitation
neuro-stimulation.
Technical
breakthroughs
future
expected
via
bundled-type
probes,
hybrid
EEG-fNIRS
BCI,
through
detection
initial
dips.
Clinical EEG and Neuroscience,
Journal Year:
2014,
Volume and Issue:
46(4), P. 310 - 320
Published: April 21, 2014
Electroencephalography
(EEG)–based
motor
imagery
(MI)
brain-computer
interface
(BCI)
technology
has
the
potential
to
restore
function
by
inducing
activity-dependent
brain
plasticity.
The
purpose
of
this
study
was
investigate
efficacy
an
EEG-based
MI
BCI
system
coupled
with
MIT-Manus
shoulder-elbow
robotic
feedback
(BCI-Manus)
for
subjects
chronic
stroke
upper-limb
hemiparesis.
In
single-blind,
randomized
trial,
26
hemiplegic
(Fugl-Meyer
Assessment
Motor
Recovery
After
Stroke
[FMMA]
score,
4-40;
16
men;
mean
age,
51.4
years;
duration,
297.4
days),
prescreened
ability
use
BCI,
were
randomly
allocated
BCI-Manus
or
Manus
therapy,
lasting
18
hours
over
4
weeks.
Efficacy
measured
using
upper-extremity
FMMA
scores
at
weeks
0,
2,
and
12.
ElEG
data
from
quantified
revised
symmetry
index
(rBSI)
analyzed
correlation
improvements
in
score.
Eleven
15
underwent
respectively.
One
subject
group
dropped
out.
Mean
total
4,
12
improved
both
groups:
26.3
±
10.3,
27.4
12.0,
30.8
13.8,
31.5
13.5
26.6
18.9,
29.9
20.6,
32.9
21.4,
33.9
20.2
Manus,
no
intergroup
differences
(
P
=
.51).
More
attained
further
gains
week
(7
11
[63.6%])
than
(5
14
[35.7%]).
A
negative
found
between
rBSI
score
improvement
.044).
therapy
well
tolerated
not
associated
adverse
events.
conclusion,
is
effective
safe
arm
rehabilitation
after
severe
poststroke
comparable
those
intensive
(1,040
repetitions/session)
despite
reduced
exercise
repetitions
MI-triggered
(136
repetitions/session).
suggests
that
can
be
used
as
a
prognostic
measure
BCI-based
rehabilitation.
Annals of Clinical and Translational Neurology,
Journal Year:
2018,
Volume and Issue:
5(5), P. 651 - 663
Published: March 25, 2018
Abstract
Brain‐computer
interfaces
(
BCI
s)
can
provide
sensory
feedback
of
ongoing
brain
oscillations,
enabling
stroke
survivors
to
modulate
their
sensorimotor
rhythms
purposefully.
A
number
recent
clinical
studies
indicate
that
repeated
use
such
s
might
trigger
neurological
recovery
and
hence
improvement
in
motor
function.
Here,
we
a
first
meta‐analysis
evaluating
the
effectiveness
‐based
post‐stroke
rehabilitation.
Trials
were
identified
using
MEDLINE
,
CENTRAL
PED
ro
by
inspection
references
several
review
articles.
We
selected
randomized
controlled
trials
used
for
rehabilitation
provided
impairment
scores
before
after
intervention.
random‐effects
inverse
variance
method
was
calculate
summary
effect
size.
initially
524
articles
and,
removing
duplicates,
screened
titles
abstracts
473
found
26
corresponding
trials,
these,
there
nine
involved
total
235
fulfilled
inclusion
criterion
(randomized
examined
performance
as
an
outcome
measure)
meta‐analysis.
Motor
improvements,
mostly
quantified
upper
limb
Fugl‐Meyer
Assessment
FMA
‐
UE
),
exceeded
minimal
clinically
important
difference
MCID
=5.25)
six
studies,
while
reached
only
three
control
groups.
Overall,
training
associated
with
standardized
mean
0.79
(95%
CI
:
0.37
1.20)
compared
conditions,
which
is
range
medium
large
In
addition,
indicated
‐induced
functional
structural
neuroplasticity
at
subclinical
level.
This
suggests
technology
could
be
effective
intervention
However,
more
larger
sample
size
are
required
increase
reliability
these
results.
Journal of Neural Engineering,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
17(4), P. 041001 - 041001
Published: July 2, 2020
Abstract
Stroke
is
one
of
the
leading
causes
long-term
disability
among
adults
and
contributes
to
major
socio-economic
burden
globally.
frequently
results
in
multifaceted
impairments
including
motor,
cognitive
emotion
deficits.
In
recent
years,
brain–computer
interface
(BCI)-based
therapy
has
shown
promising
for
post-stroke
motor
rehabilitation.
spite
success
received
by
BCI-based
interventions
domain,
non-motor
are
yet
receive
similar
attention
research
clinical
settings.
Some
preliminary
encouraging
rehabilitation
using
BCI
seem
suggest
that
it
may
also
hold
potential
treating
deficits
such
as
impairments.
Moreover,
past
studies
have
an
intricate
relationship
between
functions
which
might
influence
overall
outcome.
A
number
highlight
inability
current
treatment
protocols
account
implicit
interplay
functions.
This
indicates
necessity
explore
all-inclusive
plan
targeting
synergistic
these
standalone
interventions.
approach
lead
better
recovery
than
individual
isolation.
this
paper,
we
review
advances
use
systems
beyond
particular,
improving
cognition
stroke
patients.
Building
on
findings
domains,
next
discuss
possibility
a
holistic
system
affect
synergistically
promote
restorative
neuroplasticity.
Such
would
provide
all-encompassing
platform,
overarching
outcomes
transfer
quality
living.
first
works
analyse
cross-domain
functional
enabled
Neurobiology of Disease,
Journal Year:
2014,
Volume and Issue:
83, P. 172 - 179
Published: Dec. 7, 2014
Stroke
is
among
the
leading
causes
of
long-term
disabilities
leaving
an
increasing
number
people
with
cognitive,
affective
and
motor
impairments
depending
on
assistance
in
their
daily
life.
While
function
after
stroke
can
significantly
improve
first
weeks
months,
further
recovery
often
slow
or
non-existent
more
severe
cases
encompassing
30–50%
all
victims.
The
neurobiological
mechanisms
underlying
those
patients
are
incompletely
understood.
However,
recent
studies
demonstrated
brain's
remarkable
capacity
for
functional
structural
plasticity
even
chronic
stroke.
As
established
rehabilitation
strategies
require
some
remaining
function,
there
currently
no
standardized
accepted
treatment
complete
muscle
paralysis.
development
brain–machine
interfaces
(BMIs)
that
translate
brain
activity
into
control
signals
computers
external
devices
provides
two
new
to
overcome
stroke-related
First,
BMIs
establish
continuous
high-dimensional
brain-control
robotic
electric
stimulation
(FES)
assist
life
activities
(assistive
BMI).
Second,
could
facilitate
neuroplasticity,
thus
enhancing
learning
(rehabilitative
Advances
sensor
technology,
non-invasive
implantable
wireless
BMI-systems
combination
stimulation,
along
evidence
BMI
systems'
clinical
efficacy
suggest
BMI-related
will
play
role
neurorehabilitation
Frontiers in Neuroengineering,
Journal Year:
2014,
Volume and Issue:
7
Published: July 29, 2014
The
objective
of
this
study
was
to
investigate
the
efficacy
an
Electroencephalography
(EEG)-based
Motor
Imagery
(MI)
Brain-Computer
Interface
(BCI)
coupled
with
a
Haptic
Knob
(HK)
robot
for
arm
rehabilitation
in
stroke
patients.
In
three-arm,
single-blind,
randomized
controlled
trial;
21
chronic
hemiplegic
patients
(Fugl-Meyer
Assessment
(FMMA)
score
10-50),
recruited
after
pre-screening
MI
BCI
ability,
were
randomly
allocated
BCI-HK,
HK
or
Standard
Arm
Therapy
(SAT)
groups.
All
groups
received
18
sessions
intervention
over
6
weeks,
3
per
week,
90
min
session.
BCI-HK
group
1
h
intervention,
and
Both
120
trials
robot-assisted
hand
grasping
knob
manipulation
followed
by
30
therapist-assisted
mobilization.
SAT
1.5
mobilization
forearm
pronation-supination
movements
incorporating
wrist
control
grasp-release
functions.
all,
14
males,
7
females,
mean
age
54.2
years,
duration
385.1
days,
baseline
FMMA
27.0
recruited.
primary
outcome
measure
upper
extremity
scores
measured
mid-intervention
at
week
3,
end-intervention
6,
follow-up
weeks
12
24.
Seven,
8
subjects
underwent
interventions
respectively.
improved
all
groups,
but
no
intergroup
differences
found
any
time
points.
Significantly
larger
motor
gains
observed
compared
12,
24,
did
not
differ
from
point.
conclusion,
is
effective,
safe,
may
have
potential
enhancing
recovery
when
combined
Journal of Computing Science and Engineering,
Journal Year:
2013,
Volume and Issue:
7(2), P. 139 - 146
Published: June 30, 2013
Recent
advances
in
computer
science
enabled
people
with
severe
motor
disabilities
to
use
brain-computer
interfaces
(BCI)
for
communication,
control,
and
even
restore
their
disabilities.
This
paper
reviews
the
most
recent
works
of
BCI
stroke
rehabilitation
a
focus
on
methodology
that
reported
data
collected
from
patients
clinical
studies
improvements
patients.
Both
types
are
important
as
former
technology
stroke,
latter
demonstrates
efficacy
stroke.
Finally
some
challenges
discussed.
Brain,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
138(8), P. 2359 - 2369
Published: June 11, 2015
Valid
biomarkers
of
motor
system
function
after
stroke
could
improve
clinical
decision-making.
Electroencephalography-based
measures
are
safe,
inexpensive,
and
accessible
in
complex
medical
settings
so
attractive
candidates.
This
study
examined
specific
electroencephalography
cortical
connectivity
as
by
assessing
their
relationship
with
deficits
across
28
days
intensive
therapy.
Resting-state
were
acquired
four
times
using
dense
array
(256
leads)
12
hemiparetic
patients
(7.3
±
4.0
months
post-stroke,
age
26–75
years,
six
male/six
female)
therapy
targeting
arm
deficits.
Structural
magnetic
resonance
imaging
measured
corticospinal
tract
injury
infarct
volume.
At
baseline,
leads
overlying
ipsilesional
primary
cortex
(M1)
was
a
robust
marker
status,
accounting
for
78%
variance
impairment;
M1
frontal-premotor
(PM)
regions
accounted
most
this
(R2
=
0.51)
remained
significant
controlling
injury.
Baseline
impairment
also
correlated
0.52),
though
not
A
model
that
combined
functional
measure
structural
(corticospinal
injury)
performed
better
than
either
alone
0.93).
Across
the
therapy,
change
good
biomarker
gains
0.61).
Ipsilesional
M1–PM
increased
parallel
gains,
greater
associated
larger
increases
0.34);
decreases
M1–parietal
0.36).
In
sum,
connectivity—particularly
between
premotor—are
strongly
related
to
improvement
may
be
useful
plasticity.
Such
might
provide
biological
approach
distinguishing
patient
subgroups
stroke.
would
assist
tailoring
optimisation
treatment.
Wu
et
al.
show
EEG
–
particularly
correlate
over
course
Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience,
Journal Year:
2016,
Volume and Issue:
34(4), P. 571 - 586
Published: Aug. 13, 2016
Contemporary
strategies
to
promote
motor
recovery
following
stroke
focus
on
repetitive
voluntary
movements.
Although
successful
movement
relies
efficient
sensorimotor
integration,
functional
outcomes
often
bias
therapy
toward
motor-related
impairments
such
as
weakness,
spasticity
and
syner
gies;
sensory
reintegration
is
implied,
but
seldom
targeted.
However,
the
planning
execution
of
requires
that
brain
extracts
information
regarding
body
position
predicts
future
positions,
by
integrating
a
variety
inputs
with
ongoing
planned
activity.
Neurological
patients
who
have
lost
one
or
more
their
senses
may
show
profoundly
affected
functions,
even
if
muscle
strength
remains
unaffected.
Following
stroke,
can
be
dictated
degree
disruption.
Consequently,
thorough
account
function
might
both
prognostic
prescriptive
in
neurorehabilitation.
This
review
outlines
key
components
human
movement,
describes
how
disruption
influence
prognosis
expected
patients,
reports
current
sensory-based
approaches
post-stroke
rehabilitation,
makes
recommendations
for
optimizing
rehabilitation
programs
based
stimulation.