The
year
2024
marks
30
years
since
the
publication
of
Bell
Curve:
Intelligence
and
Class
Structure
in
American
Life
by
Richard
Herrnstein
Charles
Murray.
book
created
a
storm
controversy
after
its
1994
publication,
including
authors’
claim
that
it
is
“highly
likely…that
both
genes
environment
have
something
to
do
with
racial
differences”
mean
IQ
scores
between
U.S.
Whites
Blacks
(African
Americans).
In
this
review,
we
evaluate
not
only
Murray’s
ethnic-differences
claims,
but
also
evidence
they
cited
support
“substantial”
within-group
heritability
(now
conflict
recent
modest
molecular
genetic
results).
We
show
“twins
reared
apart”
(TRA)
studies
supplying
what
authors
called
“most
unambiguous
direct
estimates”
contain
numerous
biases,
results
modern”
TRA
study
were
based
on
omitted
control
group
data,
reliance
false
assumptions,
other
“questionable
research
practices.”
then
describe
major
problems,
unsupported
assumptions
found
family,
reared-together
twin,
adoption
while
calling
into
question
validity
long-disputed
concepts
such
as
“heritability,”
“IQ,”
“race.”
Like
many
previous
reviewers,
conclude
Murray
presented
no
valid
causes
between-ethnic-group
or
social-class
score
differences.
addition,
unlike
most
produced
influence
differences
within
groups.
As
1994,
social
political
policy
recommendations
should
be
rejected
because,
among
reasons,
are
faulty
coming
increasingly
light
science’s
replication
crisis.
Human Genomics,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
19(1)
Published: Jan. 31, 2025
Non-communicable
diseases
(NCDs)
such
as
cardiovascular
diseases,
chronic
respiratory
cancers,
diabetes,
and
mental
health
disorders
pose
a
significant
global
challenge,
accounting
for
the
majority
of
fatalities
disability-adjusted
life
years
worldwide.
These
arise
from
complex
interactions
between
genetic,
behavioral,
environmental
factors,
necessitating
thorough
understanding
these
dynamics
to
identify
effective
diagnostic
strategies
interventions.
Although
recent
advances
in
multi-omics
technologies
have
greatly
enhanced
our
ability
explore
interactions,
several
challenges
remain.
include
inherent
complexity
heterogeneity
multi-omic
datasets,
limitations
analytical
approaches,
severe
underrepresentation
non-European
genetic
ancestries
most
omics
which
restricts
generalizability
findings
exacerbates
disparities.
This
scoping
review
evaluates
landscape
data
related
NCDs
2000
2024,
focusing
on
advancements
integration,
translational
applications,
equity
considerations.
We
highlight
need
standardized
protocols,
harmonized
data-sharing
policies,
advanced
approaches
artificial
intelligence/machine
learning
integrate
study
gene-environment
interactions.
also
opportunities
translating
insights
(GxE)
research
into
precision
medicine
strategies.
underscore
potential
advancing
enhancing
patient
outcomes
across
diverse
underserved
populations,
emphasizing
fairness-centered
strategic
investments
build
local
capacities
underrepresented
populations
regions.
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Feb. 4, 2025
Abstract
Polygenic
scores
(PGSs)
are
being
rapidly
adopted
for
trait
prediction
in
the
clinic
and
beyond.
PGSs
often
thought
of
as
capturing
direct
genetic
effect
one’s
genotype
on
their
phenotype.
However,
because
constructed
from
population-level
associations,
they
influenced
by
factors
other
than
effects,
including
stratification,
assortative
mating,
dynastic
effects
(“SAD
effects”).
Our
interpretation
application
may
hinge
relative
impact
SAD
since
be
environmentally
or
culturally
mediated.
We
developed
a
method
that
estimates
proportion
variance
PGS
(in
given
sample)
is
driven
covariance.
leverage
comparison
interest
based
standard
GWAS
with
sibling
GWAS—which
largely
immune
to
effects—to
quantify
contribution
each
type
interest.
method,
Partitioning
Genetic
Scores
Using
Siblings
(PGSUS,
pron.
“Pegasus”),
breaks
down
components
further
axes
ancestry,
allowing
nuanced
effects.
In
particular,
PGSUS
can
detect
stratification
along
major
ancestry
well
“isotropic”
respect
ancestry.
Applying
PGSUS,
we
found
evidence
using
large
meta-analyses
height
educational
attainment
range
UK
Biobank.
some
instances,
appears
stratified
axis
one
sample
but
not
another
(for
example,
comparisons
samples
different
countries,
ancient
DNA
vs.
contemporary
samples).
Finally,
show
approaches
adjustment
population
structure
GWASs
have
distinct
advantages
mitigation
ancestry-axis-specific
isotropic
PGS.
study
illustrates
how
family-based
designs
combined
population-based
guide
genomic
predictors.
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Feb. 5, 2025
Abstract
Previous
genetic
studies
of
human
assortative
mating
have
primarily
focused
on
searching
for
its
genomic
footprint
but
revealed
limited
insights
into
biological
and
social
mechanisms.
Combining
from
the
economics
marriage
market
with
advanced
tools
in
statistical
genetics,
we
perform
first
genome-wide
association
study
(GWAS)
a
latent
index
partner
choice.
Using
206,617
individuals
four
global
cohorts,
uncover
phenotypic
characteristics
processes
underlying
mating.
We
identify
broadly
robust
component
choice
between
sexes
several
countries
correlates.
also
provide
solutions
to
reduce
mating-driven
biases
complex
traits
by
conditioning
GWAS
summary
statistics
associations
index.
Molecular Psychiatry,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
29(4), P. 951 - 961
Published: Jan. 16, 2024
The
aetiology
of
conduct
problems
involves
a
combination
genetic
and
environmental
factors,
many
which
are
inherently
linked
to
parental
characteristics
given
parents'
central
role
in
children's
lives
across
development.
It
is
important
disentangle
what
extent
links
between
heritable
behaviour
due
transmission
risk
or
indirect
influences
via
the
environment
(i.e.,
nurture).
We
used
31,290
genotyped
mother-father-child
trios
from
Norwegian
Mother,
Father
Child
Cohort
Study
(MoBa),
testing
nurture
effects
on
using
13
polygenic
scores
(PGS)
spanning
psychiatric
conditions,
substance
use,
education-related
other
factors.
Maternal
self-reports
at
ages
8
14
years
were
available
for
up
15,477
children.
found
significant
12
out
PGS
age
(strongest
association:
smoking,
β
=
0.07,
95%
confidence
interval
[0.05,
0.08])
4
externalising
problems,
0.08,
0.11]).
Conversely,
we
did
not
find
our
selection
PGS.
Our
findings
provide
evidence
association
child
problems.
results
may
also
indicate
that
traits
indexed
by
limited
aetiological
importance
problems-though
small
magnitude
captured
included
remain
possibility.
Nature Human Behaviour,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
8(10), P. 2034 - 2046
Published: Aug. 26, 2024
Abstract
Non-cognitive
skills,
such
as
motivation
and
self-regulation,
are
partly
heritable
predict
academic
achievement
beyond
cognitive
skills.
However,
how
the
relationship
between
non-cognitive
skills
changes
over
development
is
unclear.
The
current
study
examined
associated
with
from
ages
7
to
16
years
in
a
sample
of
10,000
children
England
Wales.
results
showed
that
association
increased
across
development.
Twin
polygenic
scores
analyses
found
links
genetics
became
stronger
school
years.
within-family
indicated
genetic
effects
on
could
not
simply
be
attributed
confounding
by
environmental
differences
nuclear
families,
consistent
possible
role
for
evocative/active
gene–environment
correlations.
By
studying
associations
through
developmental
lens,
we
provide
further
insights
into
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: July 11, 2023
Abstract
Both
direct
genetic
effects
(effects
of
alleles
in
an
individual
on
that
individual)
and
indirect
—
(e.g.
parents)
another
offspring)
can
contribute
to
phenotypic
variation
genotype-phenotype
associations.
Here,
we
consider
a
phenotype
affected
by
parental
under
assortative
mating
at
equilibrium.
We
generalize
classical
theory
derive
decomposition
the
equilibrium
variance
terms
effect
components.
extend
this
show
popular
methods
for
estimating
or
‘genetic
nurture’
through
analysis
offspring
polygenic
predictors
(called
indices
scores
PGIs
PGSs)
are
substantially
biased
mating.
propose
improved
method
while
accounting
also
correct
heritability
estimates
bias
due
validate
our
simulations
apply
it
height
educational
attainment
(EA),
is
0.699
(S.E.
=
0.075)
finding
no
evidence
height.
estimate
very
high
correlation
between
parents’
underlying
components
EA,
0.755
0.035),
which
inconsistent
with
twin
based
possibly
confounding
EA
PGI
and/or
studies.
implement
software
package
snipar
,
enabling
researchers
data
including
observed
imputed
genotypes.
provide
theoretical
framework
understanding
results
analyses
practical
methodology
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: June 28, 2024
Abstract
Stabilizing
selection
on
a
polygenic
trait
reduces
the
trait’s
genetic
variance
by
(i)
generating
correlations
(linkage
disequilibria)
between
opposite-effect
alleles
throughout
genome
and
(ii)
selecting
against
rare
at
polymorphic
loci
that
affect
trait,
eroding
heterozygosity
these
loci.
Here,
we
characterize
impact
of
linkage
disequilibria,
which
stabilizing
generates
rapid
timescale,
subsequent
allele-frequency
dynamics
individual
loci,
proceed
slower
timescale.
We
obtain
expressions
for
expected
per-generation
change
in
minor-allele
frequency
as
functions
effect
sizes
strength
its
heritability,
relations
among
Using
whole-genome
simulations,
show
our
predict
under
more
accurately
than
have
previously
been
used
this
purpose.
Our
results
implications
understanding
architecture
complex
traits.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
121(38)
Published: Sept. 13, 2024
Family-based
genome-wide
association
studies
(GWASs)
are
often
claimed
to
provide
an
unbiased
estimate
of
the
average
causal
effects
(or
treatment
effects;
ATEs)
alleles,
on
basis
analogy
between
random
transmission
alleles
from
parents
children
and
a
randomized
controlled
trial.
We
show
that
this
claim
does
not
hold
in
general.
Because
Mendelian
segregation
only
randomizes
among
heterozygotes,
homozygotes
observable.
This
feature
will
matter
if
allele
has
different
as
can
arise
presence
gene-by-environment
interactions,
gene-by-gene
or
differences
linkage
disequilibrium
patterns.
At
single
locus,
family-based
GWAS
be
thought
providing
effect
heterozygotes
(i.e.,
local
effect;
LATE).
interpretation
extend
polygenic
scores
(PGSs),
however,
because
sets
SNPs
heterozygous
each
family.
Therefore,
other
than
under
specific
conditions,
within-family
regression
slope
PGS
cannot
assumed
LATE
for
any
subset
weighted
families.
In
practice,
potential
biases
likely
smaller
those
confounding
standard,
population-based
GWAS,
so
family
remain
important
dissection
genetic
contributions
phenotypic
variation.
Nonetheless,
their
is
less
straightforward
been
widely
appreciated.