Sustainability,
Journal Year:
2019,
Volume and Issue:
11(14), P. 3881 - 3881
Published: July 17, 2019
Transformations
towards
sustainability
are
needed
to
address
many
of
the
earth's
profound
environmental
and
social
challenges.
Yet,
actions
taken
deliberately
shift
social–ecological
systems
more
sustainable
trajectories
can
have
substantial
impacts
exclude
people
from
decision-making
processes.
The
concept
just
transformations
makes
explicit
a
need
consider
justice
in
process
shifting
sustainability.
In
this
paper,
we
draw
on
transformations,
transitions,
literature
advance
pragmatic
framing
that
includes
recognitional,
procedural
distributional
considerations.
Decision-making
processes
guide
these
three
factors
before,
during
after
transformation
period.
We
offer
practical
methodological
guidance
help
navigate
management
policies
practice.
put
forward
here
might
be
used
inform
decision
making
numerous
marine
terrestrial
ecosystems,
rural
urban
environments,
at
various
scales
local
global.
argue
cannot
considered
success
unless
is
central
concern.
The Lancet,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
386(10007), P. 1973 - 2028
Published: July 16, 2015
Far-reaching
changes
to
the
structure
and
function
of
Earth's
natural
systems
represent
a
growing
threat
human
health.
And
yet,
global
health
has
mainly
improved
as
these
have
gathered
pace.
What
is
explanation?
As
Commission,
we
are
deeply
concerned
that
explanation
straightforward
sobering:
been
mortgaging
future
generations
realise
economic
development
gains
in
present.
By
unsustainably
exploiting
nature's
resources,
civilisation
flourished
but
now
risks
substantial
effects
from
degradation
life
support
future.
Health
environment
including
climatic
change,
ocean
acidification,
land
degradation,
water
scarcity,
overexploitation
fisheries,
biodiversity
loss
pose
serious
challenges
past
several
decades
likely
become
increasingly
dominant
during
second
half
this
century
beyond.
These
striking
trends
driven
by
highly
inequitable,
inefficient,
unsustainable
patterns
resource
consumption
technological
development,
together
with
population
growth.
We
identify
three
categories
be
addressed
maintain
enhance
face
harmful
environmental
trends.
Firstly,
conceptual
empathy
failures
(imagination
challenges),
such
an
over-reliance
on
gross
domestic
product
measure
progress,
failure
account
for
harms
over
present
day
gains,
disproportionate
effect
those
poor
developing
nations.
Secondly,
knowledge
(research
information
address
social
drivers
ill
health,
historical
scarcity
transdisciplinary
research
funding,
unwillingness
or
inability
deal
uncertainty
within
decision
making
frameworks.
Thirdly,
implementation
(governance
how
governments
institutions
delay
recognition
responses
threats,
especially
when
faced
uncertainties,
pooled
common
time
lags
between
action
effect.
Although
better
evidence
needed
underpin
appropriate
policies
than
available
at
present,
should
not
used
excuse
inaction.
Substantial
potential
exists
link
reduce
damage
outcomes
nations
all
levels
development.
This
Commission
identifies
opportunities
six
key
constituencies:
professionals,
funders
academic
community,
UN
Bretton
Woods
bodies,
governments,
investors
corporate
reporting
civil
society
organisations.
Depreciation
capital
subsidy
accounted
so
economy
nature
falsely
separated.
Policies
balance
sustainability,
economy.
To
world
9–10
billion
people
more,
resilient
food
agricultural
both
undernutrition
overnutrition,
waste,
diversify
diets,
minimise
damage.
Meeting
need
modern
family
planning
can
improve
short
term—eg,
reduced
maternal
mortality
pressures
infrastructure.
Planetary
offers
unprecedented
opportunity
advocacy
national
reforms
taxes
subsidies
many
sectors
economy,
energy,
agriculture,
water,
Regional
trade
treaties
act
further
incorporate
protection
near
long
term.
Several
essential
steps
taken
transform
planetary
include
reduction
waste
through
creation
products
more
durable
require
less
energy
materials
manufacture
often
produced
present;
incentivisation
recycling,
reuse,
repair;
substitution
hazardous
safer
alternatives.
Key
messages1The
concept
based
understanding
depend
flourishing
wise
stewardship
systems.
However,
being
degraded
extent
history.2Environmental
threats
will
characterised
surprise
uncertainty.
Our
societies
clear
potent
dangers
urgent
transformative
actions
protect
generations.3The
governance
organisation
inadequate
call
aid
integration
social,
economic,
creation,
synthesis,
application
interdisciplinary
strengthen
health.4Solutions
lie
reach
redefinition
prosperity
focus
enhancement
quality
delivery
all,
respect
integrity
endeavour
necessitate
change
promoting
sustainable
equitable
consumption,
reducing
growth,
harnessing
power
technology
change.
1The
Despite
limitations,
Sustainable
Development
Goals
provide
great
integrate
sustainability
judicious
selection
relevant
indicators
wellbeing,
enabling
infrastructure
supporting
systems,
strong
governance.
The
landscape,
ecosystems,
they
contain
managed
indirectly,
disease
risk.
Intact
restored
ecosystems
contribute
resilience
(see
panel
1
glossary
terms
report),
example,
coastal
(eg,
wave
attenuation)
ability
floodplains
greening
river
catchments
flooding
events
diverting
holding
excess
water.Panel
1GlossaryHolocene1International
StratigraphyInternational
stratigraphic
chart.http://www.stratigraphy.org/ICSchart/ChronostratChart2013-01.pdfDate:
2013Google
ScholarA
geological
epoch
began
about
11
700
years
ago
encompasses
most
period
which
humanity
grown
developed,
its
written
history
major
civilisations.Anthropocene2Crutzen
PJ
Geology
mankind.Nature.
2002;
415:
23Crossref
PubMed
Scopus
(1931)
Google
ScholarThe
proposed
name
new
demarcated
activities
Anthropocene
yet
formally
recognised
dates
put
forward
mark
beginning.Ecosystem3Millennium
Ecosystem
AssessmentEcosystems
wellbeing:
synthesis.in:
Corvalan
C
Hales
S
McMichael
AJ
Island
Press,
Washington
DC2005Google
dynamic
complex
plant,
animal,
microorganism
communities
non-living
acting
functional
unit.Ecosystem
services4UKNEAThe
UK
National
Assessment:
technical
report.
United
Nations
Environment
Programme's
World
Conservation
Monitoring
Centre,
Cambridge,
UK2011Google
benefits
provided
possible
worth
living.
Examples
ecosystem
services
clean
regulation
floods,
soil
erosion,
outbreaks,
non-material
recreational
spiritual
areas.
term
usually
encompass
tangible
intangible
beings
obtain
sometimes
separated
into
goods
services.Biodiversity5Millennium
AssessmentBiodiversity.in:
Mace
G
Masundire
H
Baillie
J
Millennium
assessment:
current
state
trends:
findings
condition
working
group
well-being.
Washington,
ScholarAn
abbreviation
biological
diversity;
means
variability
among
living
organisms
sources,
inter
alia,
terrestrial,
marine,
other
aquatic
ecological
complexes
part.
includes
diversity
species,
ecosystems.Wetland6RamsarConvention
wetlands
international
importance
waterfowl
habitat
1971.
Iran,
Feb
2,
amended
protocol
Dec
3,
1982,
amendments
May
28,
1987.http://portal.unesco.org/en/ev.php-URL_ID=15398&URL_DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.htmlGoogle
Ramsar
Convention
defines
“areas
marsh,
fen,
peatland
whether
artificial,
permanent
temporary,
static
flowing,
fresh,
brackish
salt,
areas
marine
depth
low
tide
does
exceed
metres”.Representative
Concentration
Pathway
(RCP)7IPCCClimate
2013.
Physical
Science
Basis
Working
Group
I
contribution
fifth
assessment
report
Intergovernmental
Panel
Climate
Change.
Cambridge
University
Change,
New
York,
USA2013Google
ScholarRCPs
trajectories
concentrations
greenhouse
gases
atmosphere
consistent
range
emissions.
For
Fifth
Assessment
Report
scientific
community
defined
set
four
RCPs.
They
identified
their
approximate
total
radiative
forcing
(ie,
warming
effect)
year
2100
relative
1750.
RCP
8·5
pathway
very
high
gas
emissions,
emissions
line
trends.Social–ecological
systems8Stockholm
Resilience
CentreResilience
dictionary.http://www.stockholmresilience.org/21/research/what-is-resilience/resilience-dictionary.htmlDate:
2015Google
ScholarNatural
do
exist
without
cannot
totally
isolation
nature.
truly
interconnected
coevolve
across
spatial
temporal
scales.REDD+9UN-REDD
ProgrammeAbout
REDD+.http://www.un-redd.org/aboutreddDate:
ScholarReducing
Emissions
Deforestation
Forest
Degradation
(REDD)
tries
assign
financial
value
carbon
stored
trees
help
countries
invest
low-carbon
paths
REDD+
added
conservation,
management
forests,
forest
stocks.Externalities10Buchanan
JM
Stubblebine
WC
Externality.Economica.
1962;
29:
371-384Crossref
benefit
cost
affects
individual
who
did
choose
incur
cost.Circular
economy11European
CommissionTowards
circular
economy:
zero
programme
Europe.http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:52014DC0398Date:
2014Google
model
decouples
growth
finite
resources.
Circular
keep
use
possible,
allow
recycling
end
products,
eliminate
waste.State
shift12Rocha
JC
Biggs
R
Peterson
GD
Regime
shifts:
what
why
matter?.http://www.regimeshifts.org/datasets-resources/Date:
ScholarLarge,
lasting
social–ecological
impacts
systems.Resilience8Stockholm
Scholar,
13Rodin
dividend:
where
things
go
wrong.
PublicAffairs,
York2014Google
Scholar“the
capacity
any
entity—an
individual,
organization,
system—to
prepare
disruptions,
recover
shocks
stresses,
adapt
grow
disruptive
experience.”
Holocene1International
Scholar
A
civilisations.
Anthropocene2Crutzen
beginning.
Ecosystem3Millennium
unit.
services.
Biodiversity5Millennium
An
ecosystems.
Wetland6RamsarConvention
metres”.
Representative
RCPs
Social–ecological
Natural
scales.
REDD+9UN-REDD
Reducing
stocks.
Externalities10Buchanan
cost.
waste.
State
Large,
Resilience8Stockholm
“the
urban
populations
emphasises
environment,
air
pollution,
increased
physical
activity,
provision
green
space,
prevent
sprawl
decrease
magnitude
heat
islands.
Transdisciplinary
expansion.
Present
limitations
action.
In
situations
deliver
win–win
solutions
co-benefits,
rapid
scale-up
achieved
if
researchers
move
ahead
assess
solutions.
Recent
investments
towards
non-linear
shifts
important,
absence
predictability
changes,
efforts
adaptation
strategies
remain
priority.
integrated
surveillance
collect
rigorous
socioeconomic,
data
periods
early
detection
emerging
outbreaks
nutrition
non-communicable
burden.
improvement
risk
communication
policy
makers
public
make
evidence-informed
decisions
helped
systematic
reviews
briefs.
professionals
role
achievement
health:
advance
tackling
inequities,
increasing
Humanity
stewarded
successfully
21st
addressing
unacceptable
inequities
wealth
limits
Earth,
generation
knowledge,
policies,
decisive
action,
inspirational
leadership.
metrics,
today
history.
Life
expectancy
soared
47
1950–1955,
69
2005–2010.
Death
rates
children
younger
5
age
worldwide
decreased
substantially
214
per
thousand
live
births
1950–1955
59
2005–2010.14You
D
Hug
L
Chen
Y
Wardlaw
T
Newby
Levels
child
mortality.
Inter-agency
Child
Mortality
Estimation,
15Population
Division
Department
Economic
Social
Affairs
SecretariatWorld
prospects:
2012
revision.
Nations,
York2013Crossref
Human
supremely
successful,
staging
“great
escape”
extreme
deprivation
250
years.16Deaton
escape:
wealth,
origins
inequality.
Princeton
Princeton2013Google
number
poverty
fallen
0·7
30
years,
despite
increase
2
billion.17Olinto
P
Beegle
K
Sobrado
Uematsu
poor:
poor,
harder
end,
profile
world's
poor?
Bank,
DC2013Google
escape
accompanied
unparalleled
advances
care,
education,
rights
legislation,
brought
benefits,
albeit
inequitably,
humanity.
Humanity's
progress
supported
biophysical
atmosphere,
oceans,
important
wetlands,
tundra
constant
climate,
air,
recycle
nutrients
nitrogen
phosphorus,
regulate
cycle,
giving
freshwater
drinking
sanitation.3Millennium
land,
seas,
rivers,
plants
animals
contain,
also
direct
benefits—chiefly
food,
fuel,
timber,
medicinal
compounds
(figure
1).
Alongside
agriculture
industry
success,
Earth
sustenance,
shelter,
energy—underpinning
expansion
civilisation.18Sukhdev
Wittmer
Schröter-Schlaack
et
al.Mainstreaming
economics
nature:
synthesis
approach,
conclusions
recommendations
TEEB.
Economics
Ecosystems
Biodiversity,
Geneva2010Google
achieve
nutrition,
7
required
affecting
vital
ways
relied
throughout
history.19DeFries
Foley
JA
Asner
GP
Land-use
choices:
balancing
needs
function.Front
Ecol
Environ.
2004;
2:
249-257Crossref
essence,
traded
off
supportive
regulating
processes
feed
fuel
development.20Bennett
EM
Gordon
LJ
Understanding
relationships
multiple
services.Ecol
Lett.
2009;
12:
1394-1404Crossref
(1166)
scale
alteration
difficult
overstate
2).
converted
third
ice-free
desert-free
surface
planet
cropland
pasture25Foley
Monfreda
Ramankutty
N
Zaks
share
pie.Proc
Natl
Acad
Sci
USA.
2007;
104:
12585-12586Crossref
(75)
annually
roughly
accessible
appropriated
use.22Steffen
W
Broadgate
Deutsch
Gaffney
O
Ludwig
trajectory
Anthropocene:
acceleration.The
Review.
2015;
81-98Crossref
Since
2000,
cut
down
2·3
million
km2
primary
forest.26Hansen
MC
Potapov
PV
Moore
al.High-resolution
maps
21st-century
cover
change.Science.
2013;
342:
850-853Crossref
(4290)
About
90%
monitored
fisheries
harvested
at,
beyond,
maximum
yield
limits.27FAOThe
aquaculture—opportunities
challenges.
Food
Agriculture
Organization,
Rome2014Google
quest
control
dammed
60%
rivers,28World
DamsDams
development:
framework
decision-making.http://www.unep.org/dams/WCD/report/WCD_DAMS%20report.pdfDate:
November,
2000Google
0·5
km
river.29Lehner
B
Liermann
CR
Revenga
mapping
reservoirs
dams
river-flow
management.Front
2011;
9:
494-502Crossref
(0)
driving
species
extinction
rate
100
times
observed
fossil
record30Pimm
SL
Jenkins
CN
Abell
al.The
extinction,
distribution,
protection.Science.
2014;
344:
1246752Crossref
(1212)
remaining
decreasing
number.
2014
Living
Planet
Report24WWFLiving
2014:
spaces,
places.
Wide
Fund
Nature,
Gland,
Switzerland2014Google
estimates
vertebrate
have,
average,
had
sizes
45
years.
gases—carbon
dioxide,
methane,
nitrous
oxide—are
highest
least
800
000
years.7IPCCClimate
consequence
actions,
determinant
conditions,
rise
epoch,
(panel
1).2Crutzen
2005,
landmark
study
(MEA)
estimated
examined,
purification
2).3Millennium
authors
MEA
warned
planet's
sustain
no
longer
granted”.31Millennium
AssessmentLiving
beyond
our
means.
assets
Statement
Board.in:
Board
Assessment,
2006,
published
WHO
quarter
burden
was
attributable
modifiable
factors.32Prüss-Üstün
Corvalán
Preventing
healthy
environments.
Towards
estimate
disease.
Ecosystem Services,
Journal Year:
2015,
Volume and Issue:
12, P. 1 - 15
Published: Jan. 7, 2015
We
are
at
a
key
juncture
in
history
where
biodiversity
loss
is
occurring
daily
and
accelerating
the
face
of
population
growth,
climate
change,
rampant
development.
Simultaneously,
we
just
beginning
to
appreciate
wealth
human
health
benefits
that
stem
from
experiencing
nature
biodiversity.
Here
assessed
state
knowledge
on
relationships
between
biodiversity,
prepared
comprehensive
listing
reported
effects.
found
strong
evidence
linking
with
production
ecosystem
services
exposure
health,
but
many
these
studies
were
limited
rigor
often
only
correlative.
Much
less
information
available
link
health.
However,
some
robust
indicate
microbial
can
improve
specifically
reducing
certain
allergic
respiratory
diseases.
Overall,
much
more
research
needed
mechanisms
causation.
Also
re-envisioning
land-use
planning
places
well-being
center
new
coalition
ecologists,
social
scientists
planners
conduct
develop
policies
promote
interaction
Improvements
areas
should
enhance
ecosystem,
community,
as
well
resilience.
Ecology and Society,
Journal Year:
2012,
Volume and Issue:
17(4)
Published: Jan. 1, 2012
Kremen,
C.,
and
A.
Miles.
2012.
Ecosystem
services
in
biologically
diversified
versus
conventional
farming
systems:
benefits,
externalities,
trade-offs
Ecology
Society
17(4):
40.
https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-05035-170440
Ecology and Society,
Journal Year:
2013,
Volume and Issue:
18(3)
Published: Jan. 1, 2013
Milcu,
A.
Ioana,
J.
Hanspach,
D.
Abson,
and
Fischer
2013.
Cultural
ecosystem
services:
a
literature
review
prospects
for
future
research
.
Ecology
Society
18(3):44.
https://doi.org/10.5751/ES-05790-180344
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences,
Journal Year:
2011,
Volume and Issue:
369(1938), P. 1010 - 1035
Published: Jan. 31, 2011
Human
populations
and
their
use
of
land
have
transformed
most
the
terrestrial
biosphere
into
anthropogenic
biomes
(anthromes),
causing
a
variety
novel
ecological
patterns
processes
to
emerge.
To
assess
whether
human
directly
altered
sufficiently
indicate
that
Earth
system
has
entered
new
geological
epoch,
spatially
explicit
global
estimates
were
analysed
across
Holocene
for
potential
induce
irreversible
transformation
biosphere.
alteration
been
significant
more
than
8000
years.
However,
only
in
past
century
majority
intensively
used
anthromes
with
predominantly
processes.
At
present,
even
decline
substantially
or
become
far
efficient,
current
extent,
duration,
type
intensity
ecosystems
already
irreversibly
at
levels
sufficient
leave
an
unambiguous
record
differing
from
any
prior
epoch.
It
remains
be
seen
will
sustained
continue
evolve.
Proceedings of the Royal Society B Biological Sciences,
Journal Year:
2014,
Volume and Issue:
282(1799), P. 20141396 - 20141396
Published: Dec. 15, 2014
Agriculture
today
places
great
strains
on
biodiversity,
soils,
water
and
the
atmosphere,
these
will
be
exacerbated
if
current
trends
in
population
growth,
meat
energy
consumption,
food
waste
continue.
Thus,
farming
systems
that
are
both
highly
productive
minimize
environmental
harms
critically
needed.
How
organic
agriculture
may
contribute
to
world
production
has
been
subject
vigorous
debate
over
past
decade.
Here,
we
revisit
this
topic
comparing
conventional
yields
with
a
new
meta-dataset
three
times
larger
than
previously
used
(115
studies
containing
more
1000
observations)
hierarchical
analytical
framework
can
better
account
for
heterogeneity
structure
data.
We
find
only
19.2%
(±3.7%)
lower
yields,
smaller
yield
gap
previous
estimates.
More
importantly,
entirely
different
effects
of
crop
types
management
practices
compared
studies.
For
example,
found
no
significant
differences
leguminous
versus
non-leguminous
crops,
perennials
annuals
or
developed
developing
countries.
Instead,
novel
result
two
agricultural
diversification
practices,
multi-cropping
rotations,
substantially
reduce
(to
9
±
4%
8
5%,
respectively)
when
methods
were
applied
systems.
These
promising
results,
based
robust
analysis
meta-dataset,
suggest
appropriate
investment
agroecological
research
improve
could
greatly
eliminate
some
crops
regions.