Defining the value proposition in diagnostic technology: challenges and opportunities for its understanding and development – a review with a multiperspective reflective analysis
Tayana Soukup,
No information about this author
Bernarda Zamora,
No information about this author
Shayan Bahadori
No information about this author
et al.
Frontiers in Medicine,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
12
Published: Feb. 20, 2025
The
Value
Proposition
(VP)
in
diagnostic
technology
serves
as
a
"positioning
statement"
outlining
the
unique
benefits,
costs,
and
differentiation
an
innovation
under
development
offers
to
healthcare
organizations
its
ability
effectively
deliver
these
advantages
comparison
current
interventions
market.
Despite
significance
however,
VP
lacks
universally
accepted
definition,
which
is
compounded
by
diversity
of
technologies,
their
applications,
varying
needs
stakeholders.
This
paper
aims
address
this
gap
offering
detailed
conceptual
analysis,
revised
definition
VP,
actionable
recommendations
for
advancing
development.
We
conducted
targeted
narrative
review,
focusing
on
literature
explicitly
defining
VPs
technologies.
Using
Ovid's
Medline
Embase
databases,
we
identified
19
relevant
papers,
only
5
provided
explicit
definitions.
Our
analysis
incorporated
principles
team
science,
encompassing
reflective
thematic
analyses
(1)
interdisciplinary
co-author
discussions
enabling
us
weave
together
diverse
insights
into
cohesive
exploration
topic,
(2)
MTech's
publicly
available
set
anonymised
responses
from
NHS
Associates,
capture
perspectives
decision-makers
further
enhance
depth
breadth
our
discourse.
findings
highlight
multifaceted
nature
primary
hurdles:
inadequate
identification
unmet
insufficient
recognition
key
synthesized
evolution
definitions
explored
importance
development,
guided
frameworks,
such
Health
Technology
Navigation
Pathway
Tool,
ensure
meet
both
pragmatic
aspirational
goals
healthcare.
Thematic
revealed
opportunities
addressing
barriers
through
implementation
science
collaborative
strategies.
multi-perspective
approach
examination
integration
varied
viewpoints
insights.
By
employing
introduced
guide
diagnostics.
These
stakeholder
diversity,
needs,
intricacies
blending
advance
field.
Language: Английский
Barriers and facilitators of conducting research with team science approach: a systematic review
BMC Medical Education,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
23(1)
Published: Sept. 5, 2023
Abstract
Background
The
present
review
aimed
to
systematically
identify
and
classify
barriers
facilitators
of
conducting
research
with
a
team
science
approach.
Methods
PubMed,
EMBASE,
PsycINFO,
Scopus,
Web
Science,
Emerald,
ProQuest
databases
were
searched
for
primary
studies
conducted
using
quantitative,
qualitative,
or
mixed
methods.
Studies
examining
approach
included
in
search.
Two
independent
reviewers
screened
the
texts,
extracted
coded
data.
Quality
assessment
was
performed
all
35
articles.
identified
categorized
within
Human,
Organization,
Technology
model.
Results
A
total
from
9,381
articles
met
inclusion
criteria,
which
42
148
identified.
Human
characteristics
researchers,
teaming
skills,
time.
We
consider
across
nine
sub-themes
as
follows:
roles,
goals,
communication,
trust,
conflict,
disciplinary
distances,
academic
rank,
collaboration
experience.
related
organization
institutional
policies,
integration,
funding.
Organizational
skills
training,
evaluation.
Facilitators
field
technology
virtual
readiness
data
management,
complexity
techniques
privacy
issues.
Conclusions
major
findings
have
important
connotations
ongoing
future
implementation
this
intervention
strategy
research.
analysis
provides
evidence
inform
policy-makers,
funding
providers,
students
on
existing
Trial
registration
This
prospectively
registered
PROSPERO
database
(PROSPERO
2021
CRD42021278704).
Language: Английский
Artificial Intelligence and Behavioral Economics: A Bibliographic Analysis of Research Field
IEEE Access,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
11, P. 139367 - 139394
Published: Jan. 1, 2023
Behavioral
economics
and
artificial
intelligence
(AI)
have
been
two
rapidly
growing
fields
of
research
over
the
past
few
years.
While
behavioral
aims
to
combine
concepts
from
psychology,
sociology,
neuroscience
with
classical
economic
thoughts
understand
human
decision-making
processes
in
complex
environment,
AI
on
other
hand,
focuses
creating
intelligent
machines
that
can
mimic
cognitive
abilities
such
as
learning,
problem-solving,
decision-making,
language
understanding.
The
intersection
these
has
led
thrilling
theories
practical
applications.
This
study
provides
a
bibliometric
analysis
literature
gain
insight
into
trends
this
field.
We
conducted
using
Web
Science
database
articles
published
between
2012
2022
were
related
economics.
VOSviewer
Bibliometrix
R
package
utilized
identify
influential
authors,
journals,
institutions,
countries
Network
was
also
performed
main
themes
their
interrelationships.
revealed
number
publications
increasing
steadily
decade.
found
most
studies
focused
customer
consumer
behavior,
including
topics
under
uncertainty,
neuroeconomics,
game
theory,
combined
mainly
machine
learning
deep
techniques.
identified
several
emerging
themes,
use
nudging
prospect
theory
finance,
well
undeveloped
AI-driven
macroeconomics.
findings
suggests
there
is
need
for
more
interdisciplinary
collaboration
researchers
AI.
suggest
future
further
consider
ethical
implications
insights
decision-making.
serve
valuable
resource
interested
Language: Английский
From Intent to Impact: Enabling Transdisciplinary Research for Responsible Scientific Stewardship
Journal of Science Policy & Governance,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
23(02)
Published: Feb. 21, 2024
Global
challenges
are
complex
and
must
be
tackled
in
a
holistic
manner.
Understanding
addressing
them
requires
collaboration
across
disciplines,
often
uniting
the
humanities
social
natural
sciences,
to
ask
better
questions
identify
practical
revolutionary
solutions.
Universities
can
excellent
vehicles
for
transformational
change
as
they
educate
next
generation
of
civically-motivated
thinkers
create
meaningful
action
impact.
Too
systemic,
artificial
barriers
exist
within
these
institutions
that
prevent
transdisciplinary
from
succeeding.
We
recommend
universities
grand
foster
culture
cross-department
with
appropriate
internal
external
resources
enable
broader
impacts.
Together,
funders
institutional
policymakers
play
critical
strategic
role
fostering
civic
scientists
researchers
solve
multifaceted
global
problems.
Language: Английский
The Dawn of Advanced Collaborative Practices
Eva Lorraine Gaudio
No information about this author
Published: May 1, 2024
The
likelihood
of
academic
collaboration
is
influenced
by
specific
characteristics
that
vary
across
attributes
and
associations.
For
instance,
social
networks
have
been
found
to
influence
the
adoption
evidence-based
instructional
practices
interdisciplinary
research
performance.
This
study
examines
at
a
university
support
initiatives
in
increasing
collaboration.
Purpose:
has
three
aims:
1)
characterize
existing
collaborative
under
systems
policies
effect
start
this
project
sample
faculty
researchers;
2)
gain
better
understanding
historical
network
structure
using
grant
proposal
data;
3)
understand
recently-established,
thematically-focused
teams
university-sponsored
address
Grand
Challenges
(GCs)
—
wicked
problems
as
they
manifest
regionally
Idaho.
Thus,
thesis
provides
two
baselines
for
assessing
future
practices:
overall
effectiveness
team
strategies.
Hypothesis:
Diverse
lead
more
innovative
thinking,
greater
productivity,
value
research.
Networks
exhibit
parochialism
inequality
are
less
productive
tend
benefit
those
already
successful.
with
limited
brokerage
disciplinary
connections.
Methods:
I
conducted
semi-structured
interviews
n
=
5
utilized
focus
group
data
on
Social
analysis
methods
analyze
proposals
Boise
State
from
2016
2020,
including
whole
statistics
predictive
modeling
exponential
random
graph
(ERGM)
assess
predictors
tie
formation.
Survey
responses
researchers
GCs
outline
interactions
experience
diversity
before
infusion
treatments.
Statistical
Analysis:
ERGM
results
indicate
uniform
homophily
(intra-college
co-proposing)
selective
mixing
(connection
patterns
based
volume)
also
significantly
predict
Results:
Thematic
reveals
shaped
culture,
institutional
structures,
interpersonal
dynamics,
influencing
its
perception
practice
affecting
balance
between
individual
efforts.
Analysis
uncovers
disparities
opportunities.
Furthermore,
network's
year-over-year
analysis,
particularly
spotlighted
pandemic's
disproportionate
impact
efforts,
highest
levels
connectivity
cumulative
advantage
observed
alongside
lowest
number
collaborators
proposals.
Selective
exposed
clear
preferential
attachment
pattern
intensified
increased
their
activity.
distribution
high
betweenness
centrality
(brokers)
select
few
occupy
significant
broker
roles,
potentially
facilitating
collaborations
within
network.
A
comprehensive
strategy
details
treatment
evaluation
strategies
foster
exemplary
while
expanding
campus-wide
Discussion:
highlighted
opportunities
State's
network,
emphasizing
emergence
scientific
stars
due
advantage.
imbalance
suggests
need
strategic
interventions
equitable
There
noted
tendency
among
collaborate
disciplines,
indicating
potential
obstacles
proposes
measuring
treatments
evaluate
enhance
success
efforts
increase
advocates
metric
selecting
members
include
not
currently
serving
brokers.
approach
aims
expand
capacity
diverse
connections
communities.
Empirical
evidence
supports
interconnections
communities
will
elevate
collaborations.
underscores
well-connected
create
self-sustaining
environment
partnerships,
reducing
additional
interventions.
Language: Английский