Energy Research & Social Science,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
90, P. 102594 - 102594
Published: March 30, 2022
Large-scale
and
highly
experimental
interventions
are
being
considered
as
strategies
to
address
climate
change.
These
include
carbon
dioxide
removal
approaches
that
becoming
a
key
pillar
of
post-Paris
assessment
governance,
well
the
more
controversial
suite
solar
geoengineering
methods.
In
this
paper,
we
ask:
Who
defends
opposes
these
experiments,
why?
After
screening
44
early-stage
conduct
qualitative
comparative
analysis
21
them
in
five
areas:
ocean
fertilization,
marine
cloud
brightening,
stratospheric
aerosol
injection,
ice
protection,
enhanced
weathering.
We
develop
common
framework
analysis,
treating
experiments
sites
which
risks
appropriate
governance
science
technology
envisioned
disputed
among
scientists
other
social
groups.
Our
contribution
is
map
explain
issues
contention
(why),
actors
(who),
tactics
(how)
have
shaped
opposition
across
linked
fields
experimentation
technological
development,
from
1990s
till
today.
doing
so,
build
upon
connect
past
studies
on
particular
insights
relevant
outlooks
perceptions,
discourses,
intents
surrounding
immature
but
potentially
crucial
technologies.
Environmental Chemistry Letters,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
18(6), P. 2069 - 2094
Published: July 30, 2020
Abstract
Climate
change
is
defined
as
the
shift
in
climate
patterns
mainly
caused
by
greenhouse
gas
emissions
from
natural
systems
and
human
activities.
So
far,
anthropogenic
activities
have
about
1.0
°C
of
global
warming
above
pre-industrial
level
this
likely
to
reach
1.5
between
2030
2052
if
current
emission
rates
persist.
In
2018,
world
encountered
315
cases
disasters
which
are
related
climate.
Approximately
68.5
million
people
were
affected,
economic
losses
amounted
$131.7
billion,
storms,
floods,
wildfires
droughts
accounted
for
approximately
93%.
Economic
attributed
2018
alone
almost
equal
collective
incurred
over
past
decade,
quite
alarming.
Furthermore,
food,
water,
health,
ecosystem,
habitat
infrastructure
been
identified
most
vulnerable
sectors
under
attack.
2015,
Paris
agreement
was
introduced
with
main
objective
limiting
temperature
increase
2
2100
pursuing
efforts
limit
°C.
This
article
reviews
strategies
abatement,
namely
conventional
mitigation,
negative
radiative
forcing
geoengineering.
Conventional
mitigation
technologies
focus
on
reducing
fossil-based
CO
emissions.
Negative
aiming
capture
sequester
atmospheric
carbon
reduce
dioxide
levels.
Finally,
geoengineering
techniques
alter
earth’s
energy
budget
stabilize
or
temperatures.
It
evident
that
not
sufficient
meet
targets
stipulated
agreement;
therefore,
utilization
alternative
routes
appears
inevitable.
While
various
presented
may
still
be
at
an
early
stage
development,
biogenic-based
sequestration
a
certain
extent
mature
can
deployed
immediately.
Energy & Environmental Science,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
14(4), P. 1701 - 1721
Published: Jan. 1, 2021
This
review
provides
a
perspective
on
how
to
conduct
future
Life
Cycle
Assessment
(LCA)
studies
of
carbon
dioxide
removal
technologies
in
consistent
way
avoiding
common
mistakes,
which
should
be
addressed
aid
informed
decision
making.
Environmental Research Letters,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
16(10), P. 104003 - 104003
Published: June 16, 2021
Abstract
Ocean-based
carbon
dioxide
(CO
2
)
removal
(CDR)
strategies
are
an
important
part
of
the
portfolio
approaches
needed
to
achieve
negative
greenhouse
gas
emissions.
Many
ocean-based
CDR
rely
on
injecting
CO
or
organic
(that
will
eventually
become
into
ocean
interior,
enhancing
ocean’s
biological
pump.
These
not
result
in
permanent
sequestration,
because
currents
return
injected
back
surface,
where
it
be
brought
equilibrium
with
atmosphere.
Here,
a
model
steady
state
global
circulation
and
mixing
is
used
assess
time
scales
over
which
interior
remains
sequestered
from
There
distribution
sequestration
times
for
any
single
discharge
location
due
infinite
number
pathways
connecting
at
depth
sea
surface.
The
resulting
probability
highly
skewed
long
tail
very
transit
times,
making
mean
much
longer
than
typical
scales.
Deeper
locations
sequester
purposefully
shallower
ones
median
typically
decades
centuries,
approach
1000
years
deep
North
Pacific.
Large
differences
occur
both
within
between
major
basins,
Pacific
Indian
basins
generally
having
Atlantic
Southern
Oceans.
Assessments
made
50
year
horizon
illustrates
that
most
retained
injection
depths
greater
m,
several
geographic
exceptions
such
as
Western
Atlantic.
Ocean
increase
upper
ecosystem
productivity
goal
exporting
more
have
mainly
short-term
influence
atmospheric
levels
∼70%
transported
surface
years.
results
presented
here
help
plan
appropriate
can
limit
climate
damage
caused
by
fossil
fuel
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
19(23), P. 5375 - 5399
Published: Dec. 1, 2022
Abstract.
Ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
is
a
proposed
method
to
counteract
climate
change
by
increasing
the
of
surface
ocean
and
thus
chemical
storage
capacity
seawater
for
atmospheric
CO2.
The
impact
OAE
on
marine
ecosystems,
including
phytoplankton
communities
which
make
up
base
food
web,
largely
unknown.
To
investigate
influence
communities,
we
enclosed
natural
plankton
community
from
coastal
Tasmania
22
d
in
nine
microcosms
during
spring
bloom.
Microcosms
were
split
into
three
groups,
(1)
unperturbed
control,
(2)
unequilibrated
treatment
where
was
increased
(+495
±
5.2
µmol
kg−1)
but
CO2
not
equilibrium
with
CO2,
(3)
equilibrated
(+500
3.2
Both
treatments
have
increase
inorganic
carbon
sink
21
%.
We
found
that
simulated
had
significant
generally
moderate
effects
various
groups
heterotrophic
bacteria.
More
pronounced
observed
diatom
silicic
acid
drawdown
biogenic
silica
build-up
reduced
at
alkalinity.
Observed
changes
affected
temporal
trends
key
biogeochemical
parameters
such
as
organic
matter
carbon-to-nitrogen
ratio.
Interestingly,
did
noticeably
larger
(and
bacteria)
than
treatment,
even
though
carbonate
chemistry
conditions
much
more
severe.
This
particularly
evident
occurrence
peak
bloom
experiment,
different
control.
Altogether,
inadvertent
appear
be
rather
limited
relative
enormous
climatic
benefit
note,
however,
detailed
widespread
investigations
responses
are
required
confirm
or
dismiss
this
first
impression.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
19(15), P. 3537 - 3557
Published: Aug. 1, 2022
Abstract.
Ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
is
a
method
that
can
remove
carbon
dioxide
(CO2)
from
the
atmosphere
and
counteract
ocean
acidification
through
dissolution
of
alkaline
minerals.
Currently,
critical
knowledge
gaps
exist
regarding
different
minerals
suitable
for
OAE
in
natural
seawater.
Of
particular
importance
to
understand
how
much
mineral
be
dissolved
before
secondary
precipitation
calcium
carbonate
(CaCO3)
occurs,
since
CaCO3
reduces
atmospheric
CO2
uptake
potential
OAE.
Using
two
types
proposed
OAE,
quick
lime
(CaO)
hydrated
(Ca(OH)2),
we
show
both
(<63
µm
diameter)
seawater
within
few
hours.
No
occurred
at
saturation
state
(ΩA)
∼5,
but
form
aragonite
above
an
ΩA
value
7.
This
limit
lower
than
expected
typical
pseudo-homogeneous
precipitation,
i.e.
presence
colloids
organic
matter.
Secondary
low
(∼
7)
was
result
heterogeneous
onto
surfaces,
most
likely
added
CaO
Ca(OH)2
particles.
Most
importantly,
runaway
observed,
condition
where
significantly
more
total
(TA)
removed
initially
added.
Such
could
reduce
efficiency
∼
0.8
mol
per
mole
TA
down
0.1
TA.
Runaway
appears
avoidable
by
dilution
below
threshold
5,
ideally
hours
additions
minimise
initial
precipitation.
Finally,
simulations
suggest
same
threshold,
amount
would
3
times
higher
5
∘C
30
∘C.
The
maximum
addition
also
increased
equilibrating
levels
(i.e.
pCO2
416
µatm)
during
addition.
allow
without
inducing
using
its
removal
potential.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
20(4), P. 781 - 802
Published: Feb. 20, 2023
Abstract.
According
to
modelling
studies,
ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
is
one
of
the
proposed
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
approaches
with
large
potential,
beneficial
side
effect
counteracting
acidification.
The
real-world
application
OAE,
however,
remains
unclear
as
most
basic
assumptions
are
untested.
Before
large-scale
deployment
can
be
considered,
safe
and
sustainable
procedures
for
addition
seawater
must
identified
governance
established.
One
concerns
stability
when
added
seawater.
surface
already
supersaturated
respect
calcite
aragonite,
an
increase
in
total
(TA)
together
a
corresponding
shift
carbonate
chemistry
towards
higher
ion
concentrations
would
result
further
supersaturation,
potentially
solid
precipitation.
Precipitation
minerals
consumes
increases
dissolved
CO2
seawater,
thereby
reducing
efficiency
OAE
removal.
In
order
address
alkaline
solution
well
fine
particulate
solids,
set
six
experiments
was
performed
using
natural
around
2400
µmol
kgsw−1.
CO2-equilibrated
bears
lowest
risk
losing
due
phase
formation
if
(ΔTA)
less
than
reactive
solids
cause
net
loss
ΔTA
>
600
kgsw−1
(e.g.
Mg(OH)2).
Commercially
available
(ultrafine)
Ca(OH)2
causes,
general,
TA
tested
amounts
addition,
which
has
consequences
suggested
use
slurries
supplied
from
ships.
rapid
excessive
Ca(OH)2,
exceeding
threshold
loss,
resulted
massive
(>
20
000
kgsw−1)
at
cost
lower
resultant
high
pH
values
9.5.
Analysis
precipitates
indicates
aragonite.
However,
unstable
phases
formed
partially
redissolve,
indicating
that
fraction
may
not
permanent,
important
implications
application.
Our
results
indicate
instead
particles
avoid
formation,
unless
via
solutions
shifts
system
beyond
critical
supersaturation
levels.
To
inorganic
(DIC)
reactor
techniques
considered.
These
produce
equilibrated
prior
Differing
behaviours
materials
suggest
standardized
engineered
need
developed
achieve
reactors
technologies
should
avoided.
Global Biogeochemical Cycles,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
36(5)
Published: May 1, 2022
Abstract
The
work
assesses
the
availability
and
localizations
of
different
raw
materials
suitable
for
ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE),
like
limestone,
olivine,
magnesite
brucite,
since
several
billion
tons
rocky
are
needed
to
achieve
meaningful
results
carbon
sequestration
through
OAE.
Resources
carbonates
immense
widespread
around
all
continents.
Availability
pure
is
still
very
large
(outcrop
area
4.1
million
km
2
)
not
a
constraint
large‐scale
development
Outcrops
within
10
from
coastline
below
bare
ground
or
scrub/shrub,
preferred
logistics
exploitation,
account
about
70,000
,
could
provide
5,000
Gt
limestone.
These
values
increase
by
factor
3
8
50
100
coastline,
respectively.
Potential
resources
less
easily
identifiable
geological
data,
estimated
in
order
few
hundred
only
minor
contribution
ocean‐based
removal
strategies.
A
comparison
with
current
level
world
extraction
mineral
also
provided.
annual
production
be
more
than
6.6
deposits
scattered
world,
9%
(around
44
yr
−1
),
same
magnitude
as
coal
(7.3
).
productions
(29
Mt
olivine
(8.4
brucite
(1.5
two
orders
lower.
Biogeosciences,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
20(1), P. 27 - 43
Published: Jan. 3, 2023
Abstract.
Ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
has
recently
gained
attention
as
a
potential
method
for
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
at
gigatonne
(Gt)
scale,
with
near-coast
OAE
operations
being
economically
favorable
due
to
proximity
mineral
and
energy
sources.
In
this
paper
we
study
critical
questions
which
determine
the
scale
viability
of
OAE.
Which
coastal
locations
are
able
sustain
large
flux
minimal
pH
ΩArag
(aragonite
saturation)
changes?
What
is
interference
distance
between
adjacent
projects?
How
much
CO2
absorbed
per
unit
added?
quickly
does
induced
deficiency
equilibrate
atmosphere?
Choosing
relatively
conservative
constraints
on
ΔpH
or
ΔOmega,
examine
limits
using
ECCO
LLC270
(0.3∘)
global
circulation
model.
We
find
that
sustainable
rate
varies
over
1–2
orders
magnitude
different
coasts
exhibits
complex
patterns
non-local
dependencies
vary
from
region
region.
general,
in
areas
strong
currents
enables
largest
fluxes
depending
direction
these
currents,
neighboring
sites
can
exhibit
far
400
km
more.
At
steady
state
most
regional
stretches
coastline
accommodate
order
10s
100s
megatonnes
negative
emissions
within
300
coast.
conclude
near-coastal
globally
several
Gt
yr−1
drawdown
constraints,
if
effort
spread
majority
available
coastlines.
Depending
location,
diverse
set
equilibration
kinetics,
determined
by
interplay
gas
exchange
surface
residence
time.
Most
reach
an
uptake
efficiency
plateau
0.6–0.8
mol
after
3–4
years,
there
only
slow
additional
uptake.
Regions
significant
downwelling
(e.g.,
around
Iceland)
should
be
avoided
deployments,
such
up
half
CDR
lost
bottom
waters.
The
ideal
locations,
reaching
molar
ratio
0.8,
include
North
Madagascar,
California,
Brazil,
Peru
close
Southern
Tasmania,
Kerguelen
Patagonia,
where
appears
occur
faster
than
However,
some
Hawaii)
take
significantly
longer
(up
8–10
years)
but
still
eventually
achieve
high
ratios.
Environmental Science & Technology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
57(15), P. 6169 - 6178
Published: April 3, 2023
Coastal
enhanced
weathering
(CEW)
is
a
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
approach
whereby
crushed
silicate
minerals
are
spread
in
coastal
zones
to
be
naturally
weathered
by
waves
and
tidal
currents,
releasing
alkalinity
removing
atmospheric
(CO2).
Olivine
has
been
proposed
as
candidate
mineral
due
its
abundance
high
CO2
uptake
potential.
A
life
cycle
assessment
(LCA)
of
silt-sized
(10
μm)
olivine
revealed
that
CEW's
life-cycle
emissions
total
environmental
footprint,
i.e.,
penalty,
amount
around
51
kg
CO2eq
3.2
Ecopoint
(Pt)
units
per
tonne
captured
CO2,
respectively,
these
will
recaptured
within
few
months.
Smaller
particle
sizes
dissolve
even
faster;
however,
their
footprints
(e.g.,
223
10.6
Pt
tCO2–1,
for
1
μm
olivine),
engineering
challenges
comminution
transportation,
possible
stresses
airborne
and/or
silt
pollution)
might
restrict
applicability.
Alternatively,
larger
exhibit
lower
14.2
tCO2–1
1.6
1000
olivine)
could
incorporated
zone
management
schemes,
thus
possibly
crediting
CEW
with
avoided
emissions.
However,
they
much
slower,
requiring
5
37
years
before
the
becomes
net
negative,
respectively.
The
differences
between
penalties
highlight
need
using
multi-issue
impact
methods
rather
than
focusing
on
balances
alone.
When
full
profile
was
considered,
it
identified
fossil
fuel-dependent
electricity
main
hotspot,
followed
nickel
releases,
which
may
have
large
marine
ecotoxicity.
Results
were
also
sensitive
transportation
means
distance.
Renewable
energy
low-nickel
can
minimize
profile.
Science Advances,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
9(24)
Published: June 14, 2023
It
is
increasingly
apparent
that
adequately
mitigating
anthropogenic
climate
interference
will
require
ocean
carbon
dioxide
removal
(CDR)
strategies.
Ocean
alkalinity
enhancement
(OAE)
an
abiotic
CDR
approach
aims
to
increase
the
ocean’s
CO
2
uptake
capacity
through
dispersal
of
pulverized
mineral
or
dissolved
alkali
into
surface
ocean.
However,
OAE’s
effect
on
marine
biota
largely
unexplored.
Here,
we
investigate
impacts
moderate
(~700
μmol
kg
−1
)
and
high
(~2700
limestone-inspired
additions
two
biogeochemically
ecologically
important
phytoplankton
functional
group
representatives:
Emiliania
huxleyi
(calcium
carbonate
producer)
Chaetoceros
sp.
(silica
producer).
The
growth
rate
elemental
ratios
both
taxa
showed
a
neutral
response
alkalinization.
While
our
results
are
encouraging,
also
observed
precipitation,
which
removed
nutrients
from
solution.
Our
findings
offer
evaluation
biogeochemical
physiological
responses
OAE
provide
evidence
supporting
need
for
continued
research
how
strategies
affect
ecosystems.