Fundamental challenges and likely refutations of the five basic premises of the polyvagal theory
Biological Psychology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
180, P. 108589 - 108589
Published: May 1, 2023
The
polyvagal
collection
of
hypotheses
is
based
upon
five
essential
premises,
as
stated
by
its
author
(Porges,
2011).
Polyvagal
conjectures
rest
on
a
primary
assumption
that
brainstem
ventral
and
dorsal
vagal
regions
in
mammals
each
have
their
own
unique
mediating
effects
control
heart
rate.
link
these
putative
dorsal-
vs.
ventral-vagal
differences
to
socioemotional
behavior
(e.g.
defensive
immobilization,
social
affiliative
behaviors,
respectively),
well
trends
the
evolution
vagus
nerve
Porges,
2011
&
2021a).
Additionally,
it
note
only
one
measurable
phenomenon—as
index
processes—serves
linchpin
for
virtually
every
premise.
That
phenomenon
respiratory
sinus
arrhythmia
(RSA),
heart-rate
changes
coordinated
phase
respiration
(i.e.
inspiration
expiration),
often
employed
an
vagally,
or
parasympathetically,
mediated
assume
RSA
mammalian
phenomenon,
since
Porges
(2011)
states
"RSA
has
not
been
observed
reptiles."
I
will
here
briefly
document
how
basic
premises
shown
be
either
untenable
highly
implausible
available
scientific
literature.
also
argue
reliance
equivalent
general
tone
even
cardiac
conceptually
category
mistake
(Ryle,
1949),
confusing
approximate
RSA)
(some
process)
with
itself.
Language: Английский
The neurobiology of vocal communication in marmosets
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
1528(1), P. 13 - 28
Published: Aug. 24, 2023
Abstract
An
increasingly
popular
animal
model
for
studying
the
neural
basis
of
social
behavior,
cognition,
and
communication
is
common
marmoset
(
Callithrix
jacchus
).
Interest
in
this
New
World
primate
across
neuroscience
now
being
driven
by
their
proclivity
prosociality
repertoire,
high
volubility,
rapid
development,
as
well
amenability
to
naturalistic
testing
paradigms
freely
moving
recording
imaging
technologies.
The
complement
these
characteristics
set
marmosets
up
be
a
powerful
brain
years
come.
Here,
we
focus
on
vocal
because
it
area
that
has
both
made
most
progress
illustrates
prodigious
potential
species.
We
review
current
state
field
with
various
areas
networks
involved
perception
production,
comparing
findings
from
other
animals,
including
humans.
Language: Английский
Context-dependent activation of a social behavior brain network during learned vocal production
Katherine L. Anderson,
No information about this author
Lionel Colón,
No information about this author
Violet Doolittle
No information about this author
et al.
Brain Structure and Function,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
228(7), P. 1785 - 1797
Published: Aug. 24, 2023
Language: Английский
Evolution of air‐borne vocalization: Insights from neural studies in the archeobatrachian species Bombina orientalis
The Journal of Comparative Neurology,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
532(3)
Published: March 1, 2024
Abstract
Vocalization
of
tetrapods
evolved
as
an
air‐driven
mechanism.
Thus,
it
is
conceivable
that
the
underlaying
neural
network
might
have
from
more
ancient
respiratory
circuits
and
be
made
up
homologous
components
generate
breathing
rhythms
across
vertebrates.
In
this
context,
extant
species
stem
anurans
provide
opportunity
to
analyze
connection
lung
ventilation
vocalization.
Here,
we
analyzed
fictive
vocalization
behavior
isolated
brains
Chinese
fire‐bellied
toad
Bombina
orientalis
during
their
mating
season
by
nerve
root
recordings.
We
discovered
significant
differences
in
durations
activation
male
after
stimulation
statoacoustic
or
vocalization‐relevant
forebrain
structures
comparison
female
brains.
The
increased
motor
activities
can
interpreted
calling,
male's
advertisement
calls
vivo
had
same
general
pattern
compared
ventilation,
but
longer
duration
periods.
Female
react
corresponding
stimulations
with
shorter
activity
occurred
spontaneously
both
thus
ventilations.
These
results
support
hypothesis
vocal
respiration
networks
anuran
caudal
hindbrain.
Moreover,
could
show
terrestrial
archeobatrachian
spec
.
appropriate
model
study
function
evolution
shared
generation.
Language: Английский
Courtship behavior: Resurrecting an undead song
Current Biology,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
34(13), P. R623 - R625
Published: July 1, 2024
Language: Английский
“Neural correlates of social signaling in rodents: An acoustic perspective”
Current Opinion in Neurobiology,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
89, P. 102927 - 102927
Published: Oct. 18, 2024
Language: Английский
Afferent and Efferent Connections of the Postinspiratory Complex (PiCo) Revealed by AAV and Monosynaptic Rabies Viral Tracing
The Journal of Comparative Neurology,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
532(11)
Published: Nov. 1, 2024
ABSTRACT
The
control
of
the
respiratory
rhythm
and
airway
motor
activity
is
essential
for
life.
Accumulating
evidence
indicates
that
postinspiratory
complex
(PiCo)
crucial
generating
behaviors
occur
during
phase,
including
expiratory
laryngeal
swallowing.
Located
in
ventromedial
medulla,
PiCo
defined
by
neurons
co‐expressing
two
neurotransmitter
markers
(ChAT
Vglut2/Slc17a6).
Here,
we
mapped
input–output
connections
these
using
viral
tracers
intersectional
viral‐genetic
tools.
were
specifically
targeted
focal
injection
a
doubly
conditional
Cre‐
FlpO‐dependent
AAV8
marker
(AAV8‐Con/Fon‐TVA‐mCherry)
into
left
adult
Chat
Cre/wt
:
Vglut2
FlpO/wt
mice,
anterograde
axonal
tracing.
These
experiments
revealed
projections
to
various
brain
regions,
Cu,
nucleus
solitary
tract
(NTS),
Amb,
X,
XII,
Sp5,
RMg,
intermediate
reticular
(IRt),
lateral
(LRt),
pre‐Bötzinger
(preBötC),
contralateral
PiCo,
laterodorsal
tegmental
(LDTg),
pedunculopontine
(PPTg),
periaqueductal
gray
matter
(PAG),
Kölliker–Fuse
(KF),
PB,
external
cortex
inferior
colliculus
(ECIC).
A
rabies
virus
(RV)
retrograde
transsynaptic
approach
was
taken
with
EnvA‐pseudotyped
G‐deleted
(RV‐SAD‐G‐GFP)
similarly
target
following
prior
injections
helper
AAVs
(a
mixture
AAV‐Ef1a‐Con/Fon
oG
vector
AAV8‐Con/Fon‐TVA‐mCherry).
This
combined
prominent
synaptic
inputs
from
NTS,
IRt,
A1/C1.
Although
project
axons
area,
this
did
not
detect
direct
connections.
We
suggest
serves
as
critical
integration
site,
projecting
receiving
neuronal
implicated
breathing,
arousal,
swallowing,
autonomic
regulation.
Language: Английский
Context-dependent activation of a social behavior brain network associates with learned vocal production
Katherine L. Anderson,
No information about this author
Lionel Colón,
No information about this author
Violet Doolittle
No information about this author
et al.
Research Square (Research Square),
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Feb. 17, 2023
In
zebra
finches,
an
avian
brain
network
for
vocal
control
undergoes
context-dependent
patterning
of
song-dependent
activation.
Previous
studies
in
finches
also
implicate
the
importance
dopaminergic
input
producing
context-appropriate
singing
behavior.
mice,
it
has
been
shown
that
oxytocinergic
neurons
originated
paraventricular
nucleus
hypothalamus
(PVN)
synapse
directly
onto
dopamine
ventral
tegmental
area
(VTA),
implicating
necessity
oxytocin
signaling
from
PVN
a
song.
Both
and
non-avian
axonal
tract-tracing
indicate
high
levels
innervation
by
social
behavior
network.
Here,
we
hypothesize
motivation
to
trigger
release
originates
network,
highly
conserved
interconnected
collection
six
regions
implicated
various
homeostatic
behaviors.
We
found
expression
neuronal
activity
marker
EGR1
was
not
strongly
correlated
with
song
production
any
However,
when
were
normalized
rate,
significantly
higher
except
medial
preoptic
during
female-directed
context
compared
non-social
undirected
context.
Our
results
suggest
within
male
finch
influences
synaptic
projection
VTA,
which
turn
signals
allow
production.
Language: Английский
»Polyvagal«: Die schöne Theorie und die hässlichen Fakten
Daniel Walz,
No information about this author
Paul Grossman
No information about this author
Psychotherapie,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
29(2), P. 163 - 174
Published: Oct. 1, 2024
Die
Polyvagal-Theorie
von
Stephen
Porges
postuliert
verschiedene
wissenschaftliche
Disziplinen
wie
Anatomie,
Physiologie,
Psychophysiologie,
Evolutionsund
Entwicklungsbiologie,
Sozialwissenschaften
und
Psychotherapie
zu
integrieren
menschliches
Verhalten,
insbesondere
in
nach
Stresssituationen,
auf
eine
evolutionäre
Besonderheit
des
Nervus
vagus
bei
Säugetieren
zurückführen
können.
Dabei
werden
neuroanatomische
Hypothesen
zum
mit
sozialen
psychologischen
Konzepten
verknüpft.
Vor
allem
unter
Traumatherapeuten
findet
die
Theorie
seit
Jahren
zunehmende
Verbreitung
wird
teilweise
als
bahnbrechend
bezeichnet,
so
auch
der
letzten
Ausgabe
dieser
Zeitschrift
(Ackermann,
2024;
Grassmann,
Rahm
&
Meggyesy,
2024).
v.
a.
Konzepte
rezipiert.
Allerdings
besteht
Experten
weitgehend
Konsens,
dass
grundlegenden
physiologischen
Annahmen
nicht
haltbar
sind
widerlegt
gelten
müssen.
Darüber
hinaus
wichtigsten
–
z.
B.
Bindung,
Ko-Regulation,
soziale
Interaktion
unbewusste
Wahrnehmungsprozesse
schon
Jahrzehnte
älter
polyvagalen
benötigen
für
ihre
Anwendung
Psychologie
oder
keine
Begründungen.
Für
diejenigen,
ein
biologisches
Verständnis
Prozesse
anstreben,
gibt
es
andere
Erklärungsmodelle,
das
gesamte
Nervensystem
einbeziehen
dem
heutigen
wissenschaftlichen
»Embodiment«
besser
entsprechen.
Two conserved vocal central pattern generators broadly tuned for fast and slow rates generate species-specific vocalizations inXenopusclawed frogs
Ayako Yamaguchi,
No information about this author
Manon Peltier
No information about this author
bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Jan. 28, 2023
ABSTRACT
Across
phyla,
species-specific
vocalizations
are
used
by
males
to
attract
females.
Functional
analyses
of
the
neural
circuitry
underlying
behavior
have
been
difficult,
particularly
in
vertebrates.
However,
using
an
ex
vivo
brain
preparation
that
produces
fictive
vocalizations,
we
previously
identified
anatomically
distinct
fast
and
slow
central
pattern
generators
(CPGs)
drive
clicks
male
courtship
calls
African
clawed
frogs,
Xenopus
laevis
.
To
gain
insight
into
evolution
circuits
calls,
extended
this
approach
four
additional
species.
Here,
show
although
exact
rate
duration
unique
each
species,
CPGs
X.
conserved
across
Further,
development
depends
on
testosterone
a
manner:
facilitates
species
with
call
containing
clicks,
but
not
made
entirely
clicks.
Finally,
showed
that,
unlike
other
vestigial
remain
latent,
inherited
all
species;
rather,
they
possessed
only
produce
The
results
suggest
genus
evolved
utilizing
or
broadly
tuned
generate
trains
which
appear
be
regulated
strategic
expression
receptors
Language: Английский