With what precision can the population size of Tyrannosaurus rex be estimated? A reply to Meiri DOI Creative Commons
Charles R. Marshall, Daniel Varajão de Latorre, Connor J. Wilson

et al.

Frontiers of Biogeography, Journal Year: 2021, Volume and Issue: 14(2)

Published: Dec. 17, 2021

Interested in the absolute preservation rate of one best understood dinosaurs, Tyrannosaurus rex, Marshall et al. (2021) estimated total number that ever lived.  This required estimating its geographic range, longevity, and population density, which body mass physiology.  Meiri questions precision our estimates, emphasizing difficulties densities ranges for living species, error propagation.  He posits sizes extinct species is ‘extremely unlikely’.  While we agree did not quantify some sources uncertainty (for example, physiology T. rex), calculations do depend on short-term changes density but rather their long-term averages, rendering many Meiri’s concerns moot.  We also note Monte Carlo Simulation propagates uncertainties robustly.  That is, feel have, fact, developed a general method regardless any shortfalls implementation.

Language: Английский

Population sizes of T. rex cannot be precisely estimated DOI Creative Commons
Shai Meiri

Frontiers of Biogeography, Journal Year: 2021, Volume and Issue: 14(2)

Published: Dec. 17, 2021

Marshall et al. recently estimated population densities, range sizes, instant and cumulative total sizes for Tyrannosaurus rex with narrow ranges of uncertainly. I revisit the assumptions that led them to these conclusions show many parameters are associated much wider margins error than they estimated. Biogeographic estimates seem have been especially unrealistic, seriously hampering effort calculate level parameters. posit biogeographic ecological uncertainties make it extremely unlikely be able estimate long-extinct species.

Language: Английский

Citations

4

Analysis of very small-small theropod footprints data from Imilchil tracksite (Hig Central Atlas. Morocco). A concordance model for a global scale DOI Creative Commons
Judit Mínguez Ceniceros, Moussa Masrour,

Mohamed Boutakiout

et al.

Journal of African Earth Sciences, Journal Year: 2024, Volume and Issue: 219, P. 105389 - 105389

Published: Aug. 23, 2024

Language: Английский

Citations

0

Selection, Evolution and Persistence of Paleoecological Systems DOI Open Access
Peter D. Roopnarine

bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory), Journal Year: 2024, Volume and Issue: unknown

Published: Nov. 15, 2024

1 Abstract The Phanerozoic fossil record can be organized as a nested set of persistent paleoecological units, ranging from paleocommunities to the Evolutionary Faunas. This paper argues that basis for ecological persistence on geological timescales is rooted in robustness communities, is, resistance and resilience communities when perturbed by environment. Here I present Ecological Functional Networks Hypothesis (EFNH) proposes networks species functions, or (EFNs), underlie stasis persistence, EFNs are both subject selection evolve. An EFN varies if composition hence functional structures its constituent vary, may differ each other based those numerical representation, biogeographic distribution. That variation acting community composition, determines an differential among multiple EFNs. Selection pressures turn exert top-down influence evolution extinction. Evidence presented establish reality record, example persist even changes, EFNs, which apparent during after episodes severe biotic turnover such mass extinctions. Finally, tests suggested make EFNH falsifiable, including testing correlation between emergent traits using models paleocommunity dynamics examine relationship persistence. should applied broadly throughout diverse environments. part growing body hypotheses address multilevel non-reproducing systems, ecosystems entire biospheres, addresses concepts timescales.

Language: Английский

Citations

0

Vital statistics, absolute abundance and preservation rate of Tyrannosaurus rex DOI Creative Commons
Eva Maria Griebeler

Palaeontology, Journal Year: 2023, Volume and Issue: 66(2)

Published: March 1, 2023

Abstract I present a simulation model on vital statistics, absolute abundance (N, total number of individuals that ever lived) and preservation rate (p, minimum fossils known divided by N) Tyrannosaurus rex . It is based published age‐structured population assumes reptile or bird‐like reproduction for T. to estimate its age‐specific survival rates. My applies input variables equations from recently N p. This yielded 2.5 billion (N) one fossil per 80 million (p). The average values calculated my were at 27.6% p maximum 361.5% previous uncertainties in all output always larger model. equation variable ‘population density’ introduced the largest uncertainty ‘generation time’ differed most between models, but p, huge size area modelled geological longevity minimized this difference. Unlike model, generation time as well life expectancies, gross rates, reproductive strongly contradicted our current understanding biology other theropods. Their also disagreed with those large extant reptiles, birds mammals. All these shortcomings favour assessment individual characteristics extinct species using

Language: Английский

Citations

1

Philosophical and Scientific Implications of Astrobiology and Palaeontology in the Light of Hypothesising the Existence of Intelligent Pre-human Civilisations on Earth: Empiricist, Rationalist, and Positivist Approaches DOI

Francisco Sánchez-Beristain,

Alejandro Paredes-Arriaga,

María Fernanda Martínez-Velarde

et al.

Paleontología mexicana., Journal Year: 2023, Volume and Issue: 12(1), P. 43 - 52

Published: Jan. 31, 2023

In this paper, the scientific and philosophical implications of theory that suggests existence an intelligent civilisation on Earth prior to mankind is discussed. All available evidence which would constrain such brought into discussion. Therefore, we first review Drake Equation regarding hypothesis. We summarily appraise Shadow Biosphere within scope theory. Subsequently, thoroughly analyse important geochemical sedimentological constraints proposal, mainly in context some Fossillagerstätten. This leads us discuss may have for fields Astrobiology Palaeontology, analysing them under empiricist, rationalist, positivist approaches. contextually examine concepts technological species, intelligence, industrialisation, taking account Furthermore, debate validity hypothesis, considering all it presents analysed concepts. Finally, propose hypothesis epistemological/positivist point view.

Language: Английский

Citations

1

Developmental plasticity in deep time: a window to population ecological inference DOI Creative Commons
Anieke Brombacher, Daniela N. Schmidt, Thomas H. G. Ezard

et al.

Paleobiology, Journal Year: 2022, Volume and Issue: 49(2), P. 259 - 270

Published: Aug. 4, 2022

Abstract Developmental plasticity, where traits change state in response to environmental cues, is well studied modern populations. It also suspected play a role macroevolutionary dynamics, but due lack of long-term records, the frequency plasticity-led evolution deep time remains unknown. Populations are dynamic entities, yet their representation fossil record static snapshot often isolated individuals. Here, we apply for first contemporary integral projection models (IPMs) data link individual development with expected population variation. IPMs describe effects growth discrete steps on dynamics. We parameterize using and planktonic foraminifer Trilobatus sacculifer . Foraminifera grow by adding chambers stages die at reproduction, making them excellent case studies IPMs. Our results predict that somatic rates have almost twice as much influence dynamics than survival more eight times suggesting selection would primarily target major determinant fitness. As numerous paleobiological systems rate increments single genetic individuals imaging technologies increasingly available, our open up possibility evidence-based inference developmental plasticity spanning Given centrality ecology thinking, model one approach help bridge eco-evolutionary scales while directing attention toward most relevant life-history measure.

Language: Английский

Citations

2

Dam Projects: Pro and Contra DOI

Robert Zwahlen

Environmental earth sciences, Journal Year: 2022, Volume and Issue: unknown, P. 457 - 485

Published: Jan. 1, 2022

Language: Английский

Citations

1

Patterns in Body Size DOI
José Alexandre Felizola Diniz‐Filho

Springer eBooks, Journal Year: 2023, Volume and Issue: unknown, P. 293 - 338

Published: Jan. 1, 2023

Language: Английский

Citations

0

How many T. rex ever existed? Calculation of dinosaur’s abundance offers an answer DOI

Freda Kreier

Nature, Journal Year: 2021, Volume and Issue: unknown

Published: April 15, 2021

Language: Английский

Citations

0

With what precision can the population size of Tyrannosaurus rex be estimated? A reply to Meiri DOI Creative Commons
Charles R. Marshall, Daniel Varajão de Latorre, Connor J. Wilson

et al.

Frontiers of Biogeography, Journal Year: 2021, Volume and Issue: 14(2)

Published: Dec. 17, 2021

Interested in the absolute preservation rate of one best understood dinosaurs, Tyrannosaurus rex, Marshall et al. (2021) estimated total number that ever lived.  This required estimating its geographic range, longevity, and population density, which body mass physiology.  Meiri questions precision our estimates, emphasizing difficulties densities ranges for living species, error propagation.  He posits sizes extinct species is ‘extremely unlikely’.  While we agree did not quantify some sources uncertainty (for example, physiology T. rex), calculations do depend on short-term changes density but rather their long-term averages, rendering many Meiri’s concerns moot.  We also note Monte Carlo Simulation propagates uncertainties robustly.  That is, feel have, fact, developed a general method regardless any shortfalls implementation.

Language: Английский

Citations

0