“Let’s transform!”: A systematic literature review of science learning in COVID-19 pandemic era
Eurasia Journal of Mathematics Science and Technology Education,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
19(2), P. em2224 - em2224
Published: Jan. 25, 2023
Currently,
the
world’s
science
learning
is
being
affected
by
COVID-19
pandemic,
which
requires
researchers
to
address
it.
Researchers’
attention
and
concern
for
theme
of
highly
expected,
as
evidenced
existence
publications
in
reputable
journals.
The
purpose
this
systematic
literature
review
compare
investigations
research
on
articles
published
Scopus-indexed
journals
(published
during
pandemic:
2020-2022).
used
a
“science
learning”
phrase
search
menu
Scopus
database
1,484
were
found
researchers.
Furthermore,
62
met
criteria
be
analyzed.
inclusion
exclusion
model
was
preferred
reporting
items
reviews
meta-analysis.
Based
results
analysis,
we
that
last
three
years,
there
had
been
decline
learning.
issues
could
approached
through
quantitative,
qualitative,
mix-method,
case
study,
even
development
research.
Marianne
Kinnula
author
who
has
received
most
study
According
data,
it
known
education
keywords
are
dominant
publication.
There
36
countries
origin
authors
publish
articles,
with
majority
coming
from
Europe,
though
Indonesia
(Asia).
Science
written
all
over
world.
It
discovered
more
result
collaboration.
69
institutions
globally
fund
publications.
We
offer
perspectives
transformation
pandemic
can
baseline
reference
other
or
policymakers.
As
an
implication,
second
third
have
formulated
interesting
further
study.
Language: Английский
The existence of environmental education in the COVID-19 pandemic: A systematic literature review
Eurasia Journal of Mathematics Science and Technology Education,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
19(11), P. em2347 - em2347
Published: Sept. 11, 2023
The
implementation
of
environmental
education
in
the
world
is
affected
by
COVID-19
pandemic,
so
researchers
must
be
responsive,
adjust
and
creative
strategies
to
survive,
think
about
future
anticipations.
focus
concern
towards
theme
highly
expected,
as
evidenced
research
results
published
reputable
journals.
purpose
this
systematic
literature
review
was
compare
investigations
on
articles
Scopus
indexed
We
used
phrase
“environmental
COVID-19”
disbursement
menu
Database
found
1379
articles.
Furthermore,
only
21
met
criteria
analyzed.
inclusion
exclusion
model
PRISMA.
There
has
been
a
trend
increasing
publications
last
four
years.
Environmental
issues
can
approached
through
qualitative,
quantitative,
mix-method,
case
studies,
R&D.
authors
most
spotlight
are
Lowan-Trudeau,
G.
(reference),
Aristovnik,
A.
(bibliographic
coupling),
Mehmood,
R.
(co-citation).
keywords
that
mostly
author
COVID-19,
education,
higher
sustainable
development.
This
keyword
branches
into
climate
change,
development,
adaptation.
22
countries
origin
who
articles,
dominantly
from
United
States
Republic
Korea.
Articles
equally
Europe,
Asia,
America.
It
there
were
more
collaboration
between
universities
within
one
country
countries.
Rarely
written
single
author.
20
institutions
provide
funding
for
publications.
Most
have
fulfilled
ethics
declaring
status.
succeeded
formulating
discussing
description
existence
during
pandemic.
These
findings
serve
consideration
or
baseline
study
themes
according
their
respective
backgrounds
objectives.
Language: Английский
The Usage of Augmented Reality Technology in Mathematics Education: A Systematic Literature Review
Vanessa Ivan,
No information about this author
Siti Mistima Maat
No information about this author
International Journal of Academic Research in Progressive Education and Development,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
13(1)
Published: Jan. 3, 2024
This
systematic
literature
review
aims
to
synthesise
the
trends
in
use
of
Augmented
Reality
(AR)
mathematics
education
from
2019
May
2023.
The
researcher
selected
articles
two
databases,
namely
Scopus
and
Web
Science
(WoS).
From
these
11
relevant
were
using
PRISMA
guide.
findings
this
study
show
an
increasing
trend
research
related
field
since
2019.
Indonesian
researchers
have
made
most
significant
contribution
field,
quantitative
approaches
are
commonly
used.
analysis
also
found
that
AR
technology
is
used
three
mathematical
topics
Geometry,
Algebra,
Statistics
Probability.
In
addition,
examines
impact
perspective
students'
cognitive
affective
development.
Language: Английский
Research trend of Arabic language teaching in the world: Systematic literature review based on Scopus database
Z. Zikriah,
No information about this author
Lailatul Mauludiyah
No information about this author
Research and Development in Education (RaDEn),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
4(1), P. 27 - 48
Published: Feb. 7, 2024
Arabic
is
a
very
important
communication
language
in
the
world,
especially
among
Muslims.
There
has
been
lot
of
research
related
to
teaching,
so
it
necessary
analyze
these
trends.
This
systematic
literature
review
aims
trends
teaching
world
(2008-2023),
that
can
become
reference
for
and
development
current
future
themes.
Article
searches
were
carried
out
Scopus
database.
Data
saved
*CSV
*RIS
formats,
synchronized
with
Mendeley
visualized
VOS-viewer.
We
used
Preferred
Reporting
Items
Systematic
Reviews
Meta-Analysis
(PRISMA)
model
determine
truly
appropriate
articles
(inclusion),
resulting
21
articles.
The
trend
publications
theme
shows
interesting.
discuss
year
trends,
methods
used,
dominant
authors,
most
cited
relationship
between
keywords
(there
are
four
main
keywords).
Discussions
also
held
regarding
author's
country
origin,
collaboration,
number
authors
per
article.
formulated
five
Language
Teacher
Profiles
based
on
study
It
recommended
need
be
promoted
becomes
global
attention
international
collaboration
occurs.
suggest
researchers
focus
more
assessment
evaluation
aspects.
Language: Английский
Flipped classroom strategies in biology learning: A systematic literature review
Muh. Wahyudi Jasman,
No information about this author
S. Sulisetijono,
No information about this author
Susriyati Mahanal
No information about this author
et al.
JPBI (Jurnal Pendidikan Biologi Indonesia),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
10(1), P. 164 - 184
Published: March 28, 2024
Biology
as
an
integral
part
of
science
learning
continues
to
be
maximized
by
integrating
technology
into
its
design.
The
definite
manifestation
this
integration
process
is
achieve
meaningfulness,
activeness,
and
effectiveness
the
carried
out.
flipped
classroom
(FC)
gaining
popularity
a
pedagogical
model
that
uses
important
benefits
in
environment.
FC
proven
effective
teaching
mode
empowers
students'
21st-century
skills,
stimulates
self-learning,
improves
academic
performance.
potential
interesting
explore
what
extent
biology
welcomes
FC.
aimed
systematic
literature
review
analyze
articles
published
Scopus
indexed
journals.
We
used
keywords
"Flipped
biology"
search
menu
database
succeeded
finding
72
articles.
There
were
21
met
criteria
for
further
analysis.
inclusion
exclusion
PRISMA.
findings
obtained
are
trend
publications
over
last
ten
years.
approaches
research
include
quantitative,
mixed
method,
case
study
qualitative.
Key
words
often
writers
student,
human,
biology.
keyword
has
branch,
namely
active
learning.
9
countries
origin
authors
who
publish
United
States
country
publishing.
Articles
on
each
continent
not
evenly
distributed.
dominant
collaboration
with
one
rarely
author.
have
formulating
picture
existence
These
can
consideration
or
reference
researchers
more
deeply
related
based
their
respective
urgency.
Language: Английский
Self-Evaluation Tool for Completed Action Research (Set-Car): An Innovation Ensuring Quality Control
Lee Baraquia
No information about this author
SSRN Electronic Journal,
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Jan. 1, 2024
This
study
explored
the
provision
of
support
to
researchers
with
objective
formulating,
validating,
and
evaluating
implementation
Self-Evaluation
Tool
for
Completed
Action
Research
(SET-CAR)
in
Department
Education-
Region
IX,
Zamboanga
Peninsula.
The
employed
R&D
design
utilizing
ADDIE
Model
development
validation
process.
study's
primary
data
sources
were
seven
(7)
expert
validators
who
validated
criterion
items
proposed
SET-CAR.
Eight
(8)
teacher-researchers
three
(3)
research
managers
shared
their
experiences
utilization
SET-CAR
using
survey
questionnaires.
collected
on
decision
was
analyzed
percentage
acceptability
as
descriptive
statistics.
After
careful
taking
into
account
recommendations
validators,
generally
acceptable
accepted
revision.
enhanced
deemed
appropriate
sufficient
representing
minimum
standards
each
section
manuscript.
Based
feedback
managers,
considered
a
significant
evaluation
tool
action
provided
relevant
contribution
quality.
Four
topics
emerged
from
thematic
analysis
feedback:
(1)
provides
guidance
doing
research,
(2)
prompts
deeper
insights
reflection
presents
comprehensive
user-friendly
content,
(4)
promotes
an
effective
way
enhancing
manuscripts
skills.
recommends
exploration
reliability
conducting
continuous
monitoring
evaluation.
Language: Английский
Artificial intelligence is important! A mini systematic literature review of bioethics in science learning
Research and Development in Education (RaDEn),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
4(1), P. 555 - 572
Published: June 1, 2024
The
focus
and
concern
of
researchers
on
the
theme
bioethics
its
relationship
with
science
learning
is
highly
expected,
as
evidenced
by
publications
in
reputable
journals.
purpose
this
systematic
literature
review
(SLR)
was
to
compare
investigations
researches
article
published
scopus
indexed
We
used
phrase
"bioethics+learning+science"
search
menu
database,
found
138
articles.
Furthermore,
15
articles
met
criteria
be
analyzed.
inclusion
exclusion
model
PRISMA.
publication
"bioethics"
database
likely
increase
2012.
Although
2013-2022
there
were
fluctuations.
This
can
approached
through
qualitative
or
quantitative
even
mix-method.
Almost
all
types
populations/samples
have
been
subjects,
showing
that
broad
dimension
involves
parties.
Leonora
Kaldaras
most
dominant
researcher
reference.
Bioethics
specs
are
related
artificial
intelligence.
keyword
intelligence
student,
teaching,
engineering
education,
computer
education
computing,
education.
Interesting
things
systems
aided
instruction.
from
continents
generally
written
groups.
There
four
institutions
world
fund
research
bioethics,
while
others
not
mentioned.
Most
fulfilled
one
ethics
publication,
which
clearly
mention
name
institution
/
funds
their
publication.
formulate
discuss
aspects
trend.
alignment
continues
regarding
"bioethics",
seen
based
distribution
year,
methods,
instruments,
study,
author,
keywords,
author's
internationality,
collaboration.
information
findings
gives
us
new
insights
think
about
between
Language: Английский
Human connection with nature improves wellbeing and pro-environmental behavior: A literature review
Devi Mariya Sulfa,
No information about this author
Hadi Suwono,
No information about this author
Husamah Husamah
No information about this author
et al.
JPBI (Jurnal Pendidikan Biologi Indonesia),
Journal Year:
2024,
Volume and Issue:
10(2), P. 698 - 713
Published: July 31, 2024
Given
the
world's
continuous
environmental
concerns,
there
is
a
need
for
increased
participation
in
nature
protection.
The
ecological
crisis
of
last
decade
on
Earth
has
become
one
causes
rupture
society's
relationship
with
nature.
Such
relationships
can
predict
diverse
attitudes,
intentions,
and
pro-environmental
behavior
(PEB).
A
systematic
literature
review
(SLR)
aims
to
compare,
study,
analyze
journal
articles
that
relate
issues
related
as
major
factor
behavior.
results
selecting
indexed
by
SCOPUS
found
many
1716
publications.
50
open-access
publications
were
chosen
based
specific
criteria
further
examined
identify
eight
final
align
Inclusion
Nature
Self
(INS)
scale.
Pro-environmental
strengthens
human
encourages
sense
ownership
involvement
environment.
refers
behaviors
are
beneficial
environment,
such
supporting
conservation
policies,
recycling,
participating
Research
using
INS
scale,
which
focuses
connections
nature,
still
significant
potential
should
persist
making
contributions
science
humanity.
Language: Английский
Kesadaran Metakognitif Mahasiswa pada Perkuliahan Sistem pada Hewan dengan Penugasan Berbasis Portofolio dan Jurnal Belajar
Ita Ainun Jariyah,
No information about this author
Khoirotul Ummah
No information about this author
Bioscientist Jurnal Ilmiah Biologi,
Journal Year:
2022,
Volume and Issue:
10(2), P. 1209 - 1209
Published: Dec. 30, 2022
The
rapid
development
of
the
digitalization
era
needs
to
be
improved
by
problem-solving
abilities
in
every
challenge.
One
competencies
that
support
is
metacognitive
strategies
ability.
Metacognitive
awareness
an
important
competency
learning
must
mastered
students
able
understand
and
control
knowledge
they
acquire.
This
research
a
descriptive
study
determine
proportion
students'
lecture
system
on
animals
with
portfolio-based
assignments
journals.
results
analysis
are
used
as
follow-up
design
for
next
increase
awareness.
data
measured
which
includes
aspects
declarative
knowledge,
procedural
conditional
knowledge.
showed
was
mostly
medium
category
66.67%,
rest
low
19.04%,
high
14.29%.
These
indicate
still
making
improvements
process.
Language: Английский
Can R&D Transfer and Market Openness Improve the National Export Rate? A Global Entrepreneur Perspective
Devani Nariratya Putri,
No information about this author
Iwan Hermawan,
No information about this author
Achmad Zaenuddin
No information about this author
et al.
Journal of Governance Risk Management Compliance and Sustainability,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
3(2), P. 50 - 64
Published: Oct. 31, 2023
R&D
Transfer
gives
birth
to
an
understanding
of
the
importance
role
latest
applied
research
in
developing
entrepreneurs
compete
global
market.
The
market
that
continues
be
dynamic
allows
emergence
various
access
restrictions
make
it
difficult
for
entrepreneurs,
so
existence
openness
is
needed
as
entry
point
into
This
study
aims
solve
gap
a
significant
decrease
world
export
levels
2020
by
2.1%.
problem
considered
crucial
because
this
worst
decline
last
decade.
data
was
taken
through
secondary
from
Global
Entrepreneurship
Monitor
(GEM)
and
World
Bank
countries
on
five
continents
2019-2021
period.
processed
using
Structural
Equation
Modeling
(SEM)
analysis
instruments.
empirically
requires
can
encourage
increase
rate
with
direct
effect
0.577.
Thus,
has
proven
able
create
new
technology
encourages
creation
they
lead
National
Export
Rate.
Therefore,
practical
implications
show
need
fulfillment
Physical
Infrastructure
Government
Support
opening
increased
exports.
Language: Английский