medRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory),
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
unknown
Published: Sept. 10, 2020
Abstract
Background
School
closures
around
the
world
contributed
to
reducing
transmission
of
COVID-19.
In
face
significant
uncertainty
epidemic
impact
in-person
schooling,
policymakers,
parents,
and
teachers
are
weighing
risks
benefits
returning
education.
this
context,
we
examined
different
school
reopening
scenarios
on
within
outside
schools
share
days
that
would
need
be
spent
learning
at
a
distance.
Methods
We
used
an
agent-based
mathematical
model
COVID-19
interventions
quantify
disease
extent
which
school-based
could
mitigate
spread
schools.
compared
seven
strategies
vary
degree
countermeasures
transmission,
including
use
masks,
physical
distancing,
classroom
cohorting,
screening,
testing,
contact
tracing,
as
well
schedule
changes
reduce
number
students
in
school.
considered
three
for
size
two
weeks
prior
reopening:
20,
50,
or
110
detected
cases
per
100,000
individuals
assumed
was
slowly
declining
with
full
(
R
e
=
0.9).
For
each
scenario,
calculated
percentage
have
least
one
person
arriving
active
infection
first
day
school;
lost
due
scheduled
distance
learning,
symptomatic
screening
quarantine;
cumulative
rate
students,
staff
over
months
effective
reproduction
averaged
community.
Findings
In-person
schooling
poses
teachers,
staff.
On
school,
5–42%
arrive
COVID-19,
depending
incidence
COVID
community
type.
However,
class
sizes
via
A/B
scheduling,
combined
incremental
approach
returns
elementary
keeps
all
other
remote,
can
transmission.
absence
any
schools,
expect
6
–
25%
teaching
non-teaching
4
20%
infected
upon
case
detection
rate.
Schools
lower
risk
low
0.2%
0.1%
by
hybrid
while
grades
continue
remotely.
require
60–85%
home.
Despite
population,
not
significantly
increase
community-wide
provided
sufficient
implemented
Interpretation
Without
extensive
countermeasures,
may
lead
infections
re-closures
identified
among
students.
Returning
only
scheduling
is
lowest
strategy
includes
some
learning.
Research
context
Evidence
before
study
Scientific
evidence
has
been
evolving
rapidly.
searched
PubMed
September
2020
studies
using
phrase
(“COVID-19”
OR
“SARS-CoV-2”)
AND
(“model”
“modeling”
“modelling”)
(“schools”)
(“interventions”).
This
returned
17
studies,
were
retained
after
screening.
A
wide
variety
impacts
from
reported:
2–4%
deaths
end
peak
numbers
40–60%
upper
end.
Drivers
variability
include
(a)
contexts
when
closure
enacted,
(b)
timeframes
endpoints,
(c)
structures
parameterizations.
Thus,
considerable
variation
predicted
reported.
Added
value
To
our
knowledge,
modeling
explores
trade-offs
between
increased
lost,
taking
into
account
detailed
data
demographics
patterns,
set
based
proposed
policies,
applies
them
range
levels.
If
rates
high,
will
accelerate
epidemic,
but
change
its
overall
course.
even
if
low,
complete
exponential
growth.
Staged
coupled
aggressive
safest
strategy,
so,
reactive
likely
necessary
prevent
spread.
Implications
available
The
depends
specific
used,
no
zero
risk.
layering
multiple
types
responding
quickly
increases
new
infections,
minimized.
PLoS Computational Biology,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
17(7), P. e1009149 - e1009149
Published: July 26, 2021
The
COVID-19
pandemic
has
created
an
urgent
need
for
models
that
can
project
epidemic
trends,
explore
intervention
scenarios,
and
estimate
resource
needs.
Here
we
describe
the
methodology
of
Covasim
(COVID-19
Agent-based
Simulator),
open-source
model
developed
to
help
address
these
questions.
includes
country-specific
demographic
information
on
age
structure
population
size;
realistic
transmission
networks
in
different
social
layers,
including
households,
schools,
workplaces,
long-term
care
facilities,
communities;
age-specific
disease
outcomes;
intrahost
viral
dynamics,
viral-load-based
transmissibility.
also
supports
extensive
set
interventions,
non-pharmaceutical
such
as
physical
distancing
protective
equipment;
pharmaceutical
vaccination;
testing
symptomatic
asymptomatic
testing,
isolation,
contact
tracing,
quarantine.
These
interventions
incorporate
effects
delays,
loss-to-follow-up,
micro-targeting,
other
factors.
Implemented
pure
Python,
been
designed
with
equal
emphasis
performance,
ease
use,
flexibility:
highly
customized
scenarios
be
run
a
standard
laptop
under
minute.
In
collaboration
local
health
agencies
policymakers,
already
applied
examine
dynamics
inform
policy
decisions
more
than
dozen
countries
Africa,
Asia-Pacific,
Europe,
North
America.
PLoS Biology,
Journal Year:
2020,
Volume and Issue:
18(11), P. e3000897 - e3000897
Published: Nov. 12, 2020
Severe
Acute
Respiratory
Syndrome
Coronavirus
2
(SARS-CoV-2),
the
etiological
agent
of
Disease
2019
(COVID-19)
disease,
has
moved
rapidly
around
globe,
infecting
millions
and
killing
hundreds
thousands.
The
basic
reproduction
number,
which
been
widely
used—appropriately
less
appropriately—to
characterize
transmissibility
virus,
hides
fact
that
transmission
is
stochastic,
often
dominated
by
a
small
number
individuals,
heavily
influenced
superspreading
events
(SSEs).
distinct
features
SARS-CoV-2,
e.g.,
high
stochasticity
under
low
prevalence
(as
compared
to
other
pathogens,
such
as
influenza),
central
role
played
SSEs
on
dynamics
cannot
be
overlooked.
Many
explosive
have
occurred
in
indoor
settings,
stoking
pandemic
shaping
its
spread,
long-term
care
facilities,
prisons,
meat-packing
plants,
produce
processing
fish
factories,
cruise
ships,
family
gatherings,
parties,
nightclubs.
These
demonstrate
urgent
need
understand
routes
transmission,
while
posing
an
opportunity
effectively
contain
outbreaks
with
targeted
interventions
eliminate
SSEs.
Here,
we
describe
different
types
SSEs,
how
they
influence
empirical
evidence
for
their
COVID-19
pandemic,
give
recommendations
control
SARS-CoV-2.
Nature Communications,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
12(1)
Published: May 20, 2021
Abstract
Initial
COVID-19
containment
in
the
United
States
focused
on
limiting
mobility,
including
school
and
workplace
closures.
However,
these
interventions
have
had
enormous
societal
economic
costs.
Here,
we
demonstrate
feasibility
of
an
alternative
control
strategy,
test-trace-quarantine:
routine
testing
primarily
symptomatic
individuals,
tracing
their
known
contacts,
placing
contacts
quarantine.
We
perform
this
analysis
using
Covasim,
open-source
agent-based
model,
which
has
been
calibrated
to
detailed
demographic,
epidemiological
data
for
Seattle
region
from
January
through
June
2020.
With
current
levels
mask
use
schools
remaining
closed,
find
that
high
but
achievable
are
sufficient
maintain
epidemic
even
under
a
return
full
community
mobility
with
low
vaccine
coverage.
The
easing
restrictions
2020
subsequent
scale-up
programs
September
provided
real-world
validation
our
predictions.
Although
show
test-trace-quarantine
can
both
theory
practice,
its
success
is
contingent
rates,
quarantine
compliance,
relatively
short
delays,
moderate
use.
Thus,
order
transmission
strong
performance
all
aspects
program
required.
PLoS Medicine,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
18(9), P. e1003777 - e1003777
Published: Sept. 28, 2021
Background
Rapid
detection,
isolation,
and
contact
tracing
of
community
COVID-19
cases
are
essential
measures
to
limit
the
spread
severe
acute
respiratory
syndrome
coronavirus
2
(SARS-CoV-2).
We
aimed
identify
a
parsimonious
set
symptoms
that
jointly
predict
investigated
whether
predictive
differ
between
B.1.1.7
(Alpha)
lineage
(predominating
as
April
2021
in
US,
UK,
elsewhere)
wild
type.
Methods
findings
obtained
throat
nose
swabs
with
valid
SARS-CoV-2
PCR
test
results
from
1,147,370
volunteers
aged
5
years
above
(6,450
positive
cases)
REal-time
Assessment
Community
Transmission-1
(REACT-1)
study.
This
study
involved
repeated
community-based
random
surveys
prevalence
England
(study
rounds
8,
June
2020
January
2021,
response
rates
22%–27%).
Participants
were
asked
about
occurring
week
prior
testing.
Viral
genome
sequencing
was
carried
out
for
PCR-positive
samples
N-gene
cycle
threshold
value
<
34
(
N
=
1,079)
round
8
(January
2021).
In
univariate
analysis,
all
26
surveyed
associated
positivity
compared
non-symptomatic
people.
Stability
selection
(1,000
penalized
logistic
regression
models
50%
subsampling)
among
people
reporting
at
least
1
symptom
identified
7
positively
2–7
(June
December
2020):
loss
or
change
sense
smell,
taste,
fever,
new
persistent
cough,
chills,
appetite
loss,
muscle
aches.
The
resulting
model
(rounds
2–7)
predicted
area
under
curve
(AUC)
0.77.
same
selected
infection
although
when
comparing
type,
cough
sore
more
while
smell
main
limitations
our
(i)
potential
participation
bias
despite
sampling
named
individuals
National
Health
Service
register
weighting
designed
achieve
representative
sample
population
(ii)
necessary
reliance
on
self-reported
symptoms,
which
may
be
prone
recall
therefore
lead
biased
estimates
England.
Conclusions
Where
testing
capacity
is
limited,
it
important
use
tests
most
efficient
way
possible.
that,
considered
together,
maximize
detection
community,
including
lineage.
Cognitive Computation,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
16(4), P. 1723 - 1734
Published: Feb. 19, 2021
The
coronavirus
disease
2019
(COVID-19)
has
resulted
in
an
ongoing
pandemic
worldwide.
Countries
have
adopted
non-pharmaceutical
interventions
(NPI)
to
slow
down
the
spread.
This
study
proposes
agent-based
model
that
simulates
spread
of
COVID-19
among
inhabitants
a
city.
can
be
accommodated
for
any
location
by
integrating
parameters
specific
simulation
gives
number
total
cases.
Considering
each
person
as
agent
susceptible
COVID-19,
causes
infected
individuals
transmit
via
various
actions
performed
every
hour.
is
validated
comparing
real
data
Ford
County,
KS,
USA.
Different
interventions,
including
contact
tracing,
are
applied
on
scaled-down
version
New
York
City,
USA,
and
lead
controlled
epidemic
determined.
Our
experiments
suggest
tracing
smartphones
with
more
than
60%
population
owning
smartphone
combined
city-wide
lockdown
results
effective
reproduction
(Rt)
fall
below
1
within
3
weeks
intervention.
For
75%
or
users,
new
infections
eliminated,
contained
months
Contact
accompanied
early
suppress
growth
completely
sufficient
owners.
In
places
where
it
difficult
ensure
high
percentage
ownership,
only
emergency
service
providers
during
go
long
way
contain
European Journal of Epidemiology,
Journal Year:
2023,
Volume and Issue:
38(3), P. 243 - 266
Published: Feb. 16, 2023
Abstract
Contact
tracing
is
a
non-pharmaceutical
intervention
(NPI)
widely
used
in
the
control
of
COVID-19
pandemic.
Its
effectiveness
may
depend
on
number
factors
including
proportion
contacts
traced,
delays
tracing,
mode
contact
(e.g.
forward,
backward
or
bidirectional
training),
types
who
are
traced
index
cases
cases),
setting
where
household
workplace).
We
performed
systematic
review
evidence
regarding
comparative
interventions.
78
studies
were
included
review,
12
observational
(ten
ecological
studies,
one
retrospective
cohort
study
and
pre-post
with
two
patient
cohorts)
66
mathematical
modelling
studies.
Based
results
from
six
can
be
effective
at
controlling
COVID-19.
Two
high
quality
showed
incremental
adding
digital
to
manual
tracing.
One
intermediate
that
increases
associated
drop
mortality,
acceptable
prompt
case
clusters
/
symptomatic
individuals
led
reduction
reproduction
R.
Within
seven
exploring
context
implementation
other
interventions,
was
found
have
an
effect
epidemic
not
remaining
five
However,
limitation
many
these
lack
description
extent
we
identified
following
highly
policies:
(1)
coverage
either
medium-term
immunity,
efficacious
isolation/quarantine
and/
physical
distancing
(2)
hybrid
app
adoption
isolation/
quarantine
social
distancing,
(3)
secondary
(4)
eliminating
delays,
(5)
(6)
reopening
educational
institutions.
also
highlighted
role
enhance
some
interventions
2020
lockdown
reopening.
While
limited,
shows
for
epidemic.
More
empirical
accounting
required.
Scientific Reports,
Journal Year:
2025,
Volume and Issue:
15(1)
Published: Jan. 22, 2025
Non-pharmaceutical
intervention
(NPI)
policies,
ranging
from
mild
measures
to
total
isolation,
were
implemented
worldwide
during
the
COVID-19
pandemic.
We
adopt
a
systematic
approach
guide
policymakers
in
deploying
NPI
policies
mitigate
pandemic's
effects
while
balancing
their
social
and
economic
impacts.
Our
results
show
that
each
has
an
optimal
duration,
beyond
which
its
effectiveness
plateaus.
Stricter
require
longer
durations,
when
sustained
for
period,
earlier
implementation
is
more
effective.
However,
this
duration
unattainable,
timing
becomes
critical,
as
both
early
late
reduce
efficacy.
Stringent
with
insufficient
durations
may
perform
worse
than
less
restrictive
applied
over
same
policy
aimed
at
minimizing
overall
healthcare
burden
under
fixed
significantly
intensify
peak-time
strains.
Finally,
virus
transmissible
lethal,
gap
between
stringent
narrows,
targeted
interventions
vulnerable
groups
outperforming
universal
strict
measures.
PLoS Computational Biology,
Journal Year:
2021,
Volume and Issue:
17(6), P. e1009122 - e1009122
Published: June 17, 2021
Simultaneously
controlling
COVID-19
epidemics
and
limiting
economic
societal
impacts
presents
a
difficult
challenge,
especially
with
limited
public
health
budgets.
Testing,
contact
tracing,
isolating/quarantining
is
key
strategy
that
has
been
used
to
reduce
transmission
of
SARS-CoV-2,
the
virus
causes
other
pathogens.
However,
manual
tracing
time-consuming
process
as
case
numbers
increase
smaller
fraction
cases’
contacts
can
be
traced,
leading
additional
spread.
Delays
between
symptom
onset
being
tested
(and
receiving
results),
low
symptomatic
cases
traced
also
impact
on
transmission.
We
examined
relationship
increasing
delays
pathogen
reproductive
number
R
t
,
implications
for
infection
dynamics
using
deterministic
stochastic
compartmental
models
SARS-CoV-2.
found
increased
sigmoidally
due
decreasing
efficacy.
This
results
in
accelerating
because
initially
increases,
rather
than
declines,
infections
increase.
Shifting
tracers
from
locations
high
burdens
relative
capacity
intermediate
maximizes
their
reducing
(but
minimizing
total
may
more
complicated).
Contact
efficacy
decreased
sharply
lower
tested.
Finally,
testing
reductions
sometimes
greatly
delay
highly
heterogeneous
These
demonstrate
importance
having
an
expandable
or
mobile
team
control
surges
cases.
They
highlight
synergistic
value
capacity,
easy
access
rapid
turn-around
results,
outreach
efforts
encourage
immediately
after
onset.